High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-CARB/58/2023dismissed

Ms Gaurav Rice Industries Udyog Marg Kaithal Through Its Propriter Surinder Kumar And Another v. The Haryana State Cooprative Supply And Marketing Federation Limited Through Its Society

2024-04-05Mr. Justice Arun Palli,Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal7 pages

"#$ $%!&

'%$

'( ))**$ ' +" ,($-$ $.'$'

). ))*-$

$/'% 0 1%2%' 3 4)

' 1/($5.($2$6 !$' 7(%(/.($2$6 !$' $58 2$.($2$6 !$' 7(%/$ '+$'6 !$'$

+%/8 2$6 !$'69 '($))**$ ' ::::: ;

$- % '( % '$ ' $))*%!$'%

<< %9 )*$!% 0

!'$%

! 2 '$

= '

* 9 '( $))*%!$ ' 72%' '($' '(

! 2 '% > '%

'7)

! 79 '(7%'$'

% 0 '(!

9'($7%'$'%

) ! 0$

'($''($))*%!$ '7

?)2%'' )*$!'($%

! 2

'9%

$!! '

'()$-2$ % '( $))*%!$'%

6$'($))*%!$ '!$

'7)2%''

?)*$!

'( $%

! 2

! (

' 7 '( '

9%* $ ?%'' '$'2 !79 '(7%'$'

A 0 '$

($7 0% '($!!)'$ 9'()$-2$ % '($))*%!$'%

0*-69%

2%'6'($))*%!$'%

% %2%

< ,( ) ' $))$* $$%* '( $

5 02 $' <;<< )$ 7- '( 9 *$

%'%

$* %'%!' B 06 8$%'($*6% ?(%!('()'%'%

)9 7-'($))**$

.!'%

9'(7%'$'%

!%*%$'%

!'6<CC 9 ( 'D'(<CC !'E6?$

%2% *

0 ?%'( '( )'%'%

9 '( <CC !'6

75!'%

($ $* 7 9%* 7- '( $))**$ ' % '( =! '%

)'%'%

)9 7-'( ! ( 6?(%!(?$* %2% ,()

3 %' '

9 *$% 0 '%'%! 2%** * !$' $' 1$ ?$6 ( ?$6 ($

6 8$*$-$'6 B$/($*6 $'%$6 06 8$*$ ?$*% $

$ %$ ,( $))**$ '6 $*

0 ?%'( '(6 72%'' '(% 7% $*

0?%'($ '2

- 9*$/($)'('2$

%'%

9'('

'%!,( 99 9'($))**$ '?$$!!)' > $3 %!%**6 ($

9 *$% 0 9C,)$

-9 '(-$< <;69 $ '$**$2

- 9 <*$/(,($9'6$02 $' <<< ?$$* =! ' 6?(% '('2$

%'%

0'(%!2%** ? 2$' ,() %

9'(%!2%**?$'$/ 7-'(

<<< )'('2$

%'%

9'($02 '6 '($))**$ '?'

) %'! %'- 9*$/(%

%'%

'($ '

-,($2?$)$% 7-?$- 9$!(> 7 '?$ %(

'( '$**2 ' ? $*

' )$%

$ - )

?$ 0% $%

'%!% 7-'()

'!%2% $*!

2)*$%

.!'%

< '( A0 '%$7* 9 & ' 2 ' !'6 << ?$ $* % '%' ' % $**- '( $7%'$'%

) ! 0 ? % %'%$' 9 !

- 9 $2

9 < *$/(

$!!

9 * 99 7- '( )

3 '

2)*%$ 9'('2$

%'%

9'($02 '$

'%!

7-'($))**$ ' %%

% 0 '( $7%'$'%

) ! 06

?%'' '$'2

!?$ 72%'' '( 0('() '$'% 9'($))**$ '$))$ 79 '(7%'$*,%7 $*$

2$ 7$* 72%%

0*-6'( $7%'$'%

) ! 0!

!* 9$ 9'()

3 ,( $?$ ?$ $!!

