High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/58918/2025allowed

Deepak Kumar @ Deepu v. State Of Punjab

2025-12-02Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel6 pages

! " D=$,$,%'!

@!-- $ %& '(

D=-%'*'$ $ %& *+,- $ %& *+,- $ %& *+,- $ %& *+,- $ %& /% $ %& /% $ %& /% $ %& /% .

!-'$ !-'$ !-'$ !-'$. -,%'.

-,%'.

-,%'. + )! 5

+ )! 5

+ )! 5 % *,'0. + )!

% *,'0. + )!

% *,'0. + )! 5

:1 = #

# :1 = #

# 1 1 1 1 %2*= %- &4 *@%+ $ &%! $2 $,$,%'!= != /(,'*! #,'02 #!

4 **,$,% %'

/ '( )= AAAAA AAAAA AAAAA AAAAA 1 1 1 14 = 81;

4 = 81;

# # # # !-'$ $2,!* $,$,%' 2 - ) ' &,/* '*! #+$,%' >6 %& & 2 $,3

!, #!

-2 # '2,$ 8&%! -2%!$ 9 ##:; &%! 0!

'$ %& & !0/ ,/ $ $% $2 $,$,%'! ,' + - ) !,'0 0 %= * $* =5>= >4 !0,-$!* &%!

! %&&'+- ',-2 )/ '*! #+$ $,%'- 6 64 6>4 > E > %& $2

'*, ' '

%*4 75 8&%! -2%!$ 9 :; 8 #+$,%' 65 %& */$* * #+$,%' 65< %& *** / $! %';4 $ %/,+ #$ $,%' 2,// !4 ,-$!,+$ '*2 !=

2 0!

@ ' %& $2 //0 '- ,'-$ $2 $,$,%'! ,- $2 +% / '$4 4 '

/34 # 2,/4 -%' %& B,(

!4 !%!$* $2 $ %'

=5>= >4

!%?, $/3 .65 4 2 C - -$ '*,'0 %$-,*

)%!

$%!34 !

= $ $2 $ $, 4 -,? 3%'0 ' !,*,'0 %' $2! %$%!+3+/-

!% +2* &!% $2 *,!+$,%' %& '(

/ = %'0 $2 4 $2 +% / '$ !+%0',F*

/, - 8$,$,%'! 2!,';= 2 %$%!+3+/- $!'* '

/ *,+ / #$%! '* 2 ** $%C !*- $2 +% / '$= 2 -- '$- ?2%!$* +2 %$2! $% + $+2 2, 4 + -,'0 $2 +% / '$ $% !'= 2 $,$,%'! !

,-*

'* $2 0!% +2 -* ,'$!+$* 2, = 2 $,$,%'! -$!+ $2 +% / '$ %' $2 2 * C,$2

4 + -,'0 2, $% & //= $2' */,@!* **,$,%'

)/%C-G -,'0 $2 !@!- -,*G%' $2 +% / '$:- !,02$ ! = 2 %$2!

',*'$,&,* -- '$-4 ! * C,$2 '* -C%!*-4 /-% ,'&/,+$* ,'(!,- %' 2, = - !-/$4 $2 +% / '$ /%-$ +%'-+,%-'--= ++%!*,'0 $% $2 +% / '$4 $2 ++-* $$ + * 2, C,$2 $2 ,'$'$,%' $%

,//= H2' ' !)3 %/ !

,-* ! 4 // $2 -- '$- &/* $2 -+' C,$2 $2,! !-+$,@ C %'-= 2 %$,@ )2,'* $2 ,'+,*'$4 - -$ $* )3 $2 +% / '$4 C ' @'$ &!% =5>= >4 C2'

)- &!% 2,-

$!'

/ @,// 0 $!

@/* $% 2,'$!',= !,'0 $2,- $!,4 $2 $,$,%'!

- !+%!*,'0 @,*%- %& 0,!/-4 '* $2 +% / '$ 2 * %)(+$* $% 2,- )2 @,%!= 6= 1 !'* +%'-/ &%! $2 $,$,%'! 2 - ,$!

