← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3627/2025allowed

Bimla Devi And Others v. Manoj Kumar Jindal And Another

2026-04-21Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal15 pages





       

 !"#$%&'((

!$%$)%*#$%&'(+(

,-$.##$%&'(+(

 

 !"

#$$

%!"&"



'

(&!

)



 !

#"$

  &  /0

( 12   30

*!" +

!, -

,  !

.'/   0

!,   0 /   0/

$$ ",

!, )2  0 

/    0

!, -"0  3  4  0 

/   0/

!, 5!&

 !/   0/

!, )

!

/   0

!, %$& 5 6&!/   0/

!"$

",

12   304(

5 "

1

"7 $$ 2 '& 2

0!

 , 8, 

$""





 "!0 )& 2/ 

$/ . !94/ .  

$$ 1

2 '& 2

0!

8, ,  $""

3 )& 2

)!, "

/ : &!/ "& 1

0!

,

;

"6

 

0!4/ $!"

"  9 !1!!

$!

 !

!2  "&",



,



'

(&!

)

 "&

"& "$010 $!1 !

2!

"

, <, 

=>,* 

"?&  !1

$!

'& 0

,

0"

1

 

 !"

>0&

2!

"

, <,  ?& 

"&!  6 "

!"

1&4

"0!9

/ "&

. 

! & "

2

*$

( !/

5 "

: &!/

"!0



$

! 1!

!1!!

@  "& 

7,

,

"

$!

2!

"/

 "

" !

1>

",/ / / A

5.

3!

!"

;14

B6 ",  "&

", / / A

;14

B6 "

"

 9

$

!

"

4

0" /

$!"

""",  !0$

=>,* "

>0&

!2!

>0&

"



1>

, , ,

,

!!

, , / 1&! !

"&

", / / A

;14 B6 " $

0"

?& . 0

"

!0$

=>,* >0&

,<

!!

, , /

.

110

&92"!!/ : &!

6$

.

1

9 "

" !

>$ ""

!2"!

"

 / 9&  4

$!"



,

!!

.4"

9

.

$!1 ! $!

!0/ 9&

1

906

&,

,

 2

0

 , , D ""&

1

"/ !?&"  

>0&

"

 .!/ !$4 2

"

2

0

2!

0 0

!

"

4

!1

1

"

"

"

!$4

 4

!

$!"

5 " $>/

: &!/

, , ,

,



1

2 "



>0& / "& "&

, , 8,

<,

1

- ",

 1

" .!

"

3!

$! !4

9'0

!2!

  94/ 

0&"

0

/ "& 9

9!!



0,/ .! !"

!"/ 2&

"

.!  , "

6

1

.4"

9

.

$!1 !  !

$!

!0/ . !"/ 11/ .

.

$!1 ! $!

!0,

<,

1

- , 1

"$! .!

" /

!" 0!

$! !4

9'0

", !!

$!

$!

"

5> 0/ 1!

, ,  / 0"

94

", / A &

9 2

6

2

!

0!0&" 0"/ 2

! "0

",/ / / A

 !

2

6

$0,

"

6

2!

"

9

<

>0& / 9& !

"

4

"&9"?&

 /

!

9

$ !!

9

.

$!1 ! $!

!0

. !"

1

.4"

9

.

$!1 !  !

$!

!0,  "

"

6

$ """"

!?&" 1&

>0&

"



;!

$ 2"

$!"



""&"

.! 1! +

5'( 3676! 76 #8%#.%7  9*)7# . .:!;%7 7$ --#.7#(+('.%#$<7.=%#76%7=! .- *$% =#!.7=$% $8

(4'44> 8!$; 76 ,-.=%7=88 .%# = )# 7?$ !*=,7  !:.!#=%: 76 .;@

( 3676!76,-.=%7=88= .-?.A !.#A.%#?=--=%:7$ ,!8$!;,.!7$8*$%7!.*7@

( 3676! 76 ,-.=%7=88 =  %7=7-# 8$! 76 !-=8 $8 ,*=8=*,!8$!;.%*$8*$%7!.*7>.:!;%7@

  +( 3676! 76 ,-.=%7=88 =  %7=7-# 8$! . #*! 8$! ,!;.%%7 =%B)%*7=$% ! 7!.=%=%: 76 #8%#.%7  8!$; --=%: $)7>.-=%.7=%:> ;$!7:.:>7!.% 8! $! *!.7 .%A 76=!# ,.!7A =%7! 7 $"! 76 )=7 ,!$,!7A=--:.--A.%#8$!*=<-A4. ,!.A#8$!@

( 3676! 76 )=7 $8 76 ,-.=%7=88 =  %$7 ;.=%7.=%.<-=%76,! %78$!;@  (

-=8(C

,

*!"



