← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/32041/2025disposed of

Dr Naresh Mittal v. State Of Haryana And Others

2025-12-23Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger3 pages

of paper book having already been supplied to her. She has handed over a copy of letter dated 22.12.2025 issued by the learned Tehsildar (Sales), Karnal, in Court today, which is taken on record, subject to all just exceptions. Another copy thereof has also been supplied to learned counsel for the petitioner, in Court today itself. Said letter dated 22.12.2025 reads as under:- "From Tehsildar (Sales), Karnal.

To The Advocate General Haryana, Chandigarh.

No.:-186 Dated:-22-12-2025 Subject:

CWP No.32041 of 2025 titled as Dr. Naresh Mittal v/s State of Haryana & ors., fixed for 23/12/2025. On the subject cited above, it is humbly submitted that written instructions are being submitted before your goodself to apprise the Hon'ble High Court in the subject matter, which are as follows:-

1. That the land in question was allotted to Sh. R.S. Nangia on 31.03.1995 U. No.3640-42/NTS/MO dated 16.03.1995 to Madho Nangia s/o Sh. Hemraj Nangia through Smt. Vidyawati Nangia wife of Madho Dass Nangia in village Bhola Khalsa and Chandrao.

2. That however, the allotment was challenged by the State of Haryana upto Hon'ble Supreme Court, but the allotment was confirmed/finalized by Hon'ble Supreme Court vide order dated 04.08.2016 in Review Petition (Civil) No.2169 of 2016.

3. That after the allotment, the land in question was sold by the allottee namely Smt. Vidyawati Nangia to the petitioner vide Agreement to Sate dated 05.06.1998. However, the same was not registered by any competent authority/Sub-Registrar, which is compulsory to be registered under the The Registration Act, 1908. The dispute arose between both the parties and the same was resolved on 21.02.2024 through arbitral award, vide which the Arbitrator has recognized the Agreement to Sale to be correct.

4. That the land in question was unauthorizedly occupied by the illegal occupants, who filed claimed to purchase the land in question, for which they filed number of appeals before the predecessor court of undersigned, which were rejected, as the land in question was already allotted. Thereafter, these illegal occupants approached the Court of Commissioner (Sales)-

cum-Deputy Commissioner, Karnal through number of appeals, which has been decided by the Ld. Court vide order 22.12.2025, vide which, claim of the illegal occupants has been rejected.

5. That in present scenario, as the claim of illegal occupants has been rejected by the Deputy Commissioner, Karnal and the allotment has been finalized upto Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, the office of undersigned will get vacate the land in question from illegal occupants and provide the possession to the petitioner in due course of law.

In view of above facts and circumstances, it is humbly requested your goodself to apprise Hon'ble High Court with the aforesaid facts and if Hon'ble Court is not satisfied with the above-stated facts, and order to submit the reply/written statement, in that event, an adjournment may kindly be sought to enable the undersigned to file an appropriate reply, on the adjourned date and oblige. Sd/- (22.12.2025) N.Tehsildar (Sales) Karnal "

3.

Learned State counsel, on instructions from Mr. Vijay Singh, Naib Tehsildar (Sales), Karnal, and while referring to the above extracted letter dated 22.12.2025, submits that the proposal for allotment of the land in question in favour of the petitioner already stands approved vide award dated 21.02.2024 (Annexure P-6) passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Panchkula; and in all probabilities, possession of the land in question shall be delivered to the petitioner within a period of six months from today, .

4.

Keeping in view the aforesaid submissions made by learned State counsel, the present writ petition is, accordingly, disposed of.