High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/199/2024allowed

Nancy Ghuman v. State Of Punjab

2024-01-18Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari16 pages

!"!"# $%& '!! #( )* '# !

! " %+&,-. %'/0 1'%,2 3/ %

%'+/#-%1,2 , %'

/'/ %0 1,2 %/4% %0 1'% 1&5 - ! " # !/%&+// 41/4%% 2%,&6+ /&%%/%-+6 %+,%+&6 %- 61 (" 7, , 8 1&,%' 88 8%09&,%'

1 :81 81 7 1 1 *1 " ,,, &-;&6.<1 %+%, '=/ 1 %( /+ %/'

'&6. ,1 / 0/4%&% ,

&,/ ("166./- ,6&% 0/% > /&- ,? &,*/&4,%5'+/!/ 66+ / 4% % / / / , &446, @ &%%. /% > /&- ,? &,*/&4,%5'+/1 ,1// , 6+%2%, @&%%. ,6&%4%%%0/%3/&

: !/ ("/&0%%0 %2,

*/ %4&%'+/ , ,4'+/1% %%.+66+

%0 &6 6.1 3/& % + / 2% . &/ % %0 ,3/&%2%. .66+ 6 %01/ %3 %+%,0%6./-,%@%%0 !/%62 >% / (">% ,/% %

" # $% %

% ! ! &' " # $( $ $ ) % % $

$ % *

! ) % % + ,+ +- . .

) !

/ $0 12-+#3 4 $ # # %

# %

'/2+ / ("13//00, &4%+% 8 1/ %0 ,.&046,1% /% / -%/,&1/%%1,0,04% 2/%&+/6., 3// /4% 8 !/6 %,' &6/ 46 ,%%, &%4%1

&%/, , 2 0,% '+/ = /61 '1 4&.

'&4%,61'&- 2=/ 1 %( /+ %/'

& !/ &%4%0 @//% %>% ,%26 A

4%+% / ("1 % ,3 ,&,1 3/%&41*/ %4&%'+/ , ,4'+/3% 44%/,, , 463 6%2%,%0/3 */ %4&%'+/1/32%1 -5 -6 %63 %2%,%0 ,4'+/ 4/+ -5 -6-+%2%,%0 ,4'+/1/3 6 %%,

6+3/*/ %4&%'+/ 8 1 ,1/%2%,463 B, 7 !/ %%+ &, */ %4&% '+/ , ,4 '+/6,0 * / ,&%'+/ ,'/ 54%'+/

&,/ ("13/3% %%, 8 &%+ %/1 6 60 ,: -%463 %2%,%0/%+/4@3

&,'/ 54%'+/13//3 @4641 ,1/ %- %+%+% *! 71 %2%,%0/013

6 @464(&%/%0%1&4%%+ 1 &, * / ,&%'+/ 6+ %2%, 6 6 0 ,46 :8 -%1 4&%& / ,6&% 0 &,% ' 7 / ", 2,13//3 6 @464

4 &%/% %%+ &, * / ,&% '+/ , '/ 54% '+/1

%0 '+/ ,

65 '+/ 3% 6 0 , &,/ ("13/3%%&6 6. %%, 8 8 &%+ %/1 6 6 0 , 46 :8 -% / 3 %2%,%0/%+/4@/3

%0 '+/ ,

65 '+/13//3% @464 !/&%/%%%+ &,* / ,&%'+/1 0 , A 8 1%&6,0

%-/ '+/1/ ,+ %/

61 &,/ ("1 ,1&,%' 1

:81817 1 *"3% 6 ,,, #7 8 1

%-/ '+/1/ ,+ %/613

,/2+ / ("1-./ '1%6 =/ 1/32%1,+/2620/00/ 1/3 6+!/% %1//&) C@/!/ 3 %/,/4%&4 6&66%1* &%13//%&6, %2%.&%%.% &0 1A18 ?13//3%B, -./ 0"0!

> 6 !/% %1 &, %/=&0 % 6 %5 3 %%, / (" A 1/- /4%,&3 %% , 3//4%0/ '&- 2 6)&, 6 +% 1=/

4%%+ &, %/=&0 % 6 %5 1 '

,4 '+/ 6 '3 6 0 , &,/ (" 8 7 , /3 %,+6. %%, A 7 4 %%1 '

,4'+/ 6 '&%,,6&% 0 ,+%2%, 6 60 ,46:8-% 6+3/ 62 %%,+:8-% 46 ,6 60 ,46: -% 6+3/A62 %%,+:

-%13//3% @464 !/%%+ &,'

,4'+/ 6 '6, 0

%4%'+/ 6

44. &,/ (" 7 13/3 %%, 7 * ,&4/,6&% 0

%4%'+/ 6

44.16 60 ,46:8-% ,A 62 %%,+:8-%3%%2%,13//3% @46 4%2%1&4%%+ &,'

