M/S Greymarble Infra Pvt Ltd v. State Of Punjab
!
"#$ $%&'&()*
+',$-.",/0$( ,"1#2#3 $#&#&($, 4$,'5'
6#"#$ 5(7"/"(3#8$,'
$'9(3$(#'
): 2 6 22 : 2 64;
22< !" #$ % &## #'
=&1&0,&#$#&#&(5(3$, ,#&%0$
> #8$('##&(
(3&" ,#8$&''5"(%$ "?,&#<,3$,,3&,$%#&($'9$%&"00-"?,&#&(#8$ ("#5,$ $,#&,",& , @5"'8&(A #8$ 33&#&("0 $."(3#&%$ 3"#$3 (($B5,$ + "(3 #? $."(3 #&%$' 3"#$3
(($B5,$ + C "(3 +
?8$,$/- #8$ $#&#&($,' 8"1$ /$$( %8",A$3 2+ %8",A$' 3$'9&#$ #8$ '".$ /$&(A $B90&%�- $B$.9#$3 @5" #8$ 9,7$%# #8$$#&#&($,&(#$,.' #8$9,1&'&(' (35'#,&"0",D'0&%- 3"#$3*> * (($B5,$+ &''5$3/-$'9(3$(# < $9",#.$(#
5'&(A"(3,/"( $1$09.$(#<1$,(.$(# 5(7"/"(38$(%$/$&(A ."(& $'#0-&00$A"0&(#8$&(#$,$'# 75'#&%$<
,#8$&''5"(%$ "?,&#&(#8$("#5,$ "(3".5' , 3&,$%#&(A#8$$'9(3$(#'#$B#$(3#8$ &'%"0&(%$(#&1$'##8$$#&#&($,&( #$,.' #8$(35'#,&"0",D'0&%-< *3"#$3*> * (($B5,$+ < /$&(A"((35'#,&"0",D9,7$%#?8&%8?"'"990&$3 ,"(3"99,1$3"
#$, (#& &%"#&( #8$ 0&%- 3"#$3 *> * "(3 .5%8 9,&, # #8$ ".$(3.$(###8$(35'#,&"0",D'0&%-< *1&3$#& &%"#&(3"#$3 (($B5,$+&(#8$&(#$,$'# 75'#&%$E
,#8$&''5"(%$ "?,&#&(#8$("#5,$ "(3".5' , 3&,$%#&(A #8$ $'9(3$(#' # $B#$(3 #8$ 3$1$09.$(# /$($ &#' # #8$
$#&#&($,&(#$,.' #8$(35'#,&"0",D'0&%-< *3"#$3*> * (($B5,$+ ?8$,$/-(35'#,&"0",D9,7$%#'8"1&(A".&(&.5.",$"
%,$'?$,$#/$"00?$3#3$1$09"."B&.5. F #8$'"&3",$"
"'$'&3$(#&"0"(3..$,%&"0%.9($(#&(#8$&(#$,$'# 75'#&%$E
,#8$&''5"(%$ "?,&#&(#8$("#5,$ "(3".5' , 3&,$%#&(A #8$ $'9(3$(#' # ,$%"0%50"#$ #8$ ".5(# 3$."(3$3 1&3$
33&#&("0 $."(3#&%$3"#$3 (($B5,$+ "(3 '$9","#$ $."(3 #&%$' 3"#$3 (($B5,$ + C"(3+
?8&0'#350- ,$.1&(A#8$2< <6%,5#&(- $$'"(323&
$,$(#&"0%8",A$'"(3 ,$%"0%50"#&(A#8$6 8",A$'&(#$,.' #8$(35'#,&"0"(3 5'&($''0&%-<
C (($B5,$+"(3(35'#,&"0",D'0&%-< * (($B5,$+ "(3 ,$ 5(3#8$$B%$''".5(#3$9'&#$3/-#8$$#&#&($,5(3$,9,#$'#1&3$ 1",&5' $."(3 ,"
#'3"#$3 < "(3 <
, #8$ &''5"(%$ " ?,&# &( #8$ ("#5,$ "(3".5'
3&,$%#&(A#8$$'9(3$(#>#"99,1$#8$$1&'$32"-5#0"(3"#$3 '5/.&##$3 /- #8$ $#&#&($, 1&3$ ,"?&(A 5./$, +++2G<68$$#+2G"0(A?R$##$,,$@5$'#&(A , "99,1"0 #8$$1&'$32"-5#0"(3"#$3C (($B5,$+C ?8&0$A&1&(A9,&."%-##8$(35'#,&"0",D'0&%-< *<?8&%8?"'#8$ (0- 0&%- "990&%"/0$ # #8$ (35'#,&"0 ",D 9,7$%# 0"5(%8$3 /- #8$ $#&#&($,/$&(A"99,1$3.5%8$",0&$,##8$(#& &%"#&( #8$(35'#,&"0 "(3 5'&($'' $1$09.$(#0&%-<
"'?$00"'#8$#& &%"#&(3"#$3 ?8&0'#"0'&A(,&(A#8$$1&'$32"-5#0"(3"#$3C
'5/.&##$3/-#8$$#&#&($,?>F(35'#,&"0%.9($(#5(3$,35,$''( "%%5(# #8$ '9$%& &% 3&,$%#&1$' #8$ $'9(3$(# > 1&3$ &#' *#8 .$$#&(A8$03( *C #8"##8$2"-5#0"('?&00(#/$9"''$3&(%"'$ #8$- ",$ (# ,$1&'$3 # &(%053$>F (35'#,&"0 %.9($(# &(#$,.'
