Union Bank Of India v. Debts Recovery Tribunal Ii And Others
!
CWP-30496-2025
!
CWP-35397-2025 $%&'
!
""""
!
""""
#$#%&#'() * " "
%()(+),#'() * ""
-.(/'#'() * "" '( )**+#,- ".
"
/0 "/( ) 1
* 01 " 221 3 2 01 " 2 1
1 $ , ( * #0./ 2/,,. *3 /# $ (/*$/* #0./
)( "
/4'
56789 :6:;/#58<:5 )( /4'
5;58= $ "(/>*/ #0./
:7'
56789
) :/#5'
58<:5 /# )( "
'
5;58=
????
13"
'
56789 5;58=/#58<:5):6:;/ @ ,/4 "
, //**( >"
2>"
)* #@A"
/4)#/
'
56789 5;58=):6:;/# )* #@A $% +>/A.*
'
58<:5):6:;3/ )-# "/ #@A( * / #
A@/* (/#,/( $ B=):6:;
( "" ).0 .
/4) #/(/**@ ) #/C
/4D/#$% +>/A.* 2"
'
5;58= ):6:;3 (/**@ ) #/ C D(
:
@/4 /,, # @A # "/ # @A
(/#,/(#/ #67 <6 :6:;2 E
9'
56789 :6:;30# >(.( .
"
@/4 >/ # / >(A . -" ".
#,@ / #/,/( ))./*)( @/4)
-"* /))/*# #/ #69 :6:;"/ # :5) :6::@A (/#,/(
@/4/*/,, #@A# #/ #:= <6 :6:;2 E
8'
56789 :6:;3"/ #@A( * / #
A@/* (/#,/(0# >(.(>/# . (/ "
@/4 >*# "
- "
/ ./( . # /.." 666%
'
58<:5 :6:; (/ @
" ) # @A "
@/4 >( "
@/4 /,, # @A # #/ # := <6 2 E
8'
56789 :6:;3>( @A"
@/4(/@
# . #/**> @> "
/ ./(. #/.. "*-) 666% /## #/ #:6 <:
:6:;2 E
<6
'
58<:5 :6:;3 0# >(.( /* $//, 2 A3 >/ # #/""
/"
@ ) @/*56 6< :669
'
5;58= :6:;" ) #@A$% +>/A.* 2 ( 3 +#.)((/@
04 #
4, # . .-"*A >( # #/ # 69 2 E
:'
56789 :6:;3"/ #@A (/#,/( :5 :6::* #/ 4$"%567/$58,.#29(%#:$" )5()/);(< )'5//)' %$
;
# /"" ./ .0 A@ >
( "/ /# * ),(@A@(( # >*#@ .
/A #> #" #)/.>(.((/0 * #"/,)# #/ #67 <6 2 E
9'
56789 :6:;3 := <6 :6:;2 E
8'
56789 :6:;3/#:6 <:
:6:;2 E
<6)'
58<:5 :6:;3
(/#/0/* #. #)/.* )-"
@/4
/) /.
"*.A>/, #%/4 @A( "
@/4 . -,/, #%(A"( ./ #""
A >/( ./ ) (/. #@-/**( .
/A"/"
F #@A"
@/4/#( /#*-> > #)-- - /#, 0/.
>// #@A"
@/4 > "
@/4)/#* *A, /.
)( * 0/* ).4(>,"*/.
),#,# )* /#)@/ )( ""
A
=
(/:8 << :6<8 //@8 66"
/-/+) @4 /( ""
A)
" /** )).*) # A # *A( -,/, #""
A@/*.4 ./(/##.- ( .# >/#*A " #$//, )"
@/4 >((/#0
" - /#.*/->/*#, #>(/.
.-"/A ( .*/-) (/>/*A/) ( .# ))
./- 4>/@/# F/ /.
.0 >/,@A( @/4/# - /-
0# <8"/# -.(/# ./,.-"* .* ) ( F ) ) ( */ >/ + . # /# /.. ) >/# ,/ #/ "
)-,..% 2( /) ) # / 3 /.
"*.A >/ "#/ # @A /.
.-"/A/>,/## ) >//** , #*A- #@A "
@/4 >(* , , /.
"*.A /# ) @/ ( " - >/ / # @ ,# )* >(.( ,/0 +)./ /.
.-"/A "#/ .*/- / # @A
.
# )/*>//..))/*)"
@/4
/..#,*A /,/# # .*/,/..@ (/# /""/.( #
A@/* @A)*, .G//""*./ # .<=)( .//# ..) /./* /# ).
