Ms Garg Furnace Limited v. Union Of India And Others
!"
#$%$!&'
!( ) * +,
-./ 0-
1 *%2%
/
-' 30 -/4 / 0/ 00
30 -4 / -
0
0/ 00, 4
! "
#$ % & '$%&(
! ) )*)*+ " ,- % # !
!
./%
,-*) 0 1
,-*) 0
1 * & 2 " "
34 ./5
,- *) 0'
*) 0( %
6 ! # - ! 7 $%& ! -
89 : & " 2 " 1 1
!
!
; &
%
,-*) 0' <=% ,7( ) )*)*+
>*"!
1
! % ? ,- % '%? %( ! # ,-% ' ,%( $ % & '$%&( ./@ *) 0 " ! $%& - 5 6 # ,%-
,% ! $%& 7 $%&" ,% ! ! " ! ,% 1 " "
& " A ./*) 0
,%" -
! $%&
+ & 1 B %
!"# C B % $ %& '
'
'
& %
( " ) *+"# ,
- ' ' .& .
' .
'
- ' "
* *+*# , /
/
- ( %
%
' 0
( "
** *) C B% ,
- ' , /
/
- ( '
( " 1 $ %&'
' 1 '
(
" &'( > ) ;;D:@*)*+ ) 00*:@*)*+
! B7 % 0)+*)*+ )D)0*)*+
!& B%
); *)*+%45*:/0+5*)*+ " "#!C B% $ %&'
'
5%26* 7, ,
- ' ' 5%26* ( , /
/
- ( '
( " 2 ! " ); *)*+
%45*:/0+5*)*+'-.% /89 ) /2&: * / *$6% ( *%2% &$!& !"
&:$
&:
! 8 *%( ! "
" / &
" ! !
2 ! C @
); *)*+
;
5-.% /89 ) /2&: * / *$6%
( *%2% &$!& !"
&:$
&:
! 8 *%7
0 4 "
. "
% , *) 0 , > '
, > ):% .:)0 EC(&
" ! $%& " # ) )*)*+ > !$%& - 5 D ); *)*+ -.% /89 ) /2&: * / *$6%'
(" 1 1 B% / ) <<!9%,C B% $ %& '
' '
(= ,
- ' ' 5%26* ( , /
/
- ( '
( 2 0 3
%( %
"
%%4
#!, B% ?! B % /5
( .& %
0 ( + *
"!) "
% B% $ ,(5 ( %
/
0 6%(-
( %%4
% "+""
B% 2 / . ' 7
( *%%4
**"" B% - & -
5 &
% 0
( "%%4
+8+9"
F" -
! B % 1 C ?! , ); *)*+
5
3 : 6 ,% ! ! 1
! 1 B% 1
1 '
(
,% 6 $%& , ! $%& - " ./5 *) 0
1 B%
1 '
(
5 3*. ./% , " %
6
- ! , -
" ./5 # ! !
- # " > - " # ./5 "
"
! "1
*DA
./' (% ,
*) 0
" ./ - !%
! ' " #
%
(G
" -
"
(% -
(,%
!
! (, "
:) # ./H ./ 5(C
"
! ! ;D ! ! (
2 ! : ./' (% , *) 0
! "
,
" 2
# " ,
2 ./ # :* "
./
# 2 -5
::A ! # ./ % -
G
'
! " ( ! :; ! " '(% - '( ! " ./# :+ G ./ " # , !
"
"
! "
! - ! ! ! !
'0:0;% ,( !
!
./ ------------------------------------------------------- ---- ; 2
" 2
!
# ! " -
! 2
!
! - ! B 2 B"
- ;* !
! !
!
./ "
! ./ ! "
, ! 0: 0; ! ! " ! G
! %
'
( *D % , G
!! ! # - .:% , ;: !
! !
! # ./
;;, " - ! ,
- " ! 0: 0; % , "
!
"
./ # " 6
!
!!
! " - " ------------------------------------------------------- ------ 3;D,
" "
% !
./ - " !
# 9 ) F"-
!B% 1 C , ?!" ! % !
./ *) 0 ! !I
" ,% ! " ! ./*) 0 %
"
,% $%& " !
" '"% >( 2 " B" " ! $%& = #7 "!
! !4 - " " ! "
! ! 0: 0;% ,
1 B% "
-.% /89 ) /2&: * / *$6%'
( 5 3 . "
"" 1 B% B% C , -
4
! "" -
! B % %
$ , (5 2 / . ' - & -
5 1 '
(
! " C B % ,
- ' , /
/
- ( 1 '
( !
!B7 % D 4 ! !
0)+*)*+ )D)0*)*+ B7 %
1
,
- ' , /
/
- ( 1 '
(
"
""#! B % %
, ! 1 - *) 4 ! !
0)+*)*+ )D)0*)*+ B7 %
1
,
- ' , /
/
- ( 1 '
(
"
" " # ! B % %
, ! 1 - * " @ " -!
"
$%&
'
( -
,%
@# '
(9
* J " "
" %45*:/0+5*)*+'-.% /89 ) /2&: *
/ *$6% ( *%2% &$!& !"
&:$
&:
! 8 *%( ); *)*+ :
! # !' ( ! " " ;
'
(! '
(
!
50/ 007
5-
07
!( ) * +,
4
#@ K @> 4 K @>