High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/66731/2025allowed

I v. I

2025-12-04Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel7 pages

!" #$ $% B6

*!%& !" & '(

!" & '(

!" *+!

) ) ) ) #

% ) #

% )

(!%)

(!%) # 0< # 0< # 0< # 0</ !&(%,) !&(%,) !&(%,) !&(%,) # 0</

3- 6

- - - - #6 =( (

%!(/ &7!' "!

#6 #6 .#8

/ #$ %6 >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> - - - -/ 6 1-4 / 6 1-4 / 6 1-4 / 6 1-4 #

% *

% "(+

& .%& ' (!% <@ !"

# ($ ,#( .#

% ( / 1"!#

!# 2 34 "!# ,#% !"

,.+# 5(+

# (% '

#(%, , !6 & & 60;6 ;/ ,(

& "!#

*.%(

5+ .%&

' (!% @ C ? !"

#'! ('

#., %& $'

! #!*(' .5 %'

' / ?

?@; 1"!#

!# 2 ' 34/ !+('

(!%

# &#/ ( #(' A.#.

,#78 % !"

, (!%

,(%

# (

% ''.

& !" 5 (%, (%7!+7 & (% % *

# (%(%, !

' (%7!+7(%, & # '!7 #$ !"

,6 0 ,#8 !" !*(.8 8 "#!8

# %& '! ''.

&/ %8 +$/ 9

7 : 9$6

6 - #% & '!.%

+ "!#

(% '.

!&$ (%'

60;6 ;6 - #% & '!.%

".#

.58( 8%& !#$ *#!7( (!%

7 %!

'#.*.+!.

+$ 5

'!8*+( & D( / %&

'. (!% '

.""

"#!8 (%

% & - #% & '!.%

#,.

% "+

+$ (8*+(' (% !

(% E.

(!%6 - #% & '!.%

'!% #5%& & !

% # '!7 & "#!8

# %& '!''.

& (

,6 0 ,#8 !*(.8/ D 8#,(%++$ 5!7

!+& +(8( !" %!% '!88 #'(+ E.% ( $ '("( & (%

%! ("(' (!% (

& .%&

' 6

/ # ,.+# 5(+ ( *#$ & "!#6 <6 - #% & '!.%

!**!

% * ( (!% 5$ #,.(%,

, (!% #(

& ,(%

# #

#(!.

(% % .#

%&/

# &!

%! &

'!%'

(!% !"

,.+# 5(+6 - #% & '!.%

".#

.58(

% 5(+ *+ (

5## & 5$

#(,!# ' (!% !"

' / %&

!., ! 5 &( 8(

&6 - #% & '!.%

! *+'

!% # '!#& '.

!&$ '

# ("(' & & 0<6 ;/ (%

!.# !&$/ D % !% '!#&6 ;6

#& '!.%

+ "!#

#(7+ *# (

7 ,!%

#!.,

7(+5+ '!#&

# D ##

& !% 60;6 ; D

(%"

(%7

(, (!% D '##( & !. %& '

++% D

& !% 066 ;6 ! + ; *#!

'. (!% D( %

% '( &/ 5. %!%

F8(% & (++ &

/ (%&.5( 5+

'!%'+.

(!% !"

#(+ D(++ +!%,6 %!

(% &( *.

'!% #5%& ++ &+$ # '!7 & "#!8

# %&

'!''.

& (

,6 0 ,#8 !*(.8/ D 8#,(%++$ 5!7

!+& +(8( !" %!%'!88 #'(+ E.% ( $6 +(%'

,#& '% 5

*+'

& .*!%

!#& *

& 5$ !.# (% 9& 7 (#( 7 9& 7 (#( 7 9& 7 (#( 7 9& 7 (#( 7 .%95/ .%95/ .%95/ .%95/ <<@?@ 0?/ & '(& & !% @60?6 0G

!" #$%/ !" #$%/ !" #$%/ !" #$%/ <?@ 0/ & '(& & !% 66 0G A# A# A# A#85(# 7

85(# 7

!" #$%/ !" #$%/ !" #$%/ !" #$%/ @ 0 0?/ & '(& & !% @60@6 0?) ,9( (%,

,9( (%,

: ,, (++ 7 !" .%95/ : ,, (++ 7 !" .%95/ : ,, (++ 7 !" .%95/ : ,, (++ 7 !" .%95/ < < 0?/ & '(& & !%

60 0 %& +9( A.# : +9( ! 7 !" .%95/ +9( A.# : +9( ! 7 !" .%95/ +9( A.# : +9( ! 7 !" .%95/ +9( A.# : +9( ! 7 !" .%95/ @<? 0/ & '(& & !% 0<606 0/ D

(% ''.

