Union Of India And Others v. Jarmej Singh And ANR




   
  



!"#$%&%&

  "#"'#( !"#$%&%&    ! "#"$% 
 &'     )$  *+) & ,
,

, -

  *+) ,& ,
,  
, ) ( )*+, # -.

./- 0.

" /)1)234.5 59593/

# .2)

89/(71)234.5 63

/53 ::::

,

, -

.&/ 012

7 3 (7  57  9/5./5  ;

95  8 59593/1  57 59593/

 7

9/ .+63 559/(.9) 3

).5 ) 

%// <

 '.

8.

)*+57 = ) )3  9* /.=43/4

)1;7

*+57

/5;.( ./5 )57 * 69536 3 /)9/(366157 63 4308 59/( )9.*9=95+ /529.29)9.*9=95+8 /93/

0(3'010(45"'#!&  /53 9 <.2".

>9/(7;. 3== )9/  0+  3/  

?  ./)  ;.  )947.

( )  6 30 

 ; 6

 
3/ @ /5  53  79  )947.

(  6 30  57

1  57

/5 ;.  ( ./5 )  57  63==3;9/(  )9.*9=95+* 695 .=3/(;957

)
 

   

        

 7

.65

157

/569= )1*

 9* /.= 43/4

) .57

63 ( ./536* 69536 3 /)9/(366)9.*9=95+

/5AB..(.9/5& B63 =96 ; 6



7 .9) .88=94.593/;..==3;

)29) 3

).5 ) 

%// <

 ' 7 38

.592 8.

53657 .9)3

9 )7

9/.65

  

 

   



 

  

  !"#$ "%&       $ $

#  

       "

    

 



  ! % 8 .''



=9/(  .(( )  6 30 57  .63

 3

1  57 59593/

/93/36/)9.7.69= )57

.(.9/557 9/5./5;

958 59593/ ,'678

8"# "93:

1 0# !("'#

19"3:

;

3838"#

&  557 3 5 5157 = )43 / =63 59593/

/93/ 36/)9.

5357

/)9593/%'362.

93 > )(0 /5*+57 3/C*=

8 <
3 51;7

*+1  

       

    

  6

 *09557.59/29 ;36 <835 =.593/36=.;0.)

9/157 = ) 9* /.=43/4

73 =)7.2

)57 ( ./536.

5357

/563

+ & /959.==+1.

/4 9

@ 9

)53* 0.) 538.

.87 3./)&3657

)945

)*+57 3/C*= <
3 59/4.

595= )."   # $  % &  ' (  )*+ &", #-%$-%  %    .

  /    01  2 3

) '11) 49) )3/  

7 .9)8.

.873./)& * )7

9/.65

 (  $          )    *  $  

 !   $  &  !   $  

 " )( $ &+#  

 $

   $ , 

 )      

 $   

 )   

-       

$     $  $ 

 $  $     *$  .$      # #  )     

     )    

  )   /

$$       

    0 #  

$      /#           

        .$ ))

$

        

   $                

 %             

 

 1$        )    

    

               $ % $

)    "

 1$ 23$          1$         

     

     
 

 

$  

 1$   

(23$ 

 *$    

   

   $ )        

 

          

   ) 



 $ )   

 $  $ '

 

.)9/(368.

.8733657

)945% 8 .'4= =+

6.4557.59/4.

./+4=.909795*+57 294 36) =.+ ./)=.47 157  =590.5 =+.66 459/(57 .88395 9/2 )9/)

9(75@ .57 .

0+8

3// =1* 5

=.59/(3/=+538.+0 /53

69<.593/ 36  8.+  3 /93/1  57

*+1  57  .9)  ) =.+ )  4=.901  .57

 57./ * 4309/(5 .9(75;.+

> )157 19

@ 9

)53* .==3;

)1* 5;957 .6

57.557 .

368 /93/* 9/(

) 853.8

93)3657

+ 5357 ).5 3669=9/(3657 ;

958 59593/  /57 .9)4.

9/8.

.873&57

36157 <
3 4=.