$* $2 $ $2 $,$,%'!

,- ,' +-$%*3 -,'+ 65=5>= >= 1 !'* +%'-/ 2 !0* $2 $ $2 $,$,%'! 2 - )' & /-/3 , /,+ $* ,'$% $2 ,' I-$,%'= 1 +%'-/ 2 !0* $2 $4 &!% $2 & +$ / ,/, %& $2 + - ,' 2 '*4 $2 %&&'+ '*! #+$,%' 65< %& $2 ,- '%$ * %$ ,'-$ $2 $,$,%'!= 1 !'* +%'-/ 2 - &!$2!

!0* $2 $ $2 !, !%-+$,%' C,$'--4 /34 B,'%*

! 8& $2! %& $2 ,'(!*# 2,/;4 C2' ?

,'*

!%-+$,%' H,$'-- %=4 2 - '%$ -%!$* $2 + - %& $2 !%-+$,%'

* - $!'* 2%-$,/J $2 - ,* C,$'-- 2 - @' -) ,$$* )&%! $2 +%'+!'* %!$ %' 56=5= $2 $ ,'(!*# 2,/ 2 /! *3 0%' )!% *= 1 +%'-/ 2 - &!$2! -) ,$$* $2 $ $2 $!, / ,- !%+!

-$,'

$,'0 '* &%//3 $2!%& ,- '%$ $$!,)$ )/ $% $2 $,$,%'!= 1 !'* +%'-/ 2 - !0* $2 $2 $,$,%'! ,-

' C,$2 +/ '$+*'$-= 2-4 !0/ ,/ ,- !

3* &%!= >= 1 !'* #$ $ +%'-/ - - $% / + %' !+%!* $2 +-$%*3 +!$,&,+ $ * $* 5= '* -$ $- !%!$ )3 C 3 %& &&,* @,$ * $*

<== %& # !C ' #,'02 /4 #4 $3 #!,'$'*'$ %& %/,+4 #) ,@,-,%' 2,// !4 '*2 ! 8!

/;4 ,' $2 %!$ $%* 34 C2,+2 ! $

%' !+%!*= ,-,'0 -) ,--,%'- ,' $ '* C,$2 $2 - ,* -$ $- !%!$4 / $ +%'-/ 2 - %%-* $2 !-'$ $,$,%' )3 !0,'0 $2 $ $2 //0 $,%'- ,-* ,'-$ $2 $,$,%'!

! -!,%- ,' '

$! '*4 2'+4 2 %02$ '%$ $% ) ?$'** +%'+--,%' %& !0/ =

@ 2 !* +%'-/ &%! $2 !,@ / !$,- '* 2 @ 0%' $2!%02 $2 @ )/ !+%!*- %& $2 + 7=

2 $,$,%'! C !!-$* %' 65=5>= >4 C2!,'

&$!4 $2 ,'@-$,0 $,%' C - + !!,* %$ '* +2 // ' 2 - )' !-'$* %'

=57= >=

%$ / !%-+$,%' C,$'--- 2 @ )' +,$*4 )$ %'/3 5 2 - )'

,'* $,// * $= $ ,- $2-4 ,'*),$ )/ $2 $ +%'+/-,%' %& $2 $!, / C,// $

/%'0 $, = 2 !,@ / +%'$'$,%'- !

,-* $ !J ,'+/*,'0 C,02$ 0 !I,!* $% ) $$ +2* $% $2 $-$, %'3 %& 2%-$,/ C,$'--4 ' /34 B,(

8& $2! %& $2 ,'(!*# 2,/;J -2 // ) !

$,%+,'

$* %' *!,'0 $2 +%!- %& $!, 2,- %!$ *%- '%$ * ,$ !%!, $ $% */@ * ,'$% $2- !,@

+%'$'$,%'-4 $ $2,- -$ 04 /-$ ,$ 3 !(*,+ $2 $!, %$2,'0 $ '0,)/ 2 )' )!%02$ &%!C !* $% ,'*,+ $ $2 /, /,2%%* %& $2 $,$,%'!

