Tek Chand v. State Of Punjab And Another

 5









  

  

  

   
      
      
      
       
    
    
    
  

 



A9"*"*#(

>(+%+

'

%&

A9+,# "+







 )*+ )*+ )*+ )*+  ,-#

 ,-#

 ,-#

 ,-#

/
/
/
/

(+"/ (+"/ (+"/ (+"/ +*# +*# +*# +*#/ / / /

 % (7

 % (7

 % (7

 % (7

2

2

2

2        

*./

*./

*./

*./

 % (7  % (7  % (7  % (7

2        

 =0 9 !
 !  =0 9 !
 !  =0 9 !
 !  =0 9 !
 !  0  0  0  0

(9 !

%( > 

"*  >#)

,"*"*#(9

(9 *( &

* 2   %& '9

# (+,# "

#99

?????

?????

?????

?????

0 0 0 02 9 ;06 9 ;06 9 ;06 9 ;06

!  !  !  !  (+"

,"*"*#

$*- % @: 9
92

12 + 3% #( 

;B%(   ++

% *)*  .*+"(

- ++2 *+"(*)"

!

 

(2

('72

#$$ (2

(*+*.



#9

19 @9

2 !)"*#+ @  @


# 2

: ;$#( #("

< 

=62 (.*+"(

#-*)  *+"

"(*)"

!!

(2

8--

+%'+3%"

(*+*.

($(#49

9

0 )#%+- ,"*"

"*#(

)#" 

( (2 ('7

#$$ (2 #--7 *--.

-2

('*"( (72

%+%+ 7+



$%("

)#" 

'-#8

$#--#8 % ,(#)++

,(+)(*' 9
9 0 )#%+-

$%("

*"(

-+-7 *4,-*) *"#  9 0 )#%+-

(.%

--. *)* "

,("

*+ 7  

(.*+"(

$"(

- ( 7 (+ *99 7  9 $"(

(.*+"(  2 #'

*- "+ 8(

)# @9 19 9 ))#( *.

)#%+-2

:9 :9 2

#'

*- "+

8( ,(#,(-7

-4

7"

*+"

()"*$7*.

4 (+#("*.

,(#,( ,(#) %(

5 9
9 +(>*)

'(# '-#8 *()"-7

,(#)  9
9 %("

(4#(2

9 (-7 ($-)"+

"%"#(7 ,(*#

7+

B)%"*#

- ,+

&#%(

9 #8>(2 $(+

*"*4 "*.

8

)#"( >"*#

+""- -.

,#+*"*#

$(+

"#(7 %,#

&#%(4"9 0 )#%+-

4,

+*D

% 

(% (9 %("

(4#(2 *"

+(>

#"*)

(+"( * *>+"*.

"*.

.)7 +,*"

(.%- "( >-

>* )

++,#("

;B%(+ 2 1 :69

$%("

+%'4*""

$$#("+ 8( +(>

*4 (#%.

4'

++7 $#--#8*.

,(#) %( ,(+)(*' +(>*) %,# ,(+#+

(+* *.

'(# %+2

#$$ (

.(#++ >*#-

,(*)*,-+

"%( &%+"*)

-*'( > +*# # ("

,"*"*#(9  '

+*+

+ +%'4*++*#+2 )#%+-

,( 7

-* +" +*  '*.

*--.

%&%+"*$*

) -* +"

+* 9

9

!

#("

(,-7 $*-

$$* >*"

9 9   (&*"

!2 ,%"7 !%,(*" "

#-*)2 !%'

*>*+*#  *+"(*)"

!

 

$*- 2

()#( 9 *+*.

+%'4*++*#+  4

#("

(,-72

)#%+-

#,,#+ ,"*"*#9 ($%"*.

+"

%,

,"*"*#(2 "

(.%4"+ 8(

> 4(*"+2 )#" *.

#$$)

--.

+(*#%+

"%(

*>+"*.

)# %)"

*(

,(#,( (9 %("

(4#(2 *"

+%'4*"" )#%+-

+%44#+ 8( +(> %,#

(#%.

4#"

(2 '%"

&#* ,(#) *.+2

)#4,-- '-#8

*4 ,(+# >* 

#( (9

+"

+%(( (*.

