High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/65572/2025allowed

Shubhanesh Kumar Alias Shubhnesh v. State Of Haryana

2025-11-27Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel6 pages

# $% &

# C9!'-'-( !% 2!%"

* ''! () %* C9!"/( +! '

'! () +!,-"

'! () /0( '! () /0( '! () /0( '! () /0( .

%!"! '.

%!"! '. "-( .

"-( .

(2!$ !%

(2!$ !% 5 6 5 6 5 6 5 6 (+- 1.

(2!$ !% (+- 1.

(2!$ !% 5 6 :3 9 :3 9 :3 9 :3 9 3 3 3 3 "9 1 +!!/ # %5 +2(,'! ) )(% '

! /!'-'-( !%9 %9 %$!!' - 1 5 %* ;;;;;

;;;;;

3 3 3 35 9 <3= 5 9 <3= 5 9 <3= 5 9 <3= %!"! ' /!'-'-( !! )-0!+

+!% !,'-( A7 () '

! %'-*

1%-4 4"

-'5 67 <)(% "

(%' >

:= )(% 1% ' () %!1 -0 '( ! /!'-'-( !% % - ,"!

!%- 1 (9

'!+ 69??96 5 %!1-"'!%!+ )(% '

())! ,!" /

+!% !,'-( " ? @ () '

%,('-, % 1" + "*, ('%(/-,

"' ,!" ,'5 ?

A <)(% "

(%'

' > ,':=5 ' (0-,! ''-( 8 5 -"'% %-,' 88%9 9 ! 1%2$! () '

! - B !"'-( -" '

! /!'-'-( !% -"

,, "!+ () !- 1 - 2(02!+ - /!%'- - 1 1 '( ,' - 2(02- 1 00!1!+ $( ' () ?5 5666D " +% %!,(2!%* () 419 66 1%$" () )!!$ + $( !* )%($ '

! /!'-'-( !%9 3!% !+ ,( "!0 )(% '

! /!'-'-( !% " -'!%'!+ '

! /!'-'-( !% -"

- , "'(+* "

"- ,! 69??96 9 3!% !+ ,(

"!0 !% "

$-''!+ '

$ +'(%* /% %(2-"-( " () '

(' ",% / 0( "0* !! ,($/0-!+

5 + '

"5 '

! /%("!, '-( ,"! "

))!%" )%($ - !%! ' +!)!,'"9 3!% !+ ,( "!0 " -'!%'!+ '

! '%-0 -" +!0*!+ + '

! 0- -0-'* '

!%!() , ('

)"'! !+ /( '

! /!'-'-( !%9 3!% !+ ,( "!0 !% -'!%'!+ '

/!'-'-( !% " "

))!%!+ - ,%,!%'-( )(% $(%! '

6? *!%9

"5 %!1 -0 -"

/%*!+ )(%9

3!% !+ ''! ,( "!0 " (//("!+ '

! /%!"! ' /!'-'-( * %1 - 1 ! 00!1'-( " %-"!+ 1- "' '

! /!'-'-( !% %! "!%-( " - '

%! +5 '

"5 ! /!'-'-( !% +(!" (' +!"!%2! '

! ,( ,!""-( () '

! %!1 -09 3!% !+ ''!

,( "!0 " ) !% "

$-''!+ '

! - "' '

-0 /0! -"

%%!+ ! %-1(%" () !,'-( 7 () '

,'5 + '

"5 '

! "$! ( ' '( ! +-"$-""!+9 3!% !+ ''! ,( "!0 "!!4" '( /0,! ( %!,(%+ , "'(+* ,!%'-)-,'! +'!+ 9??96 - ! ( %' '(+*5 E -" '4! ( %!,(%+9 9

!%+ ,( "!0 )(% '

! %-20 /%'-!" + 2! 1( ! '

! 2-0 0! %!,(%+" () '

9 ! /!'-'-( !% E" %%!"'!+ ( 69??96 !%!- )'!% - 2!"'-1'-( E" ,%%-!+ ( ' + , 00 E" /%!"! '!+ ( 67967969 ('0 6 /%("!, '-( E-' !""!"

!! ,-'!+5

' ( !

