← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/61895/2024allowed

Amit Aggarwal v. State Of Haryna

2024-12-16Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil11 pages

       

   

   !   "## #   #  

$!##  !

 

  

        

 







#  !%&!'

()*(+,-./01      ! "   #$%     &   &'

 '

    ()* + ,-.   /% /% ,/,$   ,,0 ,%   +

 &

'   '"

   "'



 ,  

     

     ()*

0  

         

 

!"  #$#

%&'   ( "  '()&*'   "

 *'  +,,%*'   (- - ( . /01! %   -  2     /   / "  (   ( " ("-   "  .2          3   '4         # 4+  /5 ( 6 

#   '  '     (( 2

   6 



'"..25

(.252  ( 7      

$

 2        

   #     (        ( 

    6  (

$   ( 

      ("

 *'  (

(" '     3 '4  $#$      % 89'#  #

 5

 '   ("  '-( )&*'   3%'4  $(    +,,%*'  (- -  

. /01! % -2 /  / "(&,&)(      '".8.25

(.252

$  #$  (                   "- -   311'4# / '" #  %3'4"     '-  (  )&*'    (       % 89'#   

. 

'#5'    %

89'#  (- #$ $  "

2 $ - ( (-  $(          # / '".  2   (  #        %31  '4    "  (:  '

         2( ( (  

(:

.252  

    #$ " 

( 

# #((        -      $  #$  (            (- -  # 2 1

   #8+#+$5;#5

< &!<)1'#85=+#>( # 2#

""   ( 

 ( '-( +

 (  # #(

2    ( 

   

    (  

.2  52    $  (     "     '-( +  "  !

    %3!'4  



     # #(  4+#(  

8 ),*!'

7 9  /  5    '       9

 '  (%%2

$#$ 

$#

#$%&*'   "

 # 8   5'   $-     2      "

  $ 6  (

 $

(  2

? -(( 2 (   /@@

 4(

  $  #$  " 2  (-           1

2 89'  #   #  #((   

"  # #(( (    189' #  

(  (-  

   (@

  A$  ( 2   

 /@

    "    "" 

" # #(( 

'- (  )&*'        +  ,,%*'  

(   $ #$   2     %!&, &&  '-"#BB6  '   8 89'# #'       ) &))%%

    %3 !  '4   

           "        '".8.25

(.252

   %3 %'4$#$ 2  

  4  '-  

  9 (  5     '  2 (  )&)1 & )   "

#  %3%'4"

 *'  '  ( (

."   "   "  - "2 ." 8 !  

%3!,'4 '     "

2  13 1 '44 '-"#BB6  '  8  89'# #'    

  "  

" # #( 

4 '-" (

    



" # #((   $    '-  "  4B  B6  '  ! ( 8 89' # '      

2 "

 6 

$

 2     ? -((

( 2   24(

(@

    

" # #( 4 '- " $-2(- 2   (

"  ( 2  2(@

  4

'-" 

   '- "#B6  '   " 

$ 

   "2 4 '- (+ #"  



  6 

  

" 

 

    -  

C  4  -2  ""  " 2        

(  

" "

 (  - 2 '-"#BB6  '   #

 1311'4 '-

 9 (5   '     "  "-  

   

  " 

 '-"$#$"   2( 

" # #(  (  2

"

( 

   2( 

  2 ( "  8 89'#  ( 

"

    C  



"

 

"&

C 

"

 -

   

 %

"

    6  ( 

 9$'B8D?+#B ?9.5+.$9B 

1  4/  #.'$8B  =+'#B #:+B  $' 

1  4/           +

) 4C/ 1*

BD'%*

& 



!&

"

    6  ( 

 9$'B8D?+#B ?9.5+.$9B 

1  4/  #.'$8B  =+'#B #:+B  $' 

1  4/           + 

 4C/

*

BD'!*

&  # 

      '-  

  9 (  5     '    "      "      

        

  ""    

(-       (-    "  

 

 -  '-

9 (5  A



$#$(  - 

 

 

   

"    9$'B8D?+#B ?9.5+.$9B 

1  4/  #.'$8B  =+'#B #:+B  $' 

1  4/        + 4C/

*

BD'!*

&(   B     ;(   

 (

-

 

"





"   " "

-

( 

 ="       '-  

  9 (  5   '  (- 

" #$#8$+ =4#.

