Sunny v. Ut Of Chandigarh

  









 

 

 

  
       
       
       
         
     
     
     
  

A$!(("

!* 9!*, %
& '() *&  ! "# $$% A!,."

'!

 ! "# '!+(,  ! "# '!+(,  ! "# '!+(,  ! "# '!+(,  ! "# ./"

 ! "# ./"

 ! "# ./"

 ! "# ./"

-
-
-
- *!,!

- *!,!

- *!,!

- *!,!

- ,("

- ,("

- ,("

- ,("

- !+!01!* 2 !+!01!* 2 !+!01!* 2 !+!01!* 2% " '( )- !+!01!* 2% " '( )- !+!01!* 2% " '( )- !+!01!* 2% " '( )- !+!01!* 2%  :4 $ 
   :4 $ 
   :4 $ 
   :4 $ 
   4  4  4  4 *$  ;" ( )&  ;* /% '<"+ ! #"* &! .!(("

!*$ *$ 9(*!

(1 /%  #"* &! *!,.

'!

$$%
& '() *&$ ===== ===== ===== ===== 4 4 4 4% $ 647 % $ 647 % $ 647 % $ 647         *!,!

& , 1!!

#(/!'

'!* !+("

?

"# &! & * (

) *(5  5,&  &( %

6#"* ,&"* >

:7 #"* )*  "# *!) / * 1 (/ "

&! .!(("

!* * ( + ,! 1! *( )   "$ ' !

!' @$2$ 3% *!)(,!*!' #"* &!

"##!

+!, .

(,& 1/!

'!* !+("

?67%

@6 7%

6 7%

?% 26 6 7 "# &!  & * (

&( %

6#"

#"* ,&"* > :7%  "/(+!  ("

1!*
*(0!% % !+"*%
& '() *&$

&! )* < 0!

"# &! //!) ("

, ) ( , &! .!(("

!* (, & 8*(!

+"0.

/ (  ' !' $  8 , , 10( (!' 1 &! +"0./ (

0!/ ()'& !''

% " &! %
1!*
*(0!% !+ +"* %
& '() *&% *!) *'(

+('!

 "# +

1!* #* '$ &! , !' &  8&(/!

,! *+&( ) #"* /( ! . *(0!

;"1% ,&! *!+!(<!' B& ,.. 0!,, )! #*"0 &!

01!* C@@

3@ $ &!

8 , ( #"*0!' &  &! ;"1 ( <"/<!' ( +*! ,( ) /(5!, "

/( ! <('!", ' 8 , 1,!D ''!' " !/!)* 0 )*"

. 8&!*! ,(0(/ *  ,5, 8!*! ,,() !'$ #!* +"0./!( ) #!8 , +&  ,5,% ,&! *!+!(<!' ,"0! .

' 8 , ,, *!'

"# # *&!* .*"#(,$ &! ( (( // <!,!' ,0 // 0"

 "# ₹%222 ' *!+!(<!'

₹% 22 ( $ &!*! #!*% ,&! 8 , .*!,, *!' ( " 0 5( ) / *)!* * , +("

,$

"*'!* " <"(' /",( ) &!* ( <!,!' 0"

% ,&! 0 '! 0 /(./! * ,#!*, #*"0 &!* 

' 
 5 ++"

,$  8 , //!)!' &  ,&!

/(0 !/

,#!**!' " / 0"

 "# ₹2%@@%3 2E #*"0 &!* ++"

, " &! #* ',!*,$

4! * !' +"

,!/ #"* &! .!(("

!* & , *) !' &  &! .!(("

!* (, ,( 2$23$ 3$ 4! * !' +"

,!/ & , # *&!* *) !' &  &!

!* & , 1!!

# /,!/ (0./(+ !' ( " &!   ( !,("

$ 4! * !' +"

,!/ & , # *&!* (!* !' &  ( <!,() ("

" &!  % (

+ ,!% (, +"0./!!

/0( "# &! *( / 8(//  5! /"

)$ 4! * !' +"

,!/ & , # *&!* *) !' & / , * , +("

//!)!' " & <!  5!

./ +! (, "# $  8&!*! ,% &!   (

!,("

8 , *!)(,!*!' "

@$2$ ' ) . 1!8!!

8" (, ( !F./(+ 1/!$ 4! * !' +"

,!/ & , # *&!* , 10(!' &  &! .!(("

!* (, 0 8(& +/!

!+!'!

,$ & ,% *!) / * 1 (/ (, .* !' #"*$ $ 4! * !' +"

,!/ #"* &! *!,."

'!

$$%
& '() *& ,!!5, "

./ +! "

*!+"*' + +!*(#(+ ! ' !' 2@$ 3 , /," , , *!."* 1

"# ,&"* ##(' <( ' !' 2?$ 3 "

1!& /# "# &! *!,."

