High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/894/2025allowed

Soma Singh v. State Of Punjab

2025-08-25Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel8 pages

0%2 , !*

0%2 , !* '"',$

'"',$

!"#

B/%$ $

;%+,',

'!( B/%,9 !0%!$

* * * *

+%,%!$* +%,%!$* +%,%!$* +%,%!$* 7-

7- /

- - - -

+/ /=/ #

1> 0;

2$%

+/ 1( !0%+

!"#

+3 00 $

'!()/

?????

- - - -3 / 5-8 / 5-8 / 5-8 / 5-8

+%,%!$ $# +0

& 1%0

+ 2%0'+%3 .4

5& ,# +$ 6+/ //78

9% %$ $ )%+ !"

0$%0 ../ / +%" ,$%+%0

&&%!

2%, 9'! ,#)1%

583 @ A.@

+2 $ 2

+'", ,:2# $+ 9 2

'),$!2%, .

5& ,# +$ 6

2$783

1 2%

$$ #'13 ,$+ 2$ $# !0/

"+;

<'% %,$

% !"

9%+$ !

2$ 1; !"

./A <$1,/

99:

:#',> 11%"%01:

+%2 ;%+%0 &+

-%+!%0 '!,%1 %+ $%+$%0

, !2% ../ / -%+!%0 '!

!,%1

,') $$%0 $# #$

!0$ +:

; ,

2$ #;%

,2+'9'1 ',1:

91 %0 C $#3 $#',3 ,%2'$ ,'&&%+,

!#%+%!$ 0%&%2$,/ -%+!%0 '!,%1 $%+$%0

0%1:%0 1 ) 1 $:

&,$%!%0

-%+!%0 '!,%1 $%+$%0

,'&&%+%0

$#!

:%+,/ #',3 9+:%0

-%+!%0

'!,%1

+"' !"

11%"$ + ,%0 " !,$ ,%+ !$'+%

!03 $#',3 #% %, 0%,%+;% !2%,,

-%+!%0

'!,%1 ,') $$%0 !,$!$ 91% )++%0

$#',3

'"#$

0 , ,,%0/ -%+!%0

'!,%1 ,%%>,

912%

+%2 +0 2%+$ & 2$%

0$%0 / /

0:3 C# 2# $>%!

+%2 +0/

#;% #%+0 '!,%1 + ;1 9+$ %, #;% "

!% $#+ '"#

; 1)1% +%2 +0,

2,%/

C, ++%,$%0

../ /

C#%+% !&$%+

!;%,$ "$ C, 2++ %0

2#11!

C, 9+%,%!$%0

/ /

$#%+%&$%+3 ,'991% %!$+:

2#11!

C, 9+%,%!$%0

/ #+"%,

C%+% &+ %0

4/ 4/

,%2'$ C $!%,,%, #;% 2 $%03

#;% %D !%0 #;% " ;%!

$ 11 0$%/ + ;1

!$%!$ + ,%0 + " ;% + ,%

0%)$)1% ,,'%,3 C# 2#

2 !$%0 0'+ !"

'+,%

# , %, 0%%

99+ 9+ $%

0%1;% 0%%9

$#%,% + ;1 !$%!$ !,3 ,$"%3 1%,$

9+%('0 2% $# !"

$!" )1% )+ '"#$ +C+0

!0 2$% 1 >%1 #

),2 !0 !"

2%,,

(',$ 2%

!$%+&%+ !"

,%2'$ %; 0%!2%/

A/./

!0') $)1:3 $# +0 $$% 9$

,%2'+% 1,$ 91% 9+%&%++%0

C, 0 , ,,%0 C $#0+C!

./ / / >%%9 !"

; %C

$#!

:%+

,'),$!$ 1 "+%,, $+ 13 !21 !%0

'+)1:

!, 0%+

!,$!$ 91% & $)1% +%&%+%!2%3 +%"+03 2!

('0"

%!$

9,,%0

$ $1%0 & < =#!

& < =#!

;%+,',

+:!

;%+,',

+:!

;%+,',

+:!

;%+,',

+:!

$#%+E +%1%;!$ C#%+% +%0, '!0%+*

F. /

, %9 1 "'%

;% 0 ,2',, C !"

9+ !2 91%, %+"%*

%2 !0@,'22%,, ;%

!5,8

& 1%0

!$ !)1% 1C #%!2% ,'2#

'"#$

+%(%2$%0

1%1:

!$ !) 1 $:

'2#

,%2 !0@,'22%,, ;%

!5,8

!$ !)1%

C#%$#%+

%+1 %+

0 , ,,%0

C $#0+C!@0 , ,,%0 9+%,,%0@0 , ,,%0 !9+ ,%2'$

%+1 %+ C, 0 , ,,%0

%+ $,/

,%2 !0@,'22%,, ;% !5,8

,'22%%03 !%+@991 2!$ %,,%!$ 11:@9%+$ !%!$1:

+%<' +%0

,# ,'),$!$ 1 2#!"% 2 +2'

,$!2%, ,# C !"

