Pratyek v. State Of Haryana
5
?/ &-&
"
?/ &( "# " !# $%& !# $%& !# $%& !# $%& !() !() !() !() '
'
'
' "'
"'
"'
"' &% "' &% "' &% "' &% "' 2.
1
2.
1
2.
1
2.
165 65 65 65 #%"*' #%"*' #%"*' #%"*' 2.
2.
2.
2.
165 5 5
7+/
7+/
7+/
7+/
+ + + + / ,%%)6#0 $ ! / /-2
%"*,6 "/ 88888 88888 88888 88888 + + + +6/9+:
6/9+:
6/9+:
6/9+: " ( %% " ,& .
" !%)
# -"# $% " @1; ! ,
,% *% - &,",%65; 9! &, < 7:! *" !
! *-).%) , %"$& %"* * / @# #/5/56 6 *%& #!
, &(-"%&,.) -"# $% "& 9$: !, $ %$ $ -*& "# & $, (%$ -.&"$ & $6 = =1 9! &, < $7:6 )%$ % "
" )%6%&%$, "# *,/ /
*02 " ! %" >- % " %& , , %& "
$$-& # ! .
.
%"* %"0 )0 # %" " ( %"%"* $ %"0 )0%"* * )) * # $ 0 !11*2& !
%"! 2$ $$-& #6"2 6"
A A 3, #4"
"#, &%#$ $$-& #" 2%" # #, %",%&$&
;/ + "
#$ -"& )! , ,&% #,, %&%"$-& # &%"$ ;5/5B/5/+ "
#$ -"& ),&!-, &-.2% #, 2"# ( 0%&% "& ! , $ ,0 " &$-(-) -&)
$ 2()% #C%,6"#,-&6, ( & $-% "$& &-!!
&! 2%", "# !
$&/ + "
#$ -"& ),&!-, % #,& ) .&%& & " $$-& # %& , #%&$) &- & " ! $ $$-& #6 "2 "
A 3 , #/+ "
#$ -"& ),&!-, % #,, ,&&-!!
%"$$ % "! 2 ,"5;2 ",&/ ,-&6 *-).%)%&(
#! / @/ + "
# $ -"& ) ,& (( & # , " ( %% " .
*-%"*,, )) *% "&%& #*%"&, & % -&%""- "#6,-&6, # &" # 0 &&% " !, *-).%)/ + "
# $ -"& )&
& ()$ " $ #, $-& # $ %!%$ B/ /56%", - # 6C,%$,%&
" " $ #/ /
,0 , #$ -"& )! , %0)(% &"#,0 * "
, -*, 0%).) $ #& !, /
C& # " ;5/5B/5 C, %"! 6 %"0 &%*% " C& $% # - "# , $,))" >- , ,& .
( " # " B/ 5/5/ ) ( & $-% " C%"
&& & ,0
" $% #6 .-" "
D2%"
#%))# / ,&.
"%2()%$ #& "$$-& #%", %">- &% "& ) ", .&%& !#%&$) &- !"
A3, #/&( ( & $-% "0 &% "6, %&" , 2 %) 0%).) $ ""
$, C%,, $ "."# D$ (! , &%# #%&$) &- "/ %&( %"
" " ,&-$,#%&$) &- "&6%" .& ! $ . %0 , )# )%2% "% 0)- "#
; $"" .
& ) .&%& ! %2()%$%"* , / )%"$ " ,%& -"&-.&"% # & " %& & & % -& # -.& . - , !%"
&& "# .A $%0% %"0 &%*% "/ %&" %"#%&(- ,, C&" ( ", &( / 0 $% "#C %*,* >-% # .
$, # , #%&$) &- "2# $ $$-& #C%)).
!-)) #, %2 ! %)/ %0) $ " "% "& %& # *%0 %& # ..) %&&- &6 C,%$,&,)).
% $%" #-( "#-%"*, $ -& !%)/ ,%& -# & " #
2 % (( (% # )0 #
( %" , %0) $ " "% "&6 ,%& &* 6 ) & % 2 A-#%$ %)/ ,%"* "*%.) ,& .
