Gurdev Singh v. Financial Commissioner Apeeal Punjab Main Secretariat Punjab Sector 1 Chandigarh And Others
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
-.. /0(%1 2*,34 ......
%$*$*&,%0 +
5%0+/+
88%#6+ &$4%0+ ......
%+8&,(%,$ +
; < .
2 2
0%+%,$ 0.
2#,(%%8
#*,= 0.
2#)4*,
#*,= (1&)#$%+ +.
0.
#1,%%$ 2*,34= 2%,*&0 ! /,9#:.
. . 2 =
.
<
.
%$*$*&,%0
/0(%1 2*,34 '*6%( 0$*)6%+ - &,+$*$/$*&, ,(*#= *,$%0 #6*#= +%%?*,3 ,#$/0% )%0$*&0#0* +%$$*,3 #+*(% . .
= 8#++%( #,3#
= 8#++%(
/,9#:.
.
0*%'6A= /07#*6 2*,34 '*6%( #, #886*)#$*&,= +%%?*,3 9&*,$ 7#06#= )&780*+%( C4%>#$ -=
= 8%0
#7#:#,(* = +*$/#$%( #$ 1*66#3% #((* #$>#6*= %4+*6 !*+$0*)$ 24#4%%( 4#3#$ 2*,34 #3#0
#>#,+4#40.
. $ #88%#0+ 80&)%%( #3#*,+$ %@8#0$% #'&0%+#*( '*,#6 )#7% 8#++%( . . = 1*(% .
. $ $0#,+8*0%+ )4#66%,3%( #'&0%+#*( . .
'*6*,3 #, #88%#6 :%'&0% &66%)$&0= 4&>%1%0= +#7% (*+7*++%(= 1*(% . .
80*7#0*6A 30&/,( #'$%0 *++/#,)% +#,#( $#?+%%7= #88%#6 7#*,$#*,#:6%.
. 4%0%#'$%0= 80%'%00%( 0%1*+*&,
- :%'&0%
/,9#:= (*+7*++%(= 1*(%
.
.
#'&0%7%,$*&,%( )*0)/7+$#,)%+= '*6%( 0%6*%'
+= ,&$*)%( #:&1%.
.
<%#0,%( +/:7*$+ '&66&>%( 80&8%0 80&)%(/0% +/77&, 0%+*(*,3 #:0&#( #6*'&0,*#
2 80&)%%(%( #3#*,+$ %@8#0$%.
$ '/0$4%0 +/:7*$$%( %1%, &$4%0>*+%= #0% )&,$0#0A 7&(% )#00*%( ?%%8*,3 8&++%++*&, *,$#)$= >4%0%#+ 8&++%++*&, (*+$/0:%(.
$ ,%@$ +/:7*$$%( 7#06# *.%.
240* 9*$ 2*,34 *.%.
<#+4?#0 2*,34= 1*(% +#6% (%%( . .= >4%0%*, >%+$%0, 8&0$*&,
+&6(= >4%0%#+ '*,#6
8%$*$*&,%0= #66&)#$%( 0%+8&,(%,$+ .
))&0(*,36A= +/:7*$$%( +#,#( $#?+%%7 >%66 *78/3,%( &0(%0+ +%$ #+*(% 7#$$%0 0%7#,(%( )#00A*,3 #'0%+4.
.
4#1% 4%#0(
4#1% 8%0/+%( 8#8%0:&&?
#:6% #++*+$#,)%.
.
+ '*0+$ )&,$%,$*&, 0#*+%( :%4#6'
80&8%06A +%01%(= &:+%01%( +#*( )&,$%,$*&, (/6A )&,+*(%0%(
= 0%6%1#,$ %@$0#)$+ >4%0%&'
0%#(
! " #
$ % &&' % ( ) )*
+
, - & - .
,/0,'
1 '
- 00 ,0 2,)&3 !
45
* + 6 + "
7 7) . . )
.
* % (
+
80* 9 7 7 8
%
.
. .
.
*
. 72:3
. . ; ; <
. . *
7 ! "#
$ % &&'
% (
.
. .
<
% (
+ "
*
.
.
" ' $
87 7 % (
+
.<
%
=
.
8%0/+#6 #:&1% %@$0#)$%( &:+%01#$*&,+ '*,(*,3+ 0%$/0,%(
>&/6( *,(*)#$%
*,*$*#66A= +/77&,+ >%0% *++/%( $4%0%#'$%0 %1%, 0%3*+$%0%( ,&$*)%+ >%0% +%,$ #$ #((0%++= >%0% 0%)%*1%( :#)?
0%8&0$ (*( 0%+*(% 1*66#3%.
$ #88%#0+ $4%0%#'$%0 7/+4$0* 7/,#(*
80&)6#7#$*&, *++/%( /6$*7#$%6A %1%, 8/:6*)#$*&, 7#(% ,%>+8#8%0 &,6A $4%0%#'$%0 80&)%%(%( #3#*,+$ %@8#0$%.
88#0%,$6A= #66 7&(%+ +%01*)% >%0% 0%+&0$%( $4%0%#'$%0 80&)%%(%( #3#*,+$ %@8#0$%= $4%0%'&0%= )#,,&$ 4%6( 80&8%0 80&)%(/0% '&66&>%( +%01*)% /8&, )&,)%0,%(.
. + &$4%0 )&,$%,$*&, 0#*+%( :%4#6'
'*,#6 )&,$0#0A +#,)$*&,%( 7&(%
8%$*$*&,%0;+ 8&++%++*&, (*+$/0:%(= &:+%01%( )&780*+%( &,6A
= 7#06#.
4% '#*6%( 0%'%0 #,A 7#$%0*#6 (&)/7%,$ *,(*)#$% 8&0$*&, 4% 4#1*,3 8&++%++*&,.
#:+%,)% #,A 7#$%0*#6 *,(*)#$% 8&++%++*&, +8%)*'*) 8&0$*&, 8#0$*$*&,= #'&0%+#*( 86%# 6*#:6% 0%9%)$%(.
. (& '*,( #,A '&0)% )&,$%,$*&, 0#*+%( :%4#6'
#0%#= *.%.
>%+$%0, 8&0$*&,
= #66&)#$%( 0%+8&,(%,$+ = )&8A +#6% (%%( #$$#)4%( 8%$*$*&,.
. 4#$ #8#0$= 8%0/+#6 +*$% 86#,
-= (%8*)$+ 8&+*$*&, #0%# #66&)#$%( 0%+8%)$*1% )&&>,%0+ >&/6( 0%1%#6 0%+8&,(%,$+ &>, 1%0A +7#66 )4/,?
7#9&0 8&0$*&, &>,%( &,6A.
4% #66&)#$%( +4&>, 8*,?
)&6&/0= >4%0%#+ #66&)#$%( +4&>, 30%%, )&6&/0.
, &$4%0 4#,(= #66&)#$%( +4&>, :6/% )&6&/0.
0&7 8%0/+#6 +*$% 86#,
-= #88%#0 '#*0= 9/+$ %D/*$#:6%.
. <%#0,%( )&/6( 8&*,$ >4#$ 80%9/(*)% )#/+%( 7#,,%0 '*,#6 )#00*%( &/$.
-.
1*%> #:&1%= (& '*,( #,A 7%0*$ +#7% #))&0(*,36A (*+7*++%(.
.
%,(*,3 #886*)#$*&,
+= *'
#,A= +4#66 +$#,( )6&+%(.
2
!
-..
+9?+ 4%$4%0 +8%#?*,3 0%#+&,%(
"%+
& 4%$4%0 0%8&0$#:6% "%+
&