High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/59711/2025allowed

Kulwinder Singh Alias Kinda v. State Of Punjab

2025-11-18Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel6 pages

!"# $ %& ' !( B>"))* "# # ?"#/ $)()" *+ , (- B>"/3* !" ) ()" *+ !"./ ()" *+ !"./ ()" *+ !"./ ()" *+ !"./ ()" *+ 3 ()" *+ 3 ()" *+ 3 ()" *+ 3 /* 0 *1"2-"# /* 0 *1"2-"# /* 0 *1"2-"# /* 0 *1"2-"# @7 7 7 7

*(! %0 *1"2-"# *(! %0 *1"2-"# *(! %0 *1"2-"# *(! %0 *1"2-"# @7 0 0 0 0 #"/" )0 #"/" )0 #"/" )0 #"/" )0 <4 > $ $ <4 > $ $ <4 > $ $ <4 > $ $ 4 4 4 4 #> >>$> *#(5(7 !1*.()"7 #> $>$> &

(#7 !1*.()" ( !

#> $>>$> $( !& 7 !1*.()" +* # )&" 3"))* "#> #> ( , !"# $ %& $#(7 !!)* * ( ,(-> AAAAA AAAAA AAAAA AAAAA 4 4 4 47 > :4= 7 > :4= 7 > :4= 7 > :4= $ $ $ $ #"/" ) )&#! 3"))* &(/ -""

+ !"# $".)* C@9 *+ )&"

&(#()5( (%(#6 $ #(6/&( $( &)(7 :+*# /&*#) ; $$<= +*# %#( ) *+ +

)* )&" 3"))* "# .(/" -"(# % % *> !()"! >8> C7 #"%/)"#"! +*# # )&" *++" ."/ 3 /&(- !"# $ $".)* / :

=7 :=7 :@=7 C D *+ )&" #2/ .)7 :+*# /&*#) ;#2/ .) )<=7 () * ." $)()* )5 *%(7 /)#.) *% %(>

&" %#(1(2" *+ (

"%()* / (%( /) )&" 3"))* "# / )&() (#2 !"# $ %& ' !(7 /* *+ (#/&( $ %&7 ( !

!"# $ %& '

!( :3")) * "# &"#" =7 /* *+ ( !"1 $ $ %&7 -*)& #"/!" )/ *+ ))(# # ( ( 7 /)# .) *%(7 "#" 2"2-"#/ *+ ( %( "! -5 )&" *)*#* / %( %/)"# #

(1!""3 $ %& ' *& ))(#7 /* *+ "6 $ %&7 ( /* ( #"/!" ) *+ ))(# ( ( 7 /)#.) *%(> ) / + #)&"# (

"%"! )&() )&" /(! %( %/)"# &(! / (#%" E ( ))5 *+ (#2/ ( ! (22 )* )* (#2 !"# $ %& ( ! )&"

3"))* "#> (/"! * /".#") +*#2()* #"."1"!7 ) (/ #"3*#)"! )&() )&"

(..

/"!

"#" 3#"/" ) )&" 3(#6 % (#"( -"& ! )&" /)#.) * #)/7 *%(7 +#* ) *+ )&" *++." *+ )&" "3(#)2" ) *+ ! .()* 7 *%(> &"5 "#"

"%"!

() % +*# /*2"* "

& " /"()"! ( &)" 5 !( 8 .(# -"(# % #"%/)#()* *>4 C 87 ( ! ) (/ / /3".)"! )&() )&"5

! -" (33#"&" !"!

)& ( / -/)( )( ( ))5 *+ +#"(#2/ + ( #(!

(/ .* !

.)"!> .) % * )&/ +*#2()* 7 ( #(! (/ .(##"! * )> *)& (..

/"!F(#2 !"# $ %& ( !

!"# $ %& :3"))* "# &"#" =F "#"

(33#"&" !"!

& " ())"23) % )* + "" )&" /(!

8 1"&.

"> # % )&"

3"#/* ( /"(#.& *+ (#2 !"# $ %& ' !(7 * " >9 -*#" ( )*2(). 3/)*

(/ #".*1"#"! +#*2 &/ "+) +* !7 ( ! ( *)&"# - (.6.* #"! >9 -*#" 3/)*

(/ #".*1"#"! +#*2 &/ #%&) +* !> 3*

*(! %7 ) 1" .(#)#!%"/ "#"

+* ! )&" +#/) 3/)* ( ! * "

1" .(#)#!%" )&" /".* !> # % )&"

3"#/* ( /"(#.& *+ )&" 3"))* "#7 * " .* )#52(!" >9 -*#" 3/)*

(/ #".*1"#"! +#*2 &/ "+) +* !> 3*

*(! %7 ) 1" .(#)#!%"/ "#"

#".*1"#"! +#*2 * " >9 -*#" 3/)* ( ! * "

1" .(#)#!%" +#*2 )&" /".* !

