M/S Spl Motors P Ltd v. Union Of India And Others



   
    


 



 !"#"$% &

( )*+  

,-.

./ ,.

01 /2


(#4#

  

   .




,% 5/ ,.2 . / .  //

5/ ,2 . , /

  
 
 



 


 

 
 


 
 
 
 
 




 

/ .  //+ 2


!
 " 




 


  






#
$ 
%  
&


'$%&(
 



 

)*+,)+),
 "



! "
-.
%  


#

 




  




"
/0

% 



 
-.

)+ 1

2 


  
-.

)+ 1



  
" 
3"



)
& 
" 
 
 



4" 

 


  


 

 
56
"
/07




 
-.
" 
)+ 1
'

 
" 
)+ 1(


%







" 8



#

.
 9
$%&


 "
.

  



 



"
   :;

<






= 
<

,



 

,
& 
" 

" 





"



 
  
" 


% 



  -.

)+ 1
'

 
>
?%-
9(

2 



 
-.

)+ 1
'

 
>
?2-
9(
 




)*+,)+),


=

"


 







 
" 
3"


 " 


"

% 
@ !  
-.

%"



'%@!%(
 
#
! "
-.
%  
'!-%(

$ 
%  
&


'$%&(
 
" 
"
/0

A " )+ 1
"


 


 
 

$%&
  
." 
7 +
!
 "







" 8
#

!-%

.


!-%
  



  
   


$%&
!
 " 
" 


  
 


 


 9
$%&




" !-%



 

 "



"
 




 
!-%
 
 3"


 


"
 




 " 
& 
" 


" 
" 






B





"
/0

)+ 1

"

 


!-%






 


.



$%&
C
& 
" 





"3 
2 
%" 


 

  
    !"#

D
2 
%" 

$  %&
'

 '      

& %

  

  (  " )   *+"#
,

- 
'   
 '       .& .

' .

'    


 - '  "

*   *+*#

,  /

 /

- (    %

 %  


 '0

(  "

**   *) 
!
 " 


D
2 
%" 

,

- 
' 
 ,  /

 /

- (  

'

(

 



 
3"



$ %&
'

 ' 1
 
'

(


"



&'(
= + ,,*<A)+)C

+ 11)<A)+)C
 



29
"


%" 

1+C)+)C

+*+1)+)C


& 
" 
" 
" 


2 
%" 
 



+, )+)C

%67)<01C7)+)C


 


 
#


D
2 
%" 




$ %&
'

 '

0#46( 1+ ,

- 
'   
 '     0#46( (
  ,  /

 /

- (  '

(   
 


 "  
 4" 
 

"
 



  

+, )+)C


%67)<01C7)+)C
',-# .78 .4$9 ( .

("6# & (#4# $"$

$9"

$9

(#(
!
 
"




 


 

0
& 
" 






 


"



  



"


 4" 
 


"
 
  

D   A "






+, )+)C



:  0,-# .78 .4$9 ( .

("6#

& (#4# $"$

$9"

$9

(#1


  

1
6


 
" 
 


 "








/
!








  




" 
" 
%-A2-

)+ 1

-
!

 
=
'-!=
+0B% )0, E (
& 
" 





 


"



$%&
 

#

)*+,)+),
= 


"

 

 

$%&
 

 ." 
7 +

*

  




 



+, )+)C


 

,-# .78 .4$9 ( .

("6#
'

(
 
3"


"3 
2 
%" 


 
 .

;;8#+

D
2 
%" 


$ %&
'

 ' (< ,

- 
'  
 '  0#46( (
  ,  /

 /

- (  '

(

2  0  3

 %(      %

   "


%%4 


#! - 
2 
%" 
 @ 
2 
%" 

/5   

     ( .& %

 
0(  + *

 "!)


 %"
2 
%" 

$  ,
(5 (  %

  / 


06%(-

(  
%%4

% "+""


2 
%" 

2 / .  '  
 7

(  *
%%4

**""
 

2 
%" 
   
  


- 
& -

5  
&



  % 0

(  "
%%4

+8+9
 

 "



F
.


2 
%" 
"3 
D
@ 
 - 


 

 
 

+, )+)C


"  7
5 <
!



 

 



"8
!-%
  

" 
 
"3

 
 
"




" 

"3 
2 
%" 


3"




   

   1
 
'

(
 
"



!-%
"8

 

$%&

-
"




  


$%&


 
 
.  
 
" 
"
/07
 " 
)+ 1


 
 

"3 
2 
%" 


 

  1
 
'

(


"  7
5)/
"
/0


%-
"




%



 " 

8




 
  











  

 "
.



 
  





"

"
 

 
-"



 
 



 "
.
  
"




 
  



  



" 
"
/07

#


" 
!

