← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaARB/660/2025allowed

Sandeep Kumar v. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd

2026-02-26Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri14 pages

           



  !"#"$%&& '

$(

) *+, - &&&&&&

"

"$ - .

-#+# $("

$ "/ -)-

"$ 0 (& &&&&& #)$( $

  %  10 & ' ' '          

       

      

 ' '  &

- /

 !    "  #$%#&%

 '  ("   ))&#   * 

 +% ,    " '      

-' -  

.

/"    ',     ,  0 .

.1)# 2 .%' -        -       '    "  3   "   , -""      , -"'     "

 ,   4"5    /     3  "6 '  - '7-7 '  "  7 ""   "     #"7'   ,  %""'"7 ( 

 . (,  ("  '"

  #8   ''"

  -%"7 ( #%""

             7  7     #%  9 #%      2"    ""     (       4"

(  (  "'"  ,  ""        4"  (     (     ""7    )    '   (") 1   

'  (") 1""'  -:"   

'  ,7-     -    7 (") 1'   

("& ;

1& ;

.

1) .

17      ",       "   " '""        -   ("& < 1  7    7",  -    ""'        '        "  '         -7   '  '   "-  -     ",    -     ,  '   " '       ',     ' -         '   " '7         .

.

.1.6 # 2 ;%   '    ,'7 -7    "7   2  0     ',        ,       '    ,,   "       ' "        ,  

" '  

 <

=  ""'"     ',     -   2 

     "-'    '7  "  "         !  "7  '          -         ' '" 7        > ',   (") 17      ",    7",#%  -     ""'   '   "'   !  "" -'  "  

  ",7", -   ","   ? "'""

>

 ',   -    ",  ' '7 4"  >"',        ",  '  '       

$

5 ""   

 &

 "   "6  ("  ) 1         "02     '

     

                     



  

        

   !  "  

#    $   $ %

#&    

 6   



#

# ' $   $ %

#&(. ### ### ### ###

) * +&,  , 



$

-  . /

-&    -       



  $ /

 

 

  

* * * $ 0

  1

 /2   

  

   */ $-

   

            /   4 

/#   * ### ### ### ### 566&  7-      $     *   896 89!6 56!6  

     *       *3 ) *3) 

  

  :

 ( *3 ) *3)

 

 $     *   88;6            

   /32 +) 

 *3 ) *3)   7   

 

$ * 56      32 +)          /   

   *3 ) *3) &  /    *   *3 ) *3)   *3 ) *3)   $    &  &            *  

 

*3 ) *3)<:

 (

 

$ * 88;6

 $ =

! "   -7  '  " "     

  .

.

.1.6# 2 ;%"   "7- "'7         )

!  "7  '     '7  "  "      --        ",'7       ",(") 1"7  ", '    '   /"      ,   ,   ,  >+'" ,(  



    !

"#$ !

"%& '

%       ",   ",  ""-   7     2   ,   >-    (    '"          ""   -  '@ ,  >+'" ,( ()""

$* +"!

,  !

"#$- $.  /A 0

"

0% -   ,  



    !

"1$+ $"&* '- "

1

!"-"-'7 >+'" ,(  ( )""

$* +"!

, !

"1$+ $"&$* ' "  ,  >+'" ,( B"

,2"3""2    /""!"$*"2    +

 +%   !

+% %"= &0' %         ,            ( -"   , " -""7   2  '  

 & "   

! "2,   -   ' '"  7  '  '7 (           5  "7   2  '  "    , " !"     ,  >+'" ,( ()""

$* +"!

, !

"4$ + $"&* '  >6      #

    7  /8&    

#           7  9    #

    $          .    $ .    



 ?#

 @ 7 /8&   

 ? @ 7

8   .   /8& 

             

      #          

     .          ? @ 7 8  $  #    %    

       

     !    $   &  A         #                   -         

 #  

 ;)

7 3- ) 

* 

 /    !6B  $

)

 /C

*

 ; 7* 

     #

    #              

      $ $ #

   >!65    $ # 

      7 *C

* 

     >#

#         =          

     $        

   

       .     

