High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/34004/2024dismissed

Union Of India Through Its Secretary To Government Of India, Ministry Of Defence, v. Tc 31503m Lt Col Swarup Singh Kohli Age 62 Years Son Of Sh Jharu Ram

2024-12-17Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

!"# $%&%!'()*)

!"#"

( +,

- .

- -- -

& %'() *++, &*-+.*/%01+ 2* $ ,+( * +/%01+ 3 *! /%01+ 2

- .

*&** +5$ /* $ * 2%+/$+(2* &+% 2* % %+ %

6 7 8 9/ + $+ % '( * + % :

% 1 '+ 11 %7* +2 2*1+ %+* '+9/5* '(* 1+:2 2* &+2%+'($ 5+ +5

$0 1 $234!0'#

, %:(

;<6+%& :: %+ 5

> ;;>+%%1*+& %2:

<* :

2%1*+& 2: / 5+$+1 %5:

%1+1+ &(5&*%+'( ?-@@ @

A @B * &

2* +%%+'( 5++ %C6 D22 /*5 /* +:

5 * * +'+'

&+&&+0+ %'(:+( '(:+(

1 /* %+'(5+1 1 %5* /* 2 + :

E+2(&2%+'($ 5++ %+2 2 0%

> %+ % 6F

</ +11%&(/ * 1+: 5+ , 1 1:$ +*(0% %+ %

;

&+&& %/ 2 %2+$$ ++&+* +%% /*5 /5*5+&2* 12* 2+$$ +/* 2 % /'

2 * + %:

%1 '+11 %/5* '(* 1++1*+ & * +2 +% , 1 % * +% / '

1+:

+5 % 0% % %+

6 * $ +0 $+2* +%% 8+1 %* +2

! "## $ %

& ' (& ) *+ "! !""!#

%&' (

)*+

, =

&+&& %2:* +2 +%% +$+ %$ 7$+9/'(* + %:

%1 '+11 %/* $ 2%+*+2 %* +&+* +5$ '

2 * '" 4 '$ &!"5%&!04

- 2 $1

%&:+.

+ 10 +%,%1+$ 5$ / + 2++1 2% :&5* 2+:

2+(% 0G0+(:

2* $ /'$*'

& %* +:(/% $ +* + +& /$*'

1:& %/++:

2* 1:'++ +'*:

/+* * +:

:+&% 1 %/( * +$$ $/*$ :

* &1+'

* 1& +'

&1+'

+&&+0+ %'

& +'+'

:+( /*+1E %/2:/* $1$ 2** ,%&:

"?'

$ 8/1+ + ,-+! .- ) ' (&/ $ % / . 0 *

0+ $++&+$* 2 * +% 0 %1 + 8+1 * +2

"-. /

0 123

"!+

$ . -*"7

. 84''16 9:2 12.

;6 <%6 #12= 12&

16 -2 12'

;6 #12= 12'

;#12= 12'

;#12=A 12'

4''

7B ?

1? $ 2 "!!" C 75

0 B $

7 9*-

10 +%&792* +'0 8+1 %$1$ / *&*$ %(% 1+ /*+5* +%+'('

+ %$ +(:

2* 1:'++% +'*:

/+%5*1* 8 2 6 D 0 / * $/ *&* +( 1* %+'

0+% %2:* :(/'( * +& %* 22%+'($

/* +&:

2%+'($ +( :

2* 1:'++% +'*:

/5*'

+ 5*+%+'(+E+:26 D: /':$ +0 ( + % 1++ 2: *

%1+ -+%/ +* 1+%%( $1&*+* +%++ %%+'('

&+'+'

1:&+&&+0+ %'(:+(

* +%% 1++'

, %'(* 5

$ . -*"7 . 84''16 9:2 < * : /*&** +$ :$+& 0G0* %$*(1++%:

+* +*2+(:

2* +'*:

11 %/ $ 1+(5* +* +& 2* '

1:& %/* 1%+'*'