3/)* > #)&"#7 +#*2 )&" !(/&-*(#! *+ )&" .(#7 *++."#/ #".*1"#"! * " )#52(!" >98 -*#" 3/)* ( ! * " >9 -*#" #"1* 1"#> 3*

*(! % )&"

#"1* 1"#7 ) 1" .(#)#!%"/ "#" #".*1"#"!> 9> 4"(# "! .* +*# )&" 3"))* "# &(/ )"#()"! )&() )&" 3"))* "# / .

/)*!5 / ." >8> C> 4"(# "! .* &(/ )"#()"! )&() )&"

3"))* "# &(/ -"" +( 5 23 .()"! )* )&" E "/)* > 4"(# "!

&(/ + #)&"# (#% "! )&() )&"#" / *)& % / -/)( )1" "1!" ."

(1( (- )& )&" 3#*/".

)* (%( /) )&" 3"))* "# )&() (

"%"! #".*1"#"!

"(3* / "#"

/"! ( 5 &"#" )&" .#2"> 4"(# "! .* &(/ #%"! )&() .*(..

/"! *+ )&" 3"))* "# &(/ ( #"(!5 -"" %#( )"! .* ."//* *+ #"%

(# -5 ( .**#! ()" " .& *+ )&/ * #)7 1!" *#!"# !()"! 8@>8> 3(//"! C

> 4"(# "! .* &(/ + #)&"# #%"! )&() )&"

3"))* "# &(/ / ++"#"! .(#."#()* +*# 2*#" )&( 8 5"(#> & /7 #"%

(# / 3#(5"! +*#> C> 4"(# "! $)()" .* &(/ *33*/"! )&" 3#"/" ) 3"))* -5 (#% % )&() )&" (

"%()* / #(/"! (%( /) )&" 3"))* "# (#" /"#* / () #"7 ( ! )& /7 )&" 3"))* "# !*"/ *) !"/"#1" )&" .* ."//* *+ )&" #"%

4"(# "! $)()" .* /""6/ )* 3 (." * #".*#! )&" .

/)*!5 ."#)+.()" !()"!

>> 7 )&" * #) )*!(57 &.& / )(6" * #".*#!> >

&(1" &"(#! .* +*# )&" #1( 3(#)"/ ( ! &(1" %* " )&#* %& )&" (1( (- " #".*#!/ *+ )&" .(/">

&" 3"))* "# (/ (##"/)"! * >8> C7 &"#" (+)"#7 )&"

1"/)%()* (/ .(##"! * ) ( ! )&" .&(

( &(/ -"" 3#"/" )"! * >89> C> *(..

/"! *+ )&" 3"))* "# &(/ -"" %#( )"! .* ."//* *+

-5 ( .**#! ()" " .& *+ )&/ * #)7 (/ (+*#"/(!>

2 ()* *+ )#( 7 *+.* #/"7

)(6" )/ * )2"> &" #1( .* )" )* / #(/"! () (# %1" #/" )* !"-()(- " // "/7 &.& /&(

-" #()*. ()"!

3* !

# % )&"

#/" *+ )#( > &/ * #) !*"/ *) !""2 ) (33#*3#()" )* !"

1" !""3 )* )&"/" #1( .* )" )* /7 () )&/ /)(%"7 "/) ) 2(5 3#", !." )&" )#( *)& % )( %- " &(/ -"" -#* %&) +*# (#! )* !.()" )&"

&**! *+ )&" 3"))* "# (-/.* ! % +#*2 )&" 3#*."// *+ , /)." *# )"#+"# % )& )&" 3#*/".

)* "1!" .">

-)(- 57 )&" 3#"/" ) 3"))* / )&" )&#! ())"23) -5 )&" 3"))* "# )* /".

#" #"%

> &"

(/) -( "( 3#"+"##"! -5 )&" 3"))* "#

(/ !/2//"! (/ )&!#( 8>8> C> * "1"#7 6""3 % 1"

)&"

" )#")5 *+ )&" +(.) 2()#G *+ )&" .(/" &( !H "/3".(

57 1"

*+ )&"

+(.) 2 *+ )&" 3"))* "# &(1 % / ++"#"! "G)" !"! .(#."#()* +*# 2*#"

)&( 8 5"(# ( ! 3(." *+ )#( H )&/ * #) / .

