High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/3437/2025dismissed

State Of Haryana And Another v. Surya Sangwan

2026-04-28Justice (To Be Nominated),Mr. Justice Rohit Kapoor11 pages

!"#"$%!$&''( )

''''**!++, - .-'

)

)/ ''''

!-*",%!, 0 1

' ))/2

) 3

' ) 2

Mr. Nitin Kaushal, Addl. Advocate General, Haryana, and

" #$ %!

( !

)

5' $+

+ !

/0 /1/3

# 4 # % 56780/5/1/9 : : 5 : .! !

4 % !";

& 1< /1/6"= 50& /

+ ! :!

;

" > %& !'

/1/7"?/1/7'

@?'

@& =!

:! !610% (

# #!

! !

" > %& ! +

! '

#.!

! :

#" ?;

# +:

4 % !";

/1/7'

/3 /1/6 ! : !:

61 /1/6 + !

! 68

# (

; !!

/1//: 23A

! : #

: :

# 5

# 5 ! :# %

!/17</1//"=!:

/170& ' !(

/1//

+ 61 /1/6 # ! :

/1//: !:

! !

# : # 68

) #

= ( B '

# (

!5 :

/31

7884 % !";

&: ! :

# ):

# !

: # !

( :

.! 1< /1/6"= 50&#

: '

9"!&"

& /1/7 '

# (

( (( ## !6/% (

% (

( # :

) '

: :

!! !

# !

) :

+ :

/3 /1/9:

! % ( !) 5 % 56780/5/1/9 +: ! :

# ) + :

#4 ## !

! !

9"!&"

& B

& "

&:B

: ! '

: !

# ! '

< :

# ! ; !

!8 5 :

+ ! = ! ! 5

22.

Consequently, the instant writ petition is allowed and the impugned communication dated 08.11.2023 (Annexure P-9) is set aside. The respondent(s) are directed to re-consider the claim of the petitioner and to ascertain her eligibility in terms of Rule 4(c)(i) read with Rule 8(1) and 8(2) of the Rules of 2021, as interpreted above. Let the needful be done within a period of two months on the receipt of a certified copy of this order.

23.

In case, the verification of the Sports Gradation Certificate for determining the eligibility was a pre-requisite to allow a candidate to participate in a selection/appointment process and the petitioner was not allowed to participate in the same, the petitioner shall be subjected to the same and her merit would then be determined. If on the merit so assigned, her position is above the last person already selected, an appointment letter shall be issued to the petitioner. She would be entitled to seniority and all other consequential benefits notionally with effect from the date when other persons were appointed and actually with effect from the date of actual appointment or 04 months of receipt of this order, whichever is earlier."

- !

!! #

# 4 # ! # !

# '

/1/7 # ! ! '

9"!&"

<"7& "/& : B

(

9"!&"

& !: :!

& "

& #! :

! B

% : '

< # # : !: ! ; !#

! !

# :

=! % ! *

( !

# # 68

: ?

@ /1// > #

) %

! =

! !

2 ((

! ! !# # #!

= : !# ! ! 68

(

# !

! # C : ! # #

( ! :

:#! + !

! !(

; !!

"(;& ! ((

.! !

#4 # ( # #

5 = # B

- ! #

#!!

! !

5 !

! # #

! = ! /1/7 '

: ! ! 5

!" "# $ !!% & !" # '(

)""

+ , -%.

$ "

"% , /& !""""0 1"% 2, "")% $& #

% )#&.

!"% # ' , /& # ( #"

!"% # 2 3(4 & 2 )$

' 5%60

( )4.

!"% -% & "!"

)4 "

4% '

#%)- % '

#%)--

8 9# 4 , !" "# $

"%% , !!4 !"

" , %(%) ( "

! !(" '

#%)- %

" , 4 ( "

! !(" '

#%)-- , #" )"

")$: ,),4 , #

, 0$&* (%% # #

<% 2)!=2#4!"#!

$ <% 2)!=2#4!"#!

# ;"

" 2#4!"#!

% <% 5("& 34"

&4! "

, >,&4! "= ;"

%, <% 2)!=2#4!"#!= ;"

<% 2)!=2#4!"#!"

"!"

& )%% #

&4!

34"

"# $

"%%

! 2 @$%%

" , 4 (

!" "# $

"%% , !!4 !" "

! '

#%)--

!(%% # # #"

! !% ""

# ,,& ! , # 4 #"

!&% $& # 4 # )4

???

A" 1) 8B

Sr. No.

Tournament Organizing Medal Winner Gold Silver Bronze Participation Authority 1.

Olympic Games IOC Group A Group A Group B Group C Paralympics IPC Group B Group B Group B -- 2.

Asian Games OCA Group B Group B Group C Group C Asian Para Games APC Group C Group C Group C --- 3.

4- year World Cup/ Championship (Sports events included in the Olympic Games only) International Federation of concerned game recognized by IOC Group B Group B Group C Group C 4.

World Championship (Less than 4 years) (Sports events included in the Olympic Games only) International Federation of concerned game recognized by IOC International Federation of concerned game recognized by IOC International Federation of concerned game recognized by IOC International Federation of concerned game recognized by IOC Nil 5.

Commonwealth Games CGF Group C Group C Group C Nil Commonwealth Para games CGF Group C Group C -- Nil 6.

World University Games (Sports events included in Olympic Games) IUSF -- -- -- Nil Asian Federation of concerned game affiliated to OCA or International Federation recognized by IOC 7.

4-years Asian Championship (Sports events included in Olympic Games only) Group C Group C Group C Nil 8.

Special Olympics (Sports events included in Olympic Games only) Only those which are recognized by IOC Group C Group C Group C Nil 9.

Deaflympics/4 years World Cup/Championship/Circle Kabaddi 4 years Asian Championship (Sports events included in Olympic Games only) ICSD Group C Group C Group C Nil

10. South Asian Games SAGF Group C --- --- Nil

11. 4-year Blind Cricket World Cup WBCC --- --- --- Nil

12. Ranji Trophy (Cricket) BCCI Group C Nil Nil Nil

13. 4 years World Cup/2 years Asian Championship (Circle Kabaddi) International Kabaddi Federation Group C Group C Nil Nil

14. National Games IOA Group C Group C Group C Nil

+ ! # .

: 5 !

/1/7'

+ # ! !

9"!&"

! ?(

( (( # B

& D "

# !

/1/7'

: !

! ! +

# : :: 5 !

! :

"4 !

&"& "!&

: : %

! '

9 B

+ : : ! ! .! '

: # # # ! !/1/7'

! '

# + # :

! # ! ( :

! :

! !

+! #

# # # ! ; !

< B

! .!

<"7& :

( ((:

) ! B

# ! ; !#

&"&

# : #! :

# !!

#?+

@: ! !

# ! ; ! ! =

& "&

! !'

: : # !

# ! ; ! + #.

# ! 38#

/0 !# ; !

+ ## : ! : ! ! !

: B

! ; ! : !

# !

! # :

#4 #: ?'

@ #

#= #

! 5

<"7& #

2 (( : .!

" # !# #

: ! :

"= 56&: ! : !

! :

## 68

# (

; !!

+ !

) # # !

76! !

C? ! @ B

!! E

! 68

# #

: ! !

((: !

F + B

2 (( !B ! '! !

#68

(

; !!

! : :

(; !

# #

! C B

> #:: ) ! # !!

: :

) :!

! !

! : ! ! :

)

% :

! # - %

! ! !! '

!:: .! #!

?, !

: ! : # .

/0 /1/3

#4 #

%6-76--!% !! #

!! #

)/2

) 2

&''( #

) #C GC

' GC