 !

!"$0  0,

,

! &!/ . 

 >0&

2!

"

!0$

",/ / / A

 /

"""

"&



9

9

$!



9

.

$!1 ! $!

!0

$ """"

!?&" 1&

>0&

"



 

$!1!!

$$/ . 0  .

1!"

$$

"&

0! 1!"

$$



9

9

$!



$ """"

!?&" 1&

."/  !1 !/

.

$!1 ! $!

!0,

22!

"

0"

/

1

 "&

$!"

$$,

D,

B!

" $!"

.! !

8,

"! &"4 &!2

!

"

$$ 1!"

$$ !!

0! "&, "&9

"!94 1

$!



9

.

$!1 ! $!

!0, B!

" !1!!

!

!

0& !4  

!0

0", !2&

00

"

=>,*  &

 9

6

" !

1!

0

9

$!



0

"

1!,

!2&

!

0!0&" 0"/ 1!"

$$

!!



$ """"

!?&" 1&

",

 ,

  

"&9

!



" $$! !"$

24

1

2"

!0

1!"

$$

90&"

9

9

$!



9

.

$!1 ! $!

!0

"&110

1&

"$ " >0&



"

 "&9

!

 "

$!

"&

!

",,

0!

!

0!

!/

00"





9

9 "

" !

B!

 " "

!1!!

!

!

0& !4  

!0

0",

,



"

"&9""



!

" $!",

,

"

!2!

"0 $

"0

$$/

.

"

$!

$ "

.

*& '9

E!4 / "0

$$"

$!1!!

!

9 !

$$"

!

0

<

*& '9 &!"

0/ 8D

!

0



3*3, 1!

!2!

0

9 

'& 2

&$!

0"



   0  .%# $76!  1>  6.%#!=D. .%# $76! 4 '   '  1  .

'& 2

0""

  



         



!! "

#    

        

 $

4 &$

.



.

1 !"

'& 2 "/

?&"

.

!?&!

9 1!

,

>0&

2!

"

, <, 

=>,*  !0$

!

"

4

", / / A

 !

"&

", / / A

"

 =

 !."/

&4 $!



"  2

 0,

10/ $!"

!

! !2!

>0&

2!

"



$4

",/ / / A,

4

""&

""

. ""

11,  '& 2

!!"/ .

&

9

"" 

!1!

!

0& !4

 9!

&2

!0

0",

<,

"$$

""

> *F,

11 / "&9

> 

 0 1/

"$4 !!

, , / 6$

.

1

110

&92"!!/ : &!

9 "

" !

>$ ""

"



.!/

"

11 / 9"

&4

!1!

94

1&

00 =

2

0

=>,*D/

!1!

94

1&

"$010 00



-

4  "/ > 

 0 1 "

"

2

"

1&

0 ?&"A !1"

$ """"

?& 9 "

" !

11 / . 0 "

 9

".

91 !

&92"!!/ "

4 ""

$!"



9 "

" !

>$ ""/ 9&

"

.! 2 !

$!

"

11 

!+

5( 6.7 $% #.7# ('(' 76 #,$%%7 ?.=7# 8$! 76 #8%#.%7  =% 88=* $8 )<

:= 7!.!4.%.)!.76 =-$;,-9.%.)!.-$%: ?=76 <.-.%* .- *$% =#!.7=$% .%# 9,%   $8 76 .- ## =% 8."$)! $8 76 #,$%%74 <)7 76 #8%#.%7  #=# %$7 *$; =% 76 88=* $8 )<

:= 7!.!4 .%.)! 8$! 76 9*)7=$% $8 76 .- ## =% 8."$)! $8 76 #,$%%7( 87! 76= 4 76

D

#,$%%7;.!D#6= ,! %*=%76 88=*$8)<

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

,

=

2

0

 , , D

=>,*,D/

""&

11/

!1!

94

1&

$!0&!