0*- )$ % 9$ 9 '( )

3 $

$0$% ''() '$))**$ '$

'(!*$%2?$$!!)' %%% 00% 7- '( $?$ 6 $ )'%'%

?$ )9 7- '( $))**$ '6 ?(%!( ?$ $* %2% 7- '( *$

%'%

$* %'%!'B 068$%'($*6'$'% 0'($'% !'($))**$ ($

'7 '( 9%*$ -?%'' '$'2 !6

9$ *'!

?%'('($?$ 00% 7-'($% !%%

6'() '$))$* ($7 )9

@($($ *$

*9 '($))**$ ' .( 1/( $5 .($2$6 *$

* ) '% 0 '( ' 72%'' '($' ) ) )) '

%'- ?$

' 0$ ' 7- '( 7%'$'

'($))**$ '$

'($''(!*$%2) '9 '(7-'()

3 ?$0$ ' ?%'( *% 0% '(% 1$

* 72%'' '($' '( 0( '( $))**$

)$'%!%)$'% '($7%'$'%

) ! 06% $2 !(6$

?%'' '$'2

! ?$ 72%'' 6 72%%

? *- 2$ 79 '( 7%'$'

67 ' '( 7%'$'

' !

'( 2$'' 9 2 '( !

!' ))!'% @($!

'( 72%%

2$ 7-*$

* '($))**$ '$

($$* ) '()$)

/,(!

6 9

?%'' '$'2 ! ?$ 72%'' 7- '( ' $

'( )

' ($ =$2%

?%'

6 $ %

$))$ '9 2'($?$ ;

9 !

% 0'(%

2%'6%'?

7 '%$*'

'$''($''() %'%

9*$?%7-

??**''* '($'?(%* $*% 0?%'($ )'%'%

.!'%

9'(<CC !'6'( '!

'%' $))$* '($7%'$*$?$

2$-% '9

2%'

'(*%2%' 0

) % .!'%

7%% 9'(<CC !'6%%9'($?$ % $0$% ''() 7*%!) *%!- 9'(&

%$)'(*0$*) %'%

!*$%9% 7- '(

F7*)= '6)% '

'($2

2 ''

'(<CC !'% <6$ % *$'%

9 &

%$ ) 7*%! ) *%!-6 % ' 6 % !* $ % *$'%

9 '(

$2 '$*) *%!- 9&

%$ *$?6$% *$'%

9'(% '' 9&

%$6!

9*%!' ?%'(5 '%! 2 $*%'-6$

'(=%' 9)$' '%**0$*%'-% '($7%'$* $?$

%'%

$**-6'(!

!)' 9'(D9

$2 '$*) *%!- 9&

%$ *$?E ?

2)*%$ ! ?%'( '$' ' $

5 %!%$* )! '6 $

)'% 0 $ %!%$* $)) $!(6 !

2)*%$ ! ?%'( '( )% !%)* $' $* 5 '%!6 $

7 -$

$7* '(2 6D)$' '%**0$*%'-E%'*9($7 (* 2$

'$ '%

9'( 7'$ '%*$? 9&

%$6!

'$ '%

'(<CC !'6$

'$ '%

9'('2 9'(!

'$!'& -!$6 '9 !% $7%'$*$?$ ?

' '$%*$%? 9'(2%' '( %) ' $

7 *%2%' %' $'%

6 ?( '( 9%

0 9 '( 7%'$'

$$7%'$- ) ?( '(!

