Harwinder Singh v. State Of Punjab

5

              
 



 
 



 
 



 
 



! "  ! "  ! "  ! "     
!
!
!
!

#$%&'# (% %&)* C8 %%+&# # =#- / ( +, -&.

C81+&'&  ! +, '% ! +, '% ! +, '% ! +, '% ! +, 12+ ! +, 12+ ! +, 12+ ! +, 12+
0
0
0
0

#&0

#&0

#&0

#&0 %+&0 %+&0 %+&0 %+&0 &-#3

&-#3

&-#3

&-#3 56 6 6 6 5 5 5 5 5 +'%&)0 &-#3 +'%&)0 &-#3 +'%&)0 &-#3 +'%&)0 &-#3

56 5 5 5 5 5 < 4 8 (
 ( < 4 8 (
 ( < 4 8 (
 ( < 4 8 (
 (  4  4  4  4 #8 .&%* @8 -16 '=+  ,+# * 1%%+&#8 #8 2.%&'# (%&)* (#6 ''%%+ +&2  -&./8 AAAAA AAAAA AAAAA AAAAA 4 4 4 46 4 4 4 4 (  (  (  ( 

#& 1%%+& * /& ,%2' - -&'# (%+& 5 +, * ((6 56%&# 2 2%6 B%&) >-*%&) +, * %?1 1-)&' +#'# '' 5:8

&&7-#

5 1' /3 * 2#&'

-'%%2 )%# 
26

*)#* ( *%/6 $*#/36 * 1%%+&# $  '2#'  1#+2%?' 1#+&6 %&   #% %%&) +- +,  +8 '' 5 58 85 56 -&'# (%+& :

  9:5 +, * &'%& &2
+'6 

,+# * *+# ;
< &' (%+&  +, * 

-&./ #= =2 #+,%+&2 )-2%+& 6 5

:6 #)%#'  +2%  (%+&  *)#* (*%/6 !%#% *) #* (*%/6  $22  22 *  -/>-& 1 1#+'%&) #%%&) *#,#+?8 4#&' +-&2 ,+# * 1 %%+&# * %#' * *  %?1-)&' +# #'#6 $*#/3 * 1%%+&# *  /& '2#'  1#+2%?'

'

1#+&6 % $*+223 %22)26 #/%##36 &' -&-%&/2 %& * 3 +, 2$8 4#&' +-&2 * ,-#*# %#' * * 1%%+&# * /& ,223 %?12%' %&+ *  %& >-%+&8 4#&' +-&2 * #)-' * * 1%%+&# $ 2#'3 )#&' +&%+& +, #)-2# /%2 /3 * #%2
+-#6 =%' +#'# '' 5 85 5 &' *' /& 11#%&) #)-2#23 /,+# * #%2
+-#8 4#&' +-&2 * #)-' * %#D +-' +, * 1%%+&#6 &?236 @-2$%&'# @-# $ '%)&+' $%* &# &'  * $ #%'%&) $%* * 1%%+&#6 * 1%%+&# /? /-3 %& B%&) #D#?& +, *# %#8 * ?'%2 #+#' +, * %# +, * 1%%+&# % 11&''  &&7-#  $%* * 1%%+& %& *&'8 4#&' +-&2 * %#' * * #%2
+-# /2+$ $ %&,+#?' /+- * *2* +&'%%+& +, * %# +, * 1%%+&#8 4#&' +-&2 * ,-#*# %#' * =%' +#'# ''

85 6 &+&/%2/2 $##& +, * 1%%+&# $# %-'6 &' *#,#6 =%' +#'# '' 58 85 6 * 1#+2?%+& $ %-'

