← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/60553/2024allowed

Harsh Yadav v. Directrorate Of Enforcement

2025-01-16Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat24 pages

        

 !"# !$%&%"'()) 

   

  ( * +),),),-.







 



 !

 

!  

"   

#

  

$  



% ! &  &'

(

)* 

+"

,(

  &  &    ),),-. /)

01 -

.

&  



/01 2 3,(" "  4541* 3  (  (&!& 6,  675/7 .8745-9

15:

45-9 

1/

  3+ (

' 

!

   2 3!+  4) (

!3

 



, * &

+        &   (    !

&   

 &3(

  *    

&& ( !3   

!

& &3 &    *  3 

    

   

 6*    !3    

    ;   15:

45-9 .   (   *  &&3   

 (  < #3 (  7% " 

  

+

7  8  $&* 7  #3  

 7  2

 7 

 

+ 4554 ! =,   &2 >', 2)     , -0745-0

45-0 "( &   

44 4149  , ( 3  !  ',

)

-90:

' 

!

   2 3! ,$ /564) 

  ( 

&& (& ?   &   3   !       &     6  (  41 14 *   !" 

7% " 

  

+

' 

!

    27&8,+4) 7 #3

  <

 .    *  (     3      *

   @ ++ A

3 !    ,

 -90:* && (&&3 ?

!3 < &(*    

  (&    * !

  

  !3    .  && (&  ?    3  !  * !3 < ( 78 $&** *  *  

 < *   7%

+

 

3*  6. 3 &(

&& "(3 !   <  ( !

 && (& ? 3  !   "

7(   $     <&

!((

!

*

@ ++  A   7%

+ B !   "

(

!&&*  !3 7%

+  @  ++  A     (   *            (    ( *    

&& (& ? &  3 !   (  41 14 * @ ++ A !3 7%

+ 7 #3

  <  #3 (   <&    &   

 

      *  &       #3  (> 

3  7 #3

 . 



* &3 (& & !"  (  & !"    !  * 



(

!3 <   #3 (

 !     * 7 && !3

  

 * & &C !3 <  D      (  E      !&

 6 *&&& ( &  6*& !



  41 4544 (C     & ( ( &&  -4   &3 7 8 $&*

7 #3

 7 

  < #3

(    ( "#<

7 3"     

   

 6. B      !

(  , 1/1

.* ;21  1 8& C ;6  .

  "

;/9  $(

3 (

    *

  

B

14545 



. # (        

    4:

454-   

   *  "

  !3    

     

0'/)

+4554 1454- .  &



4:

454-

 ( 36.

C " (  &?

!3  

 3!

  !3 

A E3 (  C 6. "   F E3&



-G 454- 

 ; & A , 1/14:

454- .  ;&  

 3-0 5H 454/     

 *  3!

&   3 &3 7 +6 &

+ .  E 



 ( 36. C " *

 3!

&   !3 2!   

    .       && (    * (         ! "(      &  ?

  !3 

;  86, 4/G

4:

454/



 -00 //0/:16

&



;:5$(*( (

!3 ; . 

-5 454/

*   :5

+ 4554 ?

(  

(  *

&

**    

A , 1/1 .* ;

1 8& C ;6 .

 "

;/9$( !

       3      !3  && "(   3 !  

*&

&3*

        3    !

  

   !3 

;  &!

 "

!3 !3 *3 &(?        "(   (   ?   :5

+4554  *& !&  

  & &  (  

 

 * !

!3

:5

+

/

.  

    

  *      

:5

+ 4554 !

&

 &  3  

  ,   &  ** 

 3 &3  & &&  

 .  &  !   3!

( , 1/1  .* ;12  1 8& C ;-  .

  "

;/9

$(  3!

(, -4;28& C 6. "

 $(  0:

G5 5557;  .

*(( ,   ?

 5557;  

 !

4544 *&  



:

* && ( !3  ;

*

*   

     45-0;45-9 . !3*3

"(7

 (  "

&& (&   "*( * && !  *  

 ( 

  &   && ( "(!