!% 9'( '% ( !/ ?( '( %**0$*%'- %

' '%%$* 7 ' 0 '

9 '( 2$'' $7%'$*$?$ 6( ?62$-

'7% '9 ?%'(6%9'(%? '$/ 7-'($7%'$'

%$) %7*%?7$

9$!'9 !% '(% 0$ !$ 72$ '

'(5 02 9

F7*)= '% '(!$

!"#$%6

#" ! &!6

'"$$$!$

! "

'" ( 9' '( < $2

2 '6 '(% ) %'%

2?($'

%9%

%'?$(* 7-'(. )2 '% '(!$ 9 # $ % % '($

)* +, -./.012* *3 23*. *41* 15*.- *4. ! 16.276.2*, *3 .8*+32#$ *4.1930.:3,+*+32,*127,,36.;41*637+5+.7 <-,<12**3 *4. +2,.-*+32 35 =:/121*+32 *3 .8*+32 #$

*4. ,83:. 35 832*-10.2*+323527+12:<9/+8:3/+8>41,9..2637+5+.7*3*4..=*.2* *41*+*23;6.12,5-1<73-83--<:*+32+2*4.61?+2@35*4.1;1-7 0+3/1*+3235.8*+32&!3-.8*+32( 35*4.8* 832*-10.2*+3235*4. 5<2716.2*1/ :3/+8> 35 27+12 /1;

127 8325/+8* ;+*4 *4. 63,* 91,+8 23*+32,35A<,*+8.3-63-1/+*>77+*+321//> ,<9B,.8*+32

"41,9..2 +2,.-*.7 +2 .8*+32 #$ ;4+84 :-30+7., *41* +2 81,. 35 736.,*+8 1-9+*-1*+32, 0+3/1*+32 35 27+12 :<9/+8 :3/+8> 1/,3 +28/<7., :1*.2* +//.@1/+*>1::.1-+2@32*4.518.35*4.1;1-74.:-30+,3*3*4.,16. ,*1*.,*41*121;1-7,41//23*9.,.*1,+7.6.-./>32*4.@-3<273512 .--32.3<,1::/+81*+3235*4./1;3-9>-.1::-.8+1*+3235.0+7.28.

,51-1,+2*.-5.-.28.;+*4123-7.-617.<27.-.8*+32 #$ 1, :.- .8*+32 #& +, 8328.-2.7 +* 81223* 9. 7+,:<*.7 *41* ,<84 +2*.-5.-.28. <27.- .8*+32 #& 81223* *-10./ 9.>327 *4. -.,*-+8*+32, /1+7 73;2 <27.- .8*+32 #$ 2 3*4.- ;3-7, *4. 3<-* 81223* <27.-*1?.12+27.:.27.2*1,,.,,6.2*35*4.6.-+*,35*4.1;1-7 127 6<,* 32/> 1,8.-*1+2 *41* *4. .=.-8+,. 35 :3;.- 9> *4. 3<-* <27.- .8*+32 #$ 41, 23* .=8..7.7 *4. ,83:. 35 *4. :-30+,+32 4<, +* +, .0+7.2* *41* +2 81,. 12 1-9+*-1/ 1;1-7 41, 9..2 8325+-6.7 9> *4. 3<-*<27.-.8*+32#$1279>*4.3<-*+2121::.1/<27.-.8*+32 #& *4+,3<-*6<,*9..=*-.6./>81<*+3<,127,/3; *37+,*<-9,<84 8328<--.2*5+27+2@, # 10+2@ 23*.7 *4. 1930. @-3<27, 53- +2*.-5.-.28.

;+*4 12 1-9+*-1/ 1;1-7 +* 6<,* 23; 9. 23*.7 *41* *4. +2,*12* C<.,*+32 :.-*1+2, *3 7.*.-6+2+2@ ;4.*4.- *4. 1-9+*-1/ 1;1-7 7.1/, ;+*4 1 7+,:<*. 23* 832*.6:/1*.7 9> 3- 23* 51//+2@ ;+*4+2 *4. *.-6, 35 *4. ,<96+,,+32*31-9+*-1*+32 3-832*1+2,7.8+,+32,3261**.-,9.>327*4. ,83:. 35 *4. ,<96+,,+32 *3 1-9+*-1*+32 3;.0.- *4+, C<.,*+32 41, 9..2 177-.,,.7 9> *4. 3<-*, +2 *.-6, 35 *4. 832,*-<8*+32 35 *4. 832*-18*9.*;..2*4.:1-*+., 1271,,<84+*8129.,15./>,1+7*41*1 -.0+.; 35 ,<84 1 832,*-<8*+32 81223* 9. 617. +2 *.-6, 35 -.1,,.,,6.2* 35 *4. 61*.-+1/ 32 -.83-7 9<* 32/> +2 *.-6, 35 *4. :-+28+:/.,@30.-2+2@+2*.-5.-.28.;+*4121;1-71,7+,8<,,.71930.