"! )* (++#2()1"

5 .* /!"# )&" /)( ) 3 "( +*# -( > 3#*+)(- " #"+"#" ."7 )&/ #"%(#!7 .( -" 2(!" )* ( , !%2" ) *+ )&/ * #) 3(//"! $

9 )) "! (/ (+E &( (+E &( (+E &( (+E &( 1"#/ / $)()" *+ (#5( ( ( ! ( *)&"# 1"#/ / $)()" *+ (#5( ( ( ! ( *)&"# 1"#/ / $)()" *+ (#5( ( ( ! ( *)&"# 1"#/ / $)()" *+ (#5( ( ( ! ( *)&"#H #"

"1( ) &"#"*+ #"(!/ (/ !"#0 I8> / ( "3 *% " )* )&" (-*1" !/.

//* 7 )&" +*

3# .3 "/ "2"#%"0 $".* !J/ .."//1"

3"))* :/= + 2( )( (- D &" ." / .& 3"))* * %&) *) )* -" #",".)"!

/* 5 * )&" %#* ! *+ 2( )( (- )5 )&"#"*+>

$ .& /".* !J/ .."//1"

3"))* :/= 2( )( (-

&")&"# "(# "# 3"))*

(/ !/2//"!

)&!#( J!/2//"! (/ *) 3#"//"!J!/2//"! +*# * 3#*/". )* *# "(# "# 3"))* (/ !/2//"! * 2"#)/> *# )&" /".* !J/ .."//1" #"%

(# -( 3"))* :/= )* ..""!7 )&" 3"))* "#J(33 .( ) /&(

-" "//" )(

5J3"#) " ) #"E #"! )* /&* -/)( )( .&( %" .#.

2/)( ."/ ( ! /&* *+ ( 2"#" / 3"#+.( *# */)" /- " .&( %"

! *) / ++."> &"

2")(3&*#. "G3#"//* *+ /""6 % /".* !J/ .."//1" -( "(:/= %&) *) -" (-/)#(.)"! )* )"#( )"#()* / *+ 3"))* :/= )&* -/)( )( 7 "++".)1" ( ! .* /"E " )( .&( %" .#.

2/)( ."/>

* "G&( /)1" % !"

"/ .( 3*//- 5 -"

(! !* (/ )*

&()

! .* /)) )" / -/)( )( .&( %" .#.

2/)( ."/ (/ "1"#5 .(/" &(/ )/ *

" +(.)/J.#.

2/)( ."> (6 % / .& ( ())"23) / *)& % - ) ( )*3( " !"(1* #> #%*7 )&/ // " / -"/) "+) )* )&" , !.(

/!*2 ( ! !/.#")* *+ )&" * #) !"(

)& / .& /".* !J/ .."//1" #"%

3"))* :/=> ?

.(/" ( * #) .&**/"/ )* %#( ) /".* !J/ .."//1" #"%

(# 3"))* :/=7 .*%" ) ( !

.! #"(/* / (#" 3"#) " ) 5 #"E #"! )* -" #".*#!"! +*# %#( ) % / .& 3 "( !"/3)" / .& ( 3 "( -" % /".* !J/ .."//1" 3"))* :/=> *)&"# *#!/7 )&" .( /" +*# ( * #) &(1 % .."//+

)" ( ."!J" )"#)( "!

.& /".* !J/ .."//1" 3"))* :/= * %&) )* -" #"(!

5 ( ! .

"(# !".3&"#(- " +#*2 )&" /(! *#!"# 3(//"!>K

/ 3"# .

/)*!5 ."#)+.()" !()"! >> + "! -5 "(# "!

$)()" .* 7 )&" 3"))* "# &(/ ( #"(!5 / ++"#"! .(#."#()* +*# ( 3"#*!

*+ 8 5"(#7 8 2* )&/ ( ! 8 !(5/> #)&"#7 (/ 3"# )&" /(! .

/)*!5 ."#)+.()"7 )&" 3"))* "# / /)()"! )* -" 1* 1"! *)&"# :/=> * "1"#7

)&/ +(.) 2 .( *) -" ( %#* ! / ++." ) -5 )/"

+7 )* !".

" )&" .* ."//* *+ #"%

)* )&" 3"))* "# )&" E "/)* &" ( .(/" / 2(!"

) +*# %#( ) *+ #"%

( )&" E "/)* -5 #()*. () % 3* )&"

+(.)/J.#.