!! !F$- !+ '-00 +'!9

0*5 '

! ,( ,0 "-( () '

! '%-0 E-00 '4! 0( 1 '-$!9 ! %-20 ,( '! '-( " %-"!+ ' % 1-2! %-"! '( +! 0! -""

!"5 E %'-(,- '!+ /( + %- 1 '

! ,( %"! () '%-09 -" ( %' +(!" (' +!!$ -'

//%(/%-'! '( +!02! +!!/ - '( '

!"! %-20 ,( '! '-( "5 ' '

-" "'1!5 0!"' -' $* /%!8 +-,! '

! '%-09 - 1 ' 1- !!

%( ' )(%E%+ '( - +-,'! '

0-4!0- ((+ () '

! /!'-'-( !% ",( +- 1 )%($ '

! /%(,!"" () 8 "'-,! (% - '!%)!%- 1 ! /%("!, '-( !2-+! ,!9

9?9 /!% "0 () '

! G-$ - (%+!%" /""!+ ! '%-0 ( %'5 //! +!+ ! /!'-'-( 5 - +-,'!" '

! '%-0 -" - +!!+ /%(,%"'- '- 1 + )(00* !%!() , ('

! "++0!+ /( '

! /!'-'-( !%9 " /!% , "'(+* ,!%'-)-,'! +'!+ 9??96 )-0!+ * '

! 0!% !+ ''! ,( "!05 '

! /!'-'-( !% " 0%!+* ))!%!+ - ,%,!%'-( )(% /!%-(+ () 6? *!% + 67 +*" @ -" (' " (E '( - 2(02!+ - * ('

!% <"=9 -" 2-!E () '

! $''!%5 '

! %-1(% -$/("!+

+!% !,'-( 7 () '

,' "' +" +-0 '!+ - 0-1 ' () '

! %'-,0! ? () ! ( "'-'

'-( () +-9 99 -" ( %' - 8 +1$! ' '-'0!+ " # 0E- +!% 2!%"

" ''! () # 0E- +!% 2!%"

" ''! ()

/""!+ - 6

6 6

6 <6..66 =H )'!% %!0*- 1

/( '

! %'-( +!,-+! +- () '

! 8 +1$! '" () '

! ( :

0! /%!$! ( %' - ""- % # '(( 2"9 ($! !,*95 ''! () - % <?

A6= ? A?H !

$ '

0* 2" 99 *4 <?

= ? H 2!+ 0$

- -4

2"9 ''! () %"

'% + ('

!%5 6 <7= <%-$- 0=

H ( "0-$ & ""- 2"9 ''! < () !0 -= %!/(%'!+ " 67

7??H %-$- 0 //!0 (9 D66 +'!+ 696966 '-'0!+ " I -'' -"E" 0-"

" 2"9 ! ''! () J!"' ! 10KH I -'-"

+ -4%* & / 2"9 ''! () J!"' ! 10K5 /!,-0 3!2! '( //!0 <%09= (9766 +'!+ 96A96 '-'0!+ " I( $$+ 0$ -) -4 2"9 ! ''! () 8%'KH %-$- 0 //!0 (9?? () 6 +'!+ 696A96 '-'0!+ " (/0 #%-"

'% & (/0% "$ 2"9 -( () +-5 + 4 %

%* 2"9 ''! () + * %+!"

5 6 < = <%-$- 0= ?H !0+5 '

I9A9 ! %-1 ' '( "/!!+* + !F/!+-'-( " '%-0 -" (' ( 0* 2-'0 ")!1 %+ '( /%!2! '

! + (//%!""-2! - ,%,!%'-( H '( $-'-1'!

F-!'* + ,( ,!% ,,($/ *- 1 '

"'-( " E!00 " '( , %'-0 * -$/-%$! ' - '

-0-'* () ,, "!+ '( +!)! + -$"!0)5

!%! -"

(2!%%, - 1 "(,-!'0 - '!%!"' /2- 1 E* )(% "/!!+* '%-09 -" %-1

!! %!/!'!+0* ,'

'!+ - '

! %!,! ' /"' + '

! %'-( +!,-+! +- () '

(2!%!)!%%!+ '( /%!$! ( %':" 8 +1$! '"

2! 0-+ +(E "!%-!" () +!,-"-( " (/! - 1 / !E 2-"'" () ) +$! '0 %-1 '"9 ! ,( ,!/' () "/!!+* '%-0 -" $01$'!+ - '( '

