High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/33411/2024dismissed

The Punjab State Co Operative Supply And Marketing Federation Ltd v. Jagtar Singh And ANR

2025-02-24Ms. Justice Lapita Banerji7 pages

IN THE E HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB A AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH =< N : 24.02.2025 : DATE OF DECISION

?PETITIONER

Versus

!!!RESPONDENTS CORAM : H Present :

LAPITA BANE HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE LAPI ITA BANERJI !

/%&- $ $"&"'

()*+",- !

"# $% $"&"'

()*+",-

0-,%,%*/-!

NERJI, J.(ORAL) $% "001%+",%*/ 01"+%/2 //-34- @!

001%+",%*/ "11*5-(!

*+4&-/ /, ,"#-/ -+*( 467-+, "11 74 , -3+-0,% %*/ !

/ 0- -/, 5%, 0-,%,%*/'

+$"11-/2-( "5"( 8'

9 ://-34- < 0" -( -04,;

-2% ,"'

** *0-",%)- *+%-,%- '

% 4#, "

"$%6'

://-34 4- < 0" -( 00-11",- 4,$*%,;*%/, -2% ,"

41;

://-34- < 0" -( -)% %*/"1 4,$*%,;(( (%,%*/"1 -2% ,"

:(&%/<'

**0 0-",%)- *+%-,%- !

."+, +" -'

6%-.'

"- .*11*5 >

:%< 4%/ /2 ;-"

(4- /*/&%11%/2 0"((;

+*0 A * *(-/ %+- %11 "1*4, /- -21%2-/+- - 0*/(-/, -,%-( -&01*;-- '

0-,%,%*/-"#.

.-( 4..--( .%/"/+%"1 ,4/- ! '@@'B@A!

:%%<

4 4"/, 04/% $&-/, +,*6- '

.*4 "//4"1 %/+-&-/, - 0*/(-/, - -&01*;-- -(4+-( 0* 0-+, ,%)- -..-+,!

- 0*/(-/, -& &01*;-- 0-.--( "00-"1 04/% $&-/, *(-!

:%%%< %(- 9'

://-34- 8<'

04/% $& &-/, +,*6- '

8 -, " %(-!

00-11"

,- 4,$*%,;

+*/.%&-( $-- $*,"2- %+- (4%/2 ;-"

$*,"2- *++4-( (4%/2 ;-"

999 !

$--.*-'

+4 ,*(%"/ -&01* *;-- ;-"

999 0*/ %61- $*,."11!

:%)<

"6%,",%*/ +" - %/ ,%,4,- -&01*;- -- "#.-(!

%/+- "&- %/ ,%,4,-( 5%,$%/ 0-%*( 1%&%,",%*/'

"%( "6%,",%*/ +" - (% &% -( 0%1 '

C C!

:)<

(-0* %,-( ,5* 0* ,(",-( +$-D40-,%,%*/-'

"&*4/,% %/2 !'8C'@B A -"+$ :

*,"1 !@'@8' ! < %/+ +4-( ;-"

999 !

*,$ +$-D4-

6*4/+-( +" - .%1- 4/(- -+,%*/ C

-2*,%"

61- / ,4&-/, +,'

CC "2"%/ / , &%11-!

-/,-/+- */- ;-"

%&0% */&-/, .%/- !@ A!

:)%<

+" - -+*)-;

.%1-( "2"

"%/ , &%11-&*(-/ %+- *# ( "1",!

%,$ +*/ -/, 0"

",%- '

*# ("1", (-+%(-( "/4 4";

@ 5* *41( 0";

! ' ' A %/,-- , "00-11"/,!

!@ 1"+ (-0* %,-( +" $ -&"%/%/ /2 "&*4/,'

+$-D4- $"/(-( *)- 5$%+$ 6*4/+-( "2"%/!

:)%%<

$ -/,-/+-( ;-"

%&0% */&-/, .%/- !@ A $%-.

4(%+%"1 "2% , ,",-'

% 4#, "

"$%6!

,$--".,-'

(-0* %,-( 4& !@' ' A ")*%( 04/% $& &-/,!

:)%%%<

"#.-(0-,%,%*/- ,$--".,- .% %1-( "&-/(-( 0-,%,%*/ 0%1 C C'

C -+*)-;

%/,-- , "&*4/, !'C'B'B88A -&01*;-- !

, +*/,-/(-( 1-"/-( 6%,",* -&01*;-- - 0*/(-/, +*41( $")- "&-/(-( 0-,%,%*/ -+*)-;

!'C'B'B88A 5$-/ +1"%& 0- -,%,%*/- -,,1-( 5";

(-+% %*/ *# ("1",!

:%3< 1-"/-( 6%,",* +"&- .%/(%/2 -/,--( %/,* -,,1 -&-/, -/,%- "&*4/, "1*/2 %/,-- , 0"%( 0-, ,%,%*/- 0- (-+% %*/ *# # ("1",!

$--.*-'

+1"

"%& %/,-- , "&*4/, !'C'

'B'B88A )"1%(!

:3<

4,$-&*-'

1-"/-( 6%,", ,*-04,;

-2% ,"

+"&- .%/( %/2 %/+- *# ("1", "/4";

@ @'

+*41( $")- .%1-( "&-/(-( 0-,%,%*/ 0%1 C C'

C ".,- 0-%*( ,$-- ;- -&01*;-- !

:3%<

/ "00-"1 .%1-( *% %/, -2% ,"

"#.-( $--%/ +$"11-/2%/2 -04,;

-2% ,"!

*%/, - -2% ,"

)%(- %&042/-(

+"&- (-+% %*/ )%-5 ,"#-/ 1-"/-( -04,;

-2% ," 6%,", +*-+, */- "5"

"( &-%,-( %/,-.--/+-!

