High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/29187/2023dismissed

Union Of India And ORS v. No. 14504052 M Ex. Naik Kamal Kishore Rana

2024-10-23Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

!

"#$%& '

#$#($) "#$% '

! !

*% +,* --

- .

+,* - -- - * #$ %&' () *# ( + ,

%& # - & *#.+

.

( *#.+

.

"($ *#.+

/

#0 &(

*#.+

!" # / *#.+

-

- .

/ $

/ "

*

"

" &

$

3445#

67 " %&

# 8+ 2% ++ */

%&

/ $

$*

+" $

% &

.6 6. % &"

0)1(020)34 #($"

!

6 ! /

#&59"7::;< / + $ .+ / ::;;:9 = + $

.+ *

/ $

/$ % &% $/

!

"! #$!$%&&'$$"&

()& "*$&#&$+$ #, &- >:?/ 34;;< 4 >?/ 4 :

.

$ +

4

$ + $ % % % $@$ % &

: ? ? / ;;3 4 ? ? / 4A/ * = /

*

#*%

2% ++

$

2

"" + / / .

344 5#

67 2

"

.

"

+

!

"

" # " " " $% $& %''(

%% $) *$$*+($, %* $) *$$*+&$, -% ! &

$!

$#& .

"'# .!

& & ' !% .

/

& $

$ .

0""$& .1 !'' " &!$ ( 0+$2"3#'$4 .

/ "00.

" "

" +),

$ $$

*

"

6

$

/

-(5677#$#819 2 0 $ ")#($ 28# 19 :

1717#$ 3 #

+

6

57. 0$ %&

AB% #"

9 */

%&*

"

A

%

. /

" /

*

2% ++

+

$

& < &* + = % " $ "

3

%&

AB% #"

9 +

0''5

30$ .# 6734 5

&8 9& &,!$:

;$6 .!* + :442

" $ "

3 % +

+

"

" "

"

"

"

.

2

" 3 "

"

4 # "

-

5

" - " " "

"

"

6 #

/

"

6

"

/ 7

/ " "

# " %8"

/

7

" %8"

#

""

#

# $" $ "

5" 7+ & +

+

+ &+ %&

.+ & +

*

& $

""

.

% $

=

&"

*%

$ & " & 6

" & "

*

%&*

& + *

% +$ $

/ &

* = % / *% /

"

% $ +

"

"

& "

$

/

;

+ " $ "

3

*

#"

9

+

A$ 9 / 0

"

+.

$ "

3&

/

. / ""

++ "

0$ $ 0''5

30$ .# 67 3 45

/4 &6!

+ : 8 9& & ,!$1&"

&&

2

. " $ "

/

+

'

#

"

3 " #

/ 9 '

& &$'$ &!$$$! #$#&$<"!$$$ "!$ !

"!

"#&.$&$'$ & #!$ $ 7

#

%$

#

7

#

"

# +.$ $ $'$ &%"& .!$$ $! & '$ !$ ' 23

"

:

" # 7

"

"

"

-(5677#$#819 2 0 $ ")#($ 28# 19 :#$"

$1

*

+

%

0$ "" + %

+ *

%

+ +% %

/ & "

% &"

/

""

+

$ $$57*

/ & 0 % + "

"" $ *

" + +

)$ - + 0$ " %&

AB% #"

9 * ;3*+

0!7$"

-7$49; $7#$#8$"700$"

/ + 7!72::

02#'<#8 < $ 2

. " $ "

.

+

;

. $& %% *$%%

" 5 4 " .

<

%*)' *$%%

$% $% %''8

"

" " "

# "

2

" "

"

"

"

= !:

" "

" $% $% %''8 +),

"

" "

2 "

" $% $% %''8 $% $> *$$'

#

" " <

$8

$) #8197#( 1 : $ *.% &+ & & %&

$$ /

%& +

$ + + $ " %&

++

"*

$ & %

% %&

.+ & +

A/ *

"

%.

"+"

*

$ + %&

#"

9 +

8 9& &,!$: ;$ .!3#'$4 +

6!

+ : 8 9& & ,!$3#'$41

*&

+ ++ *% +$

6

"

.6 6. *% /

% +

& "

&

$

-

&*

"

"

+

" $ "

* ++

5" 7 %&

#"

9 *

+ % $

+

$$

"*

.

% $

$$

/ +$ + + + .6 6.

$$ !

&*

%&

& $ + *

/

+

%

%& &""

.+ & +

/ .

&+ % $% + $

$ $

$$ 8

$/

+ + / + ++ .6 6.

"

/ +$ + + + %

$/

&+ "

* % $

"

%&* & %

+

. + + ++

" *"*

$ .

%&

AB% #"

9 +

+ $7#$#8$"70; 06!10 B* "

'- $27$ <* + */

* +

$*

% + /

++ 2

.

" $ "

++

5" 7

+

& 4"

/

" "

"

- "

<

% * 6'>6?

0-

" @ " ? # (% $% *$$% " 5 0

"

" 5 0

2

2 "

- "

>

3 "

7

" "

" 3

*+

% $

" *"*

$

%&

#"

9 *+

+ $7#$#8$"70; 06!10 =(: 0> =

+ /

5" 7*/

.

$

+ / .6 6.

++

% !

&*

/

$

*.6 6.

++ *

% +

+

$* /

""

=

"

+ * *

/

< (+

.

5" 7 % "+

.

%

2% ++ *

& 42 $

5" 7 ""

" +

*% &

& % :

C &

$ " + A/ * /

/

.6 6.

" *% &+ % $

= 2

* /

% $

.

"

$ 5" 7%

++ & + + +$ + =

" !

&

% $

"

$=

""

$% $ . 4 .

/ +

+ / 5" 7

+ %

" /

%&*

" / * .

5" 7

+ % .6 6.

+ ++ * *

++ *

& *

$ $

/

*

*

+"

* "

*% "

.

% & +

7$02 "

#8197#( 1 ;

9

/

/

% .

*

2

"$ (+

+ %

+

*

"

$ "" + 57* &* 57" =-

- .

> =- - *> '

.

$

9 :

037$4?

0#$ "

% ?# 9 :# 1052

% ?#