00

4 2 !G

"

$!"

110

&9 2"!!

9 "

" !

>$ ""

.4"

9

.

$!1 ! $!

!0, !

$ !

2

0

!+

5( 6.7 $% #.7# ('(' ;A *-=%7 ?.=7# 8$!A$)=%6 =-$;,-9.%.)!?=76<.-.%* .- *$% =#!.7=$%.%# 9,%  $876!:= 7!.7=$%8$! 9*)7=$%$876 .-#.#=%8."$)!$8;A*-=%74 <)7 A$) #=# %$7 *$; =% 76 6 =- $;,-9 .%.)!8$!769*)7=$%$876 .-##=%8."$)! $8 ;A *-=%7( 87! 76=  ;A *-=%7 ;.!D# 6=  ,! %*=%76$88=*$8)< := 7!.!4.%.)!( +( 6.776!.87!;A*-=%7.,,!$.*6#7$A$) .%#!E) 7#7$9*)776 .-##=%8."$)!$8 76 ;A *-=%7 .87! !*="=%: $8 <.-.%* .-

8

*$% =#!.7=$%.;$)%7. ,!.:!;%77$ --#7( ('('( )7 A$) ."$=## 76 .; $% $% ,!797$!$76!( ( 6.7 ;A *-=%7 ?. >=  .-?.A  !.#A .%# ?=--=%: .%# 7=-- !.#A 7$ ,!8$!; 6=  ,.!7 $8 *$%7!.*7=((.:!;%77$ --#7(('('. ,! 7!; .%#*$%#=7=$% $876 .;(C ,

H$

$!&"

!0 / !2"

00

"

=>,*

!

$!

&0

> 

 0 1

"""

 !

" ",

10/ " "$4

  , 3 

 !/ !

"

11/ 91 ! !

, , 

!9&

 0, ."/  !1 !/

!

$!



00

.,

9"!

1!"

$$

9'0

9

!"



! "

0&



/  !1 !/ &

9 "



9

$!

 / !!

&", 

0&

9

$!



00 .

!4 90&"

> 9

9'0

/ .

&

"$ "

!?&!

$!

 "

00 .,

!

, ,  $""

! &!/

!+

! %7& 6(67.%6.!;.4#"$*.74 8$!,-.=%7=88( 8%#.%7$(.-!.#A %&'  "=#$!#!#.7#+((( 6() 6=-2.) 6=D4#"$*.7 8$!#8%#.%7$('( ( $#.A *.  ?.  8=9# 8$! !<)77.- "=#%*4 =8 .%A $76!?=  8$! .!:);%7 ( 6( 67.%6.!;.4#"$*.78$!,-.=%7=886. .,,.!# .%#7%#!##$*);%7 9( (''7$ ('+"=#6=  7.7;%7 !*$!## ,.!.7-A( #B$)!%;%7

 

$):67( .!#( E) 7 .--$?#( $?4 *.  =  .#B$)!%# 7$ '(( 8$! !<)77.- "=#%*4 =8 .%A$76!?= 8$!.!:);%7 ( #>  )%70=;<6.

 4.%.)! (((C

D,



00

"

=>,*/



00

 !

I ! ) ;9"7

!""

IEH/ *$&!/  7,

. !



11, 9"

&4

 9!

&2

!0

$!

  ! ) ;9"

4 

11,

10/ 

00

" / 0!10 1!

C3C3C  "

$!

&0 / "  !

A"

 ! ) ;9"

  0&!!

00

"



"

$!

$!

%

(&!

)

, 5 !

!1!



,,/ 

'

(&!

)

, -

 

$!

 .  !

!

9.

%

(&!

)

, 5 !

!

/

11 /

> 

  0 1



2

0

$!

$!

$!

!

1!

.

&



!!

.

 1!

$!

$!

1!,

8,

0"

((1%D.7 61 (((( )!76A  <A0 .%#$76! 4 F4  $> &!/

. 

"0&"" ""&

""

. ""/ 

!2 1!

>0&

!0 

0!/ &"

$!





.

$!1 ! $!

!0, "



&"

""

. ""



$!0 $> 



. 0

9 $

&"

9 $!



9 9, !

9"!

1!

