Shri Ram Enterprises v. State Of Punjab And Another

  
     






!

"#$# %&  '()*  +  

, - ,,


.*$/$

,    




-& 01 -,2 ,
 1, 11

01 -2 ,
 -  1

  
 



 


 
 

  



 
 
1, 11+ 2


! 
 


"

#


$ 



  





 
% 
&  
! 
'%&!(





 #

)*+,*,-
 
$
. 
/0
&  
 



#



 
 #




12

& 



 
/0

,* )
  


 
/0

,* )




 

 

,
! 
 

 
 



3 
$
  
  


$ 

 

45

126




 
/0
 
,* )
'

 
 
,* )(
 "

&""





 7 #
"



0
# 8
%&!
#

"
0 

  
 


"





  9:

;
! 
 

 
 


$

 
3 

$




"









 #

 

 



 "
 #





 

<
! 
 


"








 
  
 



& 



  /0

,* )
'
 
=
>& /
8(

 


 
/0

,* )
'
 
=
> /
8(





)*+,*,-


?
,
$
#

"







 

 


 


 #
& 
@

.  
/0

& "

'&@.&(
#

. 
/0
&  
'./&(

% 
&  
! 
'%&!(


 

12

A  
,* )
 $




 "
 #

%&!
  

0 
6,
.

 





" 

 7



./&

0



./&
  #
 


  

   


%&!
.

 
"


 




 


 8
%&!
$


 "
 

./&
 #


#"

 
 



$ 


#

"
./&






$
$ "
 



 
  
! 
 


 
"

$

"


B

 "


12

,* )






./&
$

 



"


0

#

%&!

-
! 
 




 

 
C
& 


 

  
    !"#


D
C
& 

$  %&
'

 '      

'

& %

  

  (  " )   *+"#
,

- 
'   
 '       .& .

' .

'    


 - '  "

*   *+*#

,  /

 /

- (    %

 %  


 '0

(  "

**   *) 
.
 "



D
C
& 

,

- 
' 
 ,  /

 /

- (  

'

(
$
 



 

"

$ %&
'

 ' 1
 
'

(


 
$
!'(
? * <<+;A,*,-

* )),;A,*,-

  

"

#
C8 
 "
& 

)*-,*,-

*+*),*,-

#
! 
 
 
"


C
& 
 
 


*< ,*,-

&56,;2)-6,*,-


$ 




$

#

D
C
& 





$ %&
'

 ' 

3$/4* 5+ ,

- 
'   
 '     3$/4* (
  ,  /

 /

- (  '

(   
$ 


 " 
 3 #
 





$

    

*< ,*,-


&56,;2)-6,*,-
'-6$ ,78 ( ,/%9* , *#4$ '*$/$ %# % !

%9#

%9

7*$(
.
 
 
#


$ 


$ 

2
! 
 








$ 


 

#

  #






 3 #
 





 

D  "A 

 "

 


*< ,*,-



 :

 

3-6$ ,78 ( ,/%9* , *#4$

'*$/$ %# % !

%9#

%9

7*$5



" 

)
5


 
 

 


 


$

 



1
.


"





  
$



 
 
& /A /

,* )

/
.


?
'

/.?
*;?E-<-*F E<(
! 
 





 

$
 

#

%&!


$ 

)*+,*,-
?




 "

 #

%&!
 

 0 
6,

+

 






 

*< ,*,-


 

-6$ ,78 ( ,/%9* , *#4$
'

(
$ 
"  
C
& 


 

, ( ;; 8$+

D
C
& 


$ %&
'

 '  '

(< ,

- 
'  
 '  3$/4* (
  ,  /

 /

- (  '

(

2  0  3

 %(      %

   "


%%4 


#!/
C
& 
 @"

#
C
& 

/5   

     ( .& %

 
0(  + *

 "!)

$
  &
C
& 

$  ,
(5 (  %

  / 


06%(-

(  
%%4

% "+""



C
& 

2 / .  '  
 7

(  *
%%4

**""
 

C
& 

  
  


- 
& -

5  
&



  % 0

(  "
%%4

+8+9
$ 

 



G$
0

#
C
& 

 
D
@"

#
 /
 
 

 

 

*< ,*,-


  6

4 ;
.



 





7
./&
  #

 #




 
 




 
 #


C
& 

 "


   

   1
 
'

(




"

./&
7

 

%&!

/
 
 #

  


%&!


 
 

0  

$
 

126

 
,* )


 

 


C
& 


 

  1
 
'

(



  6
4,1

12


& /

"

$

&""



 

 7




 
  
 








  

 
0
 


 
  
 
 
  #
 

 
/ 

 
 



 
0
  
 
 


 
  
 
 


$
 

126

 #

 #
.

 

 








"

 
0
  
 


 
  
 







 
$
?
.

