High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/267/2024dismissed

Joga Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-01-19Mr. Justice Namit Kumar17 pages

# $$$$ %& '

)

* +, -.

/ 000000 (( + 1+* /

# / 000000

3- 4# /

000000 (( + 1+* /

# /

000000

3 4 54

000000 (( + 1+* /

# / 000000

33 / #

6 /

000000 (( + 1+* /

# / 000000

000000 (( + 1+* /

# / 000000

)

7 6

/ 4 54

4 54

"# $ %&'()*() (( + (* %)%,

/ 0

0 "# $ %&'

%)%, %

! %%&3%%'

" 4

0 . -

() %)%( 5 6% 7 9-:

; ! "

" < 6 6

=; ! "= .12 1 (

1 ! !

1 ! .

> ? $ 7 ; ! " .

() ) %)) 1. ? $ > ; !

/ !2 #! @ A

? $ 7 ; ! " .12 >

B 2

!!2

2 , 4

! . !

! "# $ &C'

%)C !

%* ) %)C 2 . %7 )7 %)%( .

1 %* ) %)C

%7 )7 %)%(

3 + +

-008

! " #

$%& '()*)+,-./*0%1$2( '$(3,0*)+,,4(((+ 3%56( 73$+*%8$,/, (9( ( 04:6/4,%*)%)( '%)+*$-.$/*0%$$*44%6 )%,(;

<( ( 1 2

+ +

&0&03 %*73$/,53%)%*$6%),%6*4// 4%,.3%$4/*0%$( *)$6%80,4:,53%,%*73$), 6:4%,.3%$4/*0%$( ,53%,=( (=( $),.4*,,,<( ( $*44%6, $ 64%> , .488%8 30% * 8* / * $0%,%

)04:>.%8%$*0%$%..,%.?* 4?(

*.0:/*$,604.,%*.%%.,/4$( ,!

9(9(= @

1 ? $ 7 ! () %)%( 5 6% . 1 .

& ! !

- .

. . .

? $ 7

- 1

;=1!

. 1 ! .

1! 4

() )* %)( < $ ,&* %)( !

. !

!2 . .

2 !

3A !

%C )% %)( > D

! 7

$ !

! !

&' &( )

& 9( -%8*/.$/*0$%.$+*73$% /,)%%$?***04.:,.$%$/*-%)% ,, (=(

%, (

( .-*.$/*0044%$ / 834A%B * 4%, %84 3,8 / 46 ,$.3$$%/*4?%*0%*$8*4:.*,*.%.43$% *C*6-04.:,%004:*0044%$.4)%,+ */+ 8* / 834A% 0$$, 6: * 0%$ 1* 0044%$2.%%6..0,C(D%,.3%$4/*0044%$ .34,%,-%.%:)%%8/3483)%$)0$$3$.* ,//% .%.43$%( * $36)$$%$ * * 0044%$ )04:$%88,6:*$0%,%0)%$%,*$-. 0-,*$6%3$,$.)3/48,%:*0044%$* $3$$-%)%)04:$.%$73%834A% 3%,*-%)% 4.:%,*$3:6%/*$% $36$%.4846$$(D%,%843,8*$E0%$-4:,4 ?**/.$%,4?%*$0%%,?/%,%.8% .%-%.%8$%>.%:-?(

(**$>%04.:,.$%/834A%/ $-.$/ * .%.34)04:$?*?00%, / /34/44%84864:.$0C000.,3C(%*.$/ 0044%$ %* *: ? $4., 3%, * -. 34$ 004.64*834)04:$/* 3%56%* ?$%:,-$)%$$3,6:*3%,?*.**:004, /*%88)%$834.%.34)04:/*( ?$*$-.0-,?*%,%%8)%?** 8%.:0-,?>/.%.%)$%,.%,%$( *$-.0-,$4.,*.%,,$%,$3004,*$) *-%)%0)%(%

$ !