)%& * 1%%+&# $*#%& &+ 1%,% ' &' %? $ ?&%+&' ,+# ?B%&) 11#& /,+# * #%2
+-#8 4#&' +-&2 # * * %?1-)&' +#'# % 7 ,% %22)26 #/%##3 &' -&-%&/2 %& * 3 +, 2$ &' %6 *#,+#6 2%/2 + / %'8 4#&' +-&2 # * * %?1-)&' +#'# * /& 1' $%*+- 1#+1#23 #-%&%E%&) +# =#%,3%&) * -*&%%3 +, * #1+# -/?%' /3 * #=%&) +,,%%28
+&>-&236 * +#'# '2#%&) * 1%%+&#   1#+2%?' 1#+&% -&-%&/2 %& * 3 +, 2$ &' '#= + / >-*'8 8 4#&' ( +-&2 * ,%2' *+# #123 /3 $3 +, & ,,%'=% ''

6 $*%* % 2#'3 +& #+#'8 %%&) -/?%%+&

%& &'? $%* * %' *+# #1236 2#&' ( +-&2 +11+' * 1#& 1%%+&8F*%2 #,-%&) *   -1 /3 * 1%%+&#6 '%2' #)-?& $# '=&' +& ?#%6 +&&'%&) *6 *+-)*6 * 1%%+&# $ )#&' +&%+& +, #)-2# /%2 /3 * #%2
+-#6 /- * /&' *%?2, +& :8 85 /,+# * #%2
+-#8 *#,#6 &+% $ %-' + * 1%%+&#6 $*%* $ '-23 #='6 /- '1% *6 * 1%%+&# ,%2' + 11# /,+# * #%2
+-# &' *#,+#6 *% /%2 +#'# $ &22'8 4#&' ( +-&2 * ,-#*# #)-' * +& 58 85 6 * 1#+2?%+& $ %-' )%& * 1%%+&# '%#%&) *%? + 11# /,+# * #%2
+-# +& :8

8 4#&' ( +-&2 * %#' * ?&$*%26 -1+& & 112%%+& ?+=' /3 * 1%%+&#6 * #%2
+-# $*%2 B%&) 2&%& =%$ +& +-& +, '?% +, %# +, * 1%%+&#6 22+$' * %' 112%%+& +, * 1%%+&# ,+# )#& +, /%26 +& #%& +&'%%+&G /- '1% *6 * 1%%+&# ,%2' + ,-#&%* /%2D -#3 /+&'8 4#&' ( +-&2 * ,-#*# %#' * ,# ,+22+$%&) '- 1#+'-#  &=%)' -&'# (%+& 5 +, *
#8 8
86 * 1%%+&# $ #%)*23 '2#' 1#+2%?' 1#+& =%' %?1-)&' +#'# '' 5:8

8  * ,-#*# /& 1+%&' +- * * 2#&'
+-# /2+$ #-1-2+-23 '*#' + * 1#+'-# 1##%/' -&'# (%+& 5 +, *
+' +,
#%?%&2

#+'-#6 H6 &' &+ %&,%#?%3 +# %##)-2#%3 % '%#&%/2 ,#+? * #+#'8 4#&' ( +-&2 *6 *#,+#6 +&&'' * * +&'- +, * 1%%+&# 2#23 /2%* *% '2%/# ',%& +, * .-'%%2 1#+ &' ?%- +, * +&%+& +, /%28 +#'%&)236 '%?%2 +, * %&& 1%%+& * /& 1#3' ,+#8

:

:8  *= *#' * 2#&' +-&2 ,+# * #%=2 1#% &' #,-223 1#-' * #+#' +, * 8

* 2$ % $22 2' * &+ 1#+& & / '2#'  1#+2%?' +,,&'#D1#+& -&2 * 1#+'-# 1##%/' -&'# (%+& 5 +, *
+' +,
#%?%&2 #+'-#6 H % ?%-2+-23 '*#' +8  % #% 2$ * * 1#+=%%+& +, (%+& 5 # ?&'+#3 %& &-#6 &' &3 &+&+?12%& *#+, =%% * &%# 1#+'%&)8 & * 1#& 6 * 1%%+&# $ #2%# )#&' +&%+& +, #)-2# /%2 /3 * #%2
+-# &' *#,#6 * $ +&''236 11#%&) #)-2#23 + , * #%2 /,+# * #%2
+-#8  % #' * '- + *2* +&'%%+& +, * %#D + -' +, * 1%%+&#6 &?236 @-2$%&'# @-# &' ,-#*#6 +& +-& +, *# '?%6 * 1%%+&# +-2' &+ 11# /,+# * #%2
+-#8  * /& #' * &+ -* %,%+&6  #>-%#' -&'# (%+& 5 +, *
#8