& D

%+#, & !% 5(+ (% '

& # '!7 #$ D

+(, +$ 8!#

E.% ( $

'#(5 & "!# '!88 #'(+ ' ,!#$ .%&

' 6

#(7+ % (!% #(

& # ,(7

! & 5 5+

/ D

++ 5

# (!'(% & .*!% &.#(%,

'!.#

!" #(+6

!.# &!

%! &

8 ( **#!*#( ! & +7

* (% !

#(7+ '!% % (!% /

, / +

8$ *# 9.&('

#(+6 (%, %,(5+

% 5#!., "!#D#& !

(%&('

+( +( !!& !"

# 5 '!%&(%, "#!8

*#!'

!# (% #"

#(%, D(

'. (!% 7(& 66

#(+ ( (%&

& *#!'# (% (%, %& "!++$

!" '%%! 5

&&+ & .*!%

#6 # '.

!&$ '

# ("(' & & 0<6 ; "(+ 5$

#% & '!.%

+# &$ .""

& (%'#'

# (!% "!# * #(!& !" 0 8!%

%& 0 &$ C ( %!

!D% ! 5 (%7!+7 & (% %$

# 1 7( D !"

#(,!# (8*!

& .%& ' (!%

&(+.

& (% +(,

# ('+

!% ( . (!% %&(6

!.# (% 9.&,8 % ( + & A.+D(%& # 7 A.+D(%& # 7 A.+D(%& # 7 A.+D(%& # 7 .%95 .%95 .%95 .%95 *

& (% <0< <0< <0< <0< <

< 1 ;))00 ?;4G "

# # +$(%, .*!%

# (! & '(& %&( !"

9.&,8

!%35+ .*# !.# (% .

(%# A !!% 7 6 !8

'$6/ !" ( # 1?@04 @G 5&.+

8% % .+$ 7 66 $ 1??

;G 7 & .+8 5(

( 6 !" #

# %& %!

<14 1#(8(%+4 <?<G !

& .

+(8 : .

(% 7 6 !" (4 # *!# &

G #(8(%+ ** + !6 <;H 0 & & 060 0 ( + & I ( ( D +( .5

!" J

%,+KG I ( (

& (#$ :

*% 7

!" J

%,+K/ * '(+ - 7 ! ** + 1#+64

!6;;0

60@6

( + & I!

88& +8% %("

(

!" .9# KG #(8(%+ ** + !6? !"

& 0;60@6

( + & !*+ A#(

% # : !*+#.

8 7 6 %(!% !"

%&(/ %& %.# .& #$ 7 6 !" & $ #&

<1<4 1#(8(%+4

+&/ ) I6@6

#(, !

&$ %& F* &( (!.

#(+ ( %! !%+$ 7( + "

,.#& ! *# % .%&.

%& !**#

(7 (%'#'

# (!%G ! 8( (,

%F( $ %& '!%'

#% ''!8*%$(%,

''.

(!% ++ ! '.# (+ %$ (8*(#8 % (%

5(+( $ !" % ''.

& ! & %& (8

+"/ 5.

!7 ##'

!'( + (%

*7(%, D$ "!#

&$ #(+6

#(,

% # &+$ ' . & (%

% *

# (! & '(& %&( !"

5!7 # ## & ! .*# !.# 3 9.&,8

7 +(& &!D%

'( (!% !* %(%, .* % D 7( !" ".%&8 % + #(,

'!%'

* !"

&$ #(+ ( 8+,8 & (% !

# ('+

% (+ *# !"

".%&8 % + #(, ! +("

%& +(5 # $/ ,.#%

& %& *#

#7 & .%& # !.# !% ( . (!%6

#(,

&$ #(+ 5 ,(% D(

' .+ #

#(% (8*!

''.

& %& '!%

(%'#'

# (!% D '!% (%.

++ ,

/ %8 +$/

, (%7

(, (!%/ (%E.(#$/ #(+/ ** + %& # 7( (!% %$ *!

(5+

9.&('

8$ #

.+ &.

! (8* #8(

(5+ %& 7!(&5+ +$ (%'

'!88(

(!% !"