! %'-,0! ? " !""! '-0 /%' () '

) +$! '0 %-1 ' '( 0-)! + 0- !%'*5 1 % '!!+ + /%!"!%2!+ +!% ( ( "'-'

'-( 9 ! %-1 ' '( "/!!+* '%-0 !1- " E-'

! ,'

0 %!"'%- '

-$/("!+ ' '

! '-$! () '

! %%!"' () '

! ,, "!+ + ,( "!B ! '

- ,%,!%'-( E ,( '- !" ' 00 "'1!"5 $!0*5 '

! "'1! () - 2!"'-1'-( 5 - B -%*5 '%-05 //!0 + %!2-"-( "( '

' * /(""- /%!8 +-,! '

' $* %!"

0' + ! '( -$/!%$-""- 0! + 2(-+ 0! +!0* "- ,!

! '-$! () '

! ,($$-""-( () '

! ())! ,! '-00 '

! ,%-$- 0 /%(,!!+- 1"

,( "

$$'! - '( )- 0-'*5 ,( 0+ ! 2!%'!+9 ! "/!!+* '%-05 !%0*

!%- 1 + B -,4 +-"/("0 %! "- ! B ( () ,%-$- 0 8 %-"/% +! ,!9 (2!%,%(E+!+ ( %'+(,4!'"5 '

!2* 2(0 $! () E(%4 + '

! %!"

0' '

/%!""

%! ( '

! /%("!, '-( + '

! (0-,!5 - +

0* 4!!/" '

! ! '-%!

,%-$- 0 8 %-"/% +! '-0 $!, -"$ +!% "'%!"" + "'%- 9 (E!2!%5 '

, ('

! !F, "! )(% 4!!/- 1 '

! "E(%+ () $(,0!"

1- 1 ( '

,, "!+ )(% - +!)- -'! /!%-(+ () '-$!9 ' +(!" (' "!%2! * ,%!+-' '( '

,%-$- 0 8 "'-,! "*"'!$5 %'

!% -' $4!" )(% "+ "''! () ))-%"9 % '!! () "/!!+* '%-0 -" - '! +!+ '( 2(-+ (//%!""-( + /%!2! ' +!0* * -$/("- 1 ( '

! ( %' + '

! /%("!, '-( ( 0-1'-( '( /%(,!!+ E-'

! '%-0 E-'

%!"( 0! +-"/', 9 ! 1 % '!! "!%2!"

%!!)(0+ / %/("!9 -%"'0*5 -' /%('!,'" '

"!+ 1- "' (//%!""-2! /%! '%-0 -$/%-"( $! 'H "!,( +0*5 -' %!0-!2!" ' ! ,, "!+ () '

! F-!'* + /

0-, "

"/-,-( + ! '( %!"(02!+ ,%-$- 0 , %1!" + 0"'0*5 -' /%('!,'"

1- "' '

! %-"4 '

' !2-+! ,! E-00 ! 0("' (% $!$(%-!" +-$$!+ * '

/""1! () '-$!5 '

"5 -$/-%- 1 '

-0-'* () '

! ,, "!+ '( +!)! +

-$"!0)9 ' 1(!" E-'

' "*- 1 '

! ,( "!B ! ,!" () /%!'%-0 +!'! '-( %! 1%2!9 ,, "!+5 /%!"

$!+ - (,! '5 '-00 /%(2! ('

!%E-"!5 %!

8!,'!+ '( /"*, (0(1-,0 + / *"-,0 +!/%-2'-( " () 8-00-)!5 00*

+!% ( !%( " ,( +-'-( "9 B 00* -$/(%' '5 '

%+! () +!'! '-( () , ,, "!+ )%!B ! '0* )00"

!2-0* ( '

! - (,! ' $!$ !%" () )$-0*9 !%! -" *!' ('

!% "/!,' () '

! $''!% E +!"!%2!"

,( "-+!%'-( ' '

-" "'1!9 ! 00!1'-( " - '

! /%!"! ' ,"! %!0'! '( ,, "!+ !- 1 - 2(02!+ - %!0'- 1 '( ,($$!%,-0 B '-'* () ,( '% +!% '

,'5 ?