8
86 #)#'%&) '- 7-%+& +, 1#+2?%+& )%& * 1%%+&# * /& #+#'' %& * %?1-)&' +#'#8 +$=#6 * #%2
+-# =%' %?1-)&' +#'# '' 5:8

'2#' * 1%%+&#  1#+2%?' 1#+& $*%* % &+ *+$& + *= /& 7-' %& +&,+#?%3 $%* (%+& 5 +, *
#8

8
8 8 *%
+-# ,%&' * +-# '+1' /3 *
+-# /2+$ % &%*% + * 1#+=%%+& +, (%+& 5 +, *
+' +,
#%?%&2 #+'-#6

H8 *
+-# /2+$ * +??%' %22)2%3 /3 %-%&) * %' 1#+2?%+& -&'# (%+& 5 +, *
#%?%&2 #+'-#
+'6 H $%*+- +?12%& +, ?&'+#3 #>-%#?& +, 2$8 * 2#&'
+-# /2+$6 $*%2 '2#%&) * 1%%+&#  1#+2%?' 1#+&6 ,%2' + %,3

%2, #)#'%&) '- 7-%+& +, 1#+2?%+& &' 1#+'' %&  ?*&%2 ?&&#8 (-* & +#'# /%&) =%+2%= +, ?&'+#3 1#+=%%+& +, 2$6 &&+ / -%&'8 (%+& 5 +, *
#%?%&2 #+'-#
+'6

H #'  -&'#0 I58 #+2?%+& ,+# 1#+& /+&'%&)8 58 #+2?%+& ,+# 1#+& /+&'%&)8 58 #+2?%+& ,+# 1#+& /+&'%&)8 58 #+2?%+& ,+# 1#+& /+&'%&)8   , &3
+-# * #+& + /2%= $**# ,# B%&) =%'& +# &+ * &3 1#+& )%& $*+?  $##& * /& %-' /3 % * /+&'' +# % +&2%&) *%?2, + * -* $##& &&+ / 7-'6 -*
+-# ?3 1-/2%*  $#%& 1#+2?%+& #>-%#%&) *%? + 11#   1%,%' 12 &'   1%,%' %? &+ 2 *& *%#3 '3 ,#+? * ' +, 1-/2%*%&) -* 1#+2?%+&8

5 * 1#+2?%+& *22 / 1-/2%*'  ,+22+$0 

%  % *22 / 1-/2%23 #' %& +? +&1%-+- 12 +, * +$& +# =%22) %& $*%* -* 1#+& +#'%&#%23 #%'G

/ % *22 / ,,%7' + +? +&1%-+- 1# +, * *+- +# *+?' %& $*%* -* 1#+& +#'%&#%23 #%' +# + +? +&1%-+- 12 +, -* +$& +# =%22)G

  +13 *#+, *22 / ,,%7' + +? +&1%-+- 1# +, * +-# *+-G

%% *
+-# ?3 2+6 %, % *%&B ,%6 '%#  +13 +, * 1#+2?%+& + / 1-/2%*' %&  '%23 &$11# %#-2%&) %& * 12 %& $*%* -* 1#+& +#'%&#%23 #%'8