:3%%<

$--".,-'

-)% %*/ 0-,%,%*/ .%1-( "#.-( ((%,%*/"1 -2% , "!

%(- %&042/-( 4 41;

((%,%*/"1 -2% ,"

$-1( (% 04,- -,, ,1-( 6-,5--/ "#.-(0-,%,%* */- *# ( "1",!

)-/ 04/% $%/2 "4,$*%,;

$ *(--( -+*)-;

.*& -&01*;- -- */1;

+" -'

"&- -+*)--( .*& &%11-!

$--.* -'

*/+- 0-,%,%*/-"#.-( +*/ -/,-( -,,1-&-/, (*/- 5% %,$ &%11-'

%, +*41( "% - "/;

+1"%& - 0-+, "&- !

:3%%%<

1-"/-( ((%,%*/"1 -2% ,"

"1 * +"&- .%/(%/2 */+-

,"61% $&-/, ..%+- 0-,%,%*/-"#.-( $%& -1.

% 4-( 1- -,,- *!

A AA A@@ ("

",-( '

(-+%(%/2 0*+--( -&01*;-- '

.4,$- +*41( 6- -+*)-- .*& -&01*;-- !

++ +*(%/21;'

$-1(

%&042/- 8'

9 &-%,-( %/,-.

.--/+- -)% %*/ 0-,%,%*/ (% &% -(!

%(- -+-&6 6- 0" -( **(%/",- - -/+$ ,$% *4,'

(%-+,-( 0*(4+- 1-,,- '

% 4-( %,

"61% $&-/, ..%+-!

1-,,- '

6--/ 0*(4+-( -+*(!

-"/-( +*4/ -1 "00-"%/2 6- -$"1.

46&%, ,$-- -,,1-&-/, - 0*/(- -/, -&01*;-- ,$--.*-'

,$-- 6"

"% %/2 +1"%& $-&!

4..--( 5*4 41( 41,%&",-1;

6461%+ -3+$-D4- ,$--.*-'

(- 0%,- *( (- 0" -( *# ("1",'

-&01*;-- - 0*/(-/, $*41( 6- "11*5-( 2* +*,.--!

$% *4, $"

$-"( 1-"/-( +*4/ -1 0-4 -( &"

",-%"1 -+*(!

*& 0-4 "1 "5"( 0"

" -( -04,;

-2% ,"

%&04 42/-( 0" -( * %/, -2% ,"

((%,%*/"1 -2% ,"'

%, 6- -+*&- +1-"

+1"%& 0-,%,%*/-"#.-( $"

6--/ -,,1-( *# ("1",!

"%( +1"%& & ! '@@'B@A $"

6--/ 5$*11;

-,,1-( (!

$--.*-'

*/+- -/,%- +1"

"%& $"

6--/ -,,1-( *# ("1",'

- 0*/(-/, +"//*, 6- *0-( 0";

"/;

%/,-- , "% %/2 *4, "%( +1"%&!

4,$ $-&*-'

- 0*/(-/, -,%-( 1*/2 6"

"+#!

(% +%01%/";

0*+--(%/2 5$%+$ %/%,%",-( (4%/2 ,-/4- ,$-% -)%+-'

6--/ D4" $-( !

* (% +%01%/";

0*+--(%/2

0-/(%/2 - 0*/(-/, -&01 1*;-- ", ,%&- ,$-% -,%-&-/,!

$ --.*-'

-+*)-;

+"/ 6- &"( (- ", 4+$ 6-1",-( ,"2- .*& -,%-( -&0 01*;-- !

*-*)-'

.*& 0-4 "1 1-,,- '

% 4-(

,"61% $&-/, ..%+- "

"#.-(0-,%,%*/-'

%, 6-+*&- "&01;

+1-"

$", (-+%(-( -+* *)- "&*4/, .*& */1;

;

.*& +4 ,*(%"/ - &01*;-- !

((%,%*/"11;'

.*& &%/4,- &--,%/2 *..%+%"1

+*/+-/-( "#.-( "00-11"/, $-1( *)-&6- 9'

%, 6- -+*&- "&01;

+1-"

*"( (-+ +%(-( 0*+--( -&01*;-- +4 ,*(%"/ %/+4-( (4%/2 ;-"

999 !

(-+%(-( 0*+--(%/2 +%)%1 "- , &";

6- %/%,%",-( %, 5*41( 6- "00*0%",- $*1( -&0 01*;-- 0-,%,%*/-"#.

.-( - 0*/ %61-!

%/,-- , +*&0*/-/, (-+%(-( 6- ,-",-( ,"( (- 4+$ (-+% %*/ -D4%-( 601"+-( +*&0-,-/, "4 4,$*%,;

"00*)"1!

*5 0-,%,%*/-"

#.-( +"/ 6- "11*5-( - %1- .*& %, *5/ (-+% %*/ "1 * +*41( 6-

4%,"61;

-301"%/-( 1-"/ /-( +*4/ -1 "00-"%/2 0-,%,%*/-!

/ 1%2$, ".*- "%( (% +4 %*/ '

,$% *4, .%/( "((1- -,% %-( -&01*;-- /*5 %/,-- , +*&0*/-/, 5%11 6- 5$*1 11;

%11-2"1 "6%,";'

+"4 %/2 2")- 0-74(%+- -&01*;-- !

$ $% *4, .%/( ,$-- %/.%&%,;

%&042/-( 8'

41;

*! */ -D4-/,1;'

Connected application(s), if any, s shall also stand disposed of.

24.02.2025 Prince Whether speak Whether report (LAPITA BANERJI) JUDGE king/reasoned :

Yes/No table :

Yes/No