Union Of India And Others v. Ex Naik Sardara Singh And Another










  
 

















 

!
"#
$

%&%

"#"'#( !
"#
$
%%




   

    

   )$
 *+
) 
 ,
,

,
-

 *+
) ,
 ,
,  
, )    ! "##$#% #% & %'$'

(# )
   ,

,
-

.


* # ##%+ &# #,
( %& % (# % (#  % **-..-..

/0  ,*1&  %  %    #  '% 2  3  %'

33 &+# #3'%2( *(# %(

%'  +%%''+

/(0'/1
/(23"'#!

. # *4 2 .5***67.%( %  (  #%'#     +%  3#%  (2  83    -5*-*69- #%(&#+%,''  $83+(-:-**69:

#  3  (  #  83&  #  3 %'  (



;

<

"

  "=><  <  >?    %%

 %% $&#+% 3#% :-***66@%(8

(%  (*5 %**2#% -. % #2(# '%&# %' +%% A:-B('( : #  %'  '2  3'%2  (  #     +% 43  #$2 # 8 ' % *:-7*669&# #  #%# % %' +%#%%' 

  (2'% 83 5 '  %

8 &       *  (  %

%'

%#43'&#%2+%43  #$2  #  ' % :--9.-*9 #%(& * ('  &  (  #  '% 2  3  %'  33 & +# #3%%3#%'' #%(% 43  #%

&3%2%''+ 8   % **-..-.. # %8 % (#%  0%3 #%(
        



   



        

   

   

 

     

    

   

     !!"#$ % 

&

  

          

            



  '  ( 
 

       



 !

 



"

  

     

  

 

      

           ! 

      

  

      

             









)*+(  ,   (           

#-%       .

C '

8 (2#%(%  % %  #/ %1& #'% 2 3 %'33 &#

,
( %#%(' #% %#%+  (#$ #4

#(

"4
056
"'0 7 =( 3 2%D%((38% 4 3% # + & %('%%3( 2 +## #(%''2(%  %8,E,8% 22(# (3

'& # '' #%2 &  %#%'

% & #32 ' &%%22(#32%%

(3%'#2&%##%22%  3 & #

 &# '2#3 3%' #3 %' 3%'32%



%%'2'% 83&#%3F &(2&# 3 ' (##4

2   # G' 0$&3%'

% #$ 

&$  "

    &   ' ( ) %

*  #  '8%  %% % #  (  #  %  8 3  %  0%3

#%( !/

      

   

0

  1 234 

      

  

        

 

   5   



    %         

          

  

   

 
6  

  7

  (   8

   /

 !- 9  

/

:5++27  "&3

23/    

       

  

 

         

 + 

   



    



             



  

 ;7 $)7 <23= 23*        2 



           

 



   /      

       

  

 

   27 !3 23+ 



     

   



  



   

 

  

   

  



    

    

  

  ;7 <23= 23+      



  

   >   







      >       

  





 ;<23= 23+        



   

     :     

   



  

   

 



 ?

@        

;<23=A   23+    ?

@ 

 

  (  5++  9B ?

2?



 C  96  

  1  B

  8 

     "

- ! 

   & 

    

       



 



       

 

 

 @ 38% /1(#%80%3 3 '& # #  '  3'%&#%+#% %' 32%'  % 22(#32%% (3%'#2&% +#3# # 0 ( .- B  8& # & # # %  3# %'

22F 8%' (2#2 & # F %  #(( %'   9 #'&#% 2( %'  % 22(#32%% (3%'#2&+#32%'

+

+#% %' %F%2(.-B2&2 %8'

F  %  3'%%  (2  #  " 3%'  =% &  %#  3% '

3 #%#% %% %'  %%' 32

 2'% 83 #% 3'%%32 4  #
6  

7

( 8

 /

!- 9 /

:5++27  "&3 6 #2&# ##% 2 % 

8,E,8# # 3%'% 2%'#%'#(% 22(#

(3%'#233 & 3%'' +#%#% (# 32 '' &#3 %#32  +#%  %"8&# ###%'%(#

2 &  #%  +#  %  %  #&  #  33 F' &  #   #   %  #%

  (  %/1    (%  %&%# 2 %F'(#    83  %  %  22  (  #  (3  %'#2 2 %8' &#( 8 # +2F%( / %18,E,8#33 & #2 ' &%  3%&#% 2%, 3#% &# &#3'%2% 32' 38 %'  "8&%''#(%3 %  332%3  % %    #     (  83    # 33 &%3'' 3H &#( 3'% +### (%  %8,E,8#33 &%F'F%  ( 2'%  83 % ) #  %2   %

     

%%'2'% 83

*

*- =#%%2% &#32%'(#%(#

3 '/1#% #3% %'( %'  # 33 &'  !