  ?& %& $#%%&) /3 *
+-# %-%&) * 1#+2?%+& + * ,, * * 1#+2?%+& $ '-23 1-/2%*' +&  1%,%' '36 %& * ?&&# 1%,%' %& 2- % +, -/%+& 56 *22 / +&2-%= =%'& * * #>-%#?& +, *% (%+& *= /& +?12%' $%*6 &' * * 1#+2?%+& $ 1-/2%*' +& -* '38 J : F*#  1#+2?%+& 1-/2%*' -&'# -/%+&  % %& #1 +,  1#+& -' +, & +,,& 1-&%*/2 -&'# (%+&  56  :6 :6 6 56 H56 H6 H:6 H 6 H6 H6 H6 HH6 :

6 :

56 :6 ::H6 :

H6 +# : +, * &'%& &2
+' :

+,  6 &' -* 1#+& ,%2 + 11#  * 1%,%' 12 &' %? #>-%#' /3 * 1#+2?%+&6 *
+-# ?36 ,# ?B%&) -* %&>-%#3  % *%&B ,%6 1#+&+-& *%?  1#+2%?' +,,&'# &' ?B  '2#%+& + * ,,8

 * 1#+=%%+& +, -/%+& 5 &'

 *22 1123 +  '2#%+& ?' /3 *
+-# -&'# -/%+& :  *3 1123 + * 1#+2?%+& 1-/2%*' -&'# -/%+& 8KL 8 
++#'%& &* +, *%
+-# $*%2 '2%&) $%* %&=+%+& +, * 1#+=%%+& +, (%+& 5 +, *
+' +,
#%?%&2 #+'-#6 )%& & -' %& *  +, ;(+&- =8 ( +, #3&6 5

 

#%?%&2 (+&- =8 ( +, #3&6 5

 

#%?%&2 (+&- =8 ( +, #3&6 5

 

#%?%&2 (+&- =8 ( +, #3&6 5

 

#%?%&2 H< H< H< H<6 *2'  -&'#0 IH8 * &%2 #>-%#?& +, %+& 5 +, *
#8 8
86 H ,+# %-& &' 1-/2%%+& +, 1#+2?%+& )%& & /+&'# &'



'2#%&) *%?  1#+2%?' 1#+&D+,,&'# ?3 / -??#%E'  -&'#0

% #%+# %-& +, $##& +, ## /3 *
+-# % %& >- &+& ,+# %-& &' 1-/2%%+& +, * 1#+2?%+& &' *
+-# * + ,%# %- $##& +, ## )%& * 1#+& +&#&'8 ( +*% @-?# =8 ( +, !2*%0 5


#28 8 5  8

%% *# ?- /  #1+# /,+# *
+-# * * 1#+& )%& $*+? $##& $ %-' *' /+&'' +# *' /& +&2%&) *%?2, + * * $##& +, ## +-2' &+ / 7-' )%& *%?8 +$=#6 *
+-# % &+ /+-&' + B =%'& %& *% #)#' /,+# %-%&) 

#+2?%+& -&'# %+& 5  +, *
#8 8
86 H8 ( +*% @-?# =8 ( +, !2*% 0 5


#28 8 5  8

%%% *
+-# &&+ %- * #+2?%+&   ?# +, +-# /- * +2% % B%&) ,+# %8 *
+-# ?- / 1#%? ,% %,%' * * 1#+& * /+&'' +# % +&2%&) *%?2, + * * $##& +, ##6 1#=%+-23 %-'6 &&+ / 7-'6 '1% #+&/2 '%2%)&8 ( %*-&'32*+& &' +*# =8 ?1#+# 0  H:

&  &' !=&'# (%&)* )% =8 ( +, 8 8 0 HH:
#2 4

22*/' 
 8

%= * #>-%% ' &' 12 ,+# 11#& ?- / 1%,%' %& * 1#+2?%+& #>-%#%&) -* 1#+& + 11# +& -* '  * 1%,%' 128 (-* ' ?- &+ / 2 *&  2# '3 ,#+? * ' +, %-& &' 1-/2%%+& +, * 1#+2?%+&8 ( -#11 -)2 &'

