High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/366/2024disposed of

Pawan Kumar v. Mohan Lal

2025-07-22Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul4 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()*+, ($- . /(0*12 3333344+&%( 544!++( 6!2'*' "7(8+ 33333!'4"($!( ' ) ) ) ) 98:3: 98:3: 98:3: 98:3:08 08 08 08 2!'!( ) 233:37&($-$;"% ! #"2 7!44+&%( 3 08-3 08-3 08-3 08-3 3 7!44+&%( 7'#&+!$ 7!42!'!( 44+&% &"('!!<&(==2( "#+!;! "44!+=&(' 7!>*$=1!( "#%?*& +4''!$&(%"14+&( %'!&(' & * !$*($!2:!% &"(@"# 7!!=" &A+!(' 2*1!( '% -@@

7!2!&(# !22!#!22!$ "'-B% C-/7!2!A, 7!%"14+&( #&+!$A, 7! 44+&%( /'$&'1&''!$($ 7!%%*'!$/'%?*& !$3 3 7!+&1& !$?*!' &"(2&'&(=#"2%"('&$!2 &"(&( 7!42!'!( 42"%!!$&(='&'/7! 7!2(44!+=&(' ("2$!2"#%?*& +4''!$&( %"14+&( %'!*($!2:!% &"(@"# 7!% %(A!!( !2 &(!$*($!2 7! 42";&'" " :!% &"( D "# 7! 2333 7! &(' (%! "# 7! %"14+&(( E 3 7! &''*! &' (" +"(=!2 2!' &( !=23 ( B5' !+!' &*1 B5' !+!' &*1 B5' !+!' &*1 B5' !+!' &*1 &((%&+ 6'3 3 (('!<2( %3 . : @

) .

&((%&+ 6'3 3 (('!<2( %3 . : @

) .

&((%&+ 6'3 3 (('!<2( %3 . : @

) .

&((%&+ 6'3 3 (('!<2( %3 . : @

) .

2&1&(+ @C

2&1&(+ @C- 7!"(9A+!:*42!1!"*2 * 7"2& &;!+,7!+$ 7 %"14+&(( &(42"'!%* &"(*($!2:!% &"(@"# 7!% -?*+&#&!' 'B;&% &1C*($!2:!% &"( /"# 7!2333-A!&(= 7!4!2'"(/7"

'*##!2'#&((%&++"''$*! " 7!$&'7"("*2"#%7!?*!3"('!?*!( +,- '*%7%"14+&(( &'!( & +!$ "4*2'*!(44!+=&(' %?*& +*($!2 7! 42";&'" " :!% &"( D "# 7! 2333- /& 7"* 7! 2!?*&2!1!( "# '!!<&(='4!%&++!;!*($!2:!% &"(D@

"# 7!2333

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

( 7!%"( 22,-'=&(' ("2$!2"#%?*& +- 7!: !- 72"*=7 7!*A+&%2"'!%* "2%(42!#!2(44!+!;!(&# 7!%"14+&(( $"!'(" 42!#!2'*%7(44!+- 7"*=7"# %"*2'! '*%7 ( 44!+ &' /& 7 7! +!;! "# 7! %"*2 3 "/!;!2- & &' (" +/,' (!%!''2, #"2 7! : ! "2 %"14+&(( " 42!#!2 ( 44!+3 * /7!( & %"1!' " ;&% &19'2&=7 "42!#!2(44!+- 7!&('&' !(%!"('!!<&(= '4!%&++!;! "44!+#2"1 7!&=7"*2 *($!2:!% &"( D@

"# 7! 2 /"*+$ A! %"( 22, " /7 7' A!!( &( !($!$ A, 7! 2+&1!( A, &('!2 &"( "# 7! 42";&'" " :!% &"(D "# 7!2333 "*2 7+,- 7! 2+&1!( 7' (" 1!($!$ :!% &"( D@ " %&2%*1'%2&A! 7!;&% &19'2&=7 "42!#!2(44!+>*' '& 7'/& 72!=2$ "%"14+&(( "2 7!: !#&+&(=(44!+3

( 7!" 7!27($- 7!2+&1!( 7'&('!2 !$ 7!42";&'" " :!% &"(D '"' "!(;&'=!'*4!2&"22&=7 #"2 7!;&% &1 "#("##!(%! "42!#!2(44!+"( 7!=2"*($'1!( &"(!$ 7!2!&('%"142!$ "%"14+&(( 3 &# 7+,- 7!&(;"+;!1!( "# 7!: !&(2!'4!% "#("##!(%!

