Ms Modi Exepeller Indus v. Union Of India And Another

  
       


  



 !"!

#$

% &'

( ) * 

+,- +

.//

-


("1"



 

     




+$  2/ +-3 -
 / - //

 2/ +3 -
 + /

  
 

 


 


 
 
 
 

 
 





!
 
 "


 
 





#
$$$$
/ - //* 3

!
%
 "&




' 


  







"(
) 
*  
+ 
,)*+-






  
.!!.#.#/

.0!.#.#/
 
'
% 
1
*  

"
"(


"



 
 





23

* 


  
1

#.!4
 



 



#
+ 
 

 
 



5 
'
  
  


' 

 
67

238



  
1

#.!4
,

 

#.!4-
 &

*&&





 9
"
&

"(

1
 :

)*+
"

&
1 

  
"


&





  ;<

0
+ 
 

 
 


'

 
5 

'
"

"


&









 

 

 



 &
 

"



 

=
+ 
 


"&





"



 
  
 



* 


   1

#.!4
,
 
>
?* 
:-
 




.!!.#.#/

.0!.#.#/




#
'


&

 




 


"
 


"
* 
@

%  
1

* &
,*@%*-

"(
% 
1
*  
,%*-

) 
*  
+ 
,)*+-


 

23

A 
#.!4
 '

"


 &
 

)*+
 


1 
8/
%

 





& 

 9
"(


%*

1



%*
  
"


  

   


)*+
%

 
"&


 

"

 


 :

)*+
'
"

 &
 

%*

"


&


 



' 




&
%*





"
'
' "&
"



 
 
+ 
 



 
"&

'

& 
B

 & 
23


#.!4





%*
'

"



&


1


)*+
/
+ 
 






  
C
* 


 

  
    !"#


D
C
* 

$  %&
'

 '      

'

& %

  

  (  " )   *+"#
,

- 
'   
 '       .& .

' .

'    


 - '  "

*   *+*#

,  /

 /

- (    %

 %  


 '0

(  "

**   *) 
%
 "&



D
C
* 

,

- 
' 
 ,  /

 /

- (  

,

-
'
 
"


 

&

$ %&
'

 ' 1
 
,

-

"

'

+,-
 .!==E0A#.#/

.!44#0A#.#/


"

&

"
C:"

&
* 

!4./#.#/

.E.4#.#/


+ 
 
 
"&


C
* 
 



.=!!#.#/

*78#034/8#.#/


' 




'
(
"

D
C
* 





$ %&
'

 '

4"15(6*

- 
'   
 '     4"15(-
  ,  /

 /

- (  ,

-   
' 


 "& 
 5 
 





'

"  

.=!!#.#/


*78#034/8#.#/
,+,"

-78& -1#9 ( - (!5"

% ("1"

#!

#

#9!

#9

("-
%
 
 



' 

"
' 

3
+ 
 








' 


"



  






 5 
 





 

D  &A 

 & 


.=!!#.#/



:;  4+,"

-78& -1#9 ( - (!5"

% ("1"

#!

#

#9! #9

("6



& 

4
7


 
 

 





'

"



2
%


&





  
'



 
 
* 

#.!4

 
% 

, %
.0@  .00/F!GD-
+ 
 





 

' "



)*+


'
"(

.!!.#.#/
 .0!.#.#=

"



 &

 

)*+
  

1 
8/

E

 








.=!!#.#/


 

+,"

-78& -1#9 ( - (!5"
,

-
' 

&

  
C
* 


 

-&8 << 8"*

D
C
* 


$ %&
'

 '

-=

- 
'  
 '  4"15(-
  ,  /

 /

- (  ,

-

2  0  3

 %(      %

   "


%%4 


#!
C
* 
 @&"
C
* 

/5   

     ( .& %

 
0(  + *

 "!)

'
 *
C
* 

$  ,
(5 (  %

  / 


06%(-

(  
%%4

% "+""


"
C
* 

2 / .  '  
 7

(  *
%%4

**""
" 

C
* 

  
  


- 
& -

5  
&



  % 0

(  "
%%4

+8+9
' 

 



H'
1

"
C
* 

  
D
@&"




"
 

 

 

.=!!#.#/


  8
6!0
%


"
 





9
%*
  

 

"



 
 




"
 

 
C
* 



&


   

   1
 
,

-




&

%*
9

 

)*+

 
 
"

  


)*+


 
 

1  

'
 

238


#.!4


 



 
C
* 


 

  1
 
,

-



  8
6#2

23


* 

& '

*&&



 " 

 9

"


 
  
 





"


  

 
1
"


 
  
 

"
  
 

"
 

 
 



 
1
  

"
"


 
  
 
" 


'
 

238

(
"

 
%

 

 








&

 
1
  
"


 
  
 





"(

 
'

%

 
1
  
'
"


  

"(

 
  
 
 

238



  


"


 
'
"
'
'




#E
B


 


 
 


23,!-

* 


#.!4

 

 


'
 
 

23

"
1 
"

*&&





 
"
&
,
"'

(





*&&

 -
I 


'

"
1 


'
&
 
 

  
-
*  

 
1

"
"


 
  
  
-

*&&





 
"
&



 

"


  

"
  




"
-

 

"
 
"
 '  0.
%
 

"
 
 
 
  




(

23
J 



23




8
-
D '
"
 &

 
  
 


 


"
 

=E


&


 


&
"-

  

"


&
5


&
&


"
  



" 0!

