Abhishek Goyal v. Union Of India And ORS

  
       

  



 !

"# !$%&%"'( )

) 



         
*(  +, *-) -
 , - ,,)

 +, *-) -
 * .-

) *)  




!

"

  

#   # # $%  &

 ' (


!

"

  

))) , - ,,)

/0

*

+ "

   , 

&  " "     "$ - " "

%+$.-%+/     $ *0 0103    15 *1 0103   $  &"    6 7  %      "$ !    

!

   ! 

 82
 9 

 #!"6 7
" 01*: !



"   

9"

+ "

     , ; &"

 "

  & 

 

 

 !  

 "#$%$$  &  '(  $    '

)      #(*  +%,  '(    $  - '

$ ./ + "

    $ !&  

;  

&$9",   9"

   "

    $  $  ,





  

< + "

   ,  

"!"

"$ !  9 



#!"6 7
" 01*:.  => #6
"?/  !

"    *0 0103 10 0103 15 *1 0103  

0& 

 ,    " 

$!

  "   

9"$  %

@

 "6 7  % ,.%@%/ $ !

 "6 7%.6%/- " "

%+$.-%+/   82
 
"A  01*:  &$$ !

"  " ,"

 -%+  " 
74  $  !   ,     B "$ 6%7" 6%

  !

 "  $

-%+ ,   "

$ !

""  ?-%+&"  , $ 6% !

  

,  $   & 

, $6%  9$$ !

"&"&   "

, !

   " $$ + "

   ,  & "

,C",  82
 01*: "

 6%&" !

  !

 , 7

-%+ + "

    "   9  D$% -12 00"2&

'3% 4 ) , 3) 5&) -  !

"# 67/ 8  

*

9:  ' D$%  !&
/";

-$%!'$!

4 ) , 3) 5&)

/%'$%;0
"11%&&%"'!/ '3 '" <!/8  :

*

:8 .%'=& -!$6/% 2 6/3 -!/4%$!& 4 ) , 3) 5&) !;6 2 %/!$ "/8 %/!$ "/ !

!'!/0 "# -

' !00%=!'$!8  :

*

 '3 ./6'

7!'3/ %'=&<% 5&)
"11%&&%"'!/ "#
!' /0 ""3& '3 -!/4%$!

> '3 " <!/&8  :

*

, "  ' D$ % .%'=& -!$6/% 2 ./6'

7!'3!/ %'=&<%&?"

. / &"    9$,!&
/";

-$%!'$!

), 3)?&"

 . / ! &#+."/  1*<<45A0103 1*::05A0103 "

$$ " $, D ? #,%  *:

0103 14 1:

0103 "!

+ "

 ,  D$% !"  1< ** 0103%E052:30103

 &   !&  ' D$ % "

 !&
/";

-$%!'$!

4 ) , 3 . / .%'=& -!$6/% 2 6/3 -!/4%$!& 4 ) , 3). / ./6'

7!'3/ %'=&<%. /

&   , ; 

 "

! !

   !&  ! "  1< ** 0103 %E 052:30103

*@& -<21 -6'3!/ - /%;& 4!/&6& '%"'

"#

'3% '3 " <!/&

  

 & 

&

+ "

        &!     "

 !   ; 

"

!  !

    $ ' ,A!,  "      1< ** 0103       %E052:30103  *@& -<21 -6'3!/ - /%;& 4!/&6& '%"'

"#

'3% '3 " <!/&  "

" , 

:

E !  "

     !  &   "

     ,     "

          $  &     #6
" 01*: !$ #6"



. #615FGF2*0<D0H(/  +   "

       

!

" " &     -%+  &  " *0 0103    *2 0103   ,  1* 0103    *3 **  $ !

" " ,"

 -%+  " 
7 4

 $  !

  "  1< ** "

  *@& -<21 -6'3!/ - /%;& . /&9$,  9 D$% "

 -12 00"2&  ' D$%   !&
/";

-$%!'$!

4 ) , 3). /I.%'=& -!$6/% 2 6/3 -!/4%$!& 4 ) , 3). / ./6'

7!'3/ %'=&<%. / *@& ,>1% %'!

<!1 5&) &&%& '

"11%&&%"'!/

 :

-

',%'!

- 9  6

$ D$%   @ ,

D$% A1'

*! 0 '3 00"2& 5&) <!

!;6 2
"11%&&%"'!/ "# -  !

>8 <'!8  

*

:9 &

"  %

" D$% &'

.61/ -<A 5& <!

&&%& '

"11%&&%"'!/ "# !4!'6!8 '3 -  !

>8 106B
</=!

'3 " <!/&8   -

'0%'!

0 :

::

'3 "# 00<C3 %=<
"6/ %'

*@&) * %/2 /"36$ & ,, 5&) -  !

"# )) '3 " <!/&8  

-

'0%'!