 %&*'+  #8$  8#.5$5  5B++ '#85=+#  =:B53  9B#$+  C  8#.5$5 9.=/  #89  '?5.'$5  =:#85B  $8 #++'#$5  9.=/  .B50B.B9  C.4  #4$ #//#.;#+  *  +#B    4#8  +#+ 'B.4#8B8 .*   8 <),*!  '=8#:$  9#:#  '$5B/#89$5;.#$+;#?.#9#+# '#85=+# .

8 E#>.

8 #'B.89'#5 )1%%+4$+#:+B#'B.+#:B+5+#$4 58#$8/9$'B8D?+#B?9.5+.$9B

4/#:+B##5$0B$8/.B9$B8 &#:+B :#5  8   !

!  4*9  *

 B*9  !*

& F=#8$? %1* #:+B4#8=C#5=.B9:?

.'/  +$CB  5$B85B  +$4$B9 !

*#/ $ B#B  #8+B;#.<

  9$  :#.=5 /=.#$89$#;B$/C#:+B1, &/4C

&#:+B#89.

8 %>.

8 #'B.89' #5!

)1%%+4$+#:+B'B.+#:B+5+#$4 58#$8/9$'B8D?+#B?9.5+.$9B

4/  #:+B  #5$0B  $8/.B9$B8  %  #:+B :#5  8   !

)  4*9  1*

 B*9  %*

& F=#8$? %1* #:+B4#8=C#5=.B9:?

.'/  +$CB  5$B85B  +$4$B9 !

*#/ $

  B#B#8+B;#.<

9$ :#.=5 /=.#$89$# ;B$/C#:+B!% %/4C

%#:+B #'B.+#:B+5+#$4B9.=/ 4B8$8B9  #  B.$#+  8  #  :#.B  50B.B9 =89B.89'#5#B.$#+8 %% #;B$/ , /.#4#89- C  

-2#BB6   '   #  (-( " '-

9 (5   2  "

# ( "$ 6 

  "     

""      (2 



    

2 '- "#B B6    '    

     -

%

"

$ 6  (

9$'B8D?+#B ?9.5+.$9B 

1  4/  #.'$8B  =+'#B #:+B  $' 

1  4/  :#5  8   +

) 4C/ 1*

#89BD'$.?%*

&"

     2("  ""

  " <!  - !&

"

  $ 6  (

9$'B8D?+#B ?9.5+.$9B 

1  4/  #.'$8B  =+'#B #:+B  $' 

1  4/  :#5  8   + 4C/

*

 #89  BD'$.?  !*

&    "

      2( "

     2 (   ' <   "   " 2""  " 

  

    "

  #* <  2  #$    

'-"#BB6  '   "

  '*!<! "   " 2""

$#$ 2 #*!<! '-"#B B6  '  6 " '*$<!

  6( 2 $- 2  +*,,% '        '-  "  #B  B6  '    "

       

  #

  # #(      ( "   7 "  "44$   --($4

 )!, 1,1&

   "      89'# .

%*<$5  2   - C  " "    

"" C 

 

(

C      189'#  "            -  2    '- "#BB6  '   C "  <

#* '*!   %

"

$ 6  ( 

9$'B8D?+#B?9.5+.$9B

14/ #.'$8B=+'#B#:+B$'

14/:#5 8  +

)4C/1*

#89BD'$.?%*

&E 

%

>((!% %(  "  " <    #* '*!     2(    !& "



 $ 6  ( 

9$'B8D?+#B ?9.5+.$9B 

1  4/  #.'$8B  =+'#B #:+B$'

14/:#58  + !4C/

*

#89BD'$.? !*

& E &

> (( 1, &(  " 

# #(  "44$    - -($4

 )!, 1,1&  .

%*<$  2           "   "

  2 ""(   -2 

  

6  (

C 4 

" 2

2 '-"#BB6  '     '-"#BB6  '    "-    

# #( 

  " 

 6 

 "

C     " 2  "  (

   #

  #  #((  -  

    

5<&!<)189'# 2"(  "

  $ 6   

 9"62 2   # "   "   

 $'  +     "

  (!



