Kiran Devi And Others v. Kuldeep Singh And ANR
!"
##$$ %&
&$!#'("!" )
*#! +
,! -$.! ."##$$
%!/&#.! .#!, 0" ##$ " 1 &! 12 " ##$$$3 4( "3 3# 5!!12" !6$301&$.7 " 8" 609 .&!" "1.5":#! 3 "&$!.5""4#$ $3 # &! '
" %"$.; "8" %9 5&!12" 5!5<.!&("$5!5!&(" "1 =5#$!!" . "1$(5"" *-".5&(3,$1!(7'6 1( *( , 7*';. 1( ! 12 *-"
>" "2 "! + ?1 ! ' ?2#.7.61(*(, 7*@;A@;
" 8" !( "$9 . 1( ! 12 #! "!($(3! 2"("#!. 33$"!!"(""' &$ " ! !. "1 ! *-" ! 3&$#$( &-& *#!, $!3"#
"1 5 4 /$ 7#$. 7. 5" " 5 !$! 1&(" !! 12 " " 3 *-". !! "1. =* , ;@ !! @ &!'B;.@C.@@B.@@.CB=+65 (!+$'.627 = 5 $3! " " 3 " !. !! "1 5 (! C; 2 ! 5 54( $ ( * .D # 3"
= 5 &" $3!""$35&$$2!#!&#!!
"1 ! "2 "! " & 3 !($2. 3#&3* E4"5$3!
@ *#! , 5 ! ! " !( "$ !"#12$(53.4( #$32 1- (!( & < $& !. -!2#<##$!31$2 3. " &3 " ! " ( 4 #$!&"($(#!, .5!!
0" 3# $3! 5 3! 1 "("$2 :((! = " $ . 5 #$!! " " 60 3 " $& " #! , 5 #1$ " ! F&. $1$2 "&$! 1 ! &# #!, =&63#2
@ *#! =& 63#2 $! # 5 3 4( #$32 1- (!($$&15"$3!#!, < 31$2. 3.5 !"! " !( "$5"$!( $!! ($!" " 3 (!( " ! 5 ( " =& 63#2 = 5 &" ! " #! "! $! " 3 ! ! " & #$2 *" 3"$3#5!! 3 " #$!( " #. $$5( & 53!
!
"##$%& $& '() $*& *##(!!% %( * !") "&% &+,$+& %!$-$&+ *. *..&%$&+ - $#, /"!$&+ !+$) !" $*& * 0123 124 !)(, $&+ $& * %"
*."
"/$!5
6
! 7 $ $*&!) "! & $ ,% * !#*-!
#*87&)" $*& .!*8
!)7*&%& ) $. )* * 9 " : & "&% .!*89 *85
1
! &)(!"&# #*87"&; $) &* ,$"/, *7";#*87&)" $*&")!)7*&%& * ") -$*," % "&% #*& !"-&% $&)(!"*,$#;5
<
! 7!)& 7 $ $*& $) &* 8"$& "$&"/,5
4 ,$. +$!"# !
%!5!!!@ C." 60$$5!" # $! 12 " $3. 5!( " $$5( 3#
C '
7! 6$&$ *
( C;2 =3 .D $&!( &&## ;GCD DC" !!&! #$ :# # 3""!! .@ D H;.D 2* ;.D 63# 3&$#$@##$! ;::@H C.@.D
E .D E &3 #, ..D C.D " "# &$:# .D 0$ 3# 5!! .
.D '4("3"!3#." ##$$$3" $!"##$ =" "!$!&$"# ;
0" $2 (&3 ! 12 $! &$ " ##$$ " !! "1. 5 54( $!# "3.+>@'&$ &3."!!&$2 1:3!
7&13"!#"! ! " ( 1 #!&!. " 60 " ! "$!( " "!1# !"!! "1554( $ 7 &13 " " 60. ". ! ("3"!!* ;.D#3". 1!!&35(&4$$!$1&# $( "$ 3 E! &$ $ &13 " 3 " $5 $! !5 12 " 791$ ' 6& " $*&", &)(!"&#*87"&;$8$ %-) !"&"; $"&% !) 6= >
?6@ ?#!$@ 6=4 ! "+8" &!", &)(!"&# *87"&; %-)"&( "8A ( !( "8 ?6= >@ > 1= " 3& 5!! & &3< &$ :# !$.$! 1"! .$!&$#(#! =& 63#2. &13 " " $$($2 " !(!!12" 601&+>@'&$ &3."! 3#$$2$!":3.5""!&$2# ! " !! "1 5 54( $ E!&$&"&13"&!"&3. " 60 ("$2 ! " 3 " !! ;.D#3".("31&4$$!$1& 75 ."&$!!2"&3"&3D$$ 3# 1( #21$ 3 " -&!(3 " 791$ ' 6& =! " !"&"; $ &#
7 (!!"&133!12$! &$ " ##$$. " 6& ! $$($2 " !(!!12" 60 +>@'&$ &3.##! 5 1: ! " :3 ". " ! " !! "153#$25""3!554( $$ 3" ! 5 (( * .D # 3"
7$!#!" "1$"!:3 D # 3"
'$2 A:"1 + 5 #!&!!
#"$2. "15 #33#$2'&$ &3!"!154(5" "3C 75 .":3. "!
"A:"1+ ."!1 !12"3$(5"&33 !21""!##!!"(&"3. "## 7!""$25 1(#!"
,##3$"!1&!
7 !! 45 2 : ! 3" ##3
"1 7 ! " " 5 3( 2 $!( & (!( $2 #! "1 ! " " "! 3#$2"" "1 7"!$3!2 ! ( 7 " ! " "1 !! " 2 #$3 (!( $$ 54 0" $$2 "5 " " ! 5 5 #!&! $2 #- "1 $ ! " :3 $$2 "! " ":3" , !&1. " % 5$ $($ ! *&$ ! ! ##$2 " #!( &! " ! 75 . " 1 1 3! " $ $31!
0":3'&$
&3$$2"5""5$$$1$5 @ I! " &3. " 6& ! " "
60 !! 33 2 $$($2 ( !!
"1.&4$$!$1&!("3 ;.D#3"
C 75 . 3 " $! !5 12 " '$&=!" !"&"; $ &# .$$ &3. J * C.CD. 5 F&! 1 (!
'$$ &". &$ :# ! $ . * .D &!""!.5$F&!15!!
B 7 (!!"&133!12$! &$"#."3#5!!12" 60 "!&! '
7!6$3 5!!12 60 A"! 3#
( C;2 ,"(
=3 .D $&!( && ## ;.GCD
,"(
DC " !!&! #$ :# # 3" "!! .@ D H;.D 2* ;.D ,"(
63# 3&$#$ @ ##$! ;::@H C.@.D ,"( E .D .D
E&3 $3D##$$ ..D C.D " " # .C.D C.CK
&$:# .D .D 0$ 3# 5!!
) B4 6==30
)
4==30
0" $ 3#. ". 3 * B.@.30 !!&( &3 * .
.D ! 12 " 60. " 1$ 3# 3 C.@D 0" 3& 5&$! 1 #21$ !! " 3& ! 12 " $! 60 $( 5" J L &$$2 0" !1&$ ! $1$2 #2 " 3 5&$!1#"5!
B 0"###$!($2!#! +!( ##$ . 2. "$$ $ ! !#! ? @ 6>= 6=6B %) >""#4(D! MD, >""#1$ MD,