Union Of India And Others v. Ex Hav Chhabil Dass
!"#$%&'
"#"(#) !"#$ '
*$ +,* --
- .
+,* - -- - *
! "# $%& "'
& (
)
" * &
% (
"
) % (
++++ -
- .
/ , -
)
%
./,00.,12 3,4
5 6( - (( %)
)
%
(5
3 3
0)1(020)34 "(#! 0
3
)
5 01.7,788 ) ( 5 ( ) 9..70.., : ( 5
( %
)
) )
!"!"! # $
!
" %!
#
!
9 -
%
- ((
;
5 9. < =. < ) .,,.0.., -
( ) )
./,00.,12 3,4 -
!
"
" # " " "
$$ %% $&&'()&* " +$
"
" "
,& * )& * $$ %% $&&'
&''
!
%("## '
"
! )&*!+ ' , #!- -
.
"//-
" "
" (0*
/
5
%
3
)
-(567
7"# "819 2 0 # !)"(#
28" 19 :
1717"#
=
(
3
24 * 5
>
%)
%
"
5
)
)5
%
- (( (
? % ( : 5
'= ?
>
(
* &##.
////
,&!
%
01,- .
2
3 4"!
5 6!
0 %"% ( ,9.10..1-
'= ?
(5
,
"
" "
"
"
"
-
1
" 2 "
"
3 # "
+
4
" + " " "
"
"
5 #
.
"
5
"
.
6
.
" "
# " %7"
.
6
" %7"
#
""
#
'=
2 4( (
(
( ( 5
( (
%
5
:
5
% 3
%
%
( 5%
(5
) *
%
% : ) % )
/
(
)
1
(
'?
%
(
) *
(
,?
)
7 -
)
((
* 5 * &##.
7
7,&!
%
01 , * -.
- 0"
*
5 2
3 4"!
( '
7 -
)
#
"
2 " #
3 #
!
#!
"!!
!" ! !8'" !! !
'"! "
'"
'
%! !
#!
"! !
6
#
%&
#
6
#
"
*%! !
!#!
9' %"!!
!
"
#!
"!
#
12
"
:
" # 6
"
"
"
-(567
7"# "819 2 0 # !)"(#
28" 19
:"#!
#1 ,.
%
(
5
* 5
(
( %
5 5
( (5 )
)5
(
5 @ 24%
) * (
,,
5 %
( (
$ A ( * 5
>
% 0..70.,?%( 0 7#!
-7#49;
#7"#"8#!700#!
) ( 7 72::
02"&&'"8 -
;
- &'
%% $&%%
" 4 3 " - <
%$09 $&%%
&% &% %997
"
" " "
# "
7 1
" "
"
"
"
= !:
" "
" &% &% %997 (0*
"
" "
1 "
" &% &% %997 &% &> $&&9 #
" " <
#8
#)
"8197 "( 1 ,0 - % ( 5
)
( ( (
(( %
%
5 5 @
5
( (
) %
(
( %
(
( 2
3 4"!
5 6!
%", #!- ( 0"
*
5 2
3 4"!
, #!-(
(
(( % (5
3
3 3 5% )
(
5
,9
5 %
(
% ((
2 4
%
(
(5
%
%
%
) ( ( ( ( 3 3
%
( 5%
)
5
( (
) ( 5 (@
,/ 6
5 )
( ( ) ( (( 3 3
) ( ( ( (
5 )
(
%
% 5
( 5
( ( ((
% %
5 @
>
( + #7"#"8#!70;
06 10 >%
'- #27# <% ( ,.,00.,/%)
% ( 5
%
(5 )
(( -
((
2 4
'
3"
.
" "
"
+ "
<
% $ 59>5?
/+
" @ " ? # )% &% $&&% " 4 /
"
" 4 /
: , 1
1 "
+ "
>
2 "
6
" "
" ,= -
%(
( 5
% %
5 @
%( + #7"#"8#!70;
06 10 = (: 0> : %
( )5
2 4%)
(5 ) 3 3
(( %
%
)5
%3 3
(( %
(5
(
5
5 % )
5
:
( 5% % 5
)
,? &(
2 4 ( 5 ( ,.,00.,/
5
5
- (( %
0.,1-
5
2 4 5
5 (
% 5
9 B @ ( ) % )
)5 5
3 3
% (
: 5 -
% )
2 4
((5 ( ( ( (
:
( 5
@ :
5 ,8
) (
( ) 5 2 45 @
( ) 5%
%
) 5% 5
2 4 5 @
( 3 3
(
(( % % %
(( %
5
@
)5 5
%
%
(5 %
%
(
7#02 !
"8197 "( 1 ,1
5
5
)
)
%
5 5 -
5 5 5 ,7 &(
5 (
( %
%
( 24% % 24 =-
- .
> =- - *> '
@
9 :
037#4?
"# !
$
?"
9 :" 1052
$
?"