" . -*, ! C# %"#%$ )%
)%, # ! , .&$ "#%"* ! 2 , ( $ && !A-&%$ %" !
%"*C%,, ( & $-% " / / ,%& A-"$- 6 % C -)# .
(( &% !
A-#*2 (&& ,%& -%" "&,-)#"0 &-& !-"A.
"&,-)#"0 &-& !-"A.
"&,-)#"0 &-& !-"A.
"&,-)#"0 &-& !-"A.6(&& #%" 5=@ 5=@ 5=@ 5=@5@ 5@ 5@ 5@ 95'
'55@ =1:6 C, %"6 ! %"* -( " % # "#% !, A-#*2 "& !, "7.) -( -%" !" %"*, 0 &-& ! 2%) #-6 55 -( - =4 2/
A2-"%&,6 .#-) 2%# ,"#2% 3 +# (- 0 &-& ! -A6 $ %$& " ) - -6 5@
=54 9 : "*)-- 0&/ ))-).%# ,2# %2- E "/76 5 9 : 9%2%"):B4"#F%A %"*,0&/ "6.
%"*( $%) + 0 (( )9)/: /9&: G5;6# # " B/5/5;6,&, )# ,-&' H/;
%& C )) &.)%&, # (%"$%() ! )C , $ "!
&&% " 2# $ $$-& #-"# $% "B !, $%&%", ") C (% $ /-$,& "9&:6.
2& )0 &6$"" ! 2 , & ) .&%& ! , $ "0%$% " ! " %"#%0%#-) "# 2-& . &$-%"%I # C%, -2 & $-% " %" $ "A-"$% " C%, , &-.&"%0
@
/ 6" $ 0
!!
$ #! 2, ( && &&% " ! 6C, ,&.
"&-.& >- ") %2()%$ #&"$$-& #& ) " , .&%& ! #%&$) &- & " ! , $ $$-& #/ 6 & *-).%)( %"& )%!
"#)%.
!%"#%0%#-)6 -& .)%* &%
.)"$ C
"&!
*-#%"*( & "))%.
"# "&-%"*,
!!
$%0 #2%"%&% " ! A-&%$ & )& %"0 &%*% "/ !%")
"% 0)- "##2%&&%.%)% #%&$) &- "2# $ $$-& # !)) C%,%" , # 2%" ! , %) - "# .
#A-#%$ ##-%"*, $ -& %)%"$$ #"$ C%, &.)%&, (%"$%() & !)C/ 6C,%) #A-#%$%"*() ! *-).%)6,%& - $"" 2%" .)%0% -& , $%$-2&"$ & -"# C,%$, , ( ,& .
" %*"
# %2()%$ #6 %"$)-#%"* , "- ! , )) *% "&6, )%"
%"*, , &C ))&, &( $%!%$ ) %.- # , %", $ 22%&&% " !, )) * !!
/(%2!$% D2%"% " !, !$ &%& && "%) "&- ,, ( $ && !)C%&" 2%&-& #6.-& # 2%&#% $ #/J // &( $-& # $ %!%$ #B/ /5!%) ) "
$ -"& )6, ,&) # &-!!
#%"$$ % "! ( % # ! 5; 2 ",& E B # &/ -, 6 & ( , &%# $-& # $ %!%$ ( %& & # .
%"0 )0 # %" , 9&:/ 6 ,%& !$-2 $"" .
* -"#&-!!%$% ".
%& )!6 # $)%"
&&% " ! *-) .%) , %", %">- &% "C, "$& %&2# -! *" ! *-) .%) >- , %" >- &% " .
% $%"%"* -( " , !$&G$%$-2&"$ & !, &%# / )%"$ %",%& *#$".