A9 J -0! ,( "-+!%- 1 -0 /!'-'-( - ,"! - 2(02- 1 ,($$!%,-0 B '-'*5 '

! ( " '( 4!!/ - $- + '

%-1( %" !

$!%'!+ +!% !,'-( 7 () ,'5 ?

A E $ +'!"

' ( %'" , 1% '

-0 '( ,, "!+ ( 0* )'!% !%- 1 '

! /

0-, /%("!, '(% + )'!% 2- 1 "'-")-!+ -'"!0) () 'E- ,( +-'-( " E %!

%!"( 0! 1%( +" )(% !0-!2- 1 '

! ,, "!+ -" (' 1 -0'* () '

())! ,! , %1!+D00!1!+ + '

'5 ! -" (' 0-4!0* '( ,($$-' * ())! ,!

-0! ( -09 ! "'%- 1! ' %-1( %" () !,'-( 7 () '

,'5 ?

A "'

! $!'-, 0( "0* ",% '- -G!+ 1- "' '

,4+%(/ () ,, "!+:"

) +$! '0 %-1 ' '( "/!!+* '%-09 ! %-1 ' '( 0-)! + /!%"( 0 0- !%'* , ('

! %! +!%!+ 1'(%* * E%% '!+ +!0*" - '

! 8 +-,-0 /%(,!""5 /%'-, 0%0* E !%! "

, +!0*<"= -" !-'

!% ''%-

0! '( '

"!+ (% "'-)-!+ ' '

! ! + () '

! /%("!, '-( * ,(1! ' %!"( "9 - +-2-+ , ('

! 4!/'

- + %" )(% - (%+- '! /!%-(+ () '-$!

* '4- 1 %!) 1! - %-1( %" 0-+ +(E - !,'-( 7 () '

,'5 ?

A9 0!1-"0'

%! - -'" E-"+($5 - (%+!% '( ! "

%! "/!!+* + '-$!0* +-"/("0 () ! ,"!"

+!% '

! ,'5 " /%(2-+!+ )(% '

! ,( "'-'

'-( () "/!,-0 ( %'"

+!% !,'-( 7 () '

! ,'9 (E!2!%5 '

-" ( %' , (' '

!0"( :"

!*! '( '

! /%('%,'!+ +!0*" + "*"'!$'-, - !))-,-! ,* ' ' )% "'%'! '

0!1-"0'-2! / %/("!9 ( %' () 0E -" + '* + '( ! "

%! '

' -' +(!"

!,($! ,($/0-,-' - 2-(0'-( () - +-2-+ 0:" ) +$! '0 %-1 '"5 ('E-'

"' +- 1 *'

- 1 ,( '- !+ - "''

'!9 J -0! +!0- 1 E-'

-0 /!'-'-( - ,"! 1(2!% !+ ! %-1( %" () !,'-( 7 () '

,'5 ?

A5 '

! ( %' $ "' "'%-4! 8 +-,-( 0 ,!

!'E!! '

! 0!1-"0'-2!

- '! ' '( , ! $! ,! () +% 1" + '

! ",%(" ,' %-1 ' () '

"!+ '( )-% + !F/!+-'-( " '%-09 %(0( 1!+ - ,%,!%'-( 5 E-'

' 8 "'-)- , "!5 %-"4" '% ")(%$- 1 /%!'%-0 +!'! '-( - '( / -'-2! -$/%-"( $! '5 ',($! '-'

!'-,0 '( '

! /%- ,-/0! () 8 "'-,! + !B -'*9 %1(5 '

!B -2(,0 - )!%! ,! -" '

' E !%! '

! '%-0 )-0!+ '( ,( ,0 +! E-'

- %!"( 0! '-$!5 %!"

0'- 1 - /%(0( 1!+ - ,%,!%'-( 5 -' $-0-''!" 1- "' '

! /%!,-( +$! '0 %-1 '" () 0-)!

+ 0- !%'* 1% '!+ +!% '

! 0E +5 " "

, 5 ,( +-'-( 0 0- !%'* (2!%%-+- 1 '

! "''

'(%* !$ %1( ,%!'!+ +!% !,'-( 7 () '

,'5 ?