23
,!-

* 

#.!4

"  


'

  

 
 




'

 
5  
"


 

(

'
 




  






 5

 

23

(  0#
%

'



 

   "





23
 

 



(


 
 

 5



"&
18


" 00
B


& 
 

 

(

23
 

*  

 
1

"
"


 
  
  
I  

  

"
&


"

 
"
 

"


' -
  
  0=
 

 
' 
,-
*  

 
1


"


 
  
 

,-

  

  
"
 

'
 
 

23

"
(  0/
I  

23




'





&(
"
 


 
  
 


   


& 
'






'

   
"
 &

 
  
 


&  

&




" 
%
 

"
 
 
& 
"


 

&
'
&

 &
 


 
1
  


 
 &
 

 
"

 

40

4=

* 
-


 
 
"





  


23


1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 =!
%

  
 
 




&
5






 



'



 5

 

 





 

  

  





 

"
(


 
' 

  

 
1

"


 
  


 

 5





 &



"



 


 
1
  

&

 
  
  

  
"&  


"



  

"
 
  
C



&




  


5
&



  
 
C' 



1 


  


 
  
   =#

"
&
 
  


   
&


 


 

  
  
 

 

 
 


23
'


  








%
  

23




&  
"
'

 &

 &

 

   


40


4=


 
&
"

 

  
' 
& 
I  

 &





 
&

 

*

  
,






 

"-
 


#E

* 

I  & 

 &

 




 
 
"(

"


1"

 

20

* 
 =0
 




"

   


 

  
  


 

"

"

(

23

==

'

  
"
 &

 
  
 
 1 &
 

 


 



  



  

 &

 
1
  
' 


 
40

4=

* 


& '



 
& 
 
 

& 
 &  
%

'



23

(



'

 


9



&


 


& 
 


"
   
"


 

'
 

1  


' 
1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 111111

6=E
 

 

'
 "
 &

  
'




&
* 


 

"


" 


 &









23


 &

1  
'
 
"
"

  

&



"
( 

 < !.
H'
1

"
C
* 

  
D

 @&"
'

"

* 




 


&"






23

#.!4




 
  

 



"

K

'
"

%*


&   
&  
'


"
&



  



23

#.!4

 
  
 
"

*&&



' "
%*

)*+
'
 


 

"



"
  



"





&

& 



'



, '
* 
-


5 
'  
C' 


&
&
'
"

  


)*+
 

"
?
"(:
%

'
 


 

  


 
&
"

 

&
7
 
1
  

'
' 



'
"
 &
"
& 
 

 & 
40

4=

* 
!!


 





"


 

&


C
*  
 


 
  

'
 
 

+,"

-78& -1#9 ( - (!5"
,

-

  8
6!2
%




 &  
'
 




 &
'

'

 
C
* 

C
*  D



1




 


 
  
7
 



"

 
'

'

 
1

"

C
* 

*
"

  
  

&

$   ,
(5 2  /  .   '   

- 
& - 

 5 1 
,

-



  



"



'

D
C
* 

,

-
' 
 , /

/

- ( 1

,

-


"

 "
C:"


&
* 


!E
7




& 


 &

"
   





 
!4./#.#/
 .E.4#.#/

C:"


&
* 


&


,

-
' 

,  /

 /

- ( 1


-


"


 
  

' 

 
"
&


 
'

'
(
"

C
* 

*
"

  
  
  &

"



"
 




& 1
#.
7




& 


 &

"
 
 





 
!4./#.#/

.E.4#.#/

C:"


&
* 


&


,

-
' 

,  /

 /

- ( 1

,

-


"


 
  


' 
 
"
&


 
'

'
(
"

C
* 

*
"

  
  

 &

"



"
 




& 1 #!
%




 &  
'
 & 
 A 

"


"
'
 
 




1


'
"
 &



)*+

 , -

1


%*
"
 


&



A(

 , -<

!#

 

'



 & 

"

' 



'


&
 &

*78#034/8#.#/
,+,"

-78& -1#9 (

- (!5"

% ("1"

#!

#

#9! #9

("-


.=!!#.#/
!0


 

" 

  (

  

& , -
"

 

 
'
'

!=

 
& 


, -


 -

 

4/ - //6



4+ /6

% &'

( ) * 





7

(A   
L A 

7
  "
L A