'!

% ( &!

"

* "'

% 8&(+& *!  5!

*!+"*'$  (,( ) , 10(,,("

, (

'!0 8(& &! , , *!."*% /! * !' +"

,!/ #"* &! *!,."

'!

$$%
& '() *& & , "..",!' &! .*!,!

*) ) &  &! //!) ("

, * (,!' *! ,!*("

, (

' & ,% &! .!(("

!* '"!, " '!,!*<! &! +"

+!,,("

"# &! *!) / * 1 (/$

3$

& <! &! *' +"

,!/ #"* &! . *(!, ' & <! )"

! &*"

)& &!

< (/ 1/! *!+"*', "# &! + ,!$ !#"*! '!/<( ) ( " &! 0 !* # *&!*% ( 8"

/' 1! )!*0 ! "

*!#!* &!*!( &! + ,! / 8 )"<!* ) &! (,, ! ( & '- 3$ '(5 * ,(0&

' "&!*, <,$  1/(+ *",!+ "*% '(5 * ,(0&

' "&!*, <,$  1/(+ *",!+ "*% '(5 * ,(0&

' "&!*, <,$  1/(+ *",!+ "*% '(5 * ,(0&

' "&!*, <,$  1/(+ *",!+ "*% ()&
"

* "#  '&* * '!,&   @? 
 ()&
"

* "#  '&* * '!,&   @? 
 ()&
"

* "#  '&* * '!,&   @? 
 ()&
"

* "#  '&* * '!,&   @? 
  @%  @%  @%  @% *!/!<  8&!*!"# *! ', ,

'!*- G2$ &! ,() (#(+ ' ,8!!. "# *(+/!

 0 5! &!

'!.*(< ("

"# /(1!* 0 !* "# )* <! +"

+!*

' .!*0(,,(1/!

8&!

&! / 8 &"*(,( ) ( (, *! ,"

1/!% !<!

& '!'

)! *!' " &! )" /, "# +"00

)""'

'  !

!+!,,( ,.!/ *(+/! @$

'!!'% &! +"

,('!* ("

& <! ,! "

+*(!*( *! )!*0 ! " &! +"

,( / .*".",(("

& <!

'!'

+!'$ ! ,"

1/!

!,, .", / !, ( !//()!

 + *!

' .*!'(+ !, &  '!.*(< ("

"# #*!!'"0 1 *!# , / "# 1 (/ (, " #"* .

((<!

.

*.",! 1  #"* &! 1(#"+ / ( !*!,, "# ;

,(+!" &! ( '(<('

<"/<!'

' ,"+(!

##!+!'$ $ B! 0 , 8!()& &! +"

* * # +"*, "

,8!* &! !, "# *! ,"

1/!

!,,% , 1;!+ " &!

!!' #"* ,!+ ) &! .*!,!

+!% "# &! 1 (/ ../(+  0 5!, ,!

,! " ,, 0! &  0 1 (/ & , 1!!* +& +! " .*!. *! "* .*!,!

 &(, + ,! & ! *!0 '!' (

$  ' (# .

1/(+ ;

,(+! (, " 1! .*"0"!'% 0!+& (+ / '!!

,&"

/' 1! +/",! " "

*,% &! #

+("

"# 1 (/ (, /(0(!'% H+"00

*"",H "# &!% ../(+  *! ,*!,,!'

'% #!* &! 9!* "

' ("

H,  &  (/ *";!+% 0"

! * ,&(. (, /",( )*"

'$ &! +"

,('!* 1/! .

1/(+ !F.!

,! ( 5!!.( ) (

8&!*!

" '

)!* "# '(, ..! * +! "* '(, *1 +! + *(,!% (,

!)/()(1/! +"

,('!* ("

$ D // (0."*  (, &! '!./"* 1/!

'(("

% <!*)( ) "

$ &! ( & % "# "

* , 1; (/,% &  &!

*!8 *'( ) +* !/

' !F.!

,(<! + "# <"(' 1/!

+ *+!* ("

0 5!, *!# , / "# 1 (/

*! ,"

1/!

' "/(+

# <"

) *!/! ,! ;

,/ ,!

,(1/!$   #!8 "&!* 8!()& # +"*, '!,!*<! *!#!*!

+!$ // '!.*(< ("

"# /(1!* (, < /(' !' 1 ,"+( / '!#!

' ( '(<('

+"**!+("

/"

(+*(0( / '(*!+("

$  1/(+ ;

,(+! (, +!

* / " &! 8&"/! ,+&!0! "# 1 (/ / 8$ /!!( ) ;

,(+! 0 , 1! #"*1(''!

 .