#& &%"#&(3"#$3 C <
,#8$&''5"(%$ "?,&#&(#8$("#5,$ $,#&,",& , @5"'8&(A#8$9,%$$3&(A' #8$*#8.$$#&(A #8$2"-5#0"( 99,1"0 ..&##$$<$'9(3$(#><8$03( *C (($B5,$+ ?8$,$/- #8$$1&'$32"-5#0"(3"#$3 <'5/.&##$3/-#8$$#&#&($,?"'
,$7$%#$3?8&0'#3&,$%#&(A#8"##8$(35'#,&"0%.9($(#&(#8$'"&32"-5# 0"('8503/$&(%,$"'$3#.&(&.5.>F&(#$,.' #8$#& &%"#&(3"#$3 <"'/$&(A%(#,",-##8$#& &%"#&(3"#$3 ?8$,$&(&# &''9$%& &%"00-,$%,3$3#8"##8$'".$?503"990-(0-#$?(35'#,&"0 ",D9,7$%#'E
,#8$&''5"(%$ "?,&#&(#8$("#5,$ $,#&,",& , @5"'8&(A#8$2$##$, 99,1"03"#$3 (($B5,$+?8$,$/-
#8$$1&'$32"-5#0"(3"#$3C '5/.&##$35(3$,35,$''/-#8$ $#&#&($,?"'"99,1$3"
#$,/$&(A%.9$00$3#(#(0-9"-#8$%8",A$' &00$A"00-3$."(3$31&3$ 33&#&("0 $."(3#&%$3"#$3 "(3 #?'$9","#$ $."(3#&%$'3"#$3 /5#"0'/$&(A%.9$00$3# '5/.&# #8$ $1&'$3 2"-5# 0"( 3"#$3 C ? >F (35'#,&"0 .9($(#&(#$,.' #8$#& &%"#&(3"#$3 E
, #8$ &''5"(%$ " ?,&# "(3".5' 3&,$%#&(A $'9(3$(# #"3753&%"#$59(#8$$9,$'$(#"#&(3"#$3*
(($B5,$+"33,$''$3 ##8$ $'9(3$(# #,$%"0%50"#$ "(3 ,$ 5(3#8$".5(#",/&#,",&0-3$."(3$3"(39"&3/-#8$$#&#&($,5(3$, 9,#$'#"' /$&(A&00$A"0<",/&#,",- "(3%(#,",- ##8$ (35'#,&"0 ",D' 0&%-< * "' "0' # "00? #8$ $#&#&($, # '5/.&# 2"-5# 0"(' &( "%%,3"(%$ ? #8$ .&(&.5. F (35'#,&"0 .9($(# ,"#& "'
9,$'%,&/$3/-#8$(35'#,&"0",D'0&%-< *?" 5,#8$,3&,$%#&(# #8$$'9(3$(##9,%$''#8$2"-5#0"('$B9$3&#&5'0-H ( # ) '
& *+ ,- -*-.!//$
# &
' ) )
& # & 0 # 1
#
& &/&3 # 2 ) &
3 !$ ## ) # ))
## # ## ( #
)
&# # ) #
) )) &) 4
# ) 5# # ) ## 6) & % #&) ) ) &# # %
###6 ) ## ) &# #
7# ## & 1) &
)
& ##1 )0 #& #
22 4; 2 *
8 6 0 907 8 # 907