%1#2(%33 %3(#33 2'% 83&2 32 3  #" 3%'

=%  8,%,8  #      +#  %  %  +#3# #+8&3233'    #2 (32' 1    (#  %  #(&  2%  %' F' 3233'  #" 3%'=% &   %  (2     (  2'%  83    

%%'2'% 83&%##%2 3 %' % ** #&(#2 3%' #'

#%# %3'

#%8 3 2 3%'0%2%(#33 

2% &# #32 ' 83&# &# %2+'' 2 #%8%  83& # %/ %1&#" 3%'=% F %#%( 33'  *. "8&%' 3'%  %&#%2% % (#" 3%'=% (''+#  ''% +$#% , (#I " 3%'/"'% 1&.--.JI '2!

%'3 'I *: #(&#%+ 2 +##2( #%8 3 '&+##%#2('2(# 

)

 #2 &#%(% '2% 2 3%'0%2%  2% 8,%,8##%'#&#%3%23 % 2  %    #2  % )  +##  2    3%2

 #%#% %+%% 2%% "8& %'F  2 &(2#(%3%#% &+### %3%%'0,# (# %&% )#  #(&# &# #''2(#     %D '%3&  8,%,8  #  %38       #2  ( 2'% 83&+# &#$2% 33' #%#( # %%#+%%F'(#  83#2 % %3#+%%%'3%2%

 # 

2'% 83 *5 %

&%'F  %# (2# 3 &+###" 3%'=% & %''  3 2%D%

%' 38%3 %'3#3D& %3'%' %

% # 8(# %&# #2 ' 2( %(2 3%'

3#F&  #  8'  #  '3D  3#%  3  33& +#(2&%## %3%23 "8&(#%

2 ' 2(%' '%' &# 2% 3233' F%  #(&#F#%

'2%D

'%3&%#+%3 %'+   ( 2'% 83  %%'32

(2%3(2'% 83$%' &(# %2 ' 

3#F%#% (%

'2%D '%3&# # " 3%'=% 33 &'% %33'&#%#%%#



2%3 3(%  %& #% 2% %

# #'2(%  '#%2 &%8 % (3 '%' #F%38 3) #(&

 #3( (2'% 83&+'

%%''

'% %+''33' #" 3%'=% &#%%38    3%2  3  (2  %  ((38  3%%'  3  33 +# #+'

 %'( %'   *C

+8&+#%  %8&#$F

0%3 #3(# &%3%23  # '%2 3%'%  #%20%3 &#'+ K K K K K %' = $

<

"

   , "=>< < > K K K K K <&# %' 3%'%#333 +#2'% 83 K K K K K *7 % (#3 8%'#%%#2(#

'2%D '%3%#3%22% 2 (# 3 '/ %1 3'%  # G' 0$3% ' %#$ 

&$  "

     '

, ( #" 3%'

=% &#%2 %+#3##+8& ( #   &32' #2 & 2%D '2%    (  &  #  3'%%  (  '%+    4

2  / %1  #%

# #% 2 #%#3 (#% % +%%F'( (83&F (%8%'

 + 8,%,8#  # # #% 2  %'#'% 8 3#% 2  3%2  3%     #    +8&  #  %  3%  8 3

3 3#% 8,%,8# &%#(3 '

 #% 2 &%%'' %' 3%%

 %' #" 3%'=% & '(# %8( %# &  # #  2 ' 2  (  #  %  (   '3D  3#%

3  3%%'  33  3#F/1&  +#     2%  3%2 %8' #%# (# %#%2  '& 3%23 (2%3 %' 3(%2' # "8& # +%%'F % #2 3%' &#% # %(%+''(2 %%#+%%3 %' % % 3%2#%

 3%2%%'2'% 83 *@

+8&%% ( / %1& 3'#%#%   3    %      (2  %    %  #%8   3 #0/ %1 % ' &38 3 # 2 / %1#%'  # &# &# $3%  8+ #% # (#2 3%'

% &%0%3 / %1$ 3' &# 3 33% %  # %''(2 %& # #

(# %3%% %F'(%3 %' 3 (%2' # $%' &F  3'% %(2

 (2'% 83%

&F  3'%  %%'32

  (2'% 83  #   *9 #&32(#4

2   # 0$&3%' %-      "



 >    

%

. 

)* /
+#&% 3'%%2% # 0&#%#(( ((&%##%32 +

#33  '%' %'# % (%' # 3%2  8    #       (  #  D  F%  #

 (( 2% #(%8 *6

8  #+  3  #  3'%%  (  '%+  2%    8 3/ %12%D#% 3'%%%0 '%('%+ 2&# &#0 '%('%+2&%2% 8 3 / %1%'2%D## 3( (8,%,8#

(3  '  33 &  &    &  %'  '  # 33 &#%% 2D# % (# +2% 2% # &% #%&#(''32 '2&% ' # &  38(#%&(% &( '% % '%3# .- #(&  #  %  (  #  (  (  #  %

  ((&2(#8 3/ %1   # %'

33 &%' (((2% '' %' % F   #'



6#/1
!


"4
056
"'0 .* %(2%#&#$( 2#+  % +#8%%8&#%2 2

.. #2    &% %  #'%  %'

33 &2%% % %((2  .:   (%' +#%'' 

'3%/1&(% 







7,

,
-

 7,  
, )8 %%

 2%#2%   5 
/26#3:

/ "# !

$

:"

5 
9"0/;1

$

:"