! !

(* ..0%./.4)/*0044%$$*44*3$)3%6.>, %:0364.)04:)%%4,$8,*)%,/ .4$ F%, /*%$3%(

(*83)%$/4%,.3%$4/*0044%$* *03:))$$%/$),$.**/.: .))%,, * 6$0% % 834 6$$ *$ % )0$$, 3$( 0-$% / %: $-. 34$ E*6%8 * .)0%./03:))$$%**/.: )> $3.* .))%,%$ *$ 6% ., 6/ 3$( 3.* .))%,%$ ?44 * )3% %.38%8 0.> %, .*$04.:/8348-%)%56$6:,0-%8*3%,,$ %, *3$%,$ / 4864 .%,,$ % 4 .%$ / * 6$-%$ ), 6: * 0E 3 % .: C * !"+ , -..(-)#'(-(

(%*48*/6-,$.3$$%+?/%,%/.34484 %/):%*53,8)%/4%,%843,8(

<(*004$*-%)%,.%$73%4:,$)$$,( !

=(<( = 1G@2 1 2

;=1!

% )% %),

< "! $ '&* %)( !

)& )' %)%

< $ 7)* %)% !

=/ $. )C )( %)% !

!! 1 > D

. .0

B2 E =

! !

! > D

)& )' %)%

< $ 7)* %)%

6 %*$.$*0044%/4,0,3.*$00%)% 4+ / %:+ $$3, 6: :% -%)% %: / $ ,0)%(*0044%?$4$3%64$64$***?$ 3%,*,.)04:)%/$0%,%$(3%883)%$+* .3%$4/*0044%,),**0044%%,$)* 0$%$?%88,6:*$0%,%$$ %: 0$ *38* $-. 0-, %)4: DE) 4.)% -.$( + 3%,$03,4:+ * 0044% ?$ %88, 6: 03: E.$ %, E%))$$%*38*$-.0-,( ?-+*$, 0-3$3.%88%.:?$%)04,,$0:*? 0%6:*0044%( !$

(*$)4-??$>%6:4%,%84 3,8/*$3%

< 4,$ >$*-$(* / :%%, *$+,.,,%

( ( <+?*%?$ *4,**0%*%*$%,.4%$*0?** '3%.040%+338)?**?$?>%8$% 3$3.,)04:( * 53,8)% 0$$, 6: * %H64 30) 3 % 3

4 $ 4%8 .%.34 )04:$,.4:%88,6:*-%)%4483*$ %,$%4,3$3.,)04:$(*$)$/% $$$%.*0044%('-+*0044%.%%>%:

8 6%//*%),,,((0$$,6:4%,%84 3,8%

4,$)@3)%84-$(/

:%%, *$+*$%6%8*$,%),?$ 0$$,%*6$$/,.3)/* %H6430)3% 3

4 (*/.$/*.,.$ ,$%83$*64/)*/*.$%*%,+$*$6%4,: ,$.3$$, 6-( %$73%4:+ * 0$% 004 $ *6: ,$)$$,6%8,-,/)$( !

(( 1 2 1@' 2 ;

)

%( %)%( < $ && %)% !

6 D%,%843,8*$,.4%,*$$3%./?/ )%,)3$+ ?*6:+ 0: ?$ 4$ ), 6: * 0%

0044%44?*).%%3%$-.%*0$)%%,6: *)%*//./$0%,%(9 *$-.0-,(D%, %84 3,8 *$ 4$ /, * /. * * 0%

0044%?$00%,$ %: 0%.%.6$$ *38*%3$3..%.!$-.0-,%(<( ?> % * //. / $0%,% (F (( )% %, *4, -40)% 5. //.+?%+@*4(/?>%8/ ,:$+*$$-.$?,$.%%3,6:$0%,%$(F%,9+ ?*.*$00%/)*04,%8$$$3.*%*?0% 4$(

