M/S Blue Dart Express Ltd v. N.P. Pattanayak
!! "# $
!"
" # ! % & '
(& )
* & $%&'(($)*+$%,! )$-
+ ,& & &
-./012!2( * (
& (
+ + -
3" 4 ( 5 2
) %( )6&3")& 2& 7 &
8
+-& ( 39
)++
: ;3' 2 .'! &-&'/01203$340$-5'!!
3$3$'&6$)$3 /4!, 7 )0203$- 8,
3
* '
-.
-./01 2!2) &&* & (&
2!23&2'
$* &
=.+ ,&
&3*
33 6
5 ")&* &* 3 (& 6& &
3
3
3" "
9
)*
+-& ) )"&& &7 6&& &
3" 6& &( & ) ")& )6& &7&
&
'
")& (&* 3 6 && (& 6&&
* )6&) (&
-.0&2!2
* & & (&
-.0 (&
3
3< "
'
") * ) 6&* 3 & & )
" &* (& ,& ") & &&! &(&
&* 38 -.
6 &
( "
3 3"&* )6& &
& ( *
* 6& > ") (
7 ) &')&(&&!3 !
* & &
)&(& & 6 &&* &:6*) 6"
"& ' 6& * ?
(& ) &
# ( * & : (&2
-./01&2!26 3 "6&&
3"&! 3"
&* ' -.
&2!2 5&")&! &
'
-.
3&* ?
(& & 6 &( &' ( > &&&
)&! &
&* ' -.
* (
(&&*
&(
& 5 &")& ** &'
+-&
3" 3 ,& 3 &
&* *
' &2!2
' +0-& 3"
&*
& 2!2 &
,&)& ) 6& &*
& &7 3
3*
&* '
6 && *
'
/61&2!2@ - 5&) "
( & * * ()
: ;3' 2 0)&4/9)$/&9:&5&31&3/&--0;&34&5'!$% <12$))9)$03 )0203$-==&$-9!7 :7+0/( )0203$- ==&$-9!>9:*&40*&*93>!!, 6& " (& &3 3 *")& &
8 =A+,& (6 & 3 * (& )3"&( )
3 *
" 3"
" &* * ,&( B *2
5 5 9 3) ! B
& 66(&(6& 6
& ) 6 & * "
&
( "
"
&6 3"
* & & * " &6
3 &(&
"
,& 3 & 6 &* &
7 (* (& ) 63
( 3 (
:6*) 6&
( (
* 3 7 "* 3"& ( 3 &)&
7 &* ( #"
3" ) *(0'0'?&4$1'&0/0''&//-&*-$+ /($//(&-$+*&4-$)&*?@/(0' 91)/0')&/)9'=&4/05&$3*0'
39)2$--@$''12&*/9?&/(&-$+:)92/(&034&=/093 ,& 6" 3 6 & & < %1*;2&3/ 9) *&40'093 +(04( 03/&)=)&/' $ '/$/1/& 9) =)950'093 /(&)&9: *&4-$)&'/(&2&$303;9:/(&'/$/1/&$'0/'(91-*?&493'/)1&* :)92 /(& *$/& 9: 0/' &3$4/2&3/! 3 9/(&) +9)*', /(& %1*;2&3/*&4-$)&'+($//(&-&;0'-$/1)&($*'$0*$//(&/02& +(&3 /(& -$+ +$' =)921-;$/&* $3* /(&)&:9)&, 0/ ($' )&/)9'=&4/05&&::&4/!> ") &
6& & 3 *
" *C&6 ) & ( 6 3 *& (
"3
6&&
(& 66& & & * C&& 3&6&
3& &*6"
&6&
,&
& && "& B 663
& B/ &
0 ,&) * 6&<
3"&: ;3 ' 2 &-&'/012 03$340$- / 1
0)&4/9)$/& 9:
&5&31& 3/&--0;&34& / 1) '
4 () %( )
& *
2!2
& & 2
$( "
3#
& & '
4 ()%( )&6 & D )
("!
(
) ")
" #
!8!
& <* C&&'# ($
E C&&$3 E