E( 

 , (

>  

2-   "

=" 2

  

 "

""  

// "( &,&)  '  

 "   "

   (    

   (

 "    "



2  "    .2  5

(  '" . .2  52    +#<  )%  +8/< ,&

) &  #$  #  

  %&*#   8    5 '  9 

 )31'4  

(

8 ,1 

 

5< &!<)189'# '     " " (

$ -31(31*-3, 34(05)+-+10(6(1*1*-3(7 4  '

   

     ,// 4 '

!' 5  

     5 

& ''





!  

 '

6 

    !  ''

 '      

 

!  



) !   ! '      ' 

  

! & ()* + $$7,/%   ,  +

 &

'   '"

  "'

 5    '



     

 , /% ,/,$

  ''

       8 /, ,/,# 34(05)+-+10(#151( 9    '   '

  

    

  5  "  

"   '

       & 

''&     ,// 4 '

!' 5&& -, &

  

   5  ''   

 '

6 

# 35)8,*, :



 &  

   /

 /$



 /.



 5      

    

''&     ,// 4 '

!' 5&& -, &

 

& ''





!  

 '

6 



     &    '  ''

       8 /, ,/,#  &  ! 

  8 / ,/,#

    '

%  5 '

/ 5 ! ;

    5         '   '

5''

" '&   5     !   !   

   *'    ! '

   &   

;

   < 

   

     5  ! '  &   '



& '

'

 &    '

       

 ; *'       &   

0



#  "

   7  "  

"

"

   ( 2 "     -              ( 

- 

      - 

 " 

 (

 "    

  

              "

    "   

?   "       7  "   (  ( "

(" 7"      E -6"

 2  

> 6 "

=  2    " " "" -

(  

  "  (    ("

   2(   7  "      

   ( 

2   7 (  (  

-      6      7          

2(

   2 5 2-2(5     2 ?    2   

2   "   2( 

"  ( (   

  

   

% ;   " ( (         

 

 ( -

(   " ""

  

""  2 "     -        

$ -

( (     

2    

   

  "    ( -

( 

(      

  " ( " 7  

2  (

       2       "            

    "  " (   

 -

(            -

( (     ( ""(  2 -

( (   2

  ( -

( (  (        (     6"

      ( -     7 ( 

  """   $    

2  7 (     

 

<

 

   

  

   ( 

"- 2  (



  6 2 "   - '     2 " ( B6"       % &      5    5  '    !

,  #   2    ""        2' 2  (

% &# 55 '  !

,

"

  2



    "

27 (( ""   ( 

"   

"   " 

27  

2  -  

   (   (    ( 2      

 "    -  "   "   (     

#   ! 5

 

 

- ("  (

  "

  2 5  $.<$

5 ! ) '   !,E%>.5.

E5 >%!&3 !,E1>.  #"6 (

E.

#  > %)3E !,>!55&1) & 

  (  "- 

   2     2  6"          -8  - = $ !,E! >5#+B& ((  2 

4(5 $     

 /  (-  '

7E!

)> 55 1&1    -   2  8(- (<B "#$.!

%5

%,&     "

 

. 

       B "  -  

  #$.  !

# 1&   - (   

 6 "

"-   (<  " 

"-  

  2(( 

 2

, -    

    ( -2  ( 

        2              7 ( (   

     (      



  

   6    7  

2       

   "

 2 #  

 (  (  

   "  "  2 ( (  

2   '        

 

 '

'  '

&  

 '



    !'  

    

' ,     )

  '

&   !   



 

  

;

  <!

 "



 #$ !

 %& 

'

 (

(

:     !  5  0    0 ' ' !



!' "&  5    

 

  

       

     &   !'

 

& 5  5 

      '

 



 

 

   

 '           '    ! '

         *00,.%#0,/,, '

)'* 

+    %, 

 *-   /, /$ ,/,$ 5 5' &

' ,     )    '  !

   & & '    '

   

 ! '"  !



   6 ''

 

    &     '

 ! '"  5       

'

  5        &   )   '  

   '   '

 '



  

   7 

''

!

!'

5' '

   

    '

   '

.

 #

) 5   

  !    !

  ! '   &'

 '

  & '

 

!        '

7

 &   ) 

0        !

''5

5  

 ' 

 &    ! ''

 ! 

 ;    

      &#  !'



   ' 8(

;  "(*  ? *8 ; " ? *8