,4'+/ 6 ' ,

%4%'+/ 6

44.1:

7 1'

,4'+/

% , */&4,%5'+/ 6 */, 3% 6 0 ,

&,/ ("&6 6.1 &,'

,4'+/ %3

%%,:

7 ,- ,&4/,6&% 016 ,46: -% 6+3/A62 %%,+: -%3%%2%,1 3//3% @464 :

&%+/&%2+ 1/%2%,62 %%,+

, %03%%> 0 ('C1/ 1'' %13/ %4%. , !/ & %4% &%/%0 @ %26 / %+% %1 &, */&4,%5 '+/1 > /&- , / 4% 4%13 %%, : ,,&%+%%+ 1/&%,

,6&% 0&? 7/", 2,1 3//6, %2%.6 60 ,46:8-% 6+3/ 62 %%,+ :8-%1 @&%%.3%/8

?9 @&%%.

? , @8

?< , 4 4%&,/ 0 . /&0 94%4%< : :13//3% @ 464 4%%%+ ;& &%%.1 &, */&4,%5 '+/ , / / / , 4%, / %2%, @ &%%.3// %6%3 . /&0 94%4%<1& 3//1 / / , 4 0 0& , / %0 + 0& 8

?/ ,-+%2%,-./0 &%/%,6,/ / .0 ,4%%&,-./0%4%+/ @&%%. % /4 . /&0 94% 4%< ,/%2%, 4% 6-6+ . /&0 94%4%<%,+6.1 &? % * , " 3% ,,,1 ,1 / 4%

4% 3 0 , &,/ ("2, %.

, , :??

: 8 !/% %1 /4%4% 3 %%,/ : ,,&%+%%+ 1 / , /%+&6-.

@+ ,0/ // ,+2/ @&%%. ,/%4 4% /%>/&- ,? &,*/&4,%5'+/!/% %1 A :1 /4%4%&%, ,6&% 0&? 7/", 2, ,4&%& /%1/+%2%,6&%4%%

,-6 @6&%,- + +

@&%%.8

? 9 68

?<13//3% @464 A !/6 %,%&6%/4%/ %+&,/ / ;& 21 %% , / 41 3&6, 0 @ >466.6 %/ /2+ %%,& % /%%&6 4&6 1 0, +6+/4%/ ("1 ,4/%/ 2+%%3//00/

66+,%0 7 !6,2+&%/ %+&0;& 6046 / 4%1 / 6 %, % &6 &-0 / 2620 / 4% / (" %4%& ("

, , 7 813//3 %+%,-./4% * 65'+/

&9&%%, ,2%&6+ 2%0<1&,%':7A1

,8 A"1 '26C1 '/4%%0 , &&&6&%+2* 65'+/ &("

/6 %3 ;&44,3/ 6/ % ,, 0/4%

32%13/// % 0- 0&- % -61/4%6, 046 9>&% 7< , * 65 '+/ & -% / / %0 1D000 !/ 6 %, % &6 / &%/% %+&, / / / % 0/4%,,,/%1 13+0.3/

-2 0,4%1/4%3 14%%%+% / ("1 6 66.046 ,(" , ,7 : 1&,%' :

:1:8 1:8 1:8 *1:8 1: 1

1 *"1%+%,

'D0661 %'' % 32%1/ ,("1/ 4%3 +% ,/ 4 %.- 6-. %, *//&%12,%,%, , : 8 1%,%, A !/ 6 %, % &6 / 6 46 , %6 &4 >&%813//04 %,%0 ,-. %, */ / &%1 1 &4 D 8A 1 3/%-.1 / 2+ + +.3 %% ,%06+/( 64%1(" , ,7 : 1>43/4%%6 2/&%!/%62 >% %,%, , %4%,&,/% % 5! ! .

.3 '$ ! 6).

..3 '$ $ 8 * % %)9 ( $*

* % :2 / / $ .

2;,;,, :2/ /$ < % /

**$ $ '

% *

7 ,$

( <

!/6 %,%&6&-0/ 3//&5 -6 6, %% ,4%&/4%(" , ,7 : 0&/ 1/3 +% , 4 %.- 6/% ,6+/ 6%% ,1 &,4 /&5 -6 ,%&6, 00, %%/4%/ ("1 :1,4 /%/ 2+%%3//0 &,%/ 66+,6.

