High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/3171/2025disposed of

Haryana Public Service Commission v. Lakhan Singh And Others

2026-04-23Justice (To Be Nominated),Mr. Justice Rohit Kapoor11 pages

! "#

! "# # "

! "#

! "# " $

! "#

! ! "# %& '()*+&,-./0%+.'1(02-&0.'& '()*+&,-./0%+&'0/2&

## $%&

(

)

# $% '&*+,+&-.-/

# $% '&-./&-.-0 ) "

# $% '&+-,&-.-0 3333 .'1(02-&0.'&!, 4

# '

4##

$ 5""

6% " 7!# " # !

# "

# " ! 4 "

" 8 +9 -.-/ .9 .9 -.-/ # : 4 ":# ;

4 ! 4 <

! 4 " ;

" 4 " # =& ((-(%++(/

$%&'(")*#+"&%$+"&,$""+%*#$#-%" %.$#+"&%""+$ $&$*"&(&")/ $

&"*)$" &,0 &( $ &" " #.&$, " 3435%% *%, &"+6,$)#&7/

*%, &"+6,7 . 3/ !" 87144 '

!"&97144 * !$,#)&$""+%6,743%")& # :)$"*&&(:),&9 *% :)$" -$ %. +$. "$" !% +$+% "$" -$ ' , +"& $)$" -%& *#$# $# " . % :)$" )/ ,# + /+")&%,&9-$'##)*#+"&*%-&"; -& ;

*0 *#$# $%& , :)$" "& #&9 % +$+% "$" ')''0 % / +")&% ,&9 -$ ' ##)*# +"& *% )*% :)$" % !%:)$"&-$'$;$%#$#$ $ *#$#-$%."*)&,$$,),"+35< ,&9"*&%*&$; =

#$# +")& $, % ),'& "+ #.&$# ""; -$% '&*9# *#$#0 $+ (0 -$ % *# +"& % )'=* "-#; !0 &".$## % %( %. *)&# % ,$$,), *)"++,&9"+35< !% ,&9 "'$# '( % *#$# $ % *&$; -$ " ' *")# +"& +$ *$"'*)$$,"(+"&%"&/$$; "+*;"&(/-$*#$# /4.5 67. 3/ & *$*

)&&."+$"# &$" ,"&* $"&("+ #$

#$#>"&#";&%(

#$ ))&0 #$"$(# #$*"",( &'$$("$;#($*'$$$ $* ),&*( ),'& # %$& &$"0 "&#& "+ ,;$)# * / ? . 0 $&&$" *%&0;&%0'0#)++$*$*(* ?. &( / $"&(0 ";&%(0 "$(0 *"",(0

))&* 3 .76829 3/ !$,#)&$""+6,4@%")& '

!"&97154 * !%:)$"&-$'$;$%#$#$ # &-$')'=*$.( "*#$#-$'*#+"&%$&.$- .$./ ."* ) % % *)& ,$$,), "+ @5< ,&9$% )'=* "-#;! + !%),'&"+%*#$#*#+"&$&.$- -$'-"$,0";-$%'&*9#*#$#0 $+(0"+%),'&"+#.&$#"&".$## %%(%.*)&#%,$$,),*)/"++,&9 "+@5< ;

!%-$;%/;"+% )'=* "-#;-$ '2A5< .5 67 :.76829 37

%; 9 $

"#"+ $.$&"*#)& $$ %&$( 9%(#%$$(,0343@ $$$

#$ "&** $.

#$&&%$* .

"+""#* .$ $#) - .$$ "%,,# -# )",&( - 6 % < 9 $ %&$((( %$

$$ %&$(;&$9 )&9% %$

$$$ %&$( 9%(#%$$(,0343@

0 ;9 !%-$;%;"+%$&.$--$'135< B !% +$ ,&$ $ -$ ' &&# '( ##$; % ,&9 "+ *"#;6,$$"#$&.$- (7#*$%&;$,#"&(C

# #

# > ##"

## ! ! 4 4 :# 4 #

& *$*D )&&."+$"# &$" ,"&* D$"&("+ #$D #$#>"&#";&%(D #$ ))&0 #$ "$( # #$ *"",( D & '$$( "$; # ($*'$$$ D $*),&*(),'&#%$&&$"0"&#&"+ ,;$)#*/ ?. 0 $&&$"*%&0;&%0'0 #)++$*$*(* ?. #&( /$"&(0";&%(0 "$(0*"",(0 ))&*

< "# # " 4

-/?"

# 4 4 " #

-// #"

> "" #

4 < " "

4 !

! # # 4;

"" # !

4 # &! #

@ 4#

:# !

! " !

! ! 4"

## " # !

:# !

4 >

" !> 4 ! # # 4

4 7 !

# "

=& E # .$- "+ % '".0 %$ ")& +$# *"$#&' +"&* $ % $$"&F )',$$" % % ",,$$"0 )#& % ;)$ "+ )"",(0 *" '( % *"$)$" "'$;$" "+ *")$" '( ,9$; )$& *%; " % &*&)$, &"* !%

",,$$"F , " #&- #$$*$" '- E*$"C#E"$,C""*%&$;")&"+ &$* @34@ '

$ -%"( ,$*"*$.# !% &"* "+ *$" $ " &"*#)& $#'& ') $;& # )'$.&"+%"$,&"* ")$"$ ,##.&(;"+%&*&)$,&"*0#" ,&(%"$"+$)$;"$,&"&".&0

% ",,$$" % +$# " #,"& % &"*#)& %&");%-%$*%%#*$$""&%(')"&$&"#)* - %"&$$; ,%"#"";( - &*%# !" & % ,%"#"";("+*$")*%%(')+"&%"&$$; -$%") *")$"0 $ " #+ % .&( *"$)$" &*%$*)&%&$*@34@ '

9"&&.