 

 





"


 "

 "
.
  



 
  








#




=
!


 "
.
  






 

#
 
  



" 
"
/07
 "
  

 






"


"
3" 



 
)*
B




   
 "
/0' (

%-

" 
)+ 1

 

 



  
" 
"
/0


. 


%







" 


'


#





%

 (
G" 





. 
 
"

"
 
 



 
(
%  

 "
.
"




 
  


 
(
-
%







" 



"

 



"
  


"

"



 
(
-
 


 



   <+
!
 


  
 
 


 





#
"
/0
H 

 "
/0





7
(
D 



 
  




 



" 

,*




 "

""
 "
(
"
  
"



"
4"


 "




"

"



  < 
"
/0
' (

%-
" 
)+ 1

  




  
-
   


"



 
4"  

" 

 

#


" 

"
-

  


"


 4"

 
"
/0

#  <)
!





 

    


 "
/0
 

"  





#

"


"
 

 4"


"

.7 


 <<
B
  
 

 

#
"
/0
 

%  

 "
.
"




 
  


 
G"  
"
  
"






 

 




  (
"

"
  <,
 

 
 
'(
%  

 "
.





 
  




'(
"
  

  

" 


  
" 
"
/0


#  <C
G"  
"
/0



"







#

 


 
  





  
-
"
 










   



 
  






   
 




 
!
 


 
 






 



 "


 


 "
.
  
  

 
  


" 
'
1<

1,

%-
(


 
 



 " 

"  

"
/0


....................................................... ....

, 
!

   
 

 " 


 "
4"






 


"


 4"

 

  



"
 



 

  
"



"
 


#


 
 

  

 "
.




 
  




 

 4"





 






"
 


 "
.
  



 
  


 

  
  


" 



  


 
   
2





"

  


4"
 "



  
  
2 

"

. 
 "
  


 
  


  ,)

"

 
  


   



""




" 

"

"
  


"

 

 
 
 "
/0



"   

 "



!
 
"
/0




 " 



  
-
  

 



" 


1<


1,


 




 

  
  
 
G"  

  





 


 
%
  
'






 

(
" 

)*

%-

G"   

  

 




 
"

#
"
 

.

" 

/<

%-


,<
 






   

"

"

"
  


""







#
"
/0 ,,
-


  



 
  



 .  
 

" 
-
"
" 



 " 



 " 
 

 "
.
  
  


"


1<

1,
 %-










" 



 
 




 "

 
!



"
/0

#


 


 


8









 

"


   



" 
 " 

  .  
  
....................................................... ......

5,*
-"



 


 


   



"


%" 


 




 











 " 
 "
/0




.  
"
 



  


"



#



 ;

+
F
.


2 
%" 
"3 
D
- 
 @ 




%" 






 


  "



 " 
 "
/0

)+ 1
"



 
  "

 "



 I

 

!-%




  
 " 









  
"

"
/0

)+ 1
"
 


 
"




%



 
!-%

$%&

 


 







"

"



 
 
 

 

"





'
%"


=(


4" 
  
2 



 
"


  


$%&
 


? 
# 9
!

 


" 

  

" 
 " 


 
 "
6
 "
.
  


  


"
"

 




" 




1<

1,

%-A2-


 

 "








 "

3"



2 
%"  
 


     





 

,-# .78 .4$9 ( .

("6#
'

(

"  7
5 /
!




 "

 

 



 "
 




"3 
2 
%" 

2 
%"  D

- 

.




  



     
6
 


 "
"

 




 
.



2 
%" 
%"


  
  


$   ,
(5 2  /  .   '   

- 
& - 

 5 1 
'

(



  









D
2 
%" 

,

-
' 
 , /

/

- ( 1

'

(



"
"

 
29

"


%" 


*
6




 


 


  " 





 
1+C)+)C
 +*+1)+)C

29

"


%" 

3"




,

-
' 

,  /

 /

- ( 1
 (





 
   

 

 "



 



#


2 
%" 
%"


  
  
- 






3



"

 .
)+
6




 


 


 
" 





 
1+C)+)C

+*+1)+)C

29

"


%" 
 3"




,

-
' 

,  /

 /

- ( 1

'

(





 
   


 
 "



 



#


2 
%" 
%"


  
  
- 






3




"
 .

) 
!




 "

 


 A 


" 

 
"





.








$%&

 '

(

.

!-%

 


 


A#  '

(;

)
J





 "




 









%67)<01C7)+)C
',-# .78 .4$9 (

.

("6# & (#4# $"$

$9"

$9

(#(


+, )+)C
<


 

 

"  #

  

 ' (


 

 



,

 "

'

(


 (

 

0/ .  //1



0, /1

&

( )*+  





6

# A   
K A=

6
  
K A=