High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5872/2024dismissed

The New India Assurance Co Ltd v. Baru Ram And ORS

2024-12-18Mr. Justice Alok Jain4 pages

!!"# $

$ %

& ''(( )*+ ,#"

# #!

--- #'. -

/* *- !+*.* !01 !.1+2 .3 ''((- -

*( 5- 1 '* ''( (.

*0 1((0 7*.

55-5 -

(*.

* . $(9 *6+(2 ,17

1** ***.

:*6+(; (8 < *3*8 *01 13 03 +* $9'8- - %*.

+( +69 (*.

*6+( (( *** .*90 .0 '* /*3 ! == * )1( 2 5>2 .0 +''.

13 6* '(80 +' *. .

+ '*3 1*7-

+*1* .

0*.

5>- >- 52 71* . . - >- 5 1**2 *( +' ?+.09

;6( '< $+* (.

!"#$%!&%'()!%*+$ ",-'.+&&!.!)!".!//!

01 23 ./)#" !(& #%4.5%)-'!"!+%+)!& %'()!%*+$ ",5 )'061 0#-#&162 +6 1 *0+9- @-

(*.

+( (01 1* .( .

'*' (7 '*3 ! == * )1( 2 5>2 711 *.

+.* +*+''#"78$)9+)/#"'

9* 1(( + * + *'* 8 '+6( '( 711* * +1 +((8 **80 8 '0* * 0. 3 *. 71 . 0*.

* +*0.

#0( * ! *'* +1*8 * 8 '**6.

+1*8 +1*0 19 + '( 9* 711 60 +. /*3..

0 **0 1((2 +6? 8 . 98 '.

'*92 +1* + * **0/*3..

+*1* 0 **0 982 +6? 8 . 98 '.

'*92 +1* + 0. **0 1* 71 **80 '0* * /*3..

( 0. **0 1((2 +6? 8 . 98 '.

'*92 +1* 1(.* + **0 0. * 71 *. * 6+ **.

19-A/*3..

( 71* *'* +.

8 * '*92 7(( ( +.* 1 2 +1 98 +.

1* +.* '*92 * '*92 +.

2 * +.* +1 (2 .* 7*-B 1 1(.* 0. **0 98 + 31(2 .*70 8 *(* * 9*(* 7.

192 +6? +1 . 98 '**6.A/*3..

1(.* 8 *+(.

98 + '*993* *+(.

8 1* 9*(*-B 1 '*3 +6

5 1(( ''(8 8 *'* 7.

$*( C3*9 * ! C3*9 +.

C3*9 +.

71 8 *'*D 8 *'* 7.

(( +1*8 * '* 0 +.* * 71 (( +1*8 +.

((8 *.

(02 *.

7*0 * *38 '+*'D 8 *'* +.

((8 '(2 * 6*0. * 96+( '+*'D 8 *'* +.

((8 38 *' 9+** 9'80 *'D

8 *'* +.

70 .6(.

* *930 0. *9 .6(.

'( 8D 8 *'* +.

8 1* '+6( '+*' 98 '**6.

! C3*9 1 61(D 8 *'* +.

'* 71 9++* * .( 9* 31( * 6+(. 6. 19 12 ((8 +1 *. 71 +1 . $*( C3*9 982 ( CE2 '8 1 61(DA4 4B 8 0. 31(2 0* 701 711 . <.

@2 F(0*9D +6? +1 . $*( C3*9 982 ( CE2 '82 8 *'* '+*1.

! '*.0 '(2 +.

! * 8 1* !2 71+ **80 8 '0* * 0.D 8 *'* 711 9'**(8 *0*.

+.*

@ 71( '*.0 9'8 8 '( '+*' *0* 31(DA4 4B 8 *'* 7112 70 (.2 *1G+F * 8 1* +*( (982 6*+ *.2 * +* *+92 *G+*.

.3*.

1*+01 8 1* *+2 711* 71 * +. !2 71 37 6(0 *1 .D 8 *'* +.

+1 $*( * ! C3*9 982 *.*2 '8D 8 *'* 711 +6? 1*'+*12 ( * 18'1 0*9 711 70 .+( F ' * 61( 2 '* 71 719 *.

+1 0*92 6( +1 9* *1 .D * 8 *'* 71( '*.0 9'8 8 '( '+*' *'*-A G 8 *'* 130 +.

( +.* 192 +.* +6

@ = * +6

5 2 * '(80 +.* +1 *.* 98 +.

$*( C3*9 * ! C3*9-B !+6? '*3 +6

@2 +6

5 1((2 ! C3*9 *+( 9. +.* >= '**62 ''(8 8 9* .'.

**8 9* 1 '* <(+.0 .*3*-

73*2 '* 2 .9.

' '* ..

* . .0 *'

* (..

71 0. 1

'**G+ . '(80-

+69.

(1+01 7* 92 .

F *+F 60 '(.

*. '+*' 71+ 6+ 3. G+ 9 3* (.

''((-

- (01 632 .0 9* ''(2 9 1*68 .9.-

=- ! 9 ...2 '.0 9((+ ''( 2 82 . ( .'.

- 0 1 !()!- $)$"

Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No