'$#( )#4,""

#%("2

#+ $*- ,"*"*#

(-7 ($-)"+

)# %)"

$%--7

)#()*> 4 +%(+ % ("

'-#8 +)%(

,(+)9 #(#>(2 *"

'-#8 $#--#8 ,(#) %(

*  #8

9
92

-""(

+,*(*"

*+)(, )7

"+#>(

$#("

)#4*.

$(#4 ()#( + +9 ))#( *.-72 *+4*++

,"*"*#

,( 7 $#(9

9

#

(+

-$ (+,# "

#92 +,*" +(>*)9

@9

>

)#%+- (*> ("*+

($%--7

,(%+ ()#( +9

@

8-- +""-

,(+#

#$$ (F,(+# %-++ ,(#) %( ,(+)(*'

# 
(*4* (#) %(2

+"(*)"-7

4"*)%-#%+-7

"#9

"(*"

,(#>*+*#+
(99
9

"#(7

"%(2

#)#4,-* (#$ >*"* "+ "*( ,(#) *.+9 %("

(4#(2

:;

9
9 (-7 ,(#>* +

'$#( *++%*.

(3%*(*.

,(+#

(2 4%+"

> '-*>

+%)

,(+#

B)%" 9 %("

(2 4%+"

+,)*$7

-++

7+

$(#4

,%'-*)

'$#(
#%("9

+2 ()#( ($-)"+

+%44#+

"+ 8( ("%(

%+(>

$* *.

> +(>*)9

,(%+

9 (> -+

 .*+"(

*"+-$ ()#( 

"#(7

7+ ,(*# $(#4

B)%"*#

7"

B,*(

))#( *.-72

&#%( ""(

9 8-- +""-

""(

&#%(

$"(

*++% "*#2 (3%*(

$(+

*"*4 "*.

&#%(

"9  *-%( >*"* "+ +%'+3%"

#$$ (9

-+#

($-)"+ #)#4,-*

"%"#(7 (3%*(4"

*"*.

4**4%4

7+

$"( ,%'-*) '$#(

#$$ (9

)#+* ( #,**#
#%("2

#"*) ,(*# -++

7+ $(#4

*"+ ,%'-*) 4%+"

,(#>*  *"+-$9 4 -.

,(*)*,- +3% (-7

,,-*+

+9

9

$* +

)#%(+

#," '-#8

)#"( >"*# #$2

"*"

"*) "#2 ,(#>*+*#+

# 
(*4* (#) %(2

19 '-#8

)#44*""

*$+"

*--.

-*"7 *++%*.

)"*.

%,# +%(*.

)#4,-*

"#(7 "%"#(7 (3%*(4"+9

'-#82

#$$ (2 ()#(

(3%*+*" &% *)* "*+$ )"*# (.

( *.

% B)%"*#

,(#) 

4)

,($%)"#(7 (2 ( (*.

-.

--7 %+%+"

'-9 !%)

'*.

>*#- "*>

"#(7 ,(#>*+*#+ +%+"

* 9
(*4*

(#) %(
# 2

% (/

G:9 (#)- ,(+#

'+)# *.9 :9 (#)- ,(+#

'+)# *.9 :9 (#)- ,(+#

'+)# *.9 :9 (#)- ,(+#

'+)# *.9  ;

'-*> ;8 "

$"(

>* ) #"6

,(+#

#4

*"

+%)

B)%" 2 +%)

,%'-*+

8(*"" (3%*(*.

*4

+,)*$* ,-

+,)*$* "*4 -++

*("7

7+ $(#4

,%'-*+ +%)

"*#9

;6

,%'-*+

$#--#8+/ 

;*6;

*"

,%'-*)-7

+#4 )#+,*)%#%+ ,- "#8

>*-- .

+%)

,(+# #( * (*-7 (+* +H

;'6 *"

$$*B +#4 )#+,*)%#%+ ("

#%+

#4+"

+%)

,(+# #( * (*-7 (+* + +#4 )#+,*)%#%+ ,-

+%)

"#8 >*-- .H

;)6

)#,7 (#$

$$*B +#4 )#+,*)%#%+ ("

)#%("

#%+H

;**6

-+#2 *$ *"

$*"2 *()"

)#,7

,%'-*+

*-7 8+, ,( )*()%- "*.