)-+%'*,'0 &!% $2 !%+-- %& (-$,+ %! ,'$!&!,'0 C,$2 $2 !%-+$,%' @,*'+= 7== - ! +-$%*3 +!$,&,+ $ * $* 5= &,/* )3 $2 / $ +%'-/4 $2 $,$,%'! 2 /! *3 -&&!* ,'+ !+!

$,%' &%!

!,%* %& 5 3 !4 57 %'$2- E * 3- E ,- '%$ -2%C' $% ) ,'@%/@* ,'

'3 %$2!

8-;= 7=

'*),$ )/34 $2 !-'$ $,$,%' ,- $2 $2,!* $$ $ )3 $2 $,$,%'! $% -+! !0/ 2 !/,! $C% $$ $- *,* '%$ $ C,$2 -++-- '* $2 $,$,%'- C! C,$2*!

C' %'

=5= > E 5<=5= = %C@!4 ,'0 ,' @,C $2 '$,!$3 %& $2 & +$ $!,? %& $2 + - ,'

'*J -+, //34 $2 & +$ %& $2 $,$,%'! 2 @,'0 -&&!* ?$'** ,'+ !+!

$,%'4 $2 !, !%-+$,%' C,$'--4 '

/34 B,(

! 8& $2!

%& $2 ,'(!*# 2,/; 2 @,'0 $!'* 2%-$,/ '* + %& $!, /J $2,- %!$ ,- ,'+/,'* $% &&,!

$,@/3 +%'-,*! $2 ,'-$ '$ / &%! ) ,/= !%&,$ )/ !&!'+4 ,' $2,- !0 !*4 + ' ) * $% (*0 '$ %& $2,- %!$ --* ,'

6 $,$/* - &,I ' @!-- #$ $ %& !3

&,I ' @!-- #$ $ %& !3

'%$2!

'%$2!J !/@ '$ C2!%& ! *- - '*!.

K5= - ' ,/%0 $% $2 )%@ *,-+--,%'4 $2 &%//%C,'0 !,'+,/- !0.

#+%'*L-++--,@ !0/ $,$,%'8-;

&,/* ,-

,'$ )/ ,' / C E 2'+ -+2 $,$,%' %02$ '%$ $% ) !(+$* -%//3 %' $2 0!%'* %& ,'$ ),/,$3 $2!%&=

#+2 -+%'*L-++--,@ !0/ $,$,%'8-;

,'$ )/ C2$2!

!/,!

$,$,%'

*,- ,--*

C,$2*!

C'L*,- ,--* - '%$ !--*L*,- ,--* &%! '%'!%-+$,%'

%! !/,! $,$,%' C - *,- ,--* %' !,$-= %! $2 -+%'*L-++--,@ !0/ ! ) ,/ $,$,%'8-; $% -++*4 $2 $,$,%'!L /,+ '$ -2 // ) --'$, //3L!$,''$/3 !I,!* $% -2%C -)-$ '$, / +2 '0 ,' +,!+ -$ '+- '* -2%C,'0 %& ! -!&,+, / %! %-$'-,)/ +2 '0 C%/* '%$ -&&,+= 2 $ 2%!,+ ?!--,%' %& - ,'0 -+%'*L-++--,@ ) ,/ / 8-;

%02$ '%$ ) )-$!

+$* ,'$% /,$!

/ ,$!

$,%'- %& $,$,%'8-; C,$2%$ -)-$ '$, /4 &&+$,@ '* +%'-I'$, / +2 '0 ,' +,!+ -$ '+-=

% ?2 -$,@ 0,*/,'- + ' %--,)/3 ) / ,* *%C'

- $% C2 $ C%/* +%'-$,$$ -)-$ '$, / +2 '0 ,' +,!+ -$ '+- - @!3 + - 2 - ,$- %C' ',I & +$-L+,!+ -$ '+=

,'0 -+2

$$ $ ,- '%$2,'0 )$ ' $%, ' '* @%!= !0%4 $2,- ,-- ,- )-$ /&$ $% $2 (*,+, / C,-*% '* *,-+!$,%' %& $2 %!$ * /,'0 C,$2 -+2 -+%'*L-++--,@ !0/ ,/ $,$,%'8-;=

' + - %!$ +2%%-- $% 0!