  "

  !3  ;

+4554

& &3&(   

 E    ( "( !3 <   



  *   &C(   

         !

  !3 && (&&3 ( !  && (&&3( 

  3 ,   

  #

 3 

 3!3*3( (   

* &           

    

    

       

4'-)')( 

   &   &(    &

 * &&# (&(   

 .



    3& (  

1

+4554

** !& 

/

+4554

9

+    & &3(

 *  !  &  

     !           -4     &3

78$&* 7 #3

 7 

  < #3 (    (

"#< 7 3"  6 

 !

& &3 & &3!3&& ((  !"

 &  **

 !3  ;  E &3  86, 4/G

4:

454/

 -00  //0    /:1    6

&

 

;:5  $( ' ? ;G)* (

(  6 *& && (

&    3  ,

*  (  I 5557;  

 !

4544 ?  & !

( 

 

&& (   (

+    &

 !

 3E 

 3!

(, 1/1 .* ;21

18& C ;6 .

 "

;/9 $( *&    @ 45-0!3   A 6

+

* 

2!   

  .

     3!

 !3

!3(

 3 &   

&  (

 &&*    

   *  3 E   

6 

 *      &&  3 

 

 (

  3

  3A 6

+  15&"*

      3            3     (

 &&

-/ -4 45-0*

 !

*

 

  6 *(

!

*

 

! &  &&   ?

  (

 &&  &&

    E ** (      ?

 &  

.

 *E   !3  

& (& 

  3 &3 !

*  (3   



&3 !

 *   &3 3* &

&3* !

     * &&&   *

    (

 && 

-/ -4 45-0  ' ? ;-)* ?



  (

.    3* "

 !3

      

    -/ -4 45-0       &

' ? ;4)    & 

  E  



 *&



 

*

 &

  E &   

  -10     , ( !&  6     -00- (

5 3  

 &*    , &  

**(&33    && ' ? ;1) .  

* &&   !33(

  & * *  (  !3  

+    & &3(  

 

( &  (

(

 &&  

-/ -4 45-0*  (   3E   6* ((    



*

* 3 ! 3    *&

&   (   

&&

!3  

  (&&3  

        ?

      &  

  

   

(

 &&

-/ -4 45-0 *    & 3  15 5557;

       (

 &&  E &3  

*  &      ?

  & 

 

 3 3   (&   

   &@( '

 )$(' ? ;/)

.   *    !3     &@(

'@ ) $(    

-0 454-' ?

;:)

 -5

+        &       (  

   3!



 !3

;  3!

! 3 

& 

 3E * 

 3  !

(   

          

   *

  *& 

  & !

*

  



 8   3    E   *  &      !3

7A 6  

+

,  *

 3*(

(  &3 *

 &3 

!

  

 3



+

   ;  (    86  , 4/G  

  4:

454/  

-00 //0/:16

&



;:5$( ' ? ;G) (

(

--

A& 

&3  

  *  &&     E ( 

:5

+ 4554-5 454/*  (   67/7 .8745-9     

      !



; *   * 

&& (  &    &3 !

* *

!       



  3  

    

 +        &   !    

         *   3  && ( &

&3 (

( 

 && ( 

 6 .  !

*

 

7

  * &

&3   

 

&*3 

*   ;

 &&   E !3 +    &  (

*&& (&&3

!3

;    -- 454/  &3     !      *

** "

   *



! 

 !3

 &     3& (*  ( 

.

*  3   86

 &       6!

 

&3! "(  & 

  *  !  *& 3* !3 .

  !3  ;**&&3*

&& (&  

 ;& *

3!3  !

    &*3  

 *   ; 

 *

!            *      

& 3&  & !

     & @(

@  $(   

& *



  *

   3 (! 

 .

*   3 !

 & (&(   (   . 



3    



       &3   !

       

 

!

!"

   

-00 //0  /:1 6

*

           &   

*&& (&&3

  

+   & 



 !





  ;

!

 

 **&& ( &3

   3*



 23   (        &  *  !3  >!&

    

 

  

     

    &        &    (  

     

 *&   & 

&3   !