(++

'#(8(%+ *#!'

&(%,

.88 (% ! "(%+( $/ '!.+& 5 7 &6

&$ #(+/ #+$

#(%, %& E.(' &( + #

E. %!% !" '#(8(%+ 9.#( *#.&

!7 #'#!D& & !.# &!'

7$ 7!+.8 !" D!# %&

.+ %

'. (!% %&

!+('

/ (%&.5( 5+$

% (#

'#(8(%+ 9.#( *#.& % (+ 8 %( 8 .%&

#(%6 !D

'%%! 5 F'.

"!#

*(%,

D!#& !" 8!'+

%,(%, !%

''.

& "!# % (%& "(%( #(!& !" (8 &!

#7 %$ '# &( !

'#(8(%+ 9.

8/ #

# ( 8

"!# & !" ""(#

,.#%

&$ #(+ ( %& & ! 7!(& !**#

(!% %& *# +$ 5$ (8*!

(%, !%

!.# %&

'. (!% % !5+(, (!% !

*#!'

& D(

#(+ D( # !%5+ &( * '

,.#%

"!+& *.#*!

6 (# +$/ ( *#!

''.

& ,(% !**#

(7 #(+ (8*#( !%8 % G

'!%&+$/ ( # +(

''.

& !"

%F( $ %& *.5+('

*('(!% &.

! .%#

!+7 & '#(8(%+ '

%& + +$/ ( *#!

,(%

7(& D(++ 5 +!

!# 8 8!#(

&(88 & 5$

, !" (8 / (8*(#(%,

5(+( $ !"

''.

& ! & %&

+"6 ,!

D( !.

$(%,

!" *# #(+ &

% (!% # ,#7 6 ''.

&/ *#

.8 & (%%!'

% / (++ *#!7 % !

#D(

/ #

.59 & ! * $'

!+!,('+ %& * $ ('+ & *#(7 (!% !" 9(++("

/ .

.++$ .%& # !% #!.

'!%&( (!% 6 E.++$ (8*!# % /

5.#& % !" &

% (!% !"

% ''.

& "# E.

% +$ "++

7(+$ !%

(%%!'

% 8

"8(+$6

$ %!

# ' !"

8 # D

(& # (!%

, (!%

% '

+ ''.

& 5 (%, (%7!+7 & (% % # + (%, ! '!88 #'(+ E.% ( $ !"

'!% #5%& .%&

' / ?@;6 J (+ (& #(%, 5(+ * (% '

(%7!+7(%, '!88 #'(+ E.% ( $/

!.# !

* (% 8(%&

#(,!.#

%.8 # & .%& ' (!% !"

' / ?@; D 8%&

!.# '% ,#% 5(+ ! % ''.

& !%+$ "

#(%,

*.5+('

'. !# %& "

7(%, ( "( & (

+" !" D(% '!%&( (!% #

!%5+ ,#!.%& "!# 5 +( 7(%,

''.

& ( %! ,.(+ $ !"

#, &H++ & %& /

%! +( +$ ! '!88( %$ !""

(+ !% 5(+6

#(%, % #(,!.# ' (!% !"

' / ?@;

('.+!.

+$ '#. (%(L & ,(%

5'&#!* !" ''.

".%&8 % + #(, !

&$ #(+6

#(, ! +("

%& * !%+ +(5 # $ '%%! 5 %& & %., !#$ 5$ .%D##% & & +$

9.&('(+ *#!'

*# ('.+#+$ D

+$1 4 (

# #(5. 5+

''.

& %!# 9.

("( &

%& !"

'. (!% 5$ '!, % # 6 % (%&(7(&.+ '%%! 5 * 5

(%& 5# "!# % (%!#&(% #(!& !" (8 5$ (%, "., (% #(,!.# +(& &!D% (% ' (!% !"

' / ?@;6

,( + .# (% ( D( &!8/ (% !#& # !

&$ %& (8 +$ &( + !"

.%&

' / *#!7(& & "!#

( . (!% !"

'(+ !.#

.%& ' (!% !"

' 6 !D !.# '%%! .#%

!%3

*#! #'

& & +$ $

8 (' (% ""('( %'$ "#.

,( + (7 *.#*!

6 !.# !" +D ( &. $5!.%& !

( &!

%! 5 '!8 '!8*+('( (% 7(!+ (!% !" % (%&(7(&.+3 ".%&8 % + #(,

%! D(

%&(%, %$ (%, '!% (% & (% .

