Jaspal Singh @ Bagga And Others v. State Of Punjab








   

     

     

     

               







   















  !"#$!%&'&"()  !"#$!%&'&"()  !"#$!%&'&"()  !"#$!%&'&"()*
*

 *
*

 *
*

 *
*

 '+,-&(./0..($" /!1' ***! & &"(!1 '

2!1'3' -  !"#3(45 ***!'+"($!( '

) 67 *-

) 67 *-

) 67 *-

) 67 *-

 - -   - -   - -   - -  1!'!( ) 1*(8",!!9(-&(./ &,,:$9"% !: #"1 /!+! & &"(!1'* '*(4" ;31:** *:3(45*  - - :*  - - :*  - - :*  - - :* ! & &"( 3($!1 -!% &"( <
 "# /! /1 &= .1&> -31>'/ -(/& :

? #"1 '/"1 : @ /! **-*-*A  /' 5!!( #&,!$ #"1 .1(  "# +1!11!'  5&, " /! +! & &"(!1' &(  "*
 $ !$
**

:3($!1-!% &"('???:? : ?

"# /!/1 &= ==-(/& :

? #"1'/"1 :@ /!-A :1!.&' !1!$ ",&%!-  &"( 4-('&:&' 1&% 81& '131,*

7!1(!$ "3('!, %"( !($' /  +! & &"(!1' B!1! .1( !$ &( !1&85&,5= /! ""1$&( !!(%/:9&$!"1$!1$ !$?*
*

($ &(+31'3(%! /!1!"#: /!=/9!,1!$=4"&(!$ /!&(9!' &. &"(C/!(%!: /!&1%3' "$&,&( !11". &"(&'(" 1!D3&1!$* -1-

?

?

?

?

/!5"9!#% 3,+"'& &"(&'(" $&'+3 !$5=,!1(!$-  !

"3('!,:"(&(' 13% &"('#1"8-9&($!1+,-&(./:($'358& ' /  '"( "$=:%3' "$&,&( !11". &"("# /!+! & &"(!1'&'(" 1!D3&1!$*







 !1$ ,!1(!$ "3('!, #"1 /! +1 &!' ($ +!13'!$ /! ++!15"">*







   1('+&1!' / +! & &"(!1'B!1!.1( !$&( !1&85&,5= /! ""1$&( !!(%/:9&$!"1$!1$ !$?*
*

($ /!"1$!11!$' '3($!1) E/! +1!'!(  +! & &"( &' #"1 .1(  "# ( &%&+ "1= 5&, " /! +! & &"(!1' &( %'!  "*
 $ !$
**

 3($!1 -!% &"(' ???: ? F ?

F "# /! -: 1!.&' !1!$   ",&%! -  &"( 4 -('&: &' 1&% 81& '131,* 7!1(!$%"3('!,#"1 /!+! & &"(!1''358& ' /  /!+1!'( &' 53($,!"#,&!'($&(#% (53'!"#+1"%!''"#,BB/&%/&'8$! "'! ,! /! +",& &%, '%"1!': #"1 /! 1!'"( /  /! 3(%,! "# /! +! & &"(!1 /$ %"( !' $!,!% &"('.&('  /!%"8+,&(( ($B"( /!'8!*/!1!# !1: +! & &"(!1"*
/$,"$.!$%"8+,&( "(
**

,!9!,,&(.,,!. &"(' .&('  /! /3'5($ ($ '"( "# /! %"8+,&((  "# 5!&(. 5! !( 3+ ($ /1! !(!$5=#&1!18* ( !1!' &(.,=: /!5"9!'&$%"8+,&(( &'?$='# !1 /!$ !"# &(%&$!( 1!%"1$!$&( /!($& /','"%"8!"(1!%"1$ /  /!8 !1 B'5!&(. 1&!$ "5!%"8+1"8&'!$53  /!'8!%"3,$(" 5!8 !1&,&G!$* 7!1(!$ -  ! %"3('!, /' 9!/!8!

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

%"($& &"( 5! &8+"'!$ 3+"( /! +! & &"(!1' B/&,! .1( &(. /!8 /! %"(%!''&"("#( &%&+ "1=5&,* !1$ /!,!1(!$%"3('!,#"1 /!+1 &!' ,!(. /*

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

   ) ** 5!#"1! /! (9!' &. &(. ##&%!1 ($ %""+!1 ! B& / /!(9!' &. &(..!(%=:!9!( /!

1!# !1* ( /! !9!(  "# 11!' : /! +! & &"(!1' 5! 1!,!'!$ "( &( !1&8 5&, '354!%  " #31(&'/&(. +!1'"(,F'31! = 5"($' " /! ' &'#% &"( "# /! 11!' &(.F(9!' &. &(. ##&%!1 ($ /! +! & &"(!1' '/,, 5&$! 5= /! %"($& &"(''!(9&'.!$3($!1-!% &"(<
"# /!--:

?*  &'8$!%,!1 / :&(%'!: /!+! & &"(!1'1!#"3($&(9",9!$&( (= '3%/ % &9& = "(%! .&(: /! +1!'(  %"(%!''&"( '" .1( !$ '/,, 3 "8 &%,,=' ($9% !$* $4"31(!







  &'$3,=%>("B,!$.!$5=,!1(!$-  ! "3('!, / &( +31'3(%!"# /!#"1!'&$"1$!1:+! & &"(!1'/9!4"&(!$&(9!' &. &"( ($ /!&1%3' "$&,&( !11". &"(&'(" 1!D3&1!$*

J

J

J

J (9&!B"# /!5"9!: /!1!&'("43' &#&% &"( "$!(= /! %"(%!''&"("#+1!11!' 5&, " /!+! & &"(!1'* "('!D3!( ,=:+1!'!(  +! & &"( &' ,,"B!$C &( !1&8 "1$!1 $ !$ ?*
*

 &' 8$! 5'",3 ! '354!%  " /!%"($& &"(''!(9&'.!$3($!1-!% &"(<
 --* -3-

<

<

<

<  &','"8$!%,!1 / +! & &"(!1''/,,#3,,=%""+!1 ! B& / /! (9!' &. &(. ##&%!1 ' ($ B/!( %,,!$ #"1 #31 /!1 &(9!' &. &"(*







 /!5"9!"5'!19 &"('5!(" %"(' 13!$'(!H+1!''&"( "#"+&(&"("(8!1& '"# /!%'!C1 /!1%"(#&(!$"(,= "$!%&$! /!5&, 8 !1*







    &','"%,1&#&!$ / &(%'!"#(=1!%311!(%!"( /!+1  "# +! & &"(!1': -  ! B"3,$ 5!   ,&5!1 = " 8"9! ( ++1"+1& ! ++,&% &"(#"11!%,,&(."# /&'"1$!1* !($&(. ++,&% &"( '

: &# (=: '/,, ,'" ' ($ $&'+"'!$ "##* *
*
*
*
*

*

*

*

 

 - - 

 - - 

 - - 

 - -   3,'! /&  







K/! /!1'+!>&(.F1!'"(!$) !' " K/! /!1!+"1 5,!) !'

"

-4-