 
0
  
$
 


  




 
  
 
 

126


 
  





 
$ 
$#
$
 




,+
B


 


 
 


12' (

& /

 
,* )

 

 


$
 
 

12


0  #

&""





  #
"
'
$







&""

 (
H 


$


0 


$
"
 
 

  
(
&  

 
0
 
 


 
  
  
(
/
&""





  #
"



 




  
 
  #



 
(
/
 


 



$  ;*
.
 

 
 
 
 
  






12
I 



12





6
(
D $

 "

 
  
 


 

#
 #
 

<+


"

#
 
#

"
(

  
 


"
3


"
"



  #



  ; 

12
' (

& /
 
,* )
  #


$

  
/
 
 




$

 
3  



 



$
 


/

  






 3

 

12

  ;,
.

$



 

   





12
 

 









 

 3




"
06


  ;;
B


" #
 

 



12
 

&  

 
0
 
 


 
  
  
H  

  
 
"



'

  #
 




$ (
  #
  ;<
 #

 
$ 
'(
&  

 
0


 


 
  
 

'(

  

  #

 

$
 
 

12


  ;-
H  

12




$





"

 


 
  
 


   
/

" #
$





$

   

 "

 
  
 


"  

"





.
 


 
 
" 
#


 

"
$
"

 "
 #


 
0
  
  #
 "
 #

  #

 #
'
);

)<

& /
(


 #
  #





  


12

0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 < 
.

  
 
 




"
3






 



$



 3

 

 





 

  

  #





 



#

 
$ 

  

 
0

 


 
  
 

 #

 3





 "



 #



 #


 
0
  

"

 
  
  

  
"  


 



  


 #
  
C



"




  


3
"



  
 
C$ 



0 


  


 
  
   <,

 
"#
 
  


   
"#
#

 #


 

  
  




 

 
 


12
$


  #







.
  

12



#
"  
 
$


 "
/
 "

 #

   


);


)<


 
"#


 #

  
$ #
" 
H  

 "





 
"#

 

&

  
'






 

(
 

,+

& /

H  " 

 "

 

#

#
 #
 





0 

 

1;

& /
 <;
 #




#

   


 

  
  
#

 #







12 <<
/
$

  

 "

 
  
 
 0 "#
 

 
/

 



  



  

 "

 
0
  
$ #





);

)<


& /


"

$



 #
"


 
 

"


 "

 
.

$



12





$

 


7



"


 


" 
 #

 
   #
#


 #

$
 

0  


$ 
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000

4<+
/ 

 

$
  
 "

  
$




 "
& 


 





#

 "









12


 "

0  
$
 


 #

  

"








 :

*
G$
0

#
C
&   
D
/
 @"

#
$
 #

& 




 


"

#






12

,* )




 
  

 


#


#J

$


./&


"

  #
"  
$



"

#


  



12

,* )

 
  
 
 

&""



$  
./&

%&!
$
 


 




 
  #



 





"

" 



$



'$
& 
?(


3 
$  
C$ 


"
"
$
 #

  


%&!
 


>
8
.

$#
 


 

  

 #
"  
 

 #

"
5
 
0
  

$
$ #



$ 
 " #
"


 #

 "



);

)<

& /A /




 





 


 

"


C
&  
 


 
  

$



 

-6$ ,78 ( ,/%9* , *#4$
'

(

  6
4 1
.




 "

 
$
 




 "
$

$


C
& 

C
&  D

/

0




 


 
  
5
 


#
 

 
$

$

 
0

#

C
& 

&


  
  

"

$   ,
(5 2  /  .   '   

- 
& - 

 5 1 
'

(


#
  







$

D
C
& 

,

-
' 
 , /

/

- ( 1

'

(

 
#
 

#
C8 

 "
& 


+
5



#
" 


 "
 #
   





  
)*-,*,-
 *+*),*,-

C8 

 "
& 

"


,

-
' 

,  /

 /

- ( 1
 '

(





 
  

$ 

  
"


 
$

$

#

C
& 

&


  
  
/  "
 

#


 




" 0
,*
5



#
" 


 "
 #
 
 





  
)*-,*,-

*+*),*,-

C8 

 "
& 


"


,

-
' 

,  /

 /

- ( 1

'

(





 
  


$ 
  
"


 
$

$

#

C
& 

&


  
  
/
 "
 

#


 




" 0 , 
.




 "

 
$
 "


 A 


  
$
 
 




0

#
$

 "



%&!

 '

(

0


./&
 
 


"



A

  '

(:

,
K 

$



 "



 

$ 



$


"
 "


&56,;2)-6,*,-
'-6$ ,78 ( ,/%9*

, *#4$ '*$/$ %# % !

%9#

%9

7*$(


*< ,*,-

;


 

  #

  

  

" #' (
 

 #

 
$
$

<

 
" 


'

(

#
 '

(

 #

31, 115



3-  15

 '()*  +  





5

A   
L A?

5
   
L A?