← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/65150/2024dismissed

Neeraj Kumar v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2025-01-15Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil9 pages

 

       

!"!

#$%%   

     

  $  &'(% ) () (( ' ****

 

 

 !" 



#$

%  %   )#*

+ ,*-!./ %01.2 &'(

)     "

 *+, 

 -  .  .     +/+0 &(   $ -

   .   "



   "$  $$

 12   

 " &! 3 $(      !   "

 

   

  1 

 -   "

  "$ 2!  ) " "



  $! 

12$ 

 &+(

$-

 $ " - $-   4

25  +/'' -

 6-% 

 "$ $   "

!  $  "

 

 $ "

  !  "    6  6 

  $-!  $! 6

"

7$  $   ! $ "

$     6  "

 " !  $$ $-   $ "$ !

" " "."-

+/'8 

6 $-  "  "

    "

 " $   " $

  

- 2 - "

  

"     $ 6

6" $$ 

6 "! " $

6""  ! 

6 $ 

"   

 $   $ "

"$     -  '/9 12 " !   "

   

 $    , 

      )  

   -   "

  "$   

 " $ "  



  " ! !  &0(

5" $

" 

 " "

 "!  "

 6 "  :    6   $  $"    "  

" $ $  "    $$-

!  $  " $-  "



  $    "$+'

;

  &8(

 

 

" $ 6

 12 $6   ;< 7'9'/97+/+0 6  $$ 6 

!!  +0 /9 +/+0&=  +(

!  6

 "  

   

! -

$



 " -   6

  +// "   $$ -  

 *'

''"$-  "



!"   3!   

   

       "  "! 

 

"

 +9"  &*(

1 

   $

"$2! ) "

6 - ." "





  $ !       12   

   

- 3 - 

"

 

12" $ "! "    $  !$  " ""$ $-

$ 

 

$$

12 "$    $ "  "$  " ! !     $    "$"6 6$$ ! " "

! &9(







$$

 12

 !$! $$   "

  " "

 6    $$-    "!$

 



 " $ "  "

 

 $$  $"

       " "

$     6   "  6 $ 



 "!$ "  

  " 

 

  6  

 4 

      ++ /, +/+8 &=  0(  $   >%  "$ $$

 12

   $$6   &?(

5" $

$" !-$" 

    

6   

 4

 ;   6 $ .    "" 

 "

 6 

"$  $  "  "

    -  " $ ""-    "

  "$ +*@ 12   6       $" "

$  " "

  "

 

"$  $$"     "$  

$ "

!  - $ " 

     "  4 

 !- "  "

   "    !  "

 A "

A  6   "

- 4 -

"

 7" $" "

7  $ ""- &,(

 "   &@(

B

. 

;  #$

%  %  ""  " 4

$

  



  

"

  



'// 12$ 

 4 

" -

   !  

  -  -   "   $    

 - ="

   - . $"   

   $ 6

  

 " 



 )  "

     "

 6

  !  "

     "

 " 

- "

  12 "

"

   6!"

  $$ !    "

 &'/(

4$" $

  &''(

$! 

 

"  6 $

   "

 +', ; ;  ""  6 $$-  "

  "

"  6   ""    "

  6

   $ !   6  "

 "



"

   $ ! $$- ) 



"

" "  $- "

&'+(

1 

 "

++/; ; 



  !

 ""

   $" $ $

- ""

 "

 

- 

!$ 6

 6 "

""



 

 "

   

   "

 6   ""



 

- 5 -

"

"

-

  2

  

-"

 6

   $!- "

"  7 "

&+("

++/ . "$

"

 6



"" $"

        -  $ ""   "

 7 

    "$   ""$

 "

 

 "  

 "  $" ""    -"

 6

   $ !- "

" )  

 $  

"" $ "

       -  - 

 "  $"   ""   

    "$   ""$

"



 -"" $"

       -."

++/; ; 7 



  

  

       

       



    



   

    

  !

  "        





  

 

!   

  

    !

 

  !

 

 #  !





 !



      

 

 

  

  





   

  !

     

  !

 $  

 ! 



 

     

  



  



    !   !



     

 

!

 %    

  

   !





    ! 

 !

 



   !



   

- 6 -





 !

! 

 

 

 !

   

 !  & '

        

  (

   ) * %&

+,- &'0(

) :  

" 6

"  "

6

$  !   " " $ ""- "

12$ -! 

 $  $- 

 "

    ! $ "

  $$  "

"

" $ "$   $12- 6 ! " $ 

6 C &'8(



   !"# $ % &'()  & *  6 " 6 

 ""  6

6

           6'@@/7@9- 

. $$  $

  6

6$     $"  )     ;   !

   6



 = -    $"   !  "

  $ " "

 -  ""       "D $""-E $ 7    !

         . 

 



 /





 

!

 

  !       

   



      ! ! 0

   !   



 



  





 1 

 

    !      

     2 &'*(

2  "$

 " "  "  

   4

;  + , -

   !.        '() 6  !$!  

 $ $ $"  12$

"" 

"

- 7 -

$! "

"" 7 ""  $   :    $$    !  !    $   $$$ " "

$$ -   $ 

 6 $   $12 "

&'9(

2   :   6

     6

   12   

 ""    "

  $ $$- $ 

4

 ;          4-  $

 F"        

    !

 

 



 

!

 

! 



 !

 



 -     



  !

   ! 

- )  $!  = "

 

   

 7 /&   

 !      

  !







 !

 

! 



   !

 

 

   





      



  !

  ! 

 &) 3 1  #

* 

*   ) !      !



   

   0 

    

 



   

!

  

     

     

  !



  . & 

 

                !

     ! 1  #

 *   ) ! *  !         

     4!    !  



 

    &*    !

 

  !

              

 



!    

 !  !5 % 

* ! 

 

- 8 - &(   !

                     ! 

 ! !

    ! 5  

 * ! 

 

!

      

   

      .       ! 



 &



  !

 

 



       



 !

  ! 

   !                   

 !  !5 

* ! 

 - &'?(

 " $$ 

  $  "

 12      "     "    ""-    "

 +'+&+( 

 ; ;

 )  = "   ""-

  $   !  " $$6   "

  

    "

 "

 !

 

 "$    $ -       6



  "$ "  "

  $

"" "

" &',(

G"

 "    "

    "      "

 $"

3 "



"$

"$ " !$! $!"

: " $" 

"



 "

 "   $

 

 

 ""  

   - 

 "$" ) $    6

 $"

 "

  6



6"   -"

 2 "   "  $$    "

  $     ! 3    " " $""- "

 -!  "

 ! $ "

 $$ "

"

"  $ "$   $12- 6 ! 

" $ 

6 

- 9 - &'@(

)    " !$!  "$ "      6

 $$  " "

 $ ! "

   -

     " -  )  "  

 12 $ 

"

  



 

 " $$

 $   $$

  " $ 

   "

 

-  

 "          "

 G"

  !- 6

 " $ 312 !  "

  "      "    )  -"$  

12 6 $ 

  "$  "

 6 $  "   

;  6 

12 "$  -

 ) 

 

! "

 $"

6  6





;  

 "" 

&+/(

! 

$

" $"

 $ $$-   

$"6

6

$ 6$ " $$-  $    "

 !   6

 !

    -  

  "

"

6 $ "$$- "  $

  

   3!   &+'(

2!6

!"  

!$  

 ;  "$ $$

12$ 

 $""

 of "

  of-  

 "          "

"

"  - "     &++(

>  '* /'

+/+* 66 0)#*

+ ,*-!.2

,*-

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No