Gopal v. Union Of India And Others




   
 
 

 "#$%&&% 


 




 
 
 
 

 '#  ()'

% *


 ))
  ()'

% *
+
, ' )




 


 



 !"


 




####
+
, ' )-
  $
%


 

 



$$&'(&$)
*

,$-.








 
01


/
 
01

2


"



% 
*




 

3
% 4.
(






1 
(&$-
01

 /1
 

2 
5
 /1


,6



 

1 
7

1
%
* 7%.
 

(-&8(&$9
"

:2
2

1
;

<

"




/
 
%


/
 

1
 1




 "

/ 
/

/ 
01

"


+"

-
%


/
 

 "


(-&=(&$9




6


 /1


5
 /1
> ?


 


 "
*

,9.
/
 
8
;/


 
/






 






 


/
 +"


<

0
 "


*

,@.


"

-2-




 





0

 

0





+"




*

,=.
9








 "


0 <

1
  
/



/

"

  




0




 


 "



01







 


@


01

 







*

,$$.
/
 
01


0 
% 

/ 

/

*

,$(.
/
 
0






 







/

 



$$&'(&$)
*

,$-.

 







=
 
 



0"

% 






 
01


;

0"





/
""


01


01

















/ 






 














0

" 

B



6 
;


2






 

 

4




-&&9(&$-
*

,$&.
;/





< 1


2



 



 1



/

  
 


+


 
)



0"


"
01
  
 



 
 
 
0!
'
%
 


 


%


<

1 
7

1
%
* 7%.
 
/




 "


;/

-3- 0 <

1
 
  
/


 









;

/
0



 


5$&
/ 
 
/



 



 


5$&=
 
/ 


/




 

/













/




 

 

 
/
0



%












%


"1
 

 
"!




  
2

"

1  



/




1 
(&$9,(&$@



/ 







7






/
 
 $$&'(&$)

@
1 

01
%



"
 !

 
%







B



 1




7


/  
0
  


 1
 



/


 

+


 
 < 
 




 0
/


  0 
:1





"

 

 +
1 

  0 
 

 1





$&



 1
/

0
  

0 
0
 
  


% 
 
/




0

1
 




2
$(-$


,$&
 
0  % 
/ 


0

 
0  
2

 
/ 

/
 < 



 




   




 














2 +
2





,
.%/ "! "/ 00 134! "0 !/ 00675 "!

"! 2 28 " 9/ / "372 2

"!: "!07 "!

00 ;

113  "!% "

 "!07 "! 9! / 33 "2 2 ! !/ 732 0 2 33 /  "!07 "! / 76/34 <

-4- !7<5  "6/ 0113  "!%!

"2 "!07 " "10&%=3 034! ! / 113  " 9 / 7 ! 6"70 0 ! 6"70  " 1 3 3  0! 0 9 /

" ! 6"70 !  2

" 13 ! 9 732 <  2 30 2 "83 2% / 113 "- 02 "6 "!/28 3 2/ ! " "10 &%&

 ""

>70  & 10 2 <4 /  113 " 9/ "  /! <

! 2/ "/ 10 !0 < 2!1 -/ "2 2 57!17/ ! 733! 6"70 ! "07"" "6!0 1-"

1 3- ""63 !/? "2 %
 !3 034!1

2 "  "!07 "! 3 2 2 9" " /  28 " / ! 6"70  " 1 3  0!"2 "3  0!9 732"

<  1 2"2!7/113  "!9 732 < ;

2!7550 34%

"!  2 7";<"24" 6/ 70 ;726 " "%% % %&$&

&& "%% % %&$&

&&@ ?'A  3 2 80 * "6/ +!% 3 ? "0% 2 2 " %%&&- & @A * 9/  " /2<

"/ 32!

9!# B&% /   70 ""

 3  ! 6/

 /  / "  17<3  11 "5 "- /  0 "!

   !7/ " 28 " !

09/ 35 "6"2"75< 0

1

9/ "2- !394! 0 "

> !!

 /  28 2 1 !! 9/ / " 70" 9 732 3 2    75< 0!

!

"10

!!%
 !<0 76/ "

/ ! 70 // 1   0 !"

" !

3 2!

 "6!7/! 7 "- <7/ 0 01

3!

9/ "2 270 /!<

""

2

" /  60 7"2 / / 0

05! 9  "

 "

05 4 9 / / "!07 "!% &&%
"8 9

/ !- 1 "6/ 13 

1   09 732 <  "8  "6!0 1/ ! 7 "9/ " 0 !

"10

!!

1 0!

"!9/ /8 10  1 2-9 732< 17 0 !C% &%/  !"

3 63 "

05 41 " 2 7 "/ 

"! "2 " / 76/- /  2 5"2!

D7 4 732 /8 8 3 271 "/  70-<7"

  "6/ / 9 7320 !73 "

" "6  1"2 0(!< > 9/ / 54 3

102 E  / " 0  !

!!-
5

1 "

"/"

 "

 !900" 2%  !5 !!

2%F G%
" 8 311 3 !%$$

&& 3 2 2"637C20 +!%* 72733/,/"? 0!% 2 "$%%&&- / 1 > 70/2 / 32!

9!# B&%
" /

 !7/ "37!

"!- 9  /8  3 3  / !  " "

"372 "6// "37!

"0

2<4/  6/ 70 ! "004

! "2 5 0 3! " /  0

02%
 ! !

3 2 39 / /  " <  "

-53> " "/  05!"2 "! " "

2 "/ 28 "7"3 !! 1 0

3> " !27340 2 "/ 8"073 !"2:

0 "/ 28 "%8  !1 0

3> " "/ 073 !-/ !5 732 ! 33 /8    <  !1

334 "2  2 " /  28 "%
" / " !

- "

 !7/ 073  /! <

" <0 76/  70 "

%
" !7/  075!"

!-/  6/ 70 732"

/8  !!7 2/  5176"

22 0 "! 2 0 /  3 5

 0 "  %& " /  <! !

 2 " 4 02 !7<5  2 0/ !

"10

!!9! 0-9 // 17<3 

3 !%F H%/ < ;726 "!3 034 0/ !

"!!  !7/ 073

 0 3>

"!

 513 "   /! <

<0 76/ "

 "/<4/ 113 "%I $$


/


0

/ 
"
 1


/





 1

"


 

1
 
@

 ))
A  @+
, ' )A      $%&&%