1:&'

5*+(%

0 /*&** * ++2* $ :$/ *+ 5* +( % + * / * 11 ' (/ * '( * +% *+$$ & 2 % +79 &2+(% /+* '

+ 2* & + + :

2 * % +'*:

:$ +0 (/* 2$0&* %5:

E+'

2 7$+90G0* 11 %/' %* :$( /+% 1+ /* +% :+%1*+& %/* $/* 1+:+ '

% 0 %+'($ 0 /+* 2+1 +% 11:+1 + %+ * % 2 '( * 11 %/+ '

1 (1H %/*2% 1+&5* * 2+(% 0G0* 11 %/+ E+ %

0 2 :+( +%I * +:

& +&&+0+ % '( '

& +'+'

:+(

;

- *++:+(/* '

+ 2*+2* $1$ 79*+( * 1+'

+2%+'($ * 11 %/'($) +9* :

2+11 $+1 2* 11 %:+( /:

1:& 1%

%1+ -+% 0+0 * '

& '

5* + % 5*1* *5 /'

11% ( &*:

'9 ( 2* % + * 2/ :+( + ' ('

11%

%1+-+%/ + 2: % 2 :+( '

& +'+'

:+( /+* * +:

&+ 1& +%

* /2* :

%1+$*%*+* % 1% *+0

% 1 %:

%1+ 8+:+2* 11 %'

& :+% /*$*'

1:& % /* $/* +:

%*+0 + %& /( * +7$+9/*

%1+-+% %+ * +2 11%&

0 /+% 1+ %$+/*+:+%+( 2*

%1+-+%25* &% +%%5*+$ 2* J!%

%1+7 +(

9/6

6KJ@ :

) !

+ 1$ J

/ 6 * 2 /*+'

5% : %5* :2 +'0 $1$ /5* +* :

2 :

2* * :(/*+2 +$ :+(:

%1+ 8+:+ '

&:+% 0+0** +*/*+ 1+:

1% %+' :

% '

& *: +%I 5* :

1+:

+$$ %*+* +%% 5++%:++&

0 / + : %/2:* 2+1+*+%/5* * +1++ 8 * $2* % /+%I* & 2/*$ /*$* :

2* +.& $+1 / 0+0 * +10 % '( *: 2 :+( /5* '(/*:+(11% *+* 2 % '+* 5++ 2* & * :( +%+1*5++'+'

1+:

+&&+0+ %'(* & :+(

+%%/+ &+* %2:* 1%/5* *

%1+-+%/%%+($1

%:+.

+ + %10 + +1* 1./$+1+(+$$ +&* +%0 2* % /*&* :$(:

2 + 2:

%1+ 1*E / * 0 & * '1. 1*+ & 1 1 1/ 5* 2:/+* * % 1+:

1 0 /2* +%

:$(:

2+ +(/* '(:+('

11% %E+

$* 2/*' * +$$ :

+.& $+1 /+* 5+1& +'5 %& %2 :+( % '

&+'+'

1:&+&&+0+ '($ 2:+1 2:+(

+(/2* $+ :$(

1*E +* +& 2+$$ :

+.&$+1 /*'(*

%1+-+%11 %/ +%+11/*+* + +* %:+1% 2+(% /'( * +%%:+% $*'&* :

2+($ * +:(/+0(+ 21

+(* ' +10 1I $* 2/ %&* 1 2 %2:+( /'5%++(

+%+5 11'(*

%1+-+%/*++10 $ ' '

1+:

1 % 2: + 10 1++ & 1 1 1 5* '(* 5%'

+2%+'($ =

"5 /5* +% +0/* '

8+1&* 1 2* $/+'

1+:

%1+'+% * $2* :

%1+'+% 8+1 * +2 ) +'( '+'

&&+0+ % '( 1 1 %5* 7AI9

+ +'

($ A@

2% $ +1 +

11 % * +'+'

+&&+0+ 0% $++6>1*+$ 0 2!