!% '". "'&.$" *&( '$% % % &*&)$, &"* )++& +&", "/*",$* -$% )"&("&,#*"$)$",#!%)$& *%;$(')#*$",%"#"";(-$%")&$"& *")$"0 &:)$&# )#& &$* @34@ '

"+ %

"$)$"# )B1#B3"+%&()'$*

&.$* ",,$$" $,$$" "+ G)*$" ;)$"0 1HA@0 &#& % &"* &"*#)&( +-# # ;( ))$' #,$$&$. *".$* *" ".&&$# % )"&( #)( " +""- #) &"* # )%"# *#$#I&$;%)#&&$*1J

"*)$"7/ " !%$ ")&$*",#""'&.%&*&)$," )'$* &.$* $ $%& ,& 6&*$ $ #,$$&$. &$%,$*"&,*%$*$.%%)"),&$+"&% 9"+*".$*>%;$($*",&",$#0+$& $ +"&90 # )"&( ,# & #$&;&##0 % * "+ &$* 1J # #( .$"# )*% *$&*),*0%$ ")&$#)(/'")#"$&.$% 6&*$"+$"-&)#&&$*33J"+% "$)$" "+ #$ " )& % )'$ =)$* $ #" !% =)#$*$&( *" &,$ $. "'&.& -% #,$$&$.#*$$"&)$,$+$=)$*0$ .$# $ % & * K)#$*$ &.$- ,) &"# -%&*"$)$"&$*$&9#&'$&&$ $ -&$ &; " % +* "+ % &*"&# !% & #.&$,0$,#+$$;"*$$L#% "+$ $&$*"&(0$'&+"+(&$"6) -$%$$##"'=*$.!"*"#)**&$;%

6*)#;9"-#;+"&"+)#,(&""#$ ; 6&$ $ " "( $&&$" ') *"$)$"( )' !% 0,"#,"(&0,)'*%"&#$ :)$(#;)$##'(&"$$*$" *"%$# &'$&&$'%$#%*"9"+#$*&$"!%-%" $,$$" "+ :)$+$# *#$# %&");% ;& 9"-#;+$&0%;*"+,##*")$")#& &$* @34@ '

0 # % $ #$&;&# "+ '$%# "&,-$%")-+)&"*#)&&.&*&)$,&"* %%"$;$$,*( $

- -$%") ;$(0 &"* -$%") +$&0 # #$*&$" -$%") **")'$$( & %, " ")& *"$)$" "&#& *% &*&)$, "$+$*$" $ '*""+%"+"&*")$&$*")&(&$*%$ ( ')&## '( ),"(, !% *"0 %&");%#,$$&$.%"&*")#$;0)++")% %" $*&$",)'%&#"&"0#&"*#)& ,) &+* )&" *&$; ") . "" "+ ,&$"&$") *#$# -$%") $; %$& *"& ; *",* +)#,( .$" % *"$)$" ;)&"++$&#:)""&)$( = **"&#$;(0%$ ")&%"#%% *&$;! (')"$+$#.$#%#.&$,##42423435 %+$&;0+"&%&"&*"&## %&$'".

0+$%"+&"'#&.* "%""+$ $&$*"&(-"+;$.$; :)""&)$("$)'$*,"(,'(6*)#$; $;$+$*##&.$;;,"+*#$#&,)&( # )+$&(0 % &"* #+ % .&( )&" "+ &*&)$$;%';+"&)'$*&.

$;% "+ % '".0 % ")*, ## 42423435 6)& /3 # #.&$, " 12 "+ 3435##424234356)&/1 &%&'(:)%#

&'$&&(0)&"'0#.$"$."+&$*1J1 "+ % "$)$" $ "-.&0 %

".&, -

",,$$" -")# ' $'&( " *"$#& +&% % &"* "+ *$"0 $ % $;% "+ #*$$" ,# %&$'". " +$ ) % " $ :)$" )#& % #.&$, "12 "+ 3435 ## 12123435 6)&/1 -")*,##12423435 6)&/3 C #

;

## " # ##

4 "

-,/..

## #

! # 4 " < "

4 > -/?"

" "

4 "

## ## #

! #

# "

" !

@ # # "

! :

!! # 4 4

> " !

> " ! "

": ! ## 4 "

! "

"" /.?> ! " ! ! "

> ! " # : #

" > '

4 > ""

; " " #

4 4

" # >

# "#

# # < # ### !

" "

B #

# !

## "

"# " 7 #"

# !

" # : "# 4 # 4!

#" # > !

""/.?> " !! "

> ! " # : #

" .9 .9 -.-/ 4 # " 4 <

! # # ;

4 > ""

# " "

# # # #

< "

"# ;

# :"

# "# %&'

()) &* +,-./$!

( % (* >%%&9$; &"# 7

" >%%&"&' 7