) .A . :66: 2( /) ) #/C .D3 ( /#/""*./>/-@ #/
:5 :6::/#>/# .# #@A (/#,/( (/#,/( 0# # #/ # 69 :6:; 2 E
: '
56789 :6:;3 F/(,# .)"
@/4.*/)A/..) @ /#)( ( *#/)".
#,# . @ ** ,/*
@/4>/)( # . #"/A.-"
/) ;
666%
,/# #/ #69 :6:;2 E
:'
56789
:6:;3 "/ # @A (/#,/( 0# >(.( :5 :6:: >/ /**> "
@/4(/" ) #//""
/*@ )
A ""
**/ @/*
*( >(.(/ #@ "
#,/#@ , /4 " ) >/ ) /"""/ @ .( 2# /0/*/@*A ) " #,)).
3( /( /""
/*
<6
@ F *A (/# " ) # -.
**/ /""*./@ /,$ B= :6:; :5 :6::>( -", # #/ #67 <6 :6:;2 E
9'
56789 :6:;3 := <6 2 E
8'
56789 :6:;3/#:6 <:
:6:;2 E
<6 '
58<:5 :6:;3(/0 @
"/ ( # #/ #67 <6 :6:;>/ /A #@A(0# # #/ #<9 <:
:6:;"/ #'
56789 # # #/ #<9 <:
:6:;2 E
8'
58<:5
:6:;3 "/ # '
56789 >/ .*/) # (/ @> -/A04 "0) .<82:;3) A)
@ /#/4".A. <8852( /) ) #/C<885.D3/# >/.*/) #(/# #/ #<< << :6:;2 E
B'
58<:5
:6:;3"/ #'
56789 :6:;>** / 5)- /4, . #A# ..*#, # .<82:;3)( /#. - />(*
(/#/*)* '
5;58= :6:;
4,# . /#>"
.*#,"
@/4-"* # #/ #69
<<
*,( ) /@0 # )/. )**>, F / ) .# /@ ) (1
<3 '( (/#,/(.-"
/ . -" ".
#,)
.)# #/ #69 :6:;H :3 '( # #/ # := <6 :6:; 0# >(.(@/4 (/ @
# . # /**> "
/ ) ./( . # *- " 666% "/.
)# #/ #69 :6:;./@ "/ # /# >( /- @ A# ."
) # #/ :6:;/#H '(
A@/*+) #"/,# #/ #:6 <:
:6:;H '( /A# ./ F #@ #@A( )-"* /)# #/ #69
<:
.
-", # # #/ # 67 <6 := <6 :6:; /# :6 <:
:6:;/**(/0 / # .)# #/ #69 "/ # :5):6::/# @A>/A)> "
(/ ,( -"* / ) # #/ # 69 ( "
/0 "/)# #/ #69 :6:;2 E
:'
56789
:6:;3@ , "#.
#) /#A ) .
1
!"#
$! # ! %
& '(&
"# "#
!
)
!
"
#
*+
! "
,
"# $ !
$ - '
"# %
& '(&
"#
# & "# . # "
/
0"
# ' 1 $ $ !
# #
!
2 <5
@/4.(/** ,,"> )
A@/* / . -" ".
#, >(* ., "> # .
/ #. *)"
@/4(//, #(/
@ A@/*/@/*/#//#. (/@
#>("> / . -"). -" />/ . @A0# -", ## #/ #67 <6 >( .
@/4>/ #(>./ />(A. -"".
#,@ / # #/ #67 <6 :6:;*/@* @ F/( #@ ,@ A#+#.
<7
( >(
A@/* /0 >("> / . -"".
#,
( ."
)"> )
A@/* >/#*A.# #@A 0 .()
*( ,((<#==-(%9$19'":$"/)/%//);3 <88B2<320*3<;B >( >/( *#/# 1
3
!
# "
0 4 "
#0" " $0
"
1# "
, 0" 0 0"
#
# ! "
"
,
"
0
!!
#1 # 0"
! 5! !
#"
0
" , 0"
""
!
"
<;
A@/*>/( *#@ /@/*0 #>( "
./* +#. *A A "
.). "
- # # .%<885./#/ >/)( ( *#(/# . /A.--*/>+#./#+#.*- # @/4 )/./* .-/@> "
/)) . #@A/.)@/4# .<885.