%2%, @&%%. /61/6 %,%&6/ %+&,/ / 4%/ - %% +,/ ("166./,6&% 0/%>/&- ,13/3 %%, :13/% 1/ 4%,,/ 2 .%%3//%>/&- ,1

%/%,2%/. % 8%2%1/%2%.1 /3 / 2-,%0/4%1 @&%%.8

? ,

6&%4%%1 6 46 ,%2%. !%+// %+&0;& 46 ,%2%.9&4% <1/ 6 %,%&6/ %+&,/ 3//&5 -6%0 , &&&6 %%+/4%(" , ,7 : 1

44%// ,%44,&4/0,/4%/ /0 .

-0 4%. 6046 13/%&41/+ 66, !$ 0% /%%,%/%&%. ,, 32%1 3//46 6%,% ,,//&/4%1/.

0@3 -& !$ 0% ,/.@ .

/ $.0/!$ 0% 1%,%&- /% 6

66+ ;& %2%.

,/ $.0/!$ 0% -%02,1/%.;& %2%.1 ,-./2+ +

+.13&6,/ 2-0>4, , 6, : " % / 66+ ;& /4%4+3 4%%,1 /6 %,%&6 %+&/ / ,

66+ %,1 0&/ 1/%4 4%/4% 613/%&41/6,+,

7 , , :

,/%&413+/ + ,,%1/4% 446,%, 4%1 3// 3 %,+6. &, -. / 04 &/%.

%,1 % 66+/%%4 4%" 1/&%%4 4% /4%&,./2+ +%1(" , , 7 :

6.1-.,% 3+ /&%3 %,>&% :13//04%/%,%13/%-.1 &,* / ,&%'+/1 '/ 54%'+/1*/ %4&%'+/1

65'+/1

%0 '+/1 ,4 '+/1'

,4'+/ % ,'

,4'+// 2-+% ,/ - 6-./6 %,,, 6')&,+%,1/ 6 %,%&6/ % 2,%/4%-+% , 4 %1-.

+% +/%/%+&6 %- 6

8 1/6 %,' &6/ 2/06.44, /+% %+&6 %- 6/4%1/+%&,/ 1/ / -& 6,%1 0&/ 1 %%0/4%("1/ 6 262,(" , ,7 : 1&,%':

:1 :8 1:8 1:8 *1:8 1: 1

1 *"1%+%, 'D0 661 %'' % A

/ &%/% %+&,/ /&64 -6./4%&6, - % ,%0/ / 6./+%2%, @&%%.

, 6&% 4%% %0 /% /&1 -& / 3 6 B, 3 4%1 ,1-//4 4%1// ,% 266, -% ,%2%1 / 4% 3 366 &/ 3/ /% > /&- , /%&+/ D/ 44 661/%%1// %+/6.-0 , &,1 /- ,6&% 0/%>/&- , 7

/ &%/% %+&,/ /&+/6@/ - -6/, -3/4% ,/%>/&- ,? &,1/32%1/6@ -34% ,/% &,1%03/0 &0-%66+

%0/ 2-%2%,1.- -6/,13// 6.-, /%&+/2+ !/%%1%6 +/4%- 63&6, %&6/%/ 04%+/4%+%+2+ 6.1/6 %,' &6/ %+&,/ / ('C%4% 6 -6// /&%%.%2%,%0/ 4% % @&%%.1/%%1/4%,,%2 /%+&6 %- 6

*% 0- %@+ &4 / 4% 2 6& + /

%+&0 ,,%,-./6 %,&6%/4 % ,4+ ,3 .4&4/ 41 ,0,04% 2 4&% 2%230+ 6+ 64%4 :

0=< 4!/- 4%46 %0 65&%4%&,3 6 ,,3-./ E-6'&4%0&%1 .- @716 ,0 %@5&,+06,

!"#$#!/4%46 ,%/0,+&/,&, 0 6%+/1 /%,%6 /&", !/&+//&,%6.+

-52-/,, 4%&% . 6 -6.

&,%% 613/& .21/32%1 /4% &, -&%,/%31/,04&6%. : !/%+/ 4,.% 6/%+/ , , 4% 32%13/6,,+ 446 %%+&6 %- 61/&% / 66 6 @ ,% / &, 0 6 4%4 %0 5&%4%&,13//F/4%&04G1-,/+% 2.

9<262, : "F%&

'( )

*" / E-6'&4%0&%/ %%,,/663+ (3 $) $$ '$>-1;?,//@ 1@811 $

% * %8 ,:( * % %

*$$

< * $ ( % $)-, %

$*A /

/ 7 B 8=

C.(-, / :@ :- 1;,/ D0:2,E $'

$ $ % $

$ % $$ *% )

$$ $% (% % * G! / * 9 $ $

$% (B70

) = C.(-2.;

22/ D0 - E% $ % % -1% 2- /

A /

% % $%% $* -:%

2:(% $ $*

% <$

< $*

-1 * %%$ %

$ < '

* ( = A C.(-2.2@212,/ D0 ,:E% % * % ) *

%* %%$ A /

A /

* * $*

) * * $*$ $ (%

$ $

% $ < .