%+% ,'9%+& 2 1

,$%!, )1% 2#!"% '10 ,'&& 2%/

%$9# + 2 %D9+%,,

,%%> !"

,%2 !0@,'22%,, ;% 91%5,8

'"#$ ),$+2$%0

1 $%+1 $%+$

!5,8

,'),$!$ 13 %&&%2$ ;% !,%<'%!$ 1 2#!"% 2 +2'

,$!2%,/

%D#',$ ;% "' 0%1 !%, 2!

,, )1:

1 0 C!

C#$ '10 !,$ $'$% ,'),$!$ 1 2#!"% 2 +2'

,$!2%, %;%+:

'! <'% &2$,@2 +2'

,$!2%/ > !"

,'2#

$$% 9$ $# !"

)'$ 9 !

%!0%;

'+/

,,'%

)%,$ 1%&$

('0 2 1 C ,0

0 ,2+%$

0%1 !"

,'2# ,%2 !0@,'22%,, ;% !5,8/

,%,

,%2 !0@,'22%,, ;%

!5,83 "%!$ 1'2 0 +%, 9%+$ !%!$1:

+%<' +%0

+%2 +0%0 "+!$ !"

,'2# 91% 0%,9 $% ,'2#

91% )% !"

,%2 !0@,'22%,, ;% !5,8/

+0,3 2',%

#; !"

,'22%,,&'11:

'!$%!!2%0@%!$%+$ !%0

,'2#

,%2 !0@,'22%,, ;% !5,8

'"#$

+%0 1:

21%+1:

0%2 9#%+)1% &+

, 0

+0%+ 9,,%0/I

A//

!0%%0 2+,$ !$ !"

11:

,001%0 , 2%+$ & 2$% 0$%0 / /

& 1%0

1%+!%0

'!,%13 1+%0:

,'&&%+%0

:%+,3

!$#, ..

0:,/

; %C

$$%+3

2$ ,$!0, 0 1'$%0 1 "#$

+$ 21% .

!,$ $'$

!0 /

# ,

('0"

%!$ $ $1%0 ='1C !0%+ ;%+,',

='1C !0%+ ;%+,',

'!() '!() '!() '!() 9,,%0 A 4 A 4 A 4 A 4 5 ** A 8E &$%+ +%1: !"

0%2 0%!0

('0"

%!$,

!7)1%

'9+%

',, !+ =#$

;,/

%2:/3

#+ 5. 8

.E )0'1

%# !$'1:

;, / :> 5.8

;%0 '1

)

# ># ;,/

#+,#$+ $#%+3 5 5+ !18 E

#0 ',1

J ',, !

;,/

%1# 8 +%9 +$%0

..E + 99%1 / @ 0$%0 4/ / $ $1%0 F# $$

,C, 1 ,

')#, ;,/

K%,$ %!"1IE F $ ,# 0# >+:

;,/

K%,$ %!"1I3

9%2 1 -%;%

99%1 5+1/8

0$%0 / / $ $1%0 F

! &

# >#

;,/

'(+$IE + 99%1 /..A

0$%0

/ / $ $1%0 91 =+ ,#!

$+ J 91+',

;,/ !

!0 3

!>'+ #'0#+:

;,/

0#:

+0%,#3 58

5+ !18 .4E #%103 $#',*

F4//

+ "#$

,9%%0:

%D9%0 $

!1:

; $1 ,&%"'+0

9+%;%!$ '!0'%

99+%,, ;% !E

$ "$%

!D %$:

!2%+!

9!: !"

22',$ C%11

2'+$ 1 !:

9 + %!$ ) 1 $:

0%&%!0 ,%1&3 )'$

;%++2# !"

2 %$1 !$%+%,$ 9; !"

,9%%0:

# , + "#$

+%9%$%01:

2$'$%0 +%2%!$ 9,$

0%2 0%!0

;%+%&%++%0

'9+% '+$7, ('0"

%!$, #;% 1 0 C!

,%+ %,

0%2 ,

9%! !"

!%C ; ,$,

&'!0 %!$1 + "#$,/

!2%9$

,9%%0:

$%0

+$ 21% .

%,,%!$ 1 9+$

&'!0 %!$1 + "#$

1 &% 1 )%+$:3 "'+!$%%0 9+%,%+;%0

!,$ $'$ !/

+ "#$

,9%%0:

)%" !, 2$'1 +%,$+ !$

++%,$

!,%<'%!$

C# 2# !$ !'%, ,$"%,3 %1:3 ,$"%

!;%,$ "$ !<' +:3 $+ 13 99%1 +%; ,

,, )1%

9+%('0 2%

+%,'1$ 0'%

,, )1% ;

0)1% 0%1:

, !2%

&&%!2% $ 11 2+ 2%%0 !",

!,'

& !1 $:3 '10 ;%+$%0/

,9%%0:

$+ 13 %+1:

#%+ !"

