High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/68111/2025disposed of

Narender Singh Vaid v. Serious Fraud Investigation Office

2026-05-07Mr. Justice Surya Partap Singh16 pages

" #" ! $!% !

" "

() "

* * *

!"# $" %&&" ' & ("'()& *

+' !"# $" %" ,,,,,

* *

& %&&" ' #&" -./ "$ 01

&2 &+ ' +

& .4.56 & $7&3$ " 81 9

7$&(

$":'

&3"$"

;4<.4.< =4-.4.- & $7&3 $ " &%'3 " % 72( %#& (>'

3?&3

' "% &# .45@ ''3 & $7&3$ " 0& ( "'6"(2 "

!7% )& 3 " %"# &37&3#" '# & ("'" &$&( 72 0 &"' '

!&3 &"$$&#6? & "@

#"%( &

7$&( & %&&" &" #" $" "$$#' #&"<5;?.@

)& #&"<5A?@?

@ ?

. %"!&"" #&"..?A@

)& #&"..?<@"$ "% &# .45

)& #&"A.?@"$ "% &# ;-A . 1&$(2 &3 $ #3&3$"#"

7&3 '"2 7"

2 #"&' 7(& ' #&" . "$ "% & # .45 ( '# &!&3 &" &" $$ & "$ // "% &"$ "'% &!&3 &"! (

$$ &"$ #"% &) 3 #""(( 72 !%" (20&(>&

(6 0>& B'

36 0 !B'

%""6 01&

1 (6 0 +

(6 0 C &3( 6 0 ' &( &3( 6 &!&3 &"$' ! (

3"$#""("$

! %" ) '#

&#" & #"% & 7("3&3" "'%) %%"& ""! " &) &

$ #&

$&! #"% & 7("3&3 " "'% (2 0 D&& 6 0 "

(D&& 6 0 ( # E # D&& 6 0 & #D&& 6 0 ( D&& 6"7 & ("

" '"$-./#"$"%'7(&##"7 +F$& #& (&&'&"

"' &3 "'"$ 7 +("

)& %#"&#"% &"$ "'% # " (!(-;A;<#" &!&3 &" &)

("! (

&#""$ #"% &"$ "'%

% $ ( $& #& ( #" &&3)"3 &("$ 7" &$( %'#

($&3' ' "7 & # &$ #&(&&" 7 &"$)"3$ # %"C# 7$" 7 +F$& #& (&&'&" 5 #" $' ! (

" & $&( 72 #"3&G #) +72 & ("' 7&3 %#& ( "' &" (/%" &#('

&3 %&&" )'"

##" &3"%&&"!& "

A4/.4. %&&") '" " $ # & ( $" #"&&" "$ "$$# %'&

7( ' #&"<</"$"% &# #"3&G # & %&&") + 72 ( %#& ( >'

3 " 3"'

) &#"F""(("$ $" #"% 2 $" %"&7($"

#%&! ##"'&3F" &#("'"$$ # ("" ##"'"$&(

&3 $& #& ( $ (&$&# &" "$ $ # ( " #&" )&

&"'&& < & "# #"3&G #) + 72 %#& (>'

3 "&#" (( &#('

&3 %&&" )&' $" %&&" %%(& $" &#&% "27 &( 7'

#"#&" ) & !& "

54-.4.< $&!&)"$ ( )%"%"' "67( '%"'"$

"$0 ( ( &#" "$$"#> (

H" ( $$&#6 .4.< .-. %&&"$&( &"' #&"; "$01

&2 &+ ' +

& 6 & $7&3$ " 1 +&3%&&""$'& 7" 7' &""$ %&&") && 72!&'"$"

=4-.4.- # %%&&" -

7#" 72( #"'($" %&&"

& % # #&& ( %"# &3

! 7 &&& & %&&"" &$&( 72 ((3&3 #"&&""$"$$# %'&

7(' #&"<</"$"% &# .45 & %&&" %( #"'($" %&&"&&& ((2 %&&"

%%"