,-

+%)

,(+# #( * (*-7 (+* +9

;6 "4"

8(*"*.

*++%*.

$$)"

%-7 ,%'-*+

+,)*$*

+,)*$* )- %+ ;*6 +%'+)"*# ;62

)#)-%+*>

>* )

(3%*(4"+

> )#4,-*

,%'-*+ +%)

I;@6

,%'-*+ +%'+)"*# ;

(+,)"

,(+#

#$$) ,%*+

!)"*#+  2  @2 @2

12 :2 2 2 @2 52 2 12 :2 2 @ 2 @ 2 @2 @@2 @52

@


#  ;@5

: 62

+%)

,(+# *-+

+,)*$* ,-

"*4 (3%*( "*#2

$"(

+%)

*3%*(7

*"

$*"2 ,(##%)

*4

#$$ (

$$)"9

;56 ,(#>*+*#+ +%'+)"*#+ ;6

;6

,,-7

+%'+)"*# ;@6

7

,,-7

,%'-*+ +%'+)"*# ;

69JK

##( * )

*>#)

,(#>*+*#
# 
(*4* (#) %(2

<!#% >9  (7

  ;


 ;
(*4* -6

!#% >9  (7

  ;


 ;
(*4* -6

!#% >9  (7

  ;


 ;
(*4* -6

!#% >9  (7

  ;


 ;
(*4* -6

= = = =2

-

% (/

G9 ++"* (3%*(4"+ +)"*#
(99
92

*++%

,%'-*)

'+)# (

*4

,(+#F#$$ ( +%44 (*D

% (/

;*6 (*#( *++%

((+"

+* 3%

*++%

,%'-*)

$*(+"

((+"

,(+# )#)( 9 ;! # *"

L%4 >9

- */  :

(-9 9 5

;**6 4%+"

(,#("

'$#(

,(+#

#4

((+"

)#%- B)%"

*49 #8>(2

'#%

>* ) (.

'$#( *++%*.

(#)- +)"*# :;

(99
92

19 ;! # *"

L%4

>9 - /  :

(-9 9 5

;***6

(#)-

""( )#%(+

') %+ #-*)

*"9 4%+"

,(*4

)* "*+$*

,(+#

((+"2 ,(>*#%+-7 *++% 2 B)%" 2 +,*"

*-*.)9 ;! *+ % -

(+ >9 4,(#( /

@





> (

.* >9 99 /

@
(- 0

;--

'


6

1:69

;*>6 (3%*+*"

,-

4%+"

+,)*$*

(3%*(*.

+%)

,(+#

+%)

+,)*$*

,- )9 !%)

4%+"

-++

7+ $(#4

*++%

,%'-*) "*#9 ;! %( ,,

%.

(+ >9 7+#( /


(*0 :

!

-* >9

 (7

/   ;6 
 ;
 

06 69

;>6 ,(*# '"8 *++%

,%'-*)

+,)*$*

-++

*("7

7+2

,(+#F#$$ (

,%'-*+

*9 ;! *-'

>9

%& '

;C6 /  ;:6 
 ;
 

06



+

L%4 >9  (7

/  ;@6 
 ;
 

06 55 6

;>*6 (#)-

,%'-*+ #8

+)"*# :;6
(99
92

19 #( ,%'-*)

$*(+"

,%'-*)-7

+#4 )#+,*)%#%+ ,- "#8 >*-- .

#( * (*-7 (+* +H 4

$$*B

+#4 )#+,*)%#%+ ("

#%+

#4+"

#( * (*-7 (+* + +#4 )#+,*)%#%+ ,- +%)

"#8 >*-- .

$"(

)#,7

$$*B +#4

)#+,*)%#%+ ("

#%(" #%+9 ( +%')- %++ ;

6 ;)6

+)"*# ;6;*6
(99
92

)#&%)"*>

*+&%)"*>2

4

8#%- > -* ,%'-*)

%-++

( 4# + ,%'-*)

,(#> 9 ;! 

L%4

%,"

>9 E99 /

(*0

:69 #( (+

)#,7

*"*# --7 ,%'-*+

*-7

8+, ,( )*()%- "*.

