← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/94/2025dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. Prem Devi And Another

2025-10-15Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Deepak Manchanda11 pages

    





    



!"

#$

"%&'&#(  ** 

  

+ *** + ,"-'.'



, 

 

*** + +

 )  / 0 * +

+ + +  / 0 * +

1    



    

      





   

+ + +

*

0

     

! " ""

#$% & '

  * + ,(%   - .  

. *   ) *)    

"

,

%*     %

  (   %( 

 *) /

 

*) 0 !

  " 3    5%6

     %( 

7  %  %(*  8 8

       %( 

  * %

 *

   

 $ )  %( 

% *

 ()



*  " 9  ()  %     7  % %(*  ()





  ) 

(% 

 8 %( 



 *  () 

   

  

   * *)    ,(%



 *  !:

)  ;

<   * % 

  7  %

  (  

%   %( 

    (%   (

*    % *  () =>?

; 6

 ()



" 9  )   ()  %     *     *  % %( 

( * !

7  %  % %(* % 5%



 )

 ,(%

 *)  )   

*   *% ,(%

   

  )  *  

  ,(%

  8

   

* 8) ( @ :

A      %  

  %   

(

  ,  5%

 *  

         ()  

*   %  % *

 () ,  %

 )  BC(

%* .%  





   

     

 @%*  

4% 18. We have alre"ady set out Rule 15(2)(g)(ii). We may w not 18 which "4 

           ! "    #$ % 



&'    #$  %  

   

                    

  # 

       (  

#     #& 

#& ) * #         



#         

   +    #& (   



 

         (      ,    #

 #  

   #& (     

      

(  

     

   ) %

     

   

# #& 

( ( #   - .  / %         

#$ % '#&       

#     #&  #& ) * #           

 #          

 0 1    

 0 1         

  

     # 

  

       2    

(  ,          

  

         # 

       (  #$ %    

 #  #  

           # 

          #      

       '#&         

1                   



      ,  #

 #  

   #&      





     '#& ) 

   

 

   #& #

  - .    %

3- (    

         #

4

"     

  # # ,   #   

   3- 0

 4

"    #

       %    04

"      #

 ,(   #         #  

        

  

 

#     0    #                   

# 0#  

4

 "       

        

     # 

 % 5

'#   % 5

#   #

0 # 

 #      

           #     

        #  % 5

0    

 ( (   

     #

#  #    

      ( (#  3-    # 4

"          #      

 /  (  %

( %  

 BC(

%* .%     *  (     (

 

%*  *



)  () 

*(   

* %       ()   *   () 

*(     * ( 

* /

  *) 0 !

 * ) $ *    

*%  =>?

; 6 B

*    " 3 122  % ( % *   



" 9

  )  % *   (

(% ( 

    )   

   BC(

%* .% 



 

  !"#$ 

)

*)  

* %* % ( 



*   % ( % *

)

* %



* (  

   

(% (  )



 % :

=* % .

% )  )  

13"



*)   %*  % ,    

 ;  ;"

;;

@%* 

 %

 #% '



%&

!)*2    

 #

 

6

   

0   

 # 

 

     

#   

     

 

       2 #   



  $ 

 #   7 8





 #  

  

      #       

, 

   

( #

  



# 7 8



   #

 



 #     

    2  (  &       

7 8

 

-           7  8

(    

 ! 2   #   -#



, 

 

 9:'"#    

/ ) 2    (4 ' %    7

8

                   (   

               

 #    #  

  

          

     

    4' %   

  

$ #     7 8

%   ; 6:      -   4

 %

(  ;6(   

         #   

   2#     







 <.   =   :  /        

   (

#   

                 )) %       >)    .         1  

 #    

    ##  (        #  



   #   

  ?       

      <-   / # 

#

- 2@ %, 2A   >       

 

 $  #   

 #  (

(

        0 (  



# #   

  #             /

% ( 

 @%* "   'B  #% '

* % :

1 %* %

*)   %  () *

(% (

   * )  %  % *)  * (  

%(   *  %    () 

(% ( 

   * )  )      * 

)



@%  ,(% <      () =>?

; 6 (  

(% (  )

 

 %( 

   ()  % %(    *    ()  ) %)    *

    E %  () 

*( %( 

< 

*    ()  % %( 

,(% )  

 8  

  BC(

%* .%

  (  %(%

 

"

+%    

 

 * ( ( 8

 *% ()   

 * (   *    

% %



*  ( * *) 

;

     BF(

%* .% 

 & ''( &) *!! ! ++&(  

, - . +&"( $+ /- 

0(+ +(1   +( (2(  !

!3 !   * G *)   ( 

 

*

% %

  *)    % 

    )   +%

  

 ) 

  )  *    

    8   ,       ;

!

 @%*



%&

!) 3   

 '     .(   

     #

     

    '    

C  (          #

   

 D' .    #  $ 

(3- 

  '.   1  

           E* 

 

  (   3 - 

# 



#      

            

  

#  # 

F

(** %   (    3  -     #     ?  $   

  

 ,       

    (  3  (   (     0 $ 

 

   

  #  ?   E* 0  $ 

# 3-   

    # 

F

(**G



 ( $ 

 # 3-  1 #   

,

 > 2  #    # (  % '

 4 0 $  

 # 3- ,    

  





#                 

   F

(** # 1  2



D    

#     

   E* +







#



  

  % 4 

%

   ,2

  ( 

#

 /

!



%*  

:

B

(

) ) (  % *%  

! " ""

#$% & '

 (        *  %

)   .% 

%*   

 

) *



 #' 

)   

+ + +   

1    **  

'  A  8G  

H

A  (