+*# =8 ( +, 3+# 0 HH
#%4 5 &' (*+B 2% =8 ( +, #3& 0 5

5 

4 H8

= F*# * 1#%+' /$& %-& &' 1-/2%%+& +, * 1#+2?%+& &' * 1%,%' ' +, *#%&) % 2 *& *%#3 '36 * -' &&+ / '2#'  1#+2%?' 1#+&D+,,&'# &' * 1#+2?%+& * + / %-' &' 1-/2%*' )%&8 ( !%2/)* (%&)* =8 ( +, -&./

9 0 5

 

4  &' *+B @-?# =8 ( +, #3& &' &+*# 0 5

: 

4



=% * #+2?%+& * + / 1-/2%*' %& * ?&&# 2%' '+$& %& %+& 5 5 +, *
#8 8
86 H8 +# 1-/2%%+& * 1#+2?%+& * + / ,%# 1-/2%23 #' %& +? +&1%-+- 12 +, * +$& +# =%22) %& $*%* * -' +#'%&#%23 #%'G *& * ? * + / ,,%7' + +? +&1%-+- 1# +, * *+- +# *+?' %& $*%* * -' +#'%&#%23 #%' +# + +? +&1%-+- 12 +, -* +$& +# =%22) &' *#,#  +13 +, * 1#+2?%+& * + / ,,%7' + +? +&1%-+- 1# +, *
+-#*+-8 * *# -/2-   %& %+& 5 5 % +, *
#8 8
86 H # +&.-&%= &' &+ '%.-&%=6 $*%* ?& * *# $+-2' / &+ =2%' 1-/2%%+& +, * 1#+2?%+& -&2 22 * *# ?+' +, 1-/2%%+& # 1#+='8 ( $& @-?# -1 =8 * ( +, F8 8 0 H
#%4

8 F*# *
+-# + +#'#  +13 +, * 1#+2?%+& * + / ''%%+&223 1-/2%*' %&  '%23 &$11# %#-2%&) %& * 12 %& $*%* * -' +#'%&#%23 #%'8 '=%/236 1#+2?%+& * + / %-' $%* ,+-# +1% + * +& * +, * *# +1% +, * 1#+2?%+& ?3 / ,,%7' + +? +&1%-+- 1# +, * *+- +# *+?' %& $*%* * -' +#'%&#%23 #%'6 + +? +&1%-+- 12 +, -* +$& +# =%22) &' + +? +&1%-+- 1# +, *
+-#*+- &' #1+# #)#'%&) 1-/2%%+& ?3 / ?' +& * ,+-#* +13 +, * 1#+2?%+&8 ''%%+&2 +13 $%22 / #>-%#' $*# * 1#+2?%+& % 2+ #>-%#' + / 1-/2%*' %& * &$11#8

=%% (?& +, * #=%&) +,,%# * + / #+#'' /3 *
+-#  + * ' &' ?+' +, 1-/2%%+& +, * 1#+2?%+&8 ( %#' !& =8 (0 
#%4 H 8

=%%% *
+-# %-%&) * 1#+2?%+& * + ?B  ?& %& $#%%&) %& % +#'# * * 1#+2?%+& $ '-23 1-/2%*' +&  1%,%'



'3 %&  ?&&# 1%,%' %& %+& 5 5 % +, *
#8 8
86 H8 (-* ?& %& $#%%&) /3 *
+-# % '2#' + / +&2-%= =%'& * * #>-%#?& +, (%+& 5 *= /& +?12%' $%* &' * * 1#+2?%+& $ 1-/2%*' +& -* '38 ( %#' !& =8 (0 
#%4 H 8

