Sabir v. State Of Haryana And Others



       

  





# $%&%!'(

)  * 

+) %%!' , - ,&.& *    *

)))) &/!'# '& 0(
12 0*) *     2 , & '(

0,) - ,%'# , *%'34  #6!$

/ %%!' ,) 0,) -%7, *%'345 5 :::::

   25 ) ;2< ) , 9 , "%= # .'# , ,%$=

 !'&%.%!'

'#%

& %'3

&%# ) )

&& # , &/!'# '

!)5

  !)

)  .'# , * $%!'&  
5

 , * $%!'&



5  


5 , 3%& , #

!=%$  5  ,%# #5 6%# $= %8 > '

, @ $ #)

&.>8% #

$!'6%$ # =%"

%8/,%&!'8 '

 ) 

>!6 %#  ) &.>8%&

%8 4%& $!'6%$%!'5 , 8  = !=%$9  

>= ) & / , = .& ;

< %# /!=%$95

=%"

$!'6%$ > $!8 & =%3%>= $!'&%# , ./!'

$!8/= %!'

,& & ' '$ %'$=.#%'3 , 8%&&%!'&) &.>8%&

=, #9 $!8/=  # , A.%&% / ,%!#

4.& ".="%==& =%3%>%=%9 $,% ,%

.'# ,

/!=%$9) ".,4 , &.>8%&

%' # 3!!# $!'#.$ 4,!.34!.

4%&

%'$ ,$ , %!')

%= # ,!= & 6 , = !$$ &%!'&

' 6 , 8%&.& # $!'$ &&%!'

'!, $!88% #

'9 !"" '$ #.,%'3 &.$4 / ,%!#) %& @ %= $!'#.$5 ,%$.= ,=9 #.,%'3 = "%6 ,&5 , 8 %' # %&"

$!,95

, A.%, # .'# , /!=%$9) ".,4 , $!' '# #

/ %%!' ,B&

,>%, ,%=9 , @ $ # 6%# %8/.3' # ) )

# " ,,%'3  , ,5 &!= =9 &%&

#6 ,& !/%'%!'

, &%#%'3 ""%$ ,) *.$4 , @ $%!'

$!', !

= ?5

!/%'%!'

&!.34 .'# , * $%!'

;

< , !'=9 , $!88 '# !,9

'!

>%'#%'3 ./!'

$!8/  '

.4!,%9) &.>8%&

2 6 = !88% "

%= # !

$!'&%# , >%'#%'3 @.#%$% = /, $ # '&

/!=%$9

$!'6%$%!'

8.& 3!6 ,'

$!'&%# , & ) 4 %8/.3' # ".,4 , %3'!, & & = # = 3 = /!&%%!'

!"" '$

=!'

''!

3,!.'# !

# '9 !'$ $!'6%$ %&"% & =%3%>%=%9 $!'#%%!'& .'# , /!=%$9)

".,4 ,

,3. #

%8/.3' #

,>%, ,95 .', &!'

>= 5

6%!= %6 ,%$= & 

 !'&%.%!'

'#%

6% ?

>!6 &.>8%&&%!'&5 = 4.8>=9 /, 9&

==!? #C %8/.3' # # " ,,%'3 / %%!' ,B&

&%# C

, &/!'# '
*

#%, $ # !

, $!'&%# , / %%!' ,B& "!,4?%4

$$!,# '$ , 8  = !=%$9  

& = # /,%'$%/= & = ?)

 , $!', =

6 4 8 '=9 !//!& # / %%!') &.>8%&

/ %%!' ,B& & 5 4!.34 /,!$ && # .'# , !=%$9   #.=9 $!'&%# , #

, @ $ #5

/ %%!' ,5

=!'3 4%& $!
$$.& #5 '#& $!'6%$ # !"" '$ #!.>= 8.,# ,5 3,

4 %'!.& ., 5

.'# ,3!%'3 =%"

%8/,%&!'8 ')

$!' '# #

!6 ,'8 '

D ,$%& # %& #%&$, %!'

"

%,

@.#%$%!.& '' ,5

7 /%'3 6% ?

& ,%!.&' && !"" '$ 5 , @ $%!'

/ %%!' ,B& $= %8 ".==9 @.&%"% #) !'& A. '=95 / %%!'5 > %'3 # 6!%#

'9 8 ,%5 =% !

#%&8%&& #)

 4%& @.'$., 5 = , &,%$ # 4%& /, 9 , !

"" $

?%== %&"% #5 %"

4%&

/,
, $!'&%# , #

/ , # $%&%!'

!!,#%'

 '$4 E!4=.

!=.

 6 ,&.&

!4 ,&G5 
H

# $%# #

,# = ,% &

'#5 4 %,

&&%& '$ 5 / ,.& # , $!,#)

6% ?

=%8% # /, 9 , = / %%!' ,5 4%& !., %'$=%' # !

= '% '

6% ?) !'& A. '=95

#%, $ # !

,
$!'&%# , 6% ?

# $%&%!'

!!,#%'

 '$4 !4=.

!=.

 ;&./, <5

&&

$$!,# '$ = ?%4%'

/ ,%!#

? 7& ",!8

, $ %/ $ ,%"% # $!/9 4%& !,# ,5 &,%$=9

/ , = ?) ) 4 #%&/!& #

>!6 & %#  ,8&) ;   2<

) 

 0!4% %&4'!% %< 4 4 , &/ 7%'3I, &!' #J  &I!

%%< 4 4 , , /!, >= J  &I!