)57.557 9(7
3 5;./35> 5969 )53)9

4557 

36

368 /93/432

9/(.8

93)36 &+ ./)57.5533;957 9/5

5 ? 7 .9)29 ;.=3.88 537.2 *

/.44 )9/.

> )(0 /5* 9/("   # 4   &  ' (  )*+ &", # %%  ,    )1
 2 .

  /    01 5  !   % 7

2./58.

.87;7

36.

)7

9/.65

4 

 

$ 



$ 

$  ( )



 $) - $ $





 /               1

    1

"( (  ! 1 

  ! 1   1!1 !(  '          ( 1

 (23$ #   

  

  $ )$    

  

          $   ) 

  

     $ $

    23$     

$   

 $  

  $$ ( 

 '         7!

 ' 1

   1

  

  1    , - 

  )# 

  

    5     

     

    

  23$  $ $ 

 (  

 

 $   

  ,'678

8"# "93:

1 0# !("'#

19"3:

;"#!

#3&

/57 357

7./)157 = )43 / =63

/5  *09557.557 .63

.9)> )(0 /5.

/35.88=94.*= 5357 9/5./5 4.

1  .  57  0 0*

 36  57  ) /4  430*.5./5  5.*=970 /5  ;.

.=

.)+9/

9853657 )9.*9=95+8 /93/./)57.557 /)3;0 /536 .88395 * 6957 /4 3 (70.D9/(36 3 /)9/(%'366157 ;3 =)3/=+

 =59/.> 5969.*= 9/4

9/8 /93/

/ 883 53679.

( 0 /517 8=.4 )

=9./4 3/.57

" )(  E /47  > )(0 /5  8.

)  *+  57  3/C*=  8 < 
3 51  3/

?

&19/4.

595= ).0 8#!

,8#5:< & #8"#"9
#!800#!

3:

153;7947 8 81;;

01"&== >"9%> 9.9(/ )7

2./58.

.873657 .9)2

)945.

)7

9/.65

(   $ +   6  

" 0 ( $ 7 .  3     +"8 94   



       $44(( $ 

)        



$*  *$  $         

    

) ( $        



  $      #### ####

& , 

         

      ( $       #     

       

   ( $     :

  ;5

  $      

           

    $    

44   9   $*  *$   $     )  

 ,   $        

    ) 

44  4  

   

     8 '

#9

#(

"93:8 "'3&

73 (71299*=+9/4.

./+) =.+ )03593/9 .9 )*+57

.(( );7

*+.47.== /( 94.

)53.) 4=9/9/(3

8.

*+57 43/4

)157

83/157 .99/(36.) =.+ )03593/* 50.D

.0 53* 795*+57 294 36) =.+./)=.47 3;

157

<4 8593/5357 .*32 9/498= 1. 55= )57 3 (72

)945

)*+ <
3 59/4.

595= )..

  /    01  2 3

) '1 &(, ./)9/4.

595= ).)1
 2 .

  /    01  &(,5 957.51+ 557 ) /4

3// =43/4

)1* 4309/(

/595= )53

69<.593/368 /93/29.297901* 5;957.6

9)

57.557 .9)953*

)3/=+63 .8

93)3657

+ 6 3057

).5 3669=9/(3657 59593/

 57.5.950.+1.6

<4 8593/ /5357  8

)8.

.871.344 9/57

)945% 8 .'

)*+57

8 <
3 5195357 /5157.59/4.

./9/) 9(75*

)9/57 .(( )157

83/157 .9)2 /536./9/)

9(759/57 .(( )157 ;3 =)6 =.

9/(3 .43/59/ 3

4.

 36  .4593/  29.29  57  .(( )    =5./5=+1  57

*+  57

=.+ ) .99/(36.4=.90157 ;3 =)/35.55 .4557

53 .57

*.

36=9095.593//3

*+./+8 )294 36) =.+./)=.47

;3 =) =+6 /4593/..5 0*=9/(*=34D.(.9/557 ( ./59/(36 6 == 5

=9 65357 .(( )

3 )

09/9/(;7

4.

36.4593/;7947.44

29.2957

/5

/557 ;..

9/(3 .43/59/ 3 4.