<9
2>5&?+@/%+-9/ %$":$"6/825)A>(@/% %$"3 2
<7=8 # .# #:;
:6:;3/# /%;/$> //):$"
>#+9>(%5$#' <<5,#%329/9#/);(<)'5/ )%"3 2
:5=8
:6:7 # .# #<8 6= :6:73,* &#, )( D@* (/# /0 #/( ..*(/
A@/*# )/**>( # )))( "" ) -"). <8=<
<=
>/;+%+A/.?5$>(%#25)>/:$">#259/@/%>5#)9%/. ((-#%/95&#/);19'" )%"3<89=" <787 (/ @
@ 0 #@A( D@* " /# 1
I0 $ !$ /)6
7 ! 7$
,
# !
"
#
"
7$
"
!
" , $ !$ /)6! "
" !
$%
&
&
$ 2 $ !$ /)6 1
5
#!
"
"# 1
$%
&
2 <B
D@* " /);15@59#' %$":$"
29/9# (< />/%/$>9%/ %$"3 :6:7 293 585 (/# .# / ) . -" ".
#, @A $/(//(/ / $
--) -"* /)
A@/* # "/ #)/0)/""*./>(.*/- #(- *)@ /- -@ ) $A--A >/( *#(/$A-->/ >(,( .
( @/4/#/- >/@ A# +#. ( ."
)+#.)
A@/* >/ /,/ .# # @A D@* " )9#%)/95()/. $$#9
#,()$9%+,95()(@-/)8(<)'5/19'":$"># <<5,5/.15B+5'/9(%(< .'%5,> >/%@/,#+95,/.$19'" %$"3:6<=" ;6<5 >( >/( *#/# 1
I/
"!
0 4
5
# " "
"# !!
#
"
#0" &
."
, # #
!
9
& !
$: $
66 66- $ ;&
3
! $ 0" 0
!
#
!
!
0 4 " #
! "#
5
#
"
<
0" !
#"
!
$ $ $ $ +
!!
# !
!!
!
!
4
$&
669;
0"
"
" "#
$+$
,
2
<8
( )
A@/*/(/0,(
. -"+#. ,(/#( " / J. ) .#J# .* :<;/#<:8)( )#/(/0, "> / /#"(). -")#
:6
( -"). <8=<"0# /A)/- >4 )( ./*"> ) ,(./#" '*)* #@ # .
).# +#,- @ /.( )# /4, /-.0*. -">( //.(/./#/*G
*> ( /(
A) ) >(( # . )+#./*".
#,/ .
# #/.-/*. -" # -"). <8=<.
-"".
#,./@ / #@A ,(/#" >-"-@A( A /*%*. /* 2)3#0./ /*2) 30./)+#. @A//,, #"
:<
( . )"> ). -"./@ / #)> . -". -").@#/ ,( ( )
* .(/- /A/(/%+#./ .
-"".
#, A/ 0 #( *A>(/(A/ . -"".
#, . . -"+#.-/#/A (/0 /A/(A#
::
./ )
A@/*>(.(/.@ @/* .,*- #+#.>((/0,.--*/>+
#. /A"> / . -"/0/*/@* ( # <885.# .
A@/*(,((/
,/-"* "> # .<82:;3)<885. ).
#
(> (/"> / . -"".
#, :5
# #/ #67 <6 :6:;>( @A @/*(/#/ #.
-" ".
#, ( @A F/( # (/ E
@ A @/*(> (/**@ )
. "> -"*
/"
.<82:;3)<885.
:7
0 >))/.(/
A@/*(/,/-"* "> -"* # # ./ F #@ # '
5;58=):6:;
>( (/#,(#*, .
) ()-"* /)# #/ #69 :6:;"/ # :5):6::
:;
@/4 (/ /* ,( F/(, ) # #/ := <6 :6:; 2 E
9 '
58<:5 :6:;3 /# :6 <:
2 E
<6'
58<:5 :6:;3
/*)# #/ #:= <6 (>(/
A@/*(/# #"
@/4/**> "
/)./(. #*-( E ) 666%
/ . *) (/+) #/## ( ,#(/./( . #*- >/ "/ ) . #*- ,/ # @A "
@/4/#
)
.
.*/)./ ) /.. / /# F/( ( "
@/4@#/**>"
/)./(. #*-/. )/0)
:9
( ( (/# ./ " #@ (/*))"
@/4 (/ .
A / :6:6 / ,* "// (/ @
"/# @/.4 @A ( >/# "."* /#, /# /.. # /# # ( /0A# @ )
A@/*(/
+#. ,*/ */(")@/4/#@>
A @/*./*A/#+#./ /.)@/4# . .