'& 2

$>

!+

5'( 6 ?$!#  G!.#A .%# ?=--=%:H =;,-A 76.7 76 ,-.=%7=88 ?.  ,!,.!# 7$ *.!!A $)7 76$  ,.!7 $876*$%7!.*77$76=!-$:=*.-%# $8.!.  76A #,%# ),$% 6=  ,!8$!;.%*( 6 *$%7=%)$) !.#=% .%#?=--=%:% $%76,.!7$8 76,-.=%7=88= .*$%#=7=$%,!*#%77$:!.%776 !-=8$8,!8$!;.%*(876,-.=%7=888.=- 7$=76! ."! $! ,!$" 76 .;4 6 ;) 7 8.=-( $ .#B)#: ?676! 76 ,-.=%7=88 =  !.#A .%# ?=--=%: 7$ ,!8$!; 6=  ,.!7 $8 *$%7!.*74 76 *$)!7 ;) 7 7.D =%7$ *$% =#!.7=$% 76 *$%#)*7 $8 76 ,-.=%7=88 ,!=$!4.%# )< E)%77$768=-=%:$876 )=7.-$%: ?=76 $76! .77%#=%: *=!*); 7.%* ( 6 .;$)%7 ?6=*6 6 6.  7$ ,.A 76 #8%#.%7 ;) 7 < $8 %* =7A7$<,!$"#7$<."=-.<-( =:678!$; 76 #.

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



=%*$;(  6.  %$ ,!$,!7A4 =76! ;$".<- $! =;;$".<-( !,-.76.76= !.#A7$,.A76 *$% =#!.7=$%4 ?=76$)7 .%A ;.7!=.- 7$ )< 7.%7=.776= ,-.4*.%%$7<.**,7#(7= %$7 %* .!A8$!76,-.=%7=887$,!$#)*!.#A;$%A4 <)7 =7 =  ;.%#.7$!A $% 6=  ,.!7 7$ ,!$" 76.7 6

6.  76 ;.%  7$ :%!.7 76 *$% =#!.7=$% .;$)%7( 9*,7 76 7.7;%7 $8 3'4 76! =  .< $-)7-A %$ "=#%* 7$ 6$? 76.7 76 ,-.=%7=88

6. 76;.% 7$;.D.!!.%:;%7 8$!,.A;%7 $8 *$% =#!.7=$% )%#! 76 !*$%"A.%* .:!;%7( (  6 ## $8 !*$%"A.%*4 *$%7.=%  . *-.) 8$!,.A;%7$8=%7! 7$%76*$% =#!.7=$% .;$)%7 $804>( $?"!4 76 ,-.=%7=88 6.  ,-.## 76.7 76! =  %$ .:!;%7 7$ ,.A 76 =%7! 7( 6=  6$?  76.7 76 ,-.=%7=88 ?.  %$7 !.#A 7$ ,!8$!; 6=  ,.!7 $8 76 $<-=:.7=$% .  ,! 76 .:!;%7(

)!76!4 76 ,-.=%7=88 6.# ;$!7:.:# 76 ,!$,!7A ?=76 76 <.%D .%# 76 <.%D 6.# $<7.=%# .% .?.!# .:.=% 7 76 ,-.=%7=88( 36%76 )=7,!$,!7A?. ,)7),8$!.)*7=$%476 #8%#.%7  ,.=# 76 %7=! .;$)%7 7$ 76 <.%D ?6=*6 ?.  ,.A.<- <A 76 ,-.=%7=88 )%#! 76=  .?.!#( 6=  . ,*7 .- $ =%#=*.7  76 *$%#)*7 $8 76,-.=%7=88( 99 99 99 (  .D=%: .% $"!.-- "=? $8 76 ;.77!4 76 7!=.- *$)!7 6.  !=:67-A 6-# 76.7 76 ,-.=%7=88 ?. %$7!.#A.%#?=--=%:7$,!8$!;6= ,.!7$876 *$%7!.*7( 6 =:6 $)!74  ( ) ) B) 7=8=# =% !"! =%: 76 ?--!. $%# B)#:;%7$8767!=.-*$)!7(C

 ,

!

10"

$!"

0"/

4

9

.

$ """"

!?&" 1&

"/ "! 24 ""&

2

0

1!

!2

1

"&

;9!&!4/



 8,  $!"

/ .

$!

!

"&

",, 0!

!

0!

!/ >$0

9 !4 ".1

$&!"& 2 ! ", -

&9/ &



"&

"& . 

