High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3009/2024dismissed

S.D.O. Op. Sub Division, Dhbvn And ANR. v. Ramphal

2026-02-18Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain7 pages

# $%&%!'

( )*++, + + +

-+ ./

%0%&%!'1

'!3 4 ++++++ -- 55 '& 0 4&.& 6-3

++++++ &-!'# '

(

78 + 9

9 1 +

"# " $ " "# % & " " ! ' ! ## #" ( %) * %*+

# ! #"# ( ! !

! ! , "( !! *- *% %*+"# ! . /%)0" # !. 1****0 !! , # " ' ! # 2

" !! ! "

, "#

( !! *- *% %*+ ! # ! . -/%)0 $ 3 ! , ! , 2 # ! #!"# $&. 5 ! ( "#

!"! # %- * %*%4 " % & " ! %**

89 : #"# # ! # # ; < 14%** ( "# 0 # ! %** # 89 = %1 ! " ! !! # 89 & !# !

# #" 1/

" ! " !

89 , ( 5 < 4 ! !"#! 0 # < - 89 : " < 4 1* < 4* 5" "" 89 : ( 5 " < 4 1* < 4*

! ! ! " < 4% & #! ! # " " # "

! #!

89 #! ! 2

! < ** +- 89 < !# # 5

< # " < 4

1* < 4* "

# & !< 4

< %**

# < 4 1* < 4* ! " #"

! " # <

# # < 4 879 # " < 4 1* < 4* " #"# < " !!

, " "#< !!#

" ! +- 879 ,< ! " # ! ! ! # # ,! "

! 2 ! " ! 7

! 879 ,! " # ! " ( 879 ," # ! "# < " 0 !

"# ! "2 %% & " ? "#< 41 " # " "# # ! " ! < 4 =! # ! " "# ! 0 # # < ( 5 !

< 4%** " "" ( < 41

%** % & " " #! " < $&. "# # ! & $&. "# 0 ! "# ! " < !

" . " "#$ @ ? < ! 3.5 /3 % $+ 0&+

'41 ),

.-4 6 !.4 :* < ! "

6% 77777 , 2 # 7 !#"

) ;3 4 & .

<%0 &

"%'

5%= !

!4# 4& !"

&- $% 4%/.'

5& $%0%5 $!.47& >.4%&#%$%!'

6.& / 3 5# !

/ ?$5.# # %"

3 4 %&

# @.

4 6 #= !

$%0%5 $!.4& A!.5# '!46 55= #!

&.%+ .$3 -4!0%&%!'1 3!A 0 41 #! & '!

?$5.# 3!& $ & & A3 4 -4!0%&%!'& !"

- 4%$.5 $ '!

/ '

$!6-5% # A%3 !4 & .!4= 4%/.'

& '!

$ # %'

$!'"!46%= A%3 ".'# 6 '

-4%'$%-5 & !"

>.#%$% -4!$ #.4 +

;3 4 3 4 %&

?-4 && / !"

>.4%&#%$%!'

$!.41

6%'

%!'

&$3 6 !"

- 4%$.5 $ !

"%'#

# @.

$= !4 &.""%$% '$= !"

4 6 #% & -4!0%# # = / 4 5 0 '

%& '!

# $%&%0 !

&.& %'

>.4%&#%$%!'

$%0%5 $!.4+ = 7 7 7! ! ! ! "! # 2 # !# " &

" # ! " # # 2 " " # " ! "# "

! !# ""#

"" ","

A >

2 ! ," 819 = #

# # "

!# !""#

3! "

! # !#

849= ! # 7 7

! # 8)9B !

# "

& ! !

"7! " 2 # 8-9 7 # " " # %1 & " D ! E ! < 489 " ! < %) %**

,! ! " "# < !! A #< # < 4* %** A # 8.!

9:%**4 */ *) %**4 %4 # !

#$&.

" < 4 # ! " < < 4 " "" ( < 41%**

) & $&." #" "# , 2 #"# !"! $ %& ' - ' " / $ ! !

+ < ! "

! #

9 )*++,

= ( 0

F = . " '