Janak Raj Dogra And ORS v. Sohan Lal And ORS




      

  



!

"#$%$ & '

(

(


       
 


 

   

      ! "   #         

 $$% #    &  



!'!'$'$( ) * +,- 

 # 

 0    +      +     !

(

 *  + 1 

 . $ 

  .1

 



  0  

     

/  .      0      

   2

/ 

1  

0   .   &  .1

 # 

 0 /



  

  + 1

   1 



/ 

 .    

  

 0 3 " # 

 

 

   .  (

# +

  4  # 

    5 

! " #

! $$ % ! 

 &'()* 
 
+,+! -)

.

  0   

   

    2    2/  

  2    +/1 # 

     . 0  

  

/   

1 0      

1    6 7  !'



1 

   +
  

     ./ 011 12 ."1!

0 /31 1"421/ 5101  +"+$  $ 1/  /31 1+/"

0 /31 .

"1 3 "  +"12 41!+ +  561./+ /3 /  1,+"+ +"

+/ + 5!1 + .

"1 0 4

1/ 0 ./ 011 / 3 " 511 31!2 + , +" 62$ 1/" /3 / /31 71"/+ 0 84

1/ 0 ./ 011 +"

2+"4/1 51/%11 /31 !+/+$ / 2 1$+"/ %31/31 +/ +"1"

/ /31 "/ $1 0 41"1/ /+ 0 4!

+/  /31

4 41 !

2 /31 1"421/ +" 

!! / +/11"/12 + ".3

2+"4/1            3

"31 +$3 ,  6+21 # "3 2 (-9) #  :;:

    

              

                 3+" +""1 % " +/141/12 5 /31 1 !

+$3
/ +  " ,
3 <<+  +  (-:& 1 !

;* %311+ +/ % "

31!2 /3 /  1,+"+ %+!! !+1 $ +"/ /31 21.+"+  /31 71"/+ 0 + 217 . 0 ./ 011 / /31 +"/ .1 0 /31 21 012 / 31 62$ 1/ 41=
/ + +

) /3 ,

" .

"1 "4  % "

!" 0!!%12 5 /31 >!!

1.3 0 /3+"
/ + ?" 6  /" , +23 +$3

2 /31" (-9; #  ): " 41 >!!

1.3 62$ 1/ 0 /3+"

/ +/ % " 31!2 /3 / 71"/+ 0 ./ 011 .

/ 51 $+/ /12 5 /31 !+/+$ /" + 41/+/+ 21 "1./+ ((@ 0 /31
+,+!

#.121
21 (' 31 41"1/ .

"1 +" "7 1! .,112 5 62$ 1/ 0 >!!

1.3 0 /3+"
/ 12112 + ?" 6  /" .

"1 "4  ..2+$!  + ,+1% 0 /31 0 ./"

"

1/+12 5,1

2 /31 "1//!12 4"+/+ 0 !

% + .

"1 0 4

1/ 0 ./ 011 1,+"++"

+/ + 5!1 A+"

+""12 1,+"+A+"

+""12

, 6  

/ 

1  .  ./ 

 "

     

   0   

  # 

  1 . 8

 /    1

 1

 .

/   0   0

  

 

 

  

  

.

     1    

 1         1  

/   / 0 1

1 . 0

 *

  & 0 

/

 9  

 0   

 

/ 0 1 1   



  !

( 1       

    /0  +   

/ %

  1 0 

 1 .*  * +$ : ;    2 /   # 



   / .1

 .   0  

.  2  0 

  1  < 0

1 



  $3'($'$( 0 

 

 

1  

0   0   ./    7 "

 # 

!'!'$'$(  .

    0 . 0 # &   

 1  

  0  1



/  .     0   0 1

    .  9   & 0 

.

    0  . .

 .    

 / 0    + 0

0  . 1 .     0   . 

 

 

      9

 1   

 0  . .

 

0      + 1  

 0  /. &  

  . .  .   

/ 1  0  

      0  

   /   

 

/ 

 # 

  /  1

   

  

2 1

 *  + 1  

 "

 # 

 



    *

+   



     /

/

/   

   !' = 0  .

 1 

1

. 

   

1 .  1

  



/ 

*+ ,- ./



0123 4  (

   9  >  

?>6 9 

. ?>6