< & ("'$" &#&% "27 &( 7' :'"$ %&&") #(& ")&

) ( 72 & ("' !& "

54-.4.< % ( #"'( $" %&&" $ %&&" %%"

# &"'$" (&$7'$ &( = #"'($" %&&"

$' #"

'&3 #"'"$&!&3 &" 72 %&&") ! + &"#'"

2F $" &$'((2#"! %&#&%("$( ) ( ")72 "67( '%"'"$ "$0 D (6 ?'% @##" &3"( #"'($" %&&"&!&)"$ 7"! %&&"

%%"

# & ("'$"%&&""$'&

7" &#"%(& #)& #&";"$

"67( '%"'"$ "$0 D (6?'% @%(

#"'($" %&&" :'"$ %&&"

7 #(& & ("' !& &%'3 "

=4-.4.- %'(2" 3"'

%&&") "%& "' & "$$&(&3 &""$'& &3 7" / I &( &(&3 &%'3 " #"'($" %&&"

&!&)"$ $ #

!&3 &33#2 ! $"' & %%"%& " %&&" '&3 #"' "$ &!&3 &" &!&)"$( )( ")72 "67( '%"'"$ & "$0 D (6?'% @ ) ""## &"$" & ( "'"&&$"% 2&# ( %% #"$ %&&"& "' & "$$'& &37" &!&)"$ #&";"$1

$' 7 #" 72( #"'($" %&&"

&%'3 " %

72 & ("'&#" 2" # ( ")72 "67(

- '%"'"$ "$0 D (6?'% @

%&&"& %% &!"$ $ #

&# "$C#&""$7 &(7" "7 $'& %&&" 27 +&"#'"

2 ; I &(#( &&3

&) ")& & C'& &#&""$

& ("'" +$"% 2&# (%#"$ %&&"& "'

#"'($" %&&"

&%'3 " 7&3%! & '(3# &$#"$J " & 2C'& &#&"! & "'72!&'"$ #&"-./"$1 ' &

7'3 72(

#"'($" %&&"

72 ##%&3 %%&&" &%'3

" 7 & &#&"73&!" & ("'" ##% 7 &(7" "7

($"$%&&" )& "'&&&3$" &% 2&# ( %#& "' 4 3'

! 7 #""! 72 ( &" ("'($" %" F &" ("'($" %"

$ #%"C# %&&"7$" &"' 72!&'"$& %&&" "'

72 )&&3# &$ # #"# (&3" &$$%&#'

7%"

72 %&&" 7$" &"'##" &3"( &" ("'( #" '#"$ %&&" &&(&3&7($" 2 (&$F#"& !&) &" ("'($" %"

$' #"

&" & ("$ $ #'

( %#"$ &# & $&(&3"$#"%( & & #"% &"$ "'% :'

#"3&G #" & &( 3'7"$

&#('

&3 %&&" 72 ( %#& ( >'

3 ?&3 ' "% &# .45@ ''3

")! %( &" ("'( $" %" &$ #

"7 &#(" %&&"

&3 $" !2 73&&3) #"3&G #) +72 & ("'

7#" '#&3 &($&

%&+")( 3"$ $ #

7$&( & %&&" ("

" &#"3&G #

(

27 +72 "' %&&" &

"$ %% &37$" & ("'

% &#&% &3& %"# &3 & !"& &3 & %% #& "'

7 #( %"#( & "$$ . I& 3 " 7"! &" ("'($" %"

%"& "'

& (2 %&&"

%%"

# "'"$( %#& (>'

3$" &#&% "27 &( "# 7"! &" 7$&) & " & &

"$ %%"

# &3 &3 $"'

$"3 "$7 &( "' &37$" & ("' " "

&"' #&";"$1 " %J

) #"! 3'& (&%#&7 "67( '%"'"$ "$ 0 D (6?'% @%( &" ("'($" %" & %# &%'3 "

7% ) %&+")( 3 %&&" " %% 7$" & ("'"$'& 7 &(7" ##" &3"( &" ("'( $" %" ) &(&&&3 $"% 2&# ( %% #"$ %&&"" &3)"3

