High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8045/2025dismissed

Regional Director, Employees State Insurance Corporation And Another v. Sran Construction Company Through Its Prop. Balwinder Singh

2025-11-14Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan4 pages

!"#$!%&'&"() !"#$!%&'&"() !"#$!%&'&"() !"#$!%&'&"()* * * ** * * *

!+&"(,&-!% "-./0,"1!!'2 ! ***! & &"(!-' ('3-(%! "-0"- &"(($(" 4!- 5!-'3' 2-( "(' -3% &"( "/0(1 *** !'0"($!(

) 67 2* 2 8

9 -!'!( )

-*$-'4 ,&:.$;"% !. #"- 4!0! & &"(!-* 8

9.* 8

9.* * ! & &"(!-/0,"1!!'6 2 ! ('3-(%!

"-0"- &"(. 3(<= 4!-!&(# !- -!#!--!$ " ' > 4! "-0"- &"(6 . 4' #&,!$ 4! 0-!'!( !;&'&"( ! & &"( 3($!- - &%,! ? "# 4! "(' & 3 &"(. &/03+(&(+ 4! "-$!- $ !$ **. 0''!$ =1 4! &;&, 3$+! 2!(&"- &;&'&"( . 4($&+-4/0,"1!!' 2 ! ('3-(%! "3- .

"4,&@ 4($&+-4 #"- '4"- . > 4! 2 "3- 6 . A4!-!=1 4! 00,&% &"( #&,!$ =1 4! "( -% "--!'0"($!( 4' =!!( ,,"A!$ ($ $!,1"#?$1'4'=!!(%"($"(!$.A4&,!-&'&(+%4,,!(+!=1 4! -!'0"($!( " 4! "-$!- $ !$ ** 3($!- 2!% &"( "# 4! /0,"1!!'62 !('3-(%!% .B#"-'4"- .> 4!% 6 * * 4!#% '.&(=-&!#.-! 4 4!-!'0"($!( A',," !$2

"$!'& A'%";!-!$3($!- 4!% *4!-!'0"($!( &',,!+!$ " 4;! A"-:!$ 3($!- %"( -% "# 9 !- ($ 2(& &"( (+&(!!-&(+ !0- /!( . 3(<= #-"/ *C*C &,, *** 4! 0! & &"(!- &''3!$'4"A%3'!(" &%!#"-01/!( "#%"( -&=3 &"("# 4!'4-!"#

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

"( A4&%4 '3%4 %"( -&=3 &"( 4' =!%"/!$3!.4!'4,,=!,&=,! "01'&/0,!&( !-!' 4!- !"# A!,;! 0!- %!( * 0!- ((3/ "- '3%4 4&+4!- - ! ' /1 =! '0!%&#&!$&( 4!-!+3, &"( &,, 4!$ !"#& '% 3,01/!( ) -";&$!$ 4 4&+4!- &( !-!' '0!%&#&!$ &( 4! -!+3, &"(' '4,, (" !F%!!$ 4!,!($&(+- !"#&( !-!' %4-+!$=1(1'%4!$3,!

* (;&!A"# 4!=";!. 4&' "3- #!!,' 4 & A"3,$=!&( 4! &( !-!' "# <3' &%! 4 4! / !- &' $<3$&% !$ "( /!-& ' ' 4! $!,1"( 4!0- "# 4!-!'0"($!( !/0,"1!-A"3,$=!%"/0!(' !$ " 4!0! & &"(!- "-0"- &"(=1A1"#%,&/&(+&( !-!' &(;&!A"# 4! 0-";&'&"('"#2!% &"(B &=&$* * ' -!'3, "# 4! =";! $&'%3''&"(. 4&' "3- &' "# 4! %"('&$!-!$"0&(&"( 4 ("&--!+3,-& 1"-&,,!+,& 14'=!!(%"//& !$ =1 4! 2 "3- =1 0''&(+ 4! &/03+(!$ "-$!-. ' '3%4. (" &( !-#!-!(%!&'%,,!$#"-* *

"('!G3!( ,1.0-!'!( 0! & &"(&'$&'/&''!$* * " 4&(+ "='!-;!$ 4!-!&(=";! '4,, =! %"(' -3!$ ' ( !F0-!''&"("#"0&(&"("(/!-& '"# 4!%"( -";!-'1* * !($&(+ /&'%!,,(!"3' 00,&% &"('

. &# (1. '4,, ,'" ' ($$&'0"'!$"#* * * * ** * * * K 8

9L K 8

9L 3,'! 4& 94! 4!-'0!:&(+@-!'"(!$) !' " 94! 4!- !0"- =,!) !'