2/)( ."/ *+ )&" /(! > "

( ." )&/ #"%(#! .( -" 3 (."!

3* )&" , !%2" ) *+ )&" * <- " $ 3#"2" * #) (

( ( *&!> 2# (

( ( *&!> 2# (/&(! 1> $)()" *+ >> ( ! ( *)&"#7 8 := :#2 ( = @

(/&(! 1> $)()" *+ >> ( ! ( *)&"#7 8 := :#2 ( = @

(/&(! 1> $)()" *+ >> ( ! ( *)&"#7 8 := :#2 ( = @ H ( 1/* " .& , !%2" ) *+ )&" * <- " ( .

))( %& * #) .(/" *+ $#!&(# (/ 1> $)()"7 @ :

= :#2 ( = C $#!&(# (/ 1> $)()"7 @ :

= :#2 ( = C D , !%2" )/ *+ )&/ * #) *>9@@

)) "! (/ 6& "/& $ %& 1> $)()" *+ 6& "/& $ %& 1> $)()" *+ 6& "/& $ %& 1> $)()" *+ 6& "/& $ %& 1> $)()" *+ (#5( ( (#5( ( (#5( ( (#5( (7 !".!"! * >> 7 ( ! ( #(, 1> ( #(, 1> ( #(, 1> ( #(, 1> $)()" *+ (#5( (7 @ :9= $)()" *+ (#5( (7 @ :9= $)()" *+ (#5( (7 @ :9= $)()" *+ (#5( (7 @ :9= :#2 ( = > :#2 ( = > :#2 ( = > :#2 ( = > $ ++." )* /(57 + #)&"# !")" )* *+ )&" 3"))* "# (/ !"#)#( *) (##( )"! )&" +(.) *+ )&" .(/"> >

*+ (-*1"7 )&" 3#"/" ) 3"))* / (

"!> "))* "# / *#!"#"! )* -" #"

"(/"! * #"%

* &/ + # /& % -( J/ #")5 -* !/ )* )&" /()/+(.)* *+ )&" 4!> .* ."# "! J )5 (%/)#()"> * "1"#7 (!!)* )* .* !)* / )&() 2(5 -" 23*/"! -5 )&" .* ."# "! J )5 (%/)#()"7 )&" 3"))* "# /&(

#"2( -* ! -5 )&" +*

% .* !)* /0 := &" 3"))* "# /&(

*) 2/ /" )&"

-"#)5 %#( )"!> := &" 3"))* "# /&(

*) )(23"# )& ( 5 "1!" ."7 *#(

*# !*.

2" )(#57 !

# % )&" )#( := &" 3"))* "# /&(

*) (-/" ) &2/"

+ * ( 5 !()" -"+*#"

)&" )#( :1= &" 3"))* "# /&(

*) .*22) ( 5 *++" ."

& " * :1= &" 3"))* "# /&(

!"3*/) &/ 3(//3*#):/=7 + ( 57 )& )&" )#( * #)> :1= &" 3"))* "# /&(

%1" &/ ."

3&* "

2-"#:/= )* )&"

1"/)%() % ++."#J$ *+ .* ."# "! * ." $)()* ( ! /&(

*) .&( %" &/ ."

3&* "

2-"#:/= )&* 3#*# 3"#2//* *+ )&" )#( * #)J

(E( (%/)#()"> :1= &" 3"))* "# /&(

*) ( 5 2( "# )#5 )* !"

(5 )&"

)#(

.(/" *+ -#"(.& *+ ( 5 *+ )&" (+*#"/(! .* !)* / ( ! )&*/"

&.& 2(5 -" 23*/"! -5 .* ."# "! J )5 (%/)#()" (/ !#".)"!

&"#" (-*1"

3* /&* ( 5 *)&"# ++." ) .( /"7 )&"

$)()"J.*23 ( ( ) /&(

-" () -"#)5 )* 2*1" .( ."

()* *+ -( *+ )&"

3"))* "#> > #!"#"! (..*#! % 5> 8>

*)& % /(! &"#" (-*1" /&(

-" .* /)# "! (/ ( "G3#"//* *+ *3 * * )&" 2"#)/ *+ )&" .(/"> > $ ." )&" 2( .(/" &(/ -"" !".!"!7 3" ! % 2/."

( "* (33 .()* 7 + ( 57 /&(

/* /)( !/ !/3*/"! *++> :$ 4 $ 4 $ 4 $ 4=

*1"2-"# @

*1"2-"# @7 2(&(1# L&")&"# /3"(6 %J#"(/* "!0 "/J L&")&"# #"3*#)(- "0 "/J