% '

) * %

*. $*

* *

) %. $*

$ $ ,1/ % $ $*B (* 0

)7 $ C>-:1?//, ; -:1//>/ ?E>//, , ?

$ $ *'

$ * %

$ * H '

. $ * %

$ $*%

. , 4 ,-(3 >".

?C>-:1? //1-:1//>/ ? E% $ $*3 %0%

)

>//,- ,-? $< $

$ %

< '

$4 2;(.!=(/.70 ( "=7/=>, 6 11;@ 2-? & $%

<$*

$ '

*F *%

H $ %

4 ( F % $ % *

% '

.* $ * *'

* $4 :: 61 (+ ,-- .

( / . (

( (+ --%

** / E-6'&4%0 &% / , &4 %@+ 4% - . ,2,& 6E6-%. 366 /%/.1+% %%&+ - 6!/%62 >% /5&,+09&4% <%4%,&,/% % 2 * $$ *

$ $$% **

$ * *% $

* F * H *

% $

$ '

* *

$ *

!/ &%/ ,%, / %+&0 ,,%, -. / 6 %,&6%/4 % ,> 0,/ 4/ &///% -2>% ,6,6+ 64%469<6 3 , /,%,4/ / 4 0 -6%-+

663,!/%0%0//% %>% ,% :8 "/4% 1/4%/ ,0,6.- %% .,

&,/,6&% 0/%> &- ,1/32%1 ,4 6+ , , . 4%+%+ 2+ 1 / 2+ +

+./ - -6 -6/ .6@-3/4% ,/ &,*/ %4&%'+/1 3/0/4%("3 66.

%+%,1/- %%0 !/6 @ . /4% ,/0 &,/ -,,1% /%/ - +% 66. ,0,-./2+ + +.1/ &%4%1

&%/,-%/&%!/%62 >% / &%4%1 3/%1 / -2 +% ,0 / - 0 ,1 >% , /% %

< + $% 7*3

% $% 7*3

' $

7* 3 % %

$ % % ' * 54 :A !/ -2>% ,4 %/ &%4%6 2%0%

. ,&- / 1 2 % 44%> 0/1 >& / 4% ,/0 &,*/ %4&%'+// .&% ,/ 2+ :7 " % / /4% ,/%>

/&- , %,1 66+, -0 -6/,1 /&+/ / 2+ + +./ 6,3// &%4%/%/ D/ 44 666+ /4% ,'0% '

0%13/ /&%%34%E>/&- ,? &,*/&4,%5'+/1 /32%1 / ,%, 0, / &%1 / , %/ & % 642,%/%62 4&%4!/% % ,% 3+ / -2 % , ++ . %,-6. / D/ 44 666+9&4% <1/ 1% 66/ , 66 %,%6.

-3/4% ,/%>/&- ,? &,*/&4,%5'+/1 % /%/ 0 %-3/4% ,/&%%3/ 4%E>/&- ,1 ,,6.1/00& 1 .0 , /%&+// , 661 44% /4%, :14/ %% 4%E > /&- ,? &, */&4,%5 '+/1 / 3

%%, :" % /%/ 666+ 44% + /4%, :%,1/ 0 ,46 . 6.30, 661/%%100& &6,-,0,/ 2 @46 / , : !

@+,% / 6.0 ,/% -21/% % &64 %. 2, 6 -6 %%,1 / +1

/ 4%1 3// 0 . /% 3// 66+, %0 " % / 66+ ;& /4%-+B,34 4% /%62 0 %%,1/6 %,%&6%/4% / /% -2 %,%, >46 /%1 3// , - > 0,1,&%+2+ 1-./2+ + +.%2%1

&,/4%1%03/066+ 6 %03% 66+,6.%2%,1 / 2 6% ,.-+% ,/%+&6 %- 61 ,12+

6.0461/%%1@4+/4%-/,/- %1 3// &%, %% 44%>H0/1 4%/%&,.

% 46 ,%%,-.6 %,' &613&6,%2+ &6 4&%4 : ;&6/,&0 ,/% -21/&% ,0 44%4% +% /%+&6 %- 6/4% !/%%13/&00+&4/0% ,%&0 / 4% 1/4%4)**+,-.!/4%%,%,- %6 , - 6 &%/+ - 6 -, , &%. -, / %, / )&, 6 +% ?% 6 &%?

,+ 446 9<1 .1 ,,4, %,+6.

"6 %,/ ./+-%2,/% -2/ 66/ 2 /0%/% 6 ,0 %,,+/4% 46. /! " 0 ( .-123.-4 "5-65-478-)923:;4-)7+3-. -7;+ "5-65-44-8+46)<*- -7;+