  3E .

!

*(&3

  

 +   & 

  & 

 !&   

15:

4544' ? ;-4)

 *  (

         (&  !&  !3     

  @( ;;

&  @(

 $( &&3          6   &3     (    

3"        &  @(    

+ 4554(  (&!& 

*&&*   

 59 4544' ? ;-1) .  ;

&& (  ' ?  ;-4 ;-1) * !3

!&& 3!

&&*     

  -4

+    & 



 

 ((  !

(

&3

 "(   *



 && 

*

   !    &3  * "( &&

&3 !

  3

  !3  

-1

B   &   & (!

&   !   <       &  

  (     !&     !3

 (    &  

 &

 C ;6 .

 "$(* E  &3 



.  * ! E &3

  *   

 

     *  *     !3 # (  3   6.B  !

(, -1 .* ;21 8&;5 C ;6 .

 "

;/9

$( 3 6.B   !

(, 1/1 .* ;21

18& C ;6 .

 "

/9 $ 3-4;2

8&;5 C -.

 "

 $( 3 .

    &  *  &   !

 &     4544 (C    3& (*

"

( -4  &3  &3 78$&* 7

#3

 7 

  < #3 (

       (  "#  <



7  3"       

! E &3   & *&& -G 5H 454/  * E

 3&

 -4;2 8&;5 C

6.

 "

 $( 33!



.  

  3 6.B

!

(, 1/1

.* ;21  1 8& C ;6  .

  "

  /9  $( (

    * "

!3  1454-4:

454-  * 



 ( 36. C "  &?

!3

   !

      !3           *  & 

 &    

 -0 5H 454/ *  3 !

&   !3

,   15 5557;     3*      

    *  (                /5 5557;       .  

     &  

 *E 

:5

+ 4554



 (



:5

+ 4554  *

&

  * &

&3 *  3 

 A , 1/1 .* ;2;1 18&

C ;6 .

 "

/9 $(* 

   

    *    (   *  



&&   C  

-H

 

+4554*     &    ( *   

8

 

   3

  



( 



 

 

  !" & &3 &

   3 ,  .  &  !3

 

7    (      / /5 5557;     & 3& E

 * *& 50 -- 454/ . *& 

&  *

   3& (!3



  !

 !3  

-/

6  &   &   

 

-:

8 &      6*  !3  15:

45-9  ( * &&3 

(  < #3 ( 

7% " 

  

+

78$&* 7

#3

 7 2

 7 

 

+ 4554 !=,   &2 > ', 2)      ,  -0745-0  

  54 45-0   "(  &   

44 4149 ,

 -90: *&& ( 

&& (& ? &  3 !   (  41 14 *   !"  7@

+ 7 #3

 

 <      .  && (&  ?    3  !  * !3 < ( 78 $&** *  *  

 &  6*& !

   41  (C     3& (* "

( -4  &3 78$&* 7 #3



7 

  < #3 ( 

 ( "#< 7 3"

    

49

&&   3  *

   B

14545   

         # (    3    

 4:

454-  * "

!3  ;

0'/)

+4554 1454-  *

 

    && ( &3   ; &  

 3&    3&& (&&3 3

 &3 7 +6 &  

+

6 * && ( *  (   ! "(

&?

!3  ;  86, 4/G

4:

454/ 

-00 //0/:16

&



:5 $(*(  (

!3  ( 

6 * && (

** 

     3   !

          !3&& "(3 !  6 *&  && ( !&    

  

9 & &  (  

  

*  !

  !3      

  :5   

+ 4554

*

 &



  *  !  &    !         -4     &3  7  8  $&* 7  #3 

 7    

    < #3  (

       (  "#  <

7  3"       .  &3 && ( (   !"

  & 

**

 !3 ; 86, 4/G

4:

454/

-00 //0/:16

&

:5$(* (

(  &  

 3  , !

  (

 

 15 5557;    !

4544

?  & !

( 

-G

   &    

    !       &3  !