# #/ #69 :6:;/#-"* #/@/4(//4 /A /.0 >)# #/ #69 :6:;# " "/A- )@/4 # @A .
A /:6:6 )
A@/* (/# E.
#+#.
:=
( . / # @ (/*) ) "
@/4 - /..
"/.
#- #*A
A@/*(/*- #+#.
./*A/#+#./ /..0 #@A . --*/> * )./@ ,/ #@A
A@/*/".
#,@ ) ( >( * #.-"
//#>(/
E /.. ) /** , # )/* ) "
@/4 , , /.
""
*A ./ @ # .# # *A@A /"""/ (/0, +#./#@A
A@/* #/
# (*#, @/4 @ / )/* @A (/0, /"""/ +#.%.-- */> +#. (/ @
"/ >( @A .-"
/"/A/@* (/@
F/) -*/*A
@ A@/*(/+#.# .@/4/**>,/ . #*-/*,/ ( ."
)# #/ #69 :6:;*-
/."/.
)# # .*/,/..) / "
)-,/.../@ /4 0 >)# #/ #69
* # #/ #69 :6:; /# /A #@A""
**/
@/4(//* /#A/ #(/)( /.
)# ,/) /..) / /.(/@
/ #0 >) # #/ #69
:B
( )
A@/*(/ E.
#+#. "/, # #/ # := <6 :6:; # ., "
@/4 /**> "
/)./(. #*-( E ) 666%
-*/*A # #/ #:6 <:
:6:;/**/@* @ /# @ ,/ "
/4, # /*$//, )/4@ ,-- #@A
A @/*>(,0,# /* # /).(--, ( * / @/*,((/0 ..*# #/##.* #/(>"
@/4 (/0*/ ## #/ #69 :6:;>( /) "/,)# #/ "0 /.(/@
/4 @A"
@/4/,/ /* )* / #@/*(,(*,()/* ( "/ )@/4-/4 # #/ #:6 <:
:6:;*/@* @ /#
:8
/ #. *)"
@/4(//*/, #(/# #/ #69 :6:;/-@,/#( )
*/@* @ /#
/ #(/( ,/@)# #/ #69 :6:; "/A, ( ( "."* /-/.. # .
:6:6/# / /)(, /- / #(/# ( /). -"%( ,/@)-"* /)# #/ #69 A, /0#*/@*A"/A@/.4@> #/- #- #*A( " ./
"
@/4 (/ /* /#A /""/.( # * / #
@ A ""
**/ @/* @A >/A ) /""
/* /# 0/*#A ) # #/ :6:;@+ .-/ )/#/""
/* &#.0 #( (/@
. #( " >"
# E.
"/* ..-/.
/
A""
**/ @/*>/(/0,/A " #,)).
/#+#./ /""
/*" ) #@A"
@/4/#
@ A @/* >/ "/, # * /0, "
@/4
#A * ( )
* )"
@ # .# #@A
@ A@/*%
A""
**/ @/* ( "
@/4 (/** @ )
" ( .*#, 0/*#A ) # #/ :6:;@ ) /"""/ )-
0 > )/@0 #. ( *# (/
A @/*(/"> / . -"".
#, ( # <885 .# .)-"* /)#
/
A@/*(/,"> -"* # /"
"0) .<82:;3)<885.>(.(,0 # /* #/#/-"* ">
A@/* .-"*/.
)#
5<
@ A @/* (/ +#. ,*/ */(")@/4/#@> ./*A/#+#./ /.)@/4 # "0) ./## .*/ /- @ 0#%0/*#
&#.)
A@/*( ,/#*- #
/*( *#(/@ ) --,)/A"
>(* .,"> # . <82:;3 ) -"* / ) #
@ A @/* F #,0 //(># (/@
-"* # /# +)./% / ) --, /A "
) -"* /)# >(.(/ */.4,# #/ #:6 <:
..#,*A -", ## #/ #67 <6 :6:;( E )/ ) . -" ".
#, # #/ # := <6 :6:; /# # #/ :6 <:
:6:;/ ( *#@ >(+#./#/..#,*A /#
:;
'
56789 :6:; /# '
58<:5 :6:; / /..#,*A /**> #/@0 - >( / '
5;58= :6:; #" #)>(
*@ A "
( 04 +#. )
@ A @/*/..#/.
>(*/>
1!
21 !
2 :6 :6:9 (0/%.(/+
'( / #%"
/4, % '( "/@* %