A ( ' '( ! ,( "-+!%!+ " /!% ),'" () 1-2! ,"!9 !% E(%+"5 1% ' () -0 - ,"! /!%'- - 1 '( ,($$!%,-0 B '-'*5 ( '

1%( + () ! +!0* - '%-05 , ('

! "-+ '( ! )!''!%!+ * !,'-( 7 () '

,'5 ?

A9K ))-,! '( "*5 ) !% +!'! '-( () '

! /!'-'-( !% "

+!%'%-0 -"

(' E%% '!+ - '

! ),'" + ,-%, $"' ,!" () '

2-!E () (2!5 '

! /%!"! ' /!'-'-( -" 00(E!+9 !'-'-( !% -" (%+!%!+ '( ! %!0!"!+ ( %!1 -0 ( -" ) % -"

- 1 -0D"

%!'* ( +" '( '

"'-"),'-( () '

! 3+9 ,( ,!% !+ '%-0 ( %'D '* 1-"'%'!9 (E!2!%5 - ++-'-( '( ,( +-'-( " '

' $* ! -$/("!+ ! ,( ,!% !+ '%-0 ( %'D '* 1-"'%'!5 '

! /!'-'-( !% "

00 %!$- ! )(00(E- 1 ,( +-'-( ".

<-= ! /!'-'-( !% "

00 (' $-" "! '

! 0- !%'* 1% '!+9 <--= ! /!'-'-( !% "

00 (' '$/!% E-'

* !2-+! ,!5 (%0 (% +(, $! '%*5 + %- 1 '

! '%-09 <---= ! /!'-'-( !% "

00 ('

"! '

-$"!0) ( * +'!

!)(%!

! '%-09 <-2= ! /!'-'-( !% "

00 (' ,($$-' * ())! ,! E -0! ( -09 <2= ! /!'-'-( !% "

00 +!/("-'

-" /""/(%'5 -) *5 E-'

'%-0 ( %'9 <2-= ! /!'-'-( !% "

00 1-2!

-" ,!00/ ( !

!% '( '

2!"'-1'- 1 ))-,!%D () ,( ,!% !+ (0-,! ''-( + 00 (' , 1!

-" ,!00/ ( !

!% E-'

' /%-(% /!%$-""-( () '

! '%-0 ( %'D 00B 1-"'%'!9 <2--= ! /!'-'-( !% "

00 (' - * $ !% '%* '( +!0* '

! '%-09 <2---= ! /!'-'-( !% "

00 "

$-'5 ( '

! )-%"' E(%4- 1 +* () !2!%* $( '

5 ))-+2-'5 !)(%! '

! ,( ,!% !+ '%-0 ( %'5 '( '

! !))!,' '

" ('

!! - 2(02!+ - ,($$-""-( () * ())! ,! )'!% !- 1 %!0!"!+ ( -09 ,"! '

/!'-'-( !% -" )( + '( ! - 2(02!+ - * ())! ,! )'!%

!- 1 ! 0%1!+ ( -0 - '

! /%!"! ' 5 ( '

"-" ()

-" ))-+2-' (% ('

!%E-"!5 '

! ''! -" $ +'!+ '( $(2!5 )(%'

5 )(% , ,!00'-( () -0 E /0!5

' () ,( %"!5 "

! %'-(,- '!+ /( $!%-'" '

!%!()9 A9

,"! () %!, () * () '

! )(%!"-+ ,( +-'-( " + '

("!

$* ! -$/("!+ * ,( ,!% !+ '%-0 ( %'D '* 1-"'%'! " +-%!,'!+

!%!- (2! (% /( "

(E- 1 * ('

!% "

))-,-! ' , "!5 '

! ''!D,($/0- '

! ' 0- !%'* '( $(2! , ,!00'-( () -0 () '

! /!'-'-( !%9

%+!%!+ ,,(%+- 10*9 ?69

- 1 "-+ !%!- (2! "

! ,( "'% !+ " !F/%!""-( () (/- -( ( '

! $!%-'" () '

??9 - ,! '

! $- ,"!

!! +!,-+!+5 /! +- 1 $-",!00 !( //0-,'-( 5 -) *5 "

00 0"( "' +" +-"/("!+ ())9 < 3 3 3 3=

(2!$ !% 5

(2!$ !% 5 6 2-% J !'

!% "/!4- 1D%!"( !+.

!"D J !'

!% %!/(%'

0!.

!"D