7% * +&'%%+& 1%,%' %& %+& 5 5 +, *
#8 8
86 H ,+# * 1-/2%%+& +,  #+2?%+& )%& & /+&'# # ?&'+#38 &3 &+&+?12%& *#$%* &&+ / -#'  & M%##)-2#%3M &' #&'# * #+2?%+& &' 1#+'%&) -/>-& *#+  &-22%38 ( !=&'# (%&)* )% 2% !/- =8 ( +, 8 8 &' &+*#0 HH:
#%4

 &'

2 (%&)* =8 * (0

#%4 8L 8  % 1#%&& + ?&%+& * % % /3 &+$  2' 1#%&%12 +, 2$ * /,+# %-%&)  1#+2?%+& -&'# (%+& 5
#8 8
86 *
+-# ?- #+#' % %,%+& * * -'6 )%& $*+? * 1#+2?%+& % +-)* + / %-'6 % /+&'%&) +# +&2%&) *%?2, $%* & %&& + =' ##8 *% ,+-&'%+&2 #>-%#?& % +&1%-+-23 /& %& * 1#& 8  1#-2 +, * %?1-)&' +#'# '' 5:8

#=2 * &+ -* %,%+& $ #+#'' /3 *
+-# /2+$6 &+# $ *# &3 ?#%2 + .-%,3 * %&,#& * * 1%%+&# *' /+&'' +# $ '2%/#23 =+%'%&) *% 11#&8 H8 * 1#+=%%+& +, (%+& 5 +, *
+' +,
#%?%&2 #+'-# *=%&) #%+- #?%,%%+& >- * #%)* +, * -' +&#&%&) *% 1#& %& * #%?%&2 #%2 1#+'%&) +-)* &+ / &' &&+ / %&=+B' %& -2 &' =2%# ?&&#8 * #>-%#?& +, #+#'%&) +, %,%+&6 * * -' * /+&'' +# % +&2%&) *%?2, + * $##& +, *% ## &&+ / 7-'6  ?/+'%' %& (%+& 5 +, *
+' +,
#%?%&2 #+'-#6 % + / #-1-2+-23 +?12%' $%* /' +& #2=& ?#%2 =%2/2 +& #+#' +, *  %& * #)#'8 +& '*#& + %' #>-%#?& $*%2 '2#%&) * -'  1#+2%?' 1#+& =%% * 1#+2?%+& 1#+'%&) %&%%' )%& * -'8



&6 &+ -,-2 1-#1+ $+-2' / #=' /3 B1%&) * #%?%&2 1#+'%&) 1&'%&) )%& * 1%%+&#8  %6 *#,+#6 & 11#+1#%  ,+# * 7#% +, 1+$# -&'# (%+& 5 +, ((D(%+& :5 +,
#8 8
8 &' + /#%&) + & &' * #%?%&2 1#+'%&) %&%%' %& * 2%)* +, *  %/%' )%& * 1%%+&#8

& =%$ +, * /+= ,%&'%&)6 %& * &%#3 +, , &' %#-?& +, * 1#& 6 * 1#& 1%%+& % 22+$'G &' * %?1-)&' +#'# '' 5:8

&&7-# 5 1' /3 * 2#&'

-'%%2 )%# 
26 *)#* (*%/6 $*#/36 * 1%%+&# $ '2#'  1#+2%?' 1#+&6 %&   #%%&) +- +,  +8 ''

58 85 56 -&'# (%+& :

 9 :5 +, * &'%& &2
+'6 

,+# *+# ;
< &' (%+&  +, * -&./ #=2 #+,%+&2 )-2%+& 6 5

:6 #)%#'  +2% (%+& *)#* (*%/6 !%#% *)#* (*%/ $22  * +*# +&>-&%2 1#+'%&) #%%&) *#,#+?6 # >-*'8

&'%&) 112%%+& 6 %, &36 *22 2+ &' '%1+' +, +#'%&)238

( 4 ( 4 ( 4 ( 4

!

!

!

!

&-#3

&-#3

&-#3

&-#3 56 5 5 ?*=%# F**# 1B%&)D#+&'0 "D+ F**# #1+#/20 "D+