$ *+,.C<1//>+6:3-*12**339,.-0.1**4+,A<28*<-.*41* ;4+/.+2*.-:-.*+2@*4.*.-6,351832*-18* *4.8327<8*35:1-*+.,127 83--.,:327.28., .=8412@.7 ;3</7 1/,3 9. -./.012* 518*3-, 127 +* +, ;+*4+2 *4. 1-9+*-1*3-, A<-+,7+8*+32 *3 832,+7.- *4. ,16. .. ! "

)$G ! "

&' ( )**+&,' -- & ' ./01 &)**+' 2 3/+( 4! 5 6 "

( &)**,' 3 +)3' C '% 0'

'(!$% ($

6$ 2%'' *-6'($))**$

72%' $ - ?%'' )

'( !*$%2 72%'' 7- '( )

*-2$ $* 72%%

,()

'(($

6=$2% %' %'%!'$ $0.(+$*%/$$?%'

% ! 7- ?$- 9 $ $99% $%' ?$ 72%'' ,( *$ 7%'$'

$?$ '(!*$%2 9!

- 9 <*$/($

$!!)' '(!*$%2 & '(!

9'(% '6'(7%'$'

22%' $ -%**0$*%'-%

0 6)!%$**-6

!'(!*$%2?$

)) - 2$

9 '(6 '( )

' ?$ $7* '

) %' !$ '( 0( % 9%' %'%!'$ $0 < ,( )'%'%

9 '( <CC !' ?$ $* '(9 6 %0('*- 5!' 7- '( 9 *$

* %'%!' B 06 8$%'($* &' ?$ !

79 '( $% ' '($'

)) '

%'- ($% 0?$0% '($))**$ '6*$ 0'

'(% *$'%

9'()% !%)*

$' $* 5 '%! &' ?$ $* 72%'' '($' '( )

3 ($ 9$%* *% '( )$

- 9 2%**% 0 $ ) '( '2 9 '( $02

$' <<< $

6 '(9 6 '( ?$

9$ *'

'( )$' 9 '( ',( '!

! *-'

' 9'(9$!''($'

?%'' '$'2 ! ($ 7 9%* 79 '( 7%'$'

6 $ $ *' ?(%!( '( !*$%2 ?$ $!!)' &' ?$ (* '($' $2)* $

) )

)) '

%'- 9 ($% 0 ($ 7 0$ ' '( $))**$ ' $

6 '(9 6

;

'(?$

% *$'%

9'()% !%)* $' $*5 '%!!!

0*-6'( )'%'%

9 '( <CC !'6 $ $* 75!'%

9%* '( =! '%

?%0('*- %2% <%% ,(%

'9%

'9% '( !%%

'$/

'()'%'%

.!'%

6$$* '($?$ %? 9'( 02 '9 '()! 0)$$0$)(6$$* %? 9'(9$!' '($''($))**$

' 7 '('

'''(!*$%2 9'()

7-9%*% 0?%'' '$'2 *$ 0% ! %'('( ?%'' '$'2 ! ?$ 9%*

$ - % ! ?$ *

%**0$*%'- ?$ !

22%'' %

% 0 '( !*$%2 9 '( )

'6 '( % !* 7-%'$

$!!)'% 0'($26 9!

)

0'($2 72%'

% << & %? 9'($9 $% 6?9%

'($))$*'

'$**-

92%'$

$!!

0*- %2%'($2

" !$

$ !0$0 @('()$/% 0"$

H"A @('() '$7* H"A