7#"& 72 & ("' $" &"#"%$"& '(3#" &$#& &%'3 " 5 I &( $ &3 &%'3 " &

7$' #"

72( &" ("'( $" %"

&$ #&" "

= $'& 7 &(7" ' #&";"$1 &#"%(& #)& ( ) %"%"' "67( '%"'"$ "$0 D (6 ?'% @ "&%" +"7%$" %&&"&

"$'& &%" (7" $"$'& &3%" (7" ) &#

7 & ("' % 2&# (%#"$ %&&"&# 2 ##" &3"( &" ("'( $" %" &$

& ("'

&& $"% 2&# (%#"$ %&&" "&

7 #"& I& 3 " 7"! &" ("'( $" %"

("%"& "'

! ( )%"%"' "67( '%"'"$ "$0 D (6?'% @") %#&7

)"'( 7":'&"$% 2&# (%#"$ "' ) "& )&((&3"$'& 7" ' #&";"$1 <

!&)"$ 3' &" ( "'($" %"

%%&&"

7 $&( )& "' 2(3 (7 &

&"#"%$"&$#& &%'3 " ##" &3"( &" ("'($" %" %%&&"& !"& "$& ! && ( - #"

7%' # $'((2 A 12 !&' "$ % %&&" " "$ % 2

72 %&&"&:'

&3"$"

;4<.4.<% 72( %#& ( >'

3 ?&3 ' "% & # .45@ ''3 & 7"! &" &12!&'"$ " &) "

%"#( & ' #&"/.7&' & %&&"I&

3 " " &&%&"&"

% (2$$")

72 %#& ("'"%"#'

/ %#"$ %&&"& "'""(2'" 7' ("7 &( 7( ) ) "$ )% (2&' 7' %&&" "

%% 7$" "' '# #&#' # && 72 (

"(2 #"'($)& %#& ("') "&'%"#(

&" # & & 72"7!

% 2?&% 2"@ %%&&"

3""& !+ ,+

-. = $ #" % 2&#"# %' ("$#" ")

& %# &&'!"(! "' ( )%"%"' 72

"67( '%"'"$ "$0 D (6?'% @ 7"! &" %&#&%(

!7( ")72 "67( '%"'"$

& # % &&3" &$&( 720&#" "$$"#6 $" "$$#' %!&""$"2D ' &3# &# %"!&&""$ #&"<"$D# &&( " %"!&&""$ #&" <</"$ "% &# .45 & 7(&

&&( %&#&%( 7&3 "$ #&"<"$D# 7(" #"%( & ' "% &# (" /

# "67( '%"'"$

7%( "#( (( "'7)& 3 "%"# '"7

& &# ) & &" '&3 #"'"$ :'&2F&!&3 &" %&#&%(

!7'

@ # &' #&"<<?@?7@"$ D& $&( &)&((73"! 72#&".44".4-"$ ;=5 ""$ %"!&&" &#"&)& 2 "$ %"!&&""$ DK 7@

$ ) " &(($&(&3"$ #"%( & ) &( +&3#"3&G #" &'

; #&"<<?@?7@ " ('( "' "'( &' '"" " ) !& # ) &"7 &( '"'7&' K #@ $ '"&&' ' #&".4<"$ " +&3#"3&G #"$ "$$#%'&

7(' #&"< "$ D" & &$ %% 7$" %#& ("'%''

" '"

(("7 &$ &&#'"

2 $" &&"# 2 $" &" %%(2$"7 &( ")! %#& ("'#

&# "$'& 7" &"$ #&"//"$ K

# ) %% %''

" '" 7$" %#& ("' " '$$&#&# '7&3 ") %#& ( "' # 3 J%&" $" %" (

%% # " 72 J#&&3 %") ' #&".4-"$ K @

$ "" %% $ '"&! "

"" %% " '7:'