00

:: "  D$ %  
   -6='

-;"'=!

'3 "A!/ 4 ) , 3) 5&) -6;!/%' !'3!'

"#
!' /0 > '3 " <!/&8  :

-

'0%'!





&  "

&7 D$%   9  '  @ ,

6

$     !

 

  1< ** 0103   
012'-   & 2%  ( (- '3  ## '

 (#1 34-% 3 -$ $(

(251,1*! #"

 -$   2%   &    #    +%,           ' (+%,#   #6      

      

 1     #    34-% $(

(251,1* ! #" 7

1    

      %     $#6   %$$ '&'   -#'  #      '

           -    '    (  -'

1  # #  ' '

 

-'#6  

)'( (1 2 # $ #   '

  - '

)- -68 12# 6 '



- '

)-  -  

 -'  -6 '6

( 6 3 

-

91 :# -#-# 

!" %  

##6 

''(%$$  '($!' 6)%$$"1;  #6'

6- $  1

" %#  ' '

   -  "   %$$           '(  $  '  '   (   -'

"' ' 6-1 1 2'  ##) 

1<# 

  ## "=

6'$ 

--( ' ( >9 $ ( (   $ 1 '"   '$ ?   $  $'   (  -'

01 

!"%  

 ' (6 #1#-#  6?  ' 

)#6  1 # #? 

)1 1 26 #'  

 

 )   ? # '$ ## '

1 001 :#$()

        %    #        '   '

      -1;    ' $   '  ! ## '(      '     6-"

   ( 1 0>1 - ( 6!"%#   '

           -    !"         ('   #6  

 ')1 0@1 ;   

 6 

##$)'  - -#1 $ (

6## 

6-#'$  -  $#$# '12 '      $  '(    ##      $  6

$     #$  (      #         (#$(-'( (# ! 0 >%" ( '( #  - -   

1  >1 2-  - -$  ?  ## # 6# ?   1 (    ') ( 6#  '

 

-- ( ?  $## ' ( 1 ( #   $  - '$#  -'

# '# (1 4--$  # ?    $            1  46     # ##   -1 > 1  '$( -#$( # (   (       # 

6

   (-# #- ##12 -1 

 ($  '

6 $1    $     (    #- # 0 > $('

(6- ( $1;  $ ###$(#-%

 -! ## #'" 

 9%1; $ $  #

((##(  -')  ' -- '

#  0%1 >01 - ( #' (-#  -     -          # (      ('') 

1 >>1 #6'$ 

-$ ( 1    # # -  $#  6- (   # 0 > %$#6  

($# $#

- $126  

 )      -  6           &     $-$1- (  ' - ('(# ( - -6 #61 
>91   ##  6'

$ 6 #$% ' '( ##$#1# 

- - 

#$6 '-  ' ( $ ') #1/ *1 &7 D$%   9  '  6

$

@ ,

&   %  " 

,$ 



$ $  82
 01*:   



"

"      I 

&$  6% , , &" , 

"

           82
   01*:             $   % ,,  &

 !

6%-%+&   

 !    

!

  $ 
 !  ,$ ,$   !&   ".# &% 

"/ ;&   D &!   ,, & 

!

  "-%+ "

 >$ ! "$?



&

         ,  !

 "

!  ,   E    7 " &  & $

!

   &  , "

,   , #" :5

:< % #6 **
  "    "

 !  !

  9$, D$%     $ $  &   "

 *@& -<21 -6'3!/ - /%;& . /  
12- $ 6 # -$66 34-% 4- % =  -# --#1#

( '

-6 6##'(4-% %  



'5$AB $6

CD1C=(5 ,,5 -#-5651 ,1*! #"

# (1C ' 6= 4-% B- (B 3 -*    ! #"    '   (  #   '(  4*'

    #$% 1 91 ($- $'(

  # 1 @1

@ 

@4*'

 #$%  

--3 -$ #    B-   (    B   3  -*   ! #"

'#

$    #  6  #     '  $  

  6    6  )  '(  4-  %     %  



'51- $' ( '3-  $1

1 ($- $'(

  # 1 @1

@ 

@4*'

 #$%  

--3 -$ #    B-   (    B   3  -*   ! #"

'#

$    #  6  #     '  $     6    6  )  '(  4-  %     %  



'51- $' ( '3-  $1

1 2- $ 6$# - D'  '

6    (

6'$#+%,#!" 2% '

$#-D)- !"1/ *0 F$!& " "", "  !  & 

& ,, %E052:30103 *@& -<21 -6'3!/ - /%;& 4!/&6& '%"'

"#

'3% '3 " <!/& " 1< **

*5                    

, ./ !

 "

!  ""

 "&

&

*< $,"

   "

 ./   ./ 

 ""

$

, - ,,

 )

) 

* .-

) *

"

 E $A  

JA

E 

JA