()$ -( ", A-#*2 " !, "7.) -( -%"-)" ,#/2% -)" ,#/2% -)" ,#/2% -)" ,#/2% & & & &,#% 0/ ! // "# " , 6 5 9 : 9%2%"): 1 ,#% 0/ ! // "# " , 6 5 9 : 9%2%"): 1 ,#% 0/ ! // "# " , 6 5 9 : 9%2%"): 1 ,#% 0/ ! // "# " , 6 5 9 : 9%2%"): 14 %0%&% " "$, A-#*2 " ! , "7.) )$- %*, - %" $& ! %#, & 0/ 6 ==1 9: 9%2%"): @BB %#, & 0/ 6 ==1 9: 9%2%"): @BB %#, & 0/ 6 ==1 9: 9%2%"): @BB %#, & 0/ 6 ==1 9: 9%2%"): @BB E A-#*2 "& ! ,%& - %" /;115 %) # & ,%) &, % ,%) &, % ,%) &, % ,%) &, %"*, 0/ ! "*, 0/ ! "*, 0/ ! "*, 0/ !
"
"
"
"6# # "=/ /5 6"#)A0/ "6 ==19;: )A0/ "6 ==19;: )A0/ "6 ==19;: )A0/ "6 ==19;: 9%2%"): = / 9%2%"): = / 9%2%"): = / 9%2%"): = / -!!%$ & 6 !-, # "% " ! , & " -"# %)%&" C" #%", !$&"#$%$-2&"$ & !,
B/
"0% C !. 0 6, ( "( %% "%&)) C #/ %& # # .
& # " *-).%) ",%&!-"%&,%"*.%)G&- . "#& &%&!$% " !, +#/$ "$ "
#%) -G- *%& / 6 %" ##%% " $ "#%% "& , 2 %2( & # .
$ "$ "
# %) -G- *%& 6, &,)) 2%". -"#.
! )) C%"* $ "#%% "&' 9%:
&,))" 2%&-& )%.
*" #/ 9%%:
&,))" 2( C%,"
6 ) # $-2 " 6#-%"*, %)/ 9%%%: &,))" .& ",%2& )! ""
! %)/ 9%0: &,)) " $ 22% "
!!
C,%) " .%)/ 90:
&,))# ( &%,%&(&&( 6%!"
6C%,, %) -/ 90%:
&,)) *%0 ,%& $ ))(, "
"-2.
,
"0 &%*%"* !!%$ G ! $ "$ "
# )%$ % " "#&,))" $,"* ,%&$ ))(, "
"-2.
C%, -(% ( 2%&&% " !, %) -G ))>*%& 90%%: &,)) " %" "
2""
# ) %)/ 90%%%: &,))&-.2%6 ", !%&C %"*#
2 ",6 " !!%#0%6 .
! $ "$ "
# %) -6 , !!
$ , , ,& " .
" %"0 )0 # %" $ 22%&&% " !"
! .
%"* & # ".%)/
" $& %& ! -"# .
%"0 )0 # %" "
!!
! ,%& .
%"* ")* # " .%) %" , 6 ", .&%& !,%&!!%#0% , C%& 6, %& 2"# # 2 0 6! ,C%,6! $"$ ))% " !,%&.%) C,%$, () 6 .- ! $ -& 6 &,)) .
% $%" # -( " %&, !/ 1/
"$& !. $, !"
! &%#$ "#%% "&"#, & C,%$,2 %2( & "
#%) -G- *%& &#% $ %". 0 -( " &, C%"* "
&-!!%$% $-& 6 G$ 2()%"" &,)) .
)%.
2 0 $"$ ))% " ! .%) ! , ( /
=/ # #$$ #%"*) 5/
,%"*&%#, %". 0 &,)).
$ "&- #&" D( &&% " ! (%"% " ", 2 %& !, %"$ 2%"$&
"# #6( "#%"*2%&$ ))"
-& (()%$% "6%!"
6&,)))& &"#&#%&( & # !!/ 9 + + + +:
2.
1
2.
1
2.
1
2.
165 5 2,0% K, &( %"*G & "
#' &G K, ( .) ' &G