%#& ("')&(( 7)(()& &&%")"&' ) &"$ #&"=4"$ && ((2 %#& ("' "'( &' 7 &( 7() $&&"%"&7("$$#!&# "$ 7 &( 7() #"'# 7 +" &' "7 &( 7() K $@ 7" $'& ##" &3 " #&" // & "(2 ' +&372 ) "&"&#'"

2" %% 7$" "'"

$&J ' " ##%&3 7" ' #&"//$" "" "'"

3 "$7 &(K 3@

# )

$'& 7" ' #&"//"$ &$ $ &(" %% "'7:'

%#& ("'

%")' #&"/;

)& #&"=4"$ "&' )

&#&3

((7 %"

'# 7$" %#& ("'K $'# ) &&' &)&((

() 27"%$" " %%(2$"# #(( &""$ ) 723&!&3 ' +&3" %#& ("'"

%% 7$" "'" ((

$&J 72& I &(# #((&3 ) "'# () 2 + ' +&3$" " %% 7$" "'" !2

'( %% #&%#&$&# ((2J% I

" + #'"

2"$ '&3 &!&3 &" ''

((2 %#& ("')&((J#& %")"$# #(( &""$ ) )& "'&&&3" +&3 &#'"

2%"!& ' +&3& $'& " %% 3'( (27$" "'I %#& ("' ()& &"$" # #(( &""$ ) %#& ("'&" (&3 )& &"$"7 &( # #&"<-?@)&((

! " &""'# &"K

@ I %% %''

" '" %#& ("'&%") " +7" ' #&"// "$ & 3&!# ")! &&"

"2& !2# " &#$'& &3"$7" ")! &$ ) "$

7 &' " ##"' "$ "

%% #"%"# &3' #&"/. F" #&" /5"$

!7&' & # "7("$$72 +&3 7" ' #&"//"$ )&((

!" %%(2$"# #(( &""$ ) K &@ $#"3&G #& +"$ "$$#%'&

7(' #&"<"$ D7 " &' #&" <<?@?7@ &"$$&# %")("J#& %")' #&";" %" ")

& #"%( &K

$ ) #'"

2"$ ) " %% $ !&#"$'"$"#" '#&3$' &!&3 &"& "$$# )&((

!"+#'"

2"$

72 %%(2&3" %#& ("'$ &3

%#& ( "' ' % " "

&"72#" &37&$ "I &( &3'#

&" "' 2%&#'"

2"(2&$&& &$&

#'"

(&"3 &"

3&:'& ! "'3 ) ! ' #&" ; ")! ) ) "#" '# $' &!&3 &"#"#&3 "$$# & 2 %"" ") #"%( & (

2 $&( ' #&"<<?@?7@ %"!& :'&"$ #&"; $'($&(( ;

$ $ #'

( &J"$ %# & (2G (&3 "$

%&#&%("$( ) & %&

%# &:'

(2 #"! %&#&%(%"%"' "67( '%"'"$ & "$0 D (6?'% @# &&"7!

%&#&%( 7(" %# :'&" &) &%'3 " % & ("'&' & 7("" .4 J #"$ &%'3 " % & ("' ?:'

%&&"@& ' &@ JJJ &&@ JJJ &&&@ JJJ &!@ JJJ !@ JJJ !&@ JJJ !&&@ JJJ !&&&@ JJJ &J@ JJJ

. J@ JJJ J&@ % &")"! "7

($"$ "A C'1 ( ". !

"..B &( "

".5% +

".<+& #

".A &"

(

"./ % + '% "5A C& B'

'% "5= '

& "5/

C "<4 CB'

'% "<A & B'

"-. 7 & + "2 (

"-5+' "2 ( "--!

"-; D (& B "( "A4

- !