((<! & *,& !,, ,&"

/' 1! 0( (0(,!'$ !,"* (<! '!<(+!, "

*!'!!0 &! 0 % !<!

% &*"

)& +"00

,!*<(+!% 0!'( (<!

'*(//% , +/ ,,!, "* "&!* *!,"

*+!, ,&"

/' 1! (

"< !'% ./ ) #"

/ 8(& .

1/(+ .! +! 1  0.!*( ) 8(& !<('!

+!% (0(' ( ) 8( !,,!, "* +"00(( ) "##!

+! 8&(/! "

;

'(+( //

+("

!' H#*!! !

!*.*(,!%H ,&"

/' 1! .*"<('!' ) ( ,$ " ,!!5!* "# ;

,(+! ,& // ./ #('!

+! *(+5, "

* "* +"00

& ,% +"

'(("

, 0 1! &

) *"

' 1 (/ "*'!*,% " " +*(../! 1

" .*"!+$  +& (, &! &"/(,(+ ;

*(,'(+("

' & (,(+ "*(!

<"5!' 1 &! ;

'(+( / '(,+*!("

+"**!/ !' " &!

< / !, "# "

* +"

,( $I



3$  *&!*% &! "

:1/!  .*!0!
"

* ( ;

')0!

 (/!' , *+& * ( )& <,$  ! 6 "# !/&(7 @? 67 

?% *+& * ( )& <,$  ! 6 "# !/&(7 @? 67 

?% *+& * ( )& <,$  ! 6 "# !/&(7 @? 67 

?% *+& * ( )& <,$  ! 6 "# !/&(7 @? 67 

?% & , &!/' ,

'!*- GB&!*! &! )* ) "# 1 (/ /(!, 8(&( &! '(,+*!("

"# &! +"

*% *% *% *% &! )* ) "* '!

( / (, *!) / !'% " / *)! !F!

% 1 &! # +,

' +(*+ 0, +!, "# ! +& . *(+ / * + ,!$ ( +! &! "1;!+ "# &!

'!!

"* (0.*(,"

 "# &! ++ ,!' (, " ,!+ *! &(, ..! * ' , 10(,,("

" &! ;

*(,'(+("

' &! ;

')0!

 "# *% *% *% *% &! .*(0 * (* (, 8&!&!* *!+") (J +! "* 1"

8"

/' !##!+ &  !

'$I 3$

 *&!*0"*!% &! "

:1/!  .*!0!
"

* ( ;

')0!

 (/!' , ;

& '* <,$
 2 7  

2% ;

& '* <,$
 2 7  

2% ;

& '* <,$
 2 7  

2% ;

& '* <,$
 2 7  

2% & , &!/' ,

'!*- $

1 (/ ../(+ ("

,% )!

!* // % ( & , 1!!

/ (' '"8 #*"0 &! ! */(!, (0!, &  &! "1;!+ "# 1 (/ (, " ,!+ *! &! ..! * "# &! ++ ,!' .!*,"

 &(, *( / 1 *! ,"

1/! 0"

 "# 1 (/$ &!

"1;!+ "# 1 (/ (, !(&!* .

((<!

"* .*!<!

 (<!$ !.*(< ("

"# /(1!* , 1! +"

,('!*!' .

(,&0!

/!,, ( + 1! *!D (*!'

" !

*! & ++ ,!' .!*,"

8(// , ' &(, *( / 8&!

+ //!'

$ &! +"

*, "8! 0"*! & <!*1 / *!,.!+ " &! .*( +(./! & .

(,&0!

 1!)( , #!* +"

<(+("

' &  !<!* (, '!!0!'

" 1! (

"+!

(/ '

*(!'

' '

#"

' ) (/

*"0 &! ! */(!, (0!,% ( 8 , ..*!+( !' &  '!!

.!

) +"0./!("

"# *( / +"

/' 1! + ,! "# )*!

& *',&(.$ *"0 (0! " (0!% !+!,,( '!0 ', &  ,"0!

 <(+!' .!*,"

, ,&"

/' 1! &!/' ( .!

) *( / " ,!+ &!(* !

+!  &! *( / 1 +& + ,!,% G !+!,,( I (, &!

".!* (<! !,$

&(, +"

% ( 8"

/' 1! D (! +"

* * " &!

+!. "# .!*,"

/ /(1!* ,&*( !' ( &!
"

,( &

.!*,"

,&"

/' 1! .

(,&!' ( *!,.!+ "#

0 !*% 8&(+&% &!

& , " 1!!

<(+!' "* &  (

+(*+ 0, +!,% &! ,&"

/' 1!