<' 2> 0 ,9 ,1 , !% <'

2+ ('+ ,9+'0%!2%/

;%+2+ C0%0 '+$0 2>%$,3 #%;:

;

+> +%,'1$!$

9+%,,'+%

,%2'$ 1 2%3 !0') $)1:

>%%9, %!$ +%

2+ ('+ ,9+'0%!$ 1

%2#! ,

,$+%,, ,$+ !/

%D2',% >%%9 !"

,C +0

21%, #!" !"

!0%& ! $%

%, ,%+;% !:

2+%0 $

2+ (',$ 2% ,:,$% +$#%+

>%,

,0 ,$$%

&& +,/

"'+!$%%

,9%%0:

!$%!0%0

;

99+%,, 9+%;%!$

0%1:

, !"

,%2'$

)1 "$

2%%0

+%, !)1% 0 ,9$2#/

"'+!$%% ,%+;%,

$#+%%& 9'+9 ,%/ +,$1:3 $%2$, " !,$

99+%,, ;% 9+%

9+ , %!$E ,%2 !01:3 +%1 %;%,

!D %$:

9')1 2 ,',9 2 0'%

'!+%, 2+ 2#+"%, 1,$1:3 $%2$,

" !,$ + ,> %; 0%!2% C 11 ,$

+ %,

9,,"%

%3 $#',3

9 + !"

) 1 $:

0%&%!0

,%1&/

%, ,: !"

!,%<'%!2%,

9+%$+ 1 0%$%!$

"+;%/ 22',%03 9+%,'

%0 !!

2%!$3 $ 11 ;%!

$#%+C ,%3

,')(%2$%0

9,:2# " 21 9#:, 21 0%9+ ;$

( 11 &%3 ','11:

!0 $ !,/ <'11:

+$!$3 )'+0%!

0%$%!$

,'2# &+%<'%!$1:

&11, #%; 1:

2%!$

)%+,

# ,

1:/

#%+% :%$ ,9%2$

$$%+ C# 2# 0%,%+;%,

!, 0%+$ ,$"%/ 11%"$ +%1$%

)% !"

+%1$ !"

%+2 1 <'!$ $:

!$+)!0

K# 1% !, 0%+ !"

1; !"

%+2 1 <'!$ $:3

>%%9

'+, %!'

%+$%0

C# 2#

!0$%,

'+$, 2!

!1:

&$%+ #%+ !"

9')1 2

,%2'$ &$%+ #; !"

,$ ,& %0 $,%1&

$C !

!0 $ C# 2#

+%, !)1% "+ '!0, )%1 %; !"

"' 1$:

&&%!2% 2#+"%0@11%"%0 $#$3 #% 1 >%1:

&&%!2%

C# 1%

,$+ !"%!$ '+,

',$

%$ 2'1 ',1:

,2+'$ ! L%0 " !,$ )2>0+

22',%07,

&'!0 %!$1 + "#$

,9%%0:

+ "#$

1 &% 9%+, 1 )%+$:

+%!0%+%0 !'"$ +:

'!C++!$%0 0%1:, ('0 2 1 2%,,3

9+$ 2'1+1:

C#%+% ,'2# 0%1:5,8 !% $#%+ $$+ )'$)1%

(',$ & %0 %!0

,%2'$ "%!$ +%, !,/ !

!0 ; 0'1

>%9$ )%# !0 )+, +0 !$%

$> !"

+%&'"% '+, 1 0 C!

1%" ,1$'+% $, C ,0

+0%+

%!,'+% ,9%%0:

%1:

0 ,9 ,1

2,%, ; 0%0 !,$ $'$

,9%2 1 '+$,

2$/

$'+!

%1, !7,

%:%

$+2$%0 0%1:, ,:,$% $ 2 !%&& 2 %!2:

&+',$+$%

1%" ,1$ ;% 9'+9 ,%/

1C 0'$:)

%!,'+% %,

)%2

91 2 $ ;

!0 ; 0'17, &'!0 %!$1 + "#$,3

$C $#,$!0 !"

!:$# !"

!$ !%0

,$$'$%/

K# 1% 0%1 !"

;%+!%0 '+,

',$ ,$+ >%

('0 2 )1!2% )%$C%%!

1%" ,1$ ;%

!$%!$

2'+)

%!2%

0+'", ,2+ ,!2$ + "#$

& + %D9%0 $

+ !"%0 (',$ & )1%

2',%3 + ,>, $+!,& !"