*+!/0 1-+ "AA1

(' #&" // & & "$ "!&3

&"?@""

2 ""$ %" # %7$" "' & (

2 554 "!&&"?@ ' #&" // F; 1 " " !& 3$'& &3"$7" & 7#"$ #"#

%"?@ # (( $" &"

(& 7("7 && ##" &3(2 && !" )& D &""#'"$"

%"& "'

"5A C B'

(

27 #( %"#( & %"!& "

.<4.4.- '# "!&3"$ 2'# &"" 7

($"$ &""(2&#"#&! 7'"

& & 7( )(( &(($' ( &""#'"

%"& "'

%"#(

&"%"# &3

(

2 7&&& & "A C'1 (!& "

.<4.4.- & " " ) "$$ 2 '# %"# &3

"! $""

&" 7' &

"7" " #"%7$" "'D &""#'"

("%"& "'

&#&% "27 &( &"?@"$

". !

"..B &( "

".5% +

3 ".< +& #

"5A C& B'

"<A& B'

"-.7 & +

"2 ( "-5+' "2 ( "-;D (& "( "A4 &3

"AA

(

27 && '%" "L7( &3

"' &#&% "27 &( &""$ "./ % + '%

(

27 && )&

) 7$" "L7( '%"' $' %"& "'

&#&% "27 &( &""$ "A C' ( ".A &"

( "5= '

& "5/

C "<4 C B'

'% "--!

(

27 && & ("' JJJ JJJ JJJ

< . 7 %' ("$ " %

& ("' +& 7'

(2#(

) &((2&3'%" #""$ #&";"$1 &

7"7! & ("'

%"!&&""$( ) ""!& 3$'& &3"$7" &

7#"$#"# ' :'"$%&&"$"%&&" "$'& 7" & & 7#) "' & 7( .. I& 3 " 7"! &&(!

#&";"$1 %#&7

8I 2%"$") " %% #" "$$&# %& &3& 2"'&%") "&' '"") +

!3 +!

$%0 $ 3 '# "$$&# 2:'&'# %""J#' 7" "7 &( 7" $" & %% #&'# "' " 2" "'") &#

27 $ $"& (9 .5

$ 7 %"!&&"#"%& ' #&"; "$1 & +&"#"& &" & %&

7" ' #&" ;"$1 # 7$&( 72 %""(2) &%& "' ' && 72"7!

& ("'#"& "") &( $'&3" ##% 7 &(7" & 7#"$%&&" !&)"$ 7"! && 72"7!

) &( +&3$" %#"$ %&&"& "'"&((3 (&2 )

7#"& & ("'

$" &"#"%$"& '(3# &$#& &%'3

" .<

")! &$ ## "7&3"

'&3 #"'"$

3' &

J&2"$ %&&" 7 & "

%% #7$" & ("' &%& &(27 ")" %#

&#"!&# & %% &3 & "'

%% &"

&$7" " ##% 2&3 7 +&"#'"

2 %( "$ %&&"&"" ((2'$"' % &#'( (2 &!&)"$#""% #&#7&3

"% "' &&#(!(

")! !& "

J&2"$ %&&" ) ")! !&3 &33#2 '&3 #"'"$ &!&3 &" # 7

$"((")&3

%&&"

(( %% 7$" & ("' " J

$&J $" &3

(("! :'&& &" & &"$"# ((&3"$ ) $"%&&""$'& 7" ' #&" ;"$ 1 & (&3 "$ D (6>'

3 $$"

2 " )

"! ) &# & "' & ' 7( " $" :'"$%&&"$"%&&""$'& 7" &" ##% " 7" "$"' &" & ("'&

"$ +&3 %&&"&" #'"

(($&J J

72" )")+$"

%% #"$ %&&" )& "' +&3 &&"#'"

)& "'&'&3$ ) %&"

2 7 '&(&G 72 %&&" " !

&( (3 ( 2?@ !

&( 7(" & .-

!&) "$ "7!

&" &%'3 " ) 72 &"$&( %&&"' #&";"$1

7 && & ("' & 72 & ?:'

% %&&"@ & ("'& 72" "$"((") &#'"$ "67( '%"'"$ "$0 D (6?'% @ !&)

A "$ &#&"#" & $"3"&3% 3 % %%&&" 23.4 -.. 5 ##" &3(2 6* *

" "

I % +&3F "

* I %" 7( "