,-

#( * (*-7 (+* +9

 >*+ '-72

$#%( )#,*+

#

( )#,*+

$$*B +#4 )#+,*)%#%+

("

#%+

#4+"

#( * (*-7 (+* +2

+#4 )#+,*)%#%+ ,- +%)

"#8 >*-- .

+#4 )#+,*)%#%+

("

#%+

(,#("

(.

( *.

,%'-*)

$#%("

)#,7 "*#9  *"*# )#,7 8*-- (3%*(

-+# (3%*( ,%'-*+ 8+, ,(9

;>**6 "4"

+(>*.

#$$*)(

()#( 

4#  ,%'-*) "*#9 ;! *(



>9

"/

5:

(*0 569

;>***6 *++%*.

"4"

8(*"*.

*"+

%-7 ,%'-*+

+,)*$*

+,)*$* +)"*# :;6;*6
(99
92

19 !%)

"4"

8(*"*.

)#)-%+*> >* )

(3%*(4"+

> )#4,-*

,%'-*+ +%)

;! *(



>9 "/

5:

(*0 569

;B*6 )# *"*#+ +,)*$* +)"*# :;6
(99
92

,%'-*)

(#)-

'+)# (

"#(79 7

#)#4,-* (8*"

)%(

M*((.%- (*"7M

( (+

(#)-

+%'+3%"

("#

%--*"79 ;!

> (

.*

-* '% >9 99

(/

@
(*0

1:



>9 "/

55
(*0 :69K

:9

#8

+""- ,(*)*,-

,(*#( *++%*.

9
92 (3%*( ()#( *"+

"*+$ )"*#

))%+ 2

#4 +%)

+#%.

"2

'+)# *.

*""*# >

((+"9

$#%

&%(*+ *)"*# (3%*(4"

)#+,*)%#%+-7

'+"

+9 ,(%+

(> -+

+%)

"*+$ )"*#

()#(  '-#82 #+ ()#(

*+)-#+

"(*

)#%- &%+"*$7

*$()

-*'( "-7

>#* *.

'$#(
#%("9

%("

(4#(2 *++% #'

*- "+

+"

'-*+ ,(#,( +(>*) (-*( ,(#)++;+6 #8+ #)#4,-*

% ,(#)++ (+%-"*.

+(*#%+ ,(&% *) ,"*"*#(9

:

9

,(#>*+*#+
# 
(*4* (#) %(2

>*.

+(*#%+ )*>*-

)(*4* 4*$*) "*#+ 3%

(*.

"+

))%+ 2

("*)%- (-7

$$)"*.

-*'("7

("*)*, "(* ,(#) *.+2

*>#

+% > -*( (9

"#(7 (3%*(4"

()#( *.

"*+$ )"*#

((+"

B)%" 2

4'# *

(99
92 4%+"

+)(%,%-#%+-7 )#4,-*

'

+*+ )#."

(->

"(*

> *- ()#( 9 7 #

() "%"#(7

#$$ (F,(+# >*"* "+

*( "*("79

$#(+ '

(#,2 )#+* ( #,**#

%+$%- ,%(,#+ 8#%- +(> ,(4*""*.

)(*4*

)#"*%

,"*"*#(2

$#%  %,#

*--.

,(#) %( --7 $- 8 "*#9

*+2 ($#(2

$*"

,,(#,(*

B()*+ ("

,#8(+ 5:

 !!

@:

(99
92

,(>"

'%+ ,(#)++

+)%(  +

&%+"*)9

>*8

'#> $* *.+2

)#+* (*.

"*("7

)"+

)*()%4+"

)+ +2 ,"*"*#

--#8 9

#+3%"-72

;B%( 56 ++

% *)*  .*+"(

- ++2 *+"(*)"

!

 

(2

('72

#$$ (2

(*+*.



#9

19 @9 2 !)"*#+ @  @


# 2

: ;$#( #("

< 
=62 (.*+"(

#-*) 



*+"(*)"

!!

(2

8--

)#+3%"*

(*+*.

($(#42

('7 3%  9

9

 *.

,,-*) "*#;+62 *$

-+#

*+,#+

))#( *.-79

;! 0 ! 0 ! 0 ! 06

   

 % (7

 % (7

 % (7

 % (7

2        

>*(

"

+,

*.F( +# /

+F

"

(,#("

'-/

+F