'!.*(<!' "# &(, /(1!*

&! 1!/(!# &  &! 8(//  0.!* 8(& &! 8( !,,!, (# /!#  /(1!* % , <! ( &! 0", !F* "*'(

+(*+ 0, +!,$I $ &! .!(("

!* 8 , **!,!' "

2$23$ 3 8&!*!( #!* <!,() ("

8 , + **(!' "

' +& // & , 1!!

.*!,!

!' "

$2?$ 3$ " / 2 .*",!+ 8( !,,!, & <! 1!!

+(!'

' ( (, " ( '(,.

! 1!#"*!

&(,
"

*% & ! .*",!+ 8( !,, & , 1!!

!F 0( !' (// ' !$  (,% & 1( 1/! &  + /0( "# &! *( / 8(//  5! (, "8 (0!$ &! *(< / * (,!'   * )(<! *(,! " '!1  1/! (,, !,% 8&(+& ,& // !,,!

( // 1!

* ("+( !'

) &! +"

*,! "# *( /$ &(,
"

* '"!, " '!!0 ( ..*".*( ! " '!/<! '!!. ( " &!,! *(< / +"

,%  &(, , )!% /!, ( 0

.*!;

'(+! &! *( /$ "&( )(1/! & , 1!!

1*"

)& #"*8 *' " ( '(+ ! &!

/(5!/(&""' "# &! .!(("

!* 1,+"

) #*"0 &! .*"+!,, "# ;

,(+! "* ( !*#!*( 8(& &! .*",!+ !<('!

+!$ $$ , .!* + +!*(#(+ ! ' !' 2@$ 3 #(/!' 1 /! * !'  !

,!/% &! .!(("

!* & , /*! '

##!*!' ( + *+!* ("

#"* .!*("' "# 2 0"

&, ' 2 '

,% K (, " ,&"8 " 1! ( <"/<!' (

"&!*  6,7$ ##(+! " , % # *&!* '!!

"# &! .!(("

!* ,

'!**( / (,

" 8 ** !' ( &! # +, ' +(*+ 0, +!, "# &! + ,!$ $

<(!8 "# 1"<!% &! .*!,!

(, //"8!'$ !(("

!* (, "*'!*!' " 1! *!/! ,!' "

*!) / * 1 (/ "

&(, # (,&( ) 1 (/E, 1"

', " &!

, (,# +("

"# &! 4'$ +"

+!* !'
E

 )(,* !$ "8!<!*% ( ''(("

" +"

'(("

, &  0 1! (0.",!' 1 +!* !'
E

 )(,* !% &!

!* ,& // *!0 ( 1"

' 1 &! #"//"8( ) +"

'(("

,- 6(7 &! .!(("

!* ,& // " 0(, ,! &! /(1!* )* !'$ 6((7 &! .!(("

!* ,& // "  0.!* 8(&

!<('!

+!% "* / "* '"+ % '

) &! *( /$ 6(((7 &! .!(("

!* ,& // " 1,!

 &(0,!/# "

' ! 1!#"*!

&! *( /$ 6(<7 &! .!(("

!* ,& // " +"00(

"##!

+! 8&(/!

1 (/$ 6<7 &! .!(("

!* ,& // '!.",( &(, . ,,."*% (#

% 8(& &!

*( /
"

*$ 6<(7 &! .!(("

!* ,& // )(<! &(, +!//.&"

01!* " &!

<!,() ( ) ##(+!*E "# +"

+!* !' "/(+!  ("

,& // " +& )! &(, +!//.&"

01!* 8(&"

 .*("* .!*0(,,("

"# &! *( /
"

*E // D  )(,* !$ 6<((7 &! .!(("

!* ,& // " (

!* * " '!/ &! *( /$ ?$

+ ,! "# 1*! +& "#

"# &! #"*!, (' +"

'(("

' &",!

8&(+& 0 1! (0.",!' 1 +!* !'
E

 )(,* ! , '(*!+!'

&!*!( 1"<! "* ,&"8(

"&!* , ##(+(!

,!% &!  !E+"0./ (

,& // 1!  /(1!* " 0"<! + +!// ("

"# 1 (/ "# &! .!(("

!*$ @$ *'!*!' ++"*'( )/



2$

"&( ) , (' &!*!( 1"<! ,& // 1! +"

,* !' , !F.*!,,("

"# ".( &! 0!*(, "# &! + ,!$ $ ( +! &! 0 ( + ,! & , 1!!

'!+('!'% .!

) 0(,+!// !"

../(+ ("

% (#

% ,& // /," , ', '(,.",!' "##$ 6 4  4  4  47     !+!01!* 2 !+!01!* 2 !+!01!* 2 !+!01!* 2% 0 & <(* B&!&!* ,.! 5( )E*! ,"

!'- !,E B&!&!* *!."* 1/!- !,E