Sandeep Singh v. Financial Commissioner (Appeals) Punjab And Others



   




  !




   

"#$ '$()*)%+

, -)+/0 ,,,,,, $#)#)%+$1

2$1*3*

..$"4*6 3+7"8 %#0$1* ,,,,,, $*.%+'$+#*
  9: ,

-
  -  1$*$+# 1,
,, 3+7"46

';%("#$

.$#)#)%+$1,

1, 5$*0 <35"1 <"+="16

';%("#$ (";$"#%11$*.%+'$+#

, ,  - 6

 :

, $#)#)%+$1

&)4$'

)+*#"+# .$#)#)%+

1#)(4$* > ?

%+*#)#3#)%+ +')"6 )+#$1 "4)"6 *$$@)+/ +"#31$ ($1#)%1"1) *$##)+/

6

..$"4*6 3+7"8

*0%1#
%55)**)%+$19

$1%C$.31 );)*)%+6

$1%C$.31

*0%1# 9 );)*)%+"4
%55)**)%+$19, %#)($ 5%#)%+,

,

# #0)* *#"/$6 1, 5$*0 <35"1 <"+="16

';%("#$6 =0% "..$"1)+/ 8$0"4& (";$"#%11$*.%+'$+#

"(($.#* +%#)($ 8$0"4&

";$"# ')*(0"1/$',

)#0 (%+*$+# (%3+*$4 ."1#)$*6 "1/35$+#* ("*$ 0";$ 0$"1',

 

, 1)$&4B6 '$5)*$ -01) -0$1 -)+/06 .1$;)%3* %'4"6 $0*)4

"4"4"8"'6 )*#1)(#

"C)4@"6 .1%($$')+/* =$1$ )+)#)"#$'

&)44)+/ 3.

;"("+(B,

, $0*)4'"16

"4"4"8"'

-38 "/)*#1"#$6

"4"4"8"'6 1$(%55$+'$'

("+')'"#31$

D8"4 &%1="1'$'

5"##$1
%44$(#%16

"C)4@"

*0%1# 9
%44$(#%19,

, :$"1+$'

%44$(#%16 ;)'$

, ?,

6

%'4",

,

, ?,

 (0"44$+/$'

D8"4 &)4)+/ "+ "..$"4 8$&%1$ =0)(0 ("5$ "44%=$'6 ;)'$

=0$1$8B

D8"4 %'4",

,

$$4)+/ "//1)$;$'

"/")+*#
%55)**)%+$19*

.1$*$+#

.1$&$11$'

"+ "..$"4 8$&%1$

0%=$;$16 *"5$ ')*5)**$'6 ;)'$

, $+($6 .1$*$+# .$#)#)%+,

$1$6 )# =%34'

"..%*)#$ 1$&$1 1$4"#);$

+%#)($'

%44$(#%16 =0)(0



"1#)(34"1* $#)#)%+$1

$*.%+'$+#

D8"4

/$ 

'3("#)%+"4 D3"4)&)("#)%+  #0 ."**  #0 ."**

83# +% ($1#)&)("#$ "##"(0$' %#$ $&%1$

(4")5$'

 #0 ."**, <+%=4$'/$ "8%3# 4"+/3"/$* 3+7"8) )+') +/4)*0 3+7"8) )+') +/4)*0 :"+'

%=+$'



<"+"4* 

<"+"4*
1)5)+"4 8"(@/1%3+'

)4 .$1 .%4)($ 1$(%1'*  $&"34#$1

)4 )4 #0$1 D3"4)&)("#)%+* 1$*)'$+# :%("4 31'="1"E .4"+#$'

*% 5"+B #1$$* "+(0"B"# 4"+'E

(%+'3(#$'

*$5)+"1* *#%..)+/ &)1$ ."''B *#1"=E *$5)+"1 @$$.)+/ (4$"+4)+$** $+;)1%+5$+# '13/ &1$$ 3+7"8, -%+ '$($"*$'

$(%55$+'$'

 $0*)4'"16

"4"4"8"'

- 6

"4"4"8"'

,

&#$1 #"@)+/ +%#$ ("+')'"#$*6
%44$(#%1 :"58"1'"16 %8*$1;)+/
 

 

   



   

    

      

  

   







      !



     





#"

  

    

   



  

   

     

    

   

 



#"

  

  



 

$      

  #%

   &          

  "

'#



       

               

      ( , *$# ;)'$

  .1)5"1)4B /1%3+'

#0"# +"5$

D8"4 1$(%55$+'$'

4%=$1 1$;$+3$ %&&)()"4* #0"#

 

-"18"1"0 :"58"1'"1,
%55)**)%+$19* &31#0$1 3.0$4'

%55)**)%+$1,

, + 5B (%+*)'$1$'

;)$=6

0";$ $11$'

4"= *$##)+/ "..%)+#)+/ :"58"1'"16 ;)$= *$##4$'

.%*)#)%+ 4"= #0"# 5"##$1 "..%)+#5$+# :"58"1'"16 (0%)($
%44$(#%1 +%# 4)/0#4B )+#$1&$1$'

=)#06 $;$+ )& #=% ;)$=* "1$ .%**)84$6 3+4$** #0$1$ "+B ."#$+# )44$/"4)#B %1 .$1;$1*)#B #0$1$)+,

31#0$16 1$(%55$+'"#)%+ 4%=$1 1$;$+3$ %&&)()"4* "1$ +%# 8)+')+/
%44$(#%1,

%1$%;$16 /);)+/ .1$&$1$+($ .$1*%+ =0% 1$5")+$'

-"18"1"0 "(#3"44B "5%3+#* /);)+/ .1$&$1$+($ 0$1$')#"1B (4")56 =0)(0 0$4'

34#1"

;)1$*

1#)(4$ 

%+*#)#3#)%+ +')"6 );)*)%+ $+(0 #0)*
%31#
 

    

 

;)$= *3..%1#$'

);)*)%+ $+(0 73'/5$+# #0)*
%31#

 
!

  "#"$ %&'('

$()&%,

# %8*$1;$'

#0"# +%# .%)+#$'

%3# "+B )44$/"4)#B %1 .$1;$1*)#B
%44$(#%1 +%1 *"5$ '%+$

=$44,

.."1$+#4B6 B%3+/$1 "/$ 5%1$ $'3("#$'

#0"+

)+;%4;$'

*%()"4 "(#);)#)$*,

,

+ 5B ;)$=6 1)/0#4B %'4"

%44$(#%1,

>, + 4)/0# "8%;$ ')*(3**)%+6 )+*#"+# .$#)#)%+ "44%=$',

((%1')+/4B6



6

"1$ *$#

, ?,

6

%44$(#%16 "..%)+#)+/ %'4"6 5")+#")+$',

?,

$+')+/ "..4)("#)%+

*6 )& "+B6 *0"44 *#"+'

(4%*$',

 - 

 

,

*7@* 0$#0$1 *.$"@)+/1$"*%+$'

!$*



% 0$#0$1 1$.%1#"84$ !$* 

%