9+%$+ 1 0%$%!$

9'! $ ;%

9+ , %!$3

'$2

!$ $#%$ 21

9+ !2 91%

(',$ 2% %<' $:/

'!%<' ;

21 !&%+%!2% C#%+%

& 1%0

!21'0% C $# !

+%, !)1% %3 +%,'1$ !"

!"%0

1 $$%, " !,$ 9+%2 &'!0 %!$1 + "#$,

1 &%

1 )%+$:

"+!$%0 1C !03 ,'2#3 !0 $ 1 )%+$:

;%++ 0 !"

,$$'$ +:

)+"

2+%$%0

'"#$

!, 0%+%0 &2$,

" ;%!

2,%/

+0,3

9%+$ ! !"

%+2 1 <'!$ $:3

'!0'% 0%1:

$+ 13 , 0

&%$$%+%0

. /I

A//

'+$#%+3 , 0 2%+$ & 2$%

,$$%0

2,%3 C# 2#3 0'2$ C++!$

,,'%0 " !,$ &2$'

"+ ,'&& 2 %!$

$,%1&3

0%21 !% !2%,,

<'%,$ C#%!

<'%,$ 2 !$ !"

&2$,@2 +2'

,$!2%,

, 0 /

%1 !2% +%"+0 2!

912%0 ('0"

%!$

!7)1%

'9+% '1!

#0/ ,#0 ;/

'1!

#0/ ,#0 ;/

'1!

#0/ ,#0 ;/

'1!

#0/ ,#0 ;/

$#%+3 . 5.8 5+ !18

A $#%+3 . 5.8 5+ !18

; , %!2# ('0"

%!$

!7)1% 12'$$ "#

+ 0#+ , ;/

$$%3 . 58

+ 0#+ , ;/

$$%3 . 58

+ 0#+ , ;/

$$%3 . 58

+ 0#+ , ;/

$$%3 . 58

5+ !18 44 5+ !18 44 5+ !18 44 5+ !18 44 ('0"

%!$,

$ $1%0

># 1%,#

!"# ;/

+:!

># 1%,#

!"# ;/

+:!

># 1%,#

!"# ;/

+:!

># 1%,#

!"# ;/

+:!3 0%2 0%0

/../ .3 1+( ;/

1+( ;/

+:!3 . 5+ !18 ../

'&& 2%

,:3 0%$%!$

'!0%+$+ 1 C++!$%0 &2$, 2 +2'

,$!2%,

2,%/

; %C

;%3 C%0/ %$ $

+0%+%0

+%1%,%0

# , &'+! ,# !"

) 1@,'+%$:

!0,

,$ ,&2$

-0/ !2%+!%0 '+$@'$:

" ,$+$%/

00 $

!0 $

!2%+!%0

'+$@'$:

" ,$+$%3 C !"

!0 $ !,*

5 8

,',% 1 )%+$:

"+!$%0/

5 8

%; 0%!2%3

%!$+:3 0'+ !"

5 8

),%!$ ,%1&

0$% )%&

5 ;8

&&%!2% C# 1%

5;8

0%9 , $ # , 9,,9 +$3 !:3

'+$/

5; 8

" ;% # , 2%119# !% !'

)%+

!;%,$ "$ !"

&& 2%+@

!2%+!%0 1 2%

2#!"% # , 2%119# !% !'

)%+

'+$@ 11< " ,$+$%/

5; 8 !:

!!%+ $+:

0%1:

5; 8 ,') $3

& +,$ +> !"

%;%+:

!$#3 && 0; $3 )%& !2%+!%0

'+$3

%&&%2$ #%

&&%!2% &$%+ )% !"

+%1%,%0

&&%!2% &$%+ # , )% !"

%!1+"%0

), ,

# , && 0; $

$#%+C ,%3

!0$%0

;%3 +$#C $#3 2!2%11$

# ,

C# 2# 91%3 )'$

'+,%3 2 !$%0

%+ $, &/

)+%2#

+%, 0 !0 $ $# ,%

C# 2#

!2%+!%0 '+$@'$:

" ,$+$% 0 +%2$%0

#%+% !) ;%

,# C !"

,'&& 2 %!$

2',%3

$$%@2

91 !!$ 1 )%+$:

;% 2!2%11$

+0%+%0 +0 !"1:/

. /

$# !"

, 0 #%+% !) ;% !,$+'%0 %D9+%,,

9 !

%+ $,

2,%/

../

!2%

0%2 0%03 9%!0 !"

,2%11!%

991 2$ !:3 1,

,$!0, 0 ,9

&&/

-8

'"',$

#; +

K#%$#%+ ,9%> !"@+%, !%0*

%,@

K#%$#%+ +%9 +$)1%*

%,@