3$4/*00%)%4,,(<(1%%E3

2?34,4$8%$*?*$-.0-,*,/,* %) / 0% $0%,% (F( $ 00% * 00%)%/*0%?$),6:*$-.0-,(0

(4%..%4$6 04.,30%*53,8)%,,(( %D (9</ 1'* -$( / :% %, *$2+ ?*%+ % $)4 ..3)$%.$+ * -? >% 6: 4%, %84 3,8 %

( </ 1 >$*-$(*/ :%%,*$2 ,.,,%

( ( <?$00-,(*$%%8?$** ?$ % ,. 4%$*0 / 0% ?* * '3%.04 0%+338)%,*/+0:5%%*0$/ %: 0%.%.346$$+*,6%,.4%,( / * 0044% *$ %: 484 8* 8%$ * $-. 0-,+$0%/*)$>),$+%..,%.?*4?( *?0%+$$3.*+$%)%%648%$* $-.0-,%,*$%*)04:(..,%84:+* $%)%*0$%004(*$)$,$)$$,%4)% ?**/$,46:( !

-)6=+ 1(( D21 @2

;

"6 D

- .! )5 "&67(- -.&8 9 ! 9 "#3 % %)* .12 1 ! .

2 1

*8-%./*0%%*$.$?$?*8, *,,,<(9( 1%%E3

=2+?*6:*'3%.04 0%+338)+%/),*3$3.%88%.:+*//* $0%,% *%+ * *, ,.,, * * $-.$ / * 0%?%4%873,( #:,,, (( 0$$,%*$?0%+*$

3,.,*'3%.040%+338)+.%$, * .$ / * 0% >0%8 % -? * 53,8)% / * 30)3%3

9 " -..7 &:))-6-(#%,**.$/ 8300%8*4, .%.34)04:%,%%3$3.,)04:(%%: -% 03$3% * 6- ,+ * '3%.04 0%+ 338)+0$$,,,,(

( +$%8*$%$$ ?*:,,%?%.%%3?**$-.$/*0%+ -% % 3$3.%8 6$$( % * 48* / * /$, ,-40)%+*$?0%+$/),+%4%8$3--$/ .%$,%%)$("3*+*$3$/*0%%*% ? 0% ?34, 4 8%$ % 3$3.%8 8%.:+ 6%8 0-%:?*.*$%%3*:%)$/*.4 / *%$3%(,),4:+*0%*$%,.4%$*0 ?**'3%.040%+338)(*?0%$ ..,%84:,$)$$,(; %

"6 D "# $ %%7(, %)%) !

. %7 ) %)%

% %)*

! $ !

( !

6 ; $

&-) "0 $

( "3*+*)04:((*3$3.%88%.:*$%6% )04,, $ 0: % * 0$% ? 0%( %.+ * 0%$*)04:$/*3$3.%88%.:%,* 3$3.%88%.:$%-%0:+%4/.%68%, *0%$%*6$%./%.$$:0$(

* 8, * .*44%8 / * 0%$ * 00%)%$+?*.**-6%),%3%!34:++-,, ,, = ( ( 1%%E3

92+ *- 6% ), 6: * 3$3.%8 8%.:+ ?*.* 8 .%. / * E0: / * .%./*3$3.%88%.:+?*.*00%,*0%$( **$,3$3.%88%.:$0:%*$0%%* .%,,$+?**-6%0$,?**$0%,% #%>6:* $,3$3.%88%.:+%)4:+'!$% %0$$+ %.*>34+ *0$(*6%8$+*8-%./*0%$% $0./$36$73%00%)%$%,*6:%3$3.%8 8%.:.%%68%%6:*$3%*6$%./* %.$$:0$( @0%8%-?*6-+*0$%?0%$% )%%64$*4/$38*$8%$0-8%.:+?*.* $*)04:/*0%$%,%?.%6$$3,8%$ 0-8%.:( * 0$% ? 0% $ ..,%84: ,$)$$, $ % )%%64(;

16 -

! 1!