+%&2* 1% +*++* :

2* +$$ :

+.&$+1 +* 1+:

:+% : 2* $1$ 7$+9% 1+ "?'

$ 81+ %+,-+! .- ) ' (& 1#'(*

%1+ -+%/*+:

% 5*1**5 /%%2'%* /'

%* :(/%%:+.

$ :+( & 2 / * % 1++ 2 +5 ,%&:

7$+9 *+

2 '(* +$ :$*+* 1&2* +%% 5++ 2 %2 / 2+0+'(

%5 %0+0* *&* * +%$ :$ '+'

'* +% 0% '* +%$ :$ '

1+:

1+ $ * $ "5 / * +% 1+ 0% +%%1&%1*+&&0+0* /+* 21& ( '&* +%$ :$/'++(+%%1++ %(+$*

%1+-+%/ &+& 2* +02 +*&/ *&* :$(:

2 * + 2 '1. 1*+ & 1 1++ 1 1 1*E 79/ 5* '( :+( '

1+:

%*+* &2* % * +:($ / '

1+:

1 %2:+ +& 12+:(*( 0 / '(5++ + %* :

%1+$/*+ % '2+5 2:

% ++* 5++1& +% +%'

1+:

* +&&+0+ %'('

1+:

+'+'

:+(

"5 /+ +%&2$7$+9/%1 *+*+ '

1% % + ($ % 2: +% + *+0 '

1% %* 8 7$+9 + %(/1 0% ' :$7$+9*+'

$ /* '(/* 1+ %&0 5 &*+& * $2* :

%1+ '+%/+ 8+1 %7$+9 $1(/* '(1 1+'

+& %* $+2:

% +/'

% * '(* & 2* % 1+'

+%'

+ 2+ +& 1 2+:(*( +(/ 1+ %+ 2:

%2:+(

+%%/ 1+ % '

+'+'

1:&+&&+0+ %'( %2:+( '(*

F 0 /*&*+ %* *+* % 11 %5* 1+:

$ 2:

+* +$ +1 + +/'1 * 8$ :+%+ *

0+ &+/5*1*:+.

* &2* % + $ +1 + +/'

& +2* *++1*/B &%% + 2: * % 2 :+( '

1+:

+&&+0+ %'( %2* :+(

1 /* +1.2* +% 8$ :+%+ * &+/% 1+* 11% /*+ 2* &2* +%% $ *11 %+$ +1 + +/* '(/* +% & + '

% 1+ % '

+&&+0+ % '( '

& +'+'

%2:+(

< * /1 :2* ,%&:

$ 8/1+ %+3' (& ) *+ "!>

. /04 5* /+% 1++:+% *

8 /*+* 22%&22/+* *+'

%5 * 11 +(+* % +% +'

&* '

1+:

0 % * $ 2 *

.& E+ * +$$ %&22'

&:+% *2+0 ;

@0 * 5 1 * % 1++ 2 +5 :+% %17$+9:+.

* +%% 1++'

+ 8$+2+5 :/* '(/* 8$+2+5 :/+:+% 0 %1

7$+9+:+.

* * % 12 %'

20+0* $ 11 %/ / / + * 11 %/*++(:

.* &+&2* %5:

+ :+% * % /+%*+/* 2 1:$ :

/+$ % /'

% $ 10 2* '+/2+(/2% +(+%+1*

* 2 / * &+& 2 * '

2 2 * +$$ %&22/ :2* 0 %17$+9 '+ 11 %/+% 22 2:+( &+(+% $* %'

1 4# 4!"5%&!04 6

+2 :+*/*2%:

* 5$ +%5*' 0++'0 /* +:

* :$& %% /+$+ + %'+ 11 %/:++ %+%+22:

$ %2+&5*+$ %&+$$1+79/2+(

- .

- -

)*)

+*:+ 5 5 4&6 2%'374 &!' # ( &7!

5 5 44 6!4 ( &7!