(

  (&!&!3    &@( 

+ 4554

$(       

  15:

4544  ' ? ;-4)

&&  &&   &3   (  3"  &!

(

  (&  !&  !3       &  @(    

+ 4554 $(    59 4544  ' ? ;-1)  J&  ( ( 

6  !&   (  3"

& 

+  &&*(!   ;



         

                 

 



 





    !

"  #  $%%$&  

 

     

    

 "" 

 '  (

 

 '   

      

             ) 

"       *    

        "    

 

+ '

"  





 ' , 

" 

  (  - .)/.0      

      !

"#$%%$&



 1  2

 (2

2

 (#

 2

 





          3

 "





(       

    

 

      

 /

     

  "0 

  

"    

  #( 

  

 (   (   "

   



%#

    

    2

 (2

2

 (#

 2

 





     4  

     

  

/

  "0     

"    

  #

5

.  5  

              

     

2

   6  &  (   

 

(      

  "    

  #(   

 

  5  

 '



   (     



  

 ' (     



""

 (

  

 

      

        

"    



  !

"#$%%$&

$ "     7

  (

  

 



 #

*  



   

 

 

 

        



 

"

    "   

"

     

*      

#    

   

/0 

(                          "     

  



  !

"# $%%$&(    



(      

  



 '  " 



"(

7 

  "

   " 



 '    

   

      



/0

  !

"# $%%$&



#      (  

 *     ( 

(    7

  

  "



   

 

  "

  

 

  

 ' 

* "

  * 

 

"   

 

    89* : -  9 2

   6  (;  (< 

= $%$./>? 0@(  A@ B  ?  A   A"      

     

   

"     "



    (    * *  " (

 ' * 



(  "

  

(

 ( B     "'



     

   

  

     

 '

"  #"

            

  

*"





  

=  8# -  9 C 

(<, D)E.$%.=@( A@ B?

A A"    

  

  

/0 





  7

.)/0

  !

"# $%%$&   

      

 

   "      

 - 

  

/0



       *"  "4 7

            "        4   

  5  



 

  

"   

   

   (    



 





 

  



  

(   



   "

 

"

*""4  " &

E5 A@ B?A A"  

      



 

*   

  





.)

  !

"

#$%%$& "

" 



   *""4 (  



 

    

   

 5      



 

FFFF FFFF FFFF

)FFFF FFFF FFFF

%FFFF FFFF FFFF

.FFFF FFFF FFFF

$FFFF FFFF FFFF

    

          -

  

    

 '     





    8#B  : @ / 

0(    



        





  !

"#$%%$& 

 



    " A

( (

 '           

 (    

 ' 



 " 



"

   

"""

  

     

""

"



   

 



  !

"#$%%$&(

 

.) #(

                

     

 '    

" 

 ' 

FFFF FFFF FFFF

FFFF FFFF FFFF

=FFFF FFFF FFFF

E  ?  

   

4  "    

 ( 



  

 ' 



 " 



"   (

  ""  

 '    

  5



( ( 



  8#  -  @ / 

0(  89*   :  -  @ / 

0   85    @  / 

0(

  

 '   

 * 

 

A  "



+

      

 ' (       (    

  



  

#  +    

 (   " "  

 

 (    

           



 '   

       



 '   (     -  #   -  (  - <"-  ?- *-  (

      "

   < (%%(%%%'    



 ( *

(     &

-H



  ' ?  ;-4

;-1) * !3   (&!&*(



  (  3"   !

&& ( !3  ; 3  !

 !& *

*& ( (  !& & @(          

+ 4554  $(    (*  (  &!& 3   

/:

+4554       & *&&&3      

 * =,   & 2 >', 2)     , -0745-0

54 45-0 "(  &   

44 4149 ,



-90:

-0

.  

    &&*      

   

!&( &!   :

5557;*  *

 &"



      &  *

!  !

 !&&&!

!# & &&*( ;

/0 



(

 

( *   (



 

 +      (  



   "      

 

1

/0 



   





 

-

  

  

 

-

 & ))

),),-.     J

  7 "(  7, J

  !&

  7,