$!



,,/  !

4!"/ 9& !4 10

"& "& 1!

9!/  

) &!4/  8/ . !

"

.

$ """"

9 1&

"/

."/

 !1 !/

.

$!1 ! $!

!0,

,

1!"

$$ &!/  !1 !/ !!

 $$, .!/

!2 4 !1!

!

5> & !"

6$

.

'& 2

$>

6$!! ,$%#%* <.%;  #)*.7=$%.- % 7=7)7=$% 1 ( )%. 6D.!  %!(4     " 0

! "0

",/ / / A

0" ,

,

.

1 !"

"0&""

/

1

'& 2

0!

1!"

$$

"&" 9,

,

6 $!4!

!1&

!

"

4 .,

!

0!0&" 0"/ !

2 9!4

1 !0 !4 "&, 5 "

"

6

 "

& !1

"

2!

!1&

!

"

4, .!/

$

/

!?&"

 

!"

$!

"

0



$010 1 0/ 8,

;&! !/ . "

9"

"&0 $!4!/

<

!1&

!

"

4 0

9

1! 4 9



'& 2

$>

2( ()! 61 (

( $$!%=;.  ! (4  ="=- +/ . !



!1

!1&

!

"

4 0

9

2!

""

"$0104 0

&2

&2 

+

5'(,,-A=%:76 ,!=%*=,- 7$768.*7 $876 *.  .7 6.%#4)

*

 $(  +$

  '76 )<;= =$%  $8 76 .,,--.%7 76.74 =% 76 .< %* $8 . ,*=8=* ,!.A! 8$! 76 !8)%# $8 .#".%* ;$%A ,.=# <A 76;4 !.A! *  $8 76 ,-.=%7 ?6=*6 ,*=8=  76 :!.%7 $8 I )*6 $76! !-=8 . 76$%H<-$)!7#; 8=7=%768.*7  .%# *=!*); 7.%*  $8 76 *.  =% 76 =%7! 7 $8 B) 7=*I4 *.% < *$% 7!)# 7$ =%*-)# . ,!.A! 8$! )*6.%.-7!%.7="!-=8( ( 6 !. $%=%: 7 8$!76 =% 76 *.  $8

.%=*D.;  ),!.

.  !:.!#  76 !-=8 $8 ,$  =$%)%#!*7=$%'

.

$876'F*74 *.%<.,,!$,!=.7-A=;,$!7#=%76,! %7*.  7$ .A 76.7 76 !-=8 $8 !8)%# $8 .!% 7 ;$%A )%#! *7=$% '

< =  %$7 . !-=8 76.7 .)7$;.7=*.--A 8-$?  8!$; . #*! 8$! ,*=8=* ,!8$!;.%* $8 . .- .:!;%7 .%# ;) 74 76!8$!4<9,-=*=7-A $):67( ( ,  



'  -.?*$%7.=%# )%#!*7=$% $876'F*7= .#E).7-A <!$.#.%#8-9=<-7$.--$?76.,,--.%77$ D.% .;%#;%7$876,-.=%78$!76 .=#!-=84"%.7 76 .,,--.7 7.:( $?"!4 %$ )*6 .,,-=*.7=$% 8$!.%.;%#;%7$876,-.=%7?. ;$"#=76! <8$! 76 7!=.- *$)!7 $! #)!=%: 76 *$)!  $8 76 8=! 7.,,.-<8$!76=:6$)!7(6.7= 7$ .A4 76 .,,--.%7 %"! ,!.A# 8$! 76 !8)%# $8 76 .#".%* ;$%A( !4 =7 ?$)-# < !#)%#.%7 7$ 7.776.776-.?.=# 76"=:=-.%74%$776$ ?6$ -,$"!76=!!=:67 (C

 

<,

5  9 / "

$$  .

'& 2

0!

 , 8, 

$""

1!"

$$ &!/ " "

"?& 1/

'& 2

0!

8, ,  $""

! &!/ !"

! !

9/

.!/ !1!!

0!

5> & !"

!"

1

2"

1!"

$$

$! 

"

'& 2



*

$$0

"/ 1 4/ "  "

"

"$ "

1,

12   30     ,!=-'4

F  !

"$6 2A!"

+

J"A-

F  !

!$ !9

+

J"A-