'$ -+%'*L-++--,@ !0/ ,/ $,$,%'8-;4 +%0'$ '* /+,* ! -%'- ! !$,''$/3 !I,!* $% ) !+%!** &%! 0!

'$,'0 -+2 / *-,$ -+2 / ),'0 -+%'*L-++--,@ $,$,%'8-;= ' %$2! C%!*-4 $2 + - &%!

%!$ @,'0 -++--&//3 +%'$'

'+*L'$!$ ,'* -+2 -+%'*L-++--,@ $,$,%'8-; %02$ $% ) ! *,/3 '* +/ !/3 *+,2!

)/ &!% $2 - ,* %!*! --*=M #&&,+ $% - 34 &!$2! *$'$,%' %& $2 $,$,%'!

'*!$!, / ,- '%$ C !!

'$* ,' $2 & +$- '* +,!+ -$ '+- %& $2 + <=

' @,C %& )%@4 $2 !-'$ $,$,%' ,- //%C*= $,$,%'! ,- %!*!* $% ) !/ -* %' !0/ ,/ %' 2,- &!',-2,'0 ) ,/L-!$3 )%'*- $% $2 - $,-& +$,%' %& $2 1*= %'+!'* L$3 0,-$!

$= %C@!4 ,'

**,$,%' $% +%'*,$,%'- $2 3 ) , %-* )3 $2 +%'+!'* L$3 0,-$!

$4 $2 $,$,%'! -2 // ! ,' )%'* )3 $2 &%//%C,'0 +%'*,$,%'-.

8,;

2 $,$,%'! -2 // '%$ ,-- $2 /,)!$3 0!

'$*= 8,,;

2 $,$,%'! -2 // '%$ $ ! C,$2 '3 @,*'+4 %!

/ %!

*%+ '$ !34 *!,'0 $2 $!, 8,,,;

2 $,$,%'! -2 // '%$ )-'$ 2, -/& %'

'3 * $ )&%! $2 $!, 8,@;

2 $,$,%'! -2 // '%$ +% ,$ '3 %&&'+ C2,/ %'

8@;

2 $,$,%'! -2 // *%-,$ 2,- --%!$4 ,& '34 C,$2 $2 $!, / %!$= 8@,;

2 $,$,%'! -2 // 0,@ 2,- +//2%' ' )! $% $2

'@-$,0 $,'0 &&,+!L# %& +%'+!'* %/,+ #$

'* -2 // '%$ +2 '0 2,- +//2%' ' )! C,$2%$ !,%!

! ,--,%' %& $2 L $3 0,-$!

$= 8@,,;

2 $,$,%'! -2 // '%$ ,'

'3 ''! $!3 $% */ 3 $2 $!, =

' + - %& )! +2 %& '3 %& $2 &%!- ,* +%'*,$,%'- '* $2%- C2,+2 3 ) , %-* )3 +%'+!'* L $3 0,-$!

$ - *,!+$* 2!,'

)%@ %!

-2%C,'0

'3 %$2!

-&&,+,'$ + -4 $2

$L+% / '$ -2 // ) $ /,)!$3 $% %@ + '+// $,%' %& ) ,/ %& $2 $,$,%'!= = !*!* ++%!*,'0/3= 5=

%$2,'0 - ,* 2!,'

)%@ -2 // ) +%'-$!* ' ?!--,%' %& %,',%' %' $2 !,$- %& $2 + = #,'+ $2 ,' + - 2 - )' *+,**4 '*,'0 ,-+// '%-

/,+ $,%'4 ,& '34 -2 // /-% -$ '*- *,-%-* %&&= 8# 1 # 1 # 1 # 1;

+ )! 5

@,!

H2$2! -

,'0L! -%'*.

-L % H2$2! !%!$ )/.

-L %