6 J (+ +(%, D( 5(+ ( (!% (% '

,!7 #% & 5$

#(,!.# ' (!% !"

' / ?@;/

!.# 8.

#( 9.&('(!.

5+%'

,( + (7

% ! '.#5

!" &#.,

'#!

%' #(,

''.

! "(# %& F* &( (!.

#(+6 #!+!%, & (%'#'

# (!%/ D( !. 9.

("(5+

/ #( #% "!#8(%, *# #(+ &

% (!% (% ! *.%( (7 (8*#( !%8 % / % !. '!8 % (

('+ !

*#(%'(*+ !" 9.

E.( $6 #,!/

.% E.(7!'+ (%"

#(+

"(+ & ! '!%'+.& D( (% # !%5+ (8 / #

.+ (%, (% *#!+!%, (%'#'

# (!%/ ( 8(+(

,(%

'(!.

".%&8 % + #(,

!" +("

%& +(5 # $ ,#% & .%&

+D %&/

/ '!%&( (!%+ +(5 # $ !7 ##(&(%,

. !#$ 85#,! '# & .%& ' (!% !"

' / ?@; !., ! 5 (& & # "'

!" ,(7 % '

% !

D!#& / ,#% !" 5(+ (% '

# (%(%, ! '!88 #'(+ E.% ( $/ !%

,#!.%& !" .%&.

+$ (% #(+/ '%%! 5

(& ! 5

& 5$ ' (!%

' / ?@;6K .""('

$/ ".#

# &

% (!% !"

# .%& # #(+ ( %! D##% & (%

%& '(#'.8 %'

% 7( D !" 5!7

% * ( (!% ( ++!D &6 # (

!#& & ! 5

& !% # ,.+# 5(+ !% ".#%(

(%, 5(+H .# $ 5!%&

( "' (!% !"

-&6 '!%'

#% & #(+ !.# H. $ ,( # 6 !D (% &&( (!% ! '!%&( (!%

8$ 5 (8*!

& 5$

'!%'

#% & #(+ !.# H. $ ,( #

++ # 8(% 5!.%& 5$

"!++!D(%, '!%&( (!% ) 1(4

++ %! 8( .

+(5 # $ ,#% &6 1((4

++ %! 8* # D( %$ 7(& / !#+ !# &!'.8 % #$/ &.#(%,

#(+6 1(((4

++ %! 5

+" !% %$ & "!#

#(+6 1(74

++ %! '!88( %$ !""

(+ 5(+6

++ & *

*!# / (" %$/ D(

#(+ !.# 6 17(4

++ ,(7

++* %.85 # !

(, (%, ""('

#H !" '!%'

#% & !+('

(!%

++ %! '

++* %.85 # D( !. *#(!# #8(

(!% !"

#(+ !.# H ++E ,( # 17((4

++ %! (% %$ 8%% # #$ ! & +$

#(+6 17(((4

.58( / !%

"(# D!#(%, &$ !"

#$ 8!% / % ""(&7( / 5 "!#

'!%'

#% & #(+ !.# / !

%! 5

% (%7!+7 & (% '!88(

(!% !" %$ !""

# 5 (%, #

& !% 5(+6

% '

# ( "!.%& ! 5 (%7!+7 & (% %$ "

%+#, & !% 5(+ (%

/ !%

5 ""(&7( !# !

#D(

8%& & ! 8!7 / "!# D( / "!# '%'

++ (!% !"

5(+ *+ / 5. !" '!.#

++ 5 # (!'(% & .*!%

!"6 @6

% '

!" 5# '

!" %$ !"

"!#

(& '!%&( (!%

8$ 5 (8*!

& 5$ '!%'

#% & #(+ !.# H. $ ,( # &(#

(%5!7

!# .*!%

!D(%, %$

.""('( '.

H'!8*+(%%

++ 5 +(5 # $ ! 8!7 '%'

++ (!% !" 5(+ !"

#6 ?6 #& & ''!#&(%,+$6 06

(%5!7

++ 5 #.

& F*#

(!% !"

!*(%(!% !%

6 (%'

8(% '

% & '(& &/ * %&(%, 8( ++% !.

**+(' (!%/ (" %$/

++ + &(

& !""6 1 - - - -4 # 0< # 0< # 0< # 0</ 8 7(# J

(%,H# &)

# # *!# 5+ )