*($!2:!% &"(@"# 7!% &'%"('4&%*"*'A,& 'A'!(%!3 7&'&'A!%*'! 7!%"14+&( #&+!$*($!2 7 42";&'&"(&'&( 7!( *2!"#42&; !%"14+&( '4!2:!% &"(

"# 7! 2333($:!% &"( "# 7!% A,(!F42!''&( !( &"( &(%"24"2 !' 7!42";&'&"('"# 7!2333&( 7!1 !2"# 2&+"#'*%7$!!1!$"##!(%! 2&!$'%2&1&(+"##!(%!3 7!2!#"2!- 7!%"14+&(( -/7"&' 7!;&% &1"#$&'7"("*2 "#%7!?*!1*' A!%"(' 2*!$ "A!;&% &1&( !21'"# 7! 42";&'" " :!% &"( D 2!$ /& 7 7! $!#&(& &"( "# ;&% &1 *($!2:!% &"( /"# 7!2333 FFFFFFFFF 3 ' +2!$, (" !$- 7! 42";&'" " :!% &"( D "# 7! 2333/'&('!2 !$&( 7!' * !A""<"(+,/& 7!##!% #2"1 3 3

37!"A>!% ($2!'"(#"2'*%7&('!2 &"(1*' A!2!+&'!$($1*' A!=&;!(& '#*++!##!% "A,%"*2 3( ;&!/"# 7!#"2!'&$$&'%*''&"(-/!7"+$ 7 7!;&% &1"# ("##!(%!7' 7!2&=7 "42!#!2(44!+*($!2 7!42";&'" ":!% &"(D "# 7!2333-&22!'4!% &;!"#/7! 7!27!&' %"14+&(( "2(" 3;!(&# 7!;&% &1"#("##!(%!&' %"14+&(( - 7! %( ' &++ 42"%!!$ *($!2 7! 42";&'" " :!% &"(D ($(!!$(" $;!2 "'*A'!% &"(

"#:!% &"( D@"# 7!2333H .3 7*'-/7 #+"/'#2"1 7!A";!"A'!2; &"('&' 7 7! "(9A+!:*42!1!"*2 -# !2(!F7*' &;!!F1&( &"("# 7!' * "2, #21!/"2<($42!;&"*'>*$&%&+42"("*(%!1!( '&(%+*$&(=B++&<2>*( B++&<2>*( B++&<2>*( B++&<2>*( 0"$=+&6'3: !"#02( <" 7!2'C :D.

0"$=+&6'3: !"#02( <" 7!2'C :D.

0"$=+&6'3: !"#02( <" 7!2'C :D. -%+2&#&!$ 7 7!2&=7 "#44!+%"(#!22!$*4"( 7!B;&% &1C*($!2 7!42";&'" " :!% &"(D "# 7!2333&'&($!4!($!( ($'*A' ( &;!&(( *2!-(" %"( 2"++!$ A, 7! 42"%!$*2+ 2!=&' 2 &"( *($!2 :!% &"( D@

"# 7! 2333 3 $"4 &(= 42=1 &% ($ >*' &%!"2&!( !$ 442"%7 ($ =*&$!$A, 7!42&(%&4+! 7 42"%!$*2+2*+!1*' '!2;!($(" "A' 2*% 7!%"*2'!"#>*' &%!- 7&'"*2 $!!1'& 442"42& ! "$&2!% 7 7! 42!'!( 44!+ A! 2! !$ ' "(! * 7"2& &;!+, &(' & * !$ *($!2 7!

42";&'" ":!% &"(D "# 7!2333 D3 ( ;&!/ "# 7! * 7"2& &;! 42"("*(%!1!( &( 5'!+!' &*1&((%&+9'%'! '*42 5'!+!' &*1&((%&+9'%'! '*42 5'!+!' &*1&((%&+9'%'! '*42 5'!+!' &*1&((%&+9'%'! '*42($ 7!;&!/ <!(A, 7&'"*2 +'"&(: 4+:&(=7;3: !"#*(>A(23

$&'4"'!$"##"( 3 D3 .- 7!42!'!( 44+&% &"(&'$&'4"'!$"#/& 7 $&2!% &"( 7 7!+!2(!$:!''&"('*$=!%"(%!2(!$'7++ 2! 7!42!'!( 44!+'(44!+#&+!$*($!2 7!42";&'" ":!% &"(D "# 7!2333 ($''&=( 7!'1! "(442"42& !"*2 #"2$&'4"'+"(1!2& '-&( %%"2$(%!/& 7+/3 @3 7!%"(%!2(!$44!++ !"*2 '7++42"%!!$ "$!%&$! 7! 44!+!F4!$& &"*'+,-/& 7"* A!&(=&14!$!$A,(,$!+,&(#&+&(= 7! 44!+- &( ;&!/ "# 7! +!=+ 4"'& &"( ("/ %+2&#&!$ A, 7! "(9A+! 4!F"*2 3

3 7!!=&' 2,&'$&2!% !$ " 2('1& 7&'"2$!2+"(=/& 7 %"4, "# 7! %"14+! ! 44!2 A""< ($ 2! *2( 7! 2&+ "*2 2!%"2$- &#2!%!&;!$- " 7!+!2(!$:!''&"('*$=!3 3

&'4"'!$"#%%"2$&(=+,3 *+, *+, *+, *+, ($ ($ ($ ($- .

- .

08 08 08 08 *(!! I7! 7!2'4!<&(=52!'"(!$ )

!' I7! 7!22!4"2 A+! ) "