36.4593/* 9) 63 )

09/9/(;7

.557

+9/4 8593/1 ./9/) 9(752 )9/57

/5

/5157

*+1959 +53* 9/09/)57 6.45 057.5157

2./54.

36.4593/ .44

)5357

/5

/51 83/157 0.D9/(36.2

)945*+57

3/C*= <
3 59/4.

595= ).* #8"#"9
#!80< & 07 30C1

)9/% , #18# %>%1) 49) )3/

1;7

9/1 .) 4=.

.593/90.) 5357 /5157.557 * 69536 3 /)9/(3661

.57

 7.  53  * /)3;

)  53  57  43/4

)  7

2./5 8.

.87.344 9/57

)945% 8 .'.

)7

9/.65

6.       !

&  1$     )$ 

  

   $ $     $   $ $  



   $        )    $/

(  !

&  $          

   3 $  8 !

&%4 %<!=/3&  

$      >      < ?)     

    @      

                 "   0

=  )  $  )  

  

     "   0  =      ) , )   $      ,    $*$!

&

  !

&             $/

 

   

 

( 

    - 23$ 



( $  

             



 7

19/4 .9)9/) 9(75* 4.0 9/57

/5

/51 83/157 0.D9/(3657

)945*+57 <
3 519/4.

595= ). * #8"#"9
#!80< & 07 30/ ';02& /

@ =157 ) 4=.

.593/36=.;0.) 9/57

)945% 8 .'1;7

./ 9(75* /)3;

)29.2957 43/4

)157 953 *

)  =5./5=+157 /)3;0 /53657 .9) 9(75129.2957

43/4

)1  57   *   57  43

53/  63  57   57

09/9/(1  ;7

 9/  8 3085  @ =  57

53  .57

 57

/5

/5 .9 ).4=.901./)19/5./) 057

;957

& 9/4  57  2

)945  % 8 .'  * 4.0 3/3 /4 )  3/

./)57

/5 .9 )9/5

03657 .9)2

)945157 .

03593/*

 9* /.=43/4

)19/57 +

73 (7157

/59/5

03657

)945% 8 .')9)/35 .9 .8 308503593/ 9/8  ./4

531* 5 .9 ).03593/3/=+.65

.) =.+36.*3 5 F  +   5.D9/(  8=.4   3;

1  ;7 /  57   /)3;0 /5  0.)

29.2957

/5

/51* 5/.5 .==+43/6

)./ 9/) 9(75  @ .  790 7

1  ;7 /  57  9/) 9(75 9/2 )9/57

/5

/5 .57

3 (72

)945% 8 .'* 5

?

43/43095./5=+ .=3  43/6

)  .  43/59/ 3   ./) 

9/(  4.

 36 .4593/ @ . 57

/5 

/5   =5./5=+ .=3 57

 ./ 9/) 9(75* 4.0 )9/57

/5

/563  79

D9/(@ .57 .88395 3 /)9/(366* 9/(0.) 9/796.23

 2 /  357

;9  9/4  57  ) 4=.

.593/  36  =.;  0.)  9/

)945% 8 .'0.D .9)) 4=.

.593/53* ./ <835 =.593/36=.;

9/

0157

*+157 <835 =.593/36=.;9/

01.0.) 9/2

)945 % 8 .'.=30.D

43/6

)* 69529.2957

/4

3// =  43/4

)1  531    

1  .=3  /595=  57

43/4

)157 53.5./+590 1

D57 ( ./59/(3657 /)3;0 /5.

0.)

1./)57.553319/57 6 == 54308= /51.8 =5

1* 9) 9

3657 *.

36) =.+./)=.47

8#01 !

"93:8 "'3&

 /.65

0.571579
3 569/)/30

959/57 ;

958 59593/ ./)  ;957  57  3*

2.593/  .63

.9)1  57  .0  9  )909 )  7

908 (/ )3

90.9/5.9/ )./).669 )

? 9/4 0.9/4.

95 =67.*

/) 49) )157 1.==57

/)9/(.88=94.593/%'196./+1.=35./)%')983 )36     /,

, -

 /,  
, )2 %&%&

 "G   7

8 .D9/(H

.3/ ) , I H3 7

5.*=

, I H3