!2 $

D >

. !

!2 !

!2 .

! !

. .

1 . 1

(

"6 D

)& )' %)% "# $ C% %)% !

3 <1 &6".8"-.-.

)5 "&8---.&6 =

3 1 -.".>"-.-&

)5 "666(-.-.

/! *

3 0 /

2 ! . . ! !

2 1

. ! % " 4

4 !

!2 .

2 . .!!

1! , < !

;=1!

) %

"&&::>2&&:>6&66> $3 ?

@ $

:.".:"&666 ) %

"&67(&668 @

A"B 9"

B $

.8".8"-..> 7

1 .

! 1!

!!2 4 $3 ?

!2 .

B!2 D

1. D

!2 1 1!

. .

3 ; . .

! 5

A" $ !2 . .

. ; ; D 1

D ; !

--($

)

/ !!

D D ; !

! . ;=1! 5

"&67(&668

" $

) %

A) "(.&(-..-$

3 ).

26 ? $ 7

1. !2

@ . 1

(

1 = 1! = ! = 1! ! =

;=1!

%% ** !

, ; D A"% &66-%0E '>7

%% !

!!. 1?*.**$6%00-, 6:"-3,8$#%.*/* %C6430)3%C% 0

0 -..(&-))-::

6( */2 6

($%/* 8*3%73%*73$%%,,., ?***)04:)%/.%.463%%:0.$$+0%% %:*?>%%:$64$*)%$*34,664$*,%($ )/*,.$%/*8-%)%/.%$,%8*)+$ 73, 6 .%$,, 3%, .% / * .( * %4:

.%$73%.$0-,,%*.?***0%.04)04: *463.%.-4$*0-$%/.%$<1$.2%, $0.-4:$*0%40-$%+$%-$8,3%,*./?*.* /%.):6),.%$=%,9/*.(5

--()

% $)

( ?34,%4>E0$$%:-?%*,.$% /*@%> 8*3/*35 8*31$302$%. *$,.$%$3%,.*44%8%*$3+63??34,04.% .,*?,%8?**/73,6$-%$/* ',$ 8*363*//./%% 8$%/*0%.04 )04:*%% 4.%$%8/*463.%.%?**-?/ #)6: 8*3%*/$,.$( /*-?** ,.$%$/*@4 8*3%,4* 8*3..%, ?00-*$)(;%*48*/*6-+0%$.%%6 8%,%:6%/%*0$%?0%$%%/*83%,$ 0$$,%$-.6:*0%$.:%:?8*(*?0%$ 6%8,-,/)$%,$,$)$$,(;

& '

>1 !

! .

1232 ;=1!

%% )C %)%% ) %

">786-.-- %

A) "&&&8-.-- "/ ?

E @ ! G%

--()

" 0

--((5)

--($

4 .

! ! ;=1! 5

- 3

1 2 !

. )%,)3$ 1

231232 .

231232

= 1! = ! = 1! ! =

3 !!

1 5 . 1! 2

. 1

2 1! !

! %%& " 4

. 5

! %%& !2 . 3!

2 !2

F G

2F . 5

! % "

1! !

C 4 .

! !2

. )%,)3$

! 2 1!

. . ;

! %%& 2 .

. )%,)3$ 1

2 .

2312

= 1! =

= 1! = ! = 1! ! = !2 1 2

* ! () %)%( 5 6% . ! .

!2 ? $ 7

A !2

. ! 1

5 . 1! 2

1 .

2 1! !

!26 . !

2 2

!2 ? $ 7 . .3

2F . 5

! % " 4

1!2 . !

!2 73

. 2 1 ! $%8

- 1 ! ;=1!

. ! 1 2 !2 1

2 12

! 1! 1 % > .

2 !

6? $ 7 !!

* +, -.

%4 54 '

!! # 5

H I = 5 I =