  -  

 

 

 

   >  =    

   #

  



  

  7 D7     #

   

     

  

 

   7        

                 #       &   

     EFG /+   ,

$ $  *

)

 /   .   

     

       #             



 :   

      $ 

H " / 

1*$71I /-    

 >   =    7    #     

   #&   &         $         

       . 

)

 /

 0 B 

>   =       %. #   

   

 

 -    

     

          

 $ 

  



 

#  $ 

     >   = 8. >   =

 # .            



   #  $ -        

                 $      &   . 



#  $

         %

 $   

        

 %

 = 

!"     ,   >?'"

,  (   "

,  2"3""  2     /""!"$  *"

2    +

 +%   ! +% %" $"

&* '"  >!6 

 $      $                 :





 



7 8      

-             $

     7   

     

        -          

. - 

  $      



$  



 ) $             

 

 

  

  





$      

                        

          

 

           

   

   

 



   

 

  



  

  

 J : $           

       

$         

                   -           

- 

#   $      

       

 

$        

     &   ###### 8B 

  

   7 /8&       #

      #      

 K#

 K

 

         

   7

          & 

      .      K#  K    

              9    



": / *                        

#    &      

     

      

$  

   $       #

  7 /8&    

#       7 97   $  

 1  

$ 7 9   .   $ .    



 

  

$ 

 &  $



 $#   $  

        7 8 2

       

H  " /

 #7 D  

 88        $

   #      

    %

    

- 

  

 &     #                                   

      

   $  

 #   $   

  #   $      $                    

 

  = .

C "7 >+'" ,( 55 +"5 "  6"

+.

"+*"6+5 $*+*" "6 +"$% 

"

 " -  '  - ,  ""     2    7   '        ,             !"      ,   .   

 #

  7 558

 

    *       

            #                           #

-  7       &   



# 

 7&  /8     7      

 ;!68

!;6!6B%

          

         &  /,& /B& /87 *      C

  *             





-   *  

#

 #   

 

 ;;!65 & /8  

    

 .  & /8 7 558 



 %   -   !6B 

 

 &

/8 

7 558  >/

         

     

  C

* 7* #                $   



 86 / $    $        

        

       

*7* #

  #              

    = 

  #

>  =

 -  

 . !6B    $ &0    *

)

 ( 

       * 

  558   

 7 D55B  $ >!65    $  # 

     7*C

*  

   ?#

 #                  @    

     $       

       

        

 . 

-  

 

 

=  ) 

 $$  *



)

 /&-   *

>7(   

 * $L 7

= $& >,F."$+ "5"7* , ."$ /"5

!"  5  2    $ 

!

"    ."

$+* ,  5  !

 5 + "  "8 $"+"  5  ."

   /""!"% .

/"

$":      

                 $    

?H   "   $  "  

 *  /      

? 1*$71I



 / -          

 >   =   #  

#&  &     $    

   . 

)

 /= 9! .

$ $*

"

 <  $   & 0   * 

$ &0    *

)

 / $   

 

$  &0    *

+/

$ C

* 



 

   

                               C

*

 $     &  

 

        

        <

5   ' '7""      -   ",- -     ""         ",

!(   -"     -       ",     '            2      '  "   !(   '7   "-"-'7 >+'" ,(  ()""

$* +"!

, !

"4$ + $"&$* '  "

,2"3"" 2   /""!"$*"2    +

 +%

 ! +% %" &$* ' 

$ 55 +"5 "  6"

+.

"+*"6+5 $*+*" "6 +"$% 

"

 6

5-     ,     ""-  

"D    E"   ;

"   ,   F  '"   )06.666  G,"  5:

 6 " H,"

,   ,       "  '             ' -       '    ,"  

   7"  .   

$     ' " '    ," ' 2,, '7" '    

&

E""' " '  -   E  "   '    ,

;

 /  '      "  @     ,"      ,", '  .)   



0 

@ " "- 7  '  



"D  

&&

' '  %  8 9 I9  8  '"  I9