High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/36420/2025disposed of

Kanwar Singh And Another v. State Of Haryana And Another

2026-04-16Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

& ;

+$"&% +$"&% +$"&% +$"&% ;=9&%@/ A ;=9&%@/ A ;=9&%@/ A ;=9&%@/ A 0 "3))&#

"3))&#

"3))&# = = = = 9 =

"$)$)&#"!

"(&#2"#$

!""#$

%&!

'+#2"!'++2+8-28&3+$" $'"("$)$)&#"! &*+,'+!*+- -+!.+ +#+ BBBB - / !+,0 - / !+,0 - / !+,0 - / !+,0 !

!)$$"#$+$"*"#$&%' ')' 1*+!-+#2341))$)&#&,,"3 $&!-

!5+#$+$" "(+!$*"#$- &'+6-&#5"'+,%&% %!"(&#2"#$& +#2'+5 ""# %),"2)#$'"&1!

!$-$'"+*")$+6"#&#!"3&!2 .

7+.&%(!""#$7!)$("$)$)&#-(!+ +."!'+5""#*+2"&#5"'+,%&% ("$)$)&#"!,+#2& &7#"! %&! $'" !","+" &% $+$ $1$&!. )#$"!"$ )# $'")! %+8&1! +33&1#$&%2",+.

."22)51!+,&%$'"3&*("#+$)& &#+*&1#$)#$"!*&%+7+!22+ +$"2 9 : 9(+ "25.$'"+#2341))$)&#& &,,"3$&!- !5+#$+$""(+!$*"

"#$-

&'$+6 ; !) )"%,.$+$)#<-3"!$+)#,+#2&7#"2 25.$'"("$)$)&#"!-)$1+$"2)# !"8"#1" "$+$" &% ),,+<" '+CC+!- )$!)3$ '

'+CC+! 3+*" $& 5" +341)!"2 8 8)2" #&$)%)3+$)&#2+$ $"2: : +#2= : ) 1"21#2"!"3$)&#9+#2=&% +#2341))$)& &#3$->?9/'"!")#+%$"!!"%"!!"

"2$&+D>?93$E0 7+!21# #2"! "3$)&# &% $'" 3$ 7+ +##&1#3"2 &# 9 9 : 9 # $'" *"+#7'),"- ("$)$)&#"!,+#2& &7#"! +((,)"2 %&! <!+#$ &% 5 5"#"%)$ 1#2"! $'" +#2 &&, ,)#<

3'"*" '"%+ +3$1*&%"#$)$,"*"#$&%$'"("$)$ $)&#"!,+#2&7#"!1#2"!$'"+ +#2

&&,)#< 3'"*"

" 7+ "8"# +36#&7,"2<"2 5. $'" )# $'" +7+!2 &7"8 8"!- %+3$1+,,.$'"+) )25"#"%)$7+#&$+8+),+5,"$& $'"("$)$)&#"!,+#2&7#"!+$'

'")! ,+#2 7+ +341) )!"2 %&! $'" (1!(&" &% 2"8",& &(*"#$ &% )#$)$1$)&#+, +#2 (+!

!$,. 3&**"!3)+,-!&+ +27)2"#)#<+#2<!""#5",$&% "3$&!-'+CC+!/#$)$1$)&#+,+ +#2 &**"!3)+,0 9 ') ) %+3$ 7+ #"8"! 5!&1<'$ $& & $'" #&$)3" &% $'" ("$)$)&#"

"! ,+#2&7#"! 13'- $'". 3&#$)#1"2$&7+)$ % %&! $'" <!+#$ &% 5"#"%)$1#2"!

+#2 &&,)#<3 3'"*" 2*)$$"2,.-+("!(+!+# #& 9&%$'"!"(,.-$'"3&*("#+$ $)&# +*&1#$2"$"!*)# #"28)2"7+!22+$"29 : 97+2"(&)$"25"%&!"$'","+!# #"2 22)$)&#+,)$!

!)3$12<"&#,.&#> > @ +#2$'"!"+%$"!$'"("$)$)&#"!7 7"!" *+2"+7+!"&% $'"%+3$$'+$$'"5"#"%)$1#2"!$ $'"+#2 &&,)#<3'"*"7+ +8+),+5,"$&$'"* * #13'3)!31*$+#3"-$'"( ("$)$)&#"!3,+)*+7+!2&%$+$1$ $&!. )#$"!"$)#$"!* &%"3$)&#;9&%>?93$%&!$ $'"("!)&25"$7""#9 : 9+ +#2 > > @ @ # $'"&$'"!'+#2-,"+!#"23&1#"

",%&!$'"!"(&#2"#$15*)$$ $'+$ $'"!" 7+ #& 2",+. &# $'" (+!$ &% $'" !" (&#2"#$ $&7+!2 $'" !","+" &% 3&*("#+$)&#+ *&1#$+$'"("$)$)&#"!,+#2&7 7#"!'+2+((,)"2%&!$'"<!+#$ $&% 5"#"%)$ 1#2"! $'

'" +#2 &&,)#< 3'"*" +#2 + + &&# + $'&" +((,)3+$)&# 7 7"!" 7)$'2!+7#- $'" +*&1#$ &% 3&*("#+$)&# 1#2"

"! $'" +7+!2 7+ 2"(&)$"2 5"% %&!" ,"+!#"2$'","+!

!#"222)$)&#+,)$!)3$12<"& &#> > @ $7+$'1-(!+.

."2 $'+$$'"7!)$("$) )$)&#7+,)+5,"$&5"2)*)"2 = '

'+8" '"+!2 ,"+!#"2 3&1#", %&! $'" (+!$)" +#2 <&#" $'!&1<' (+("!5&&6

# 2)(1$"2,.-$'",+#2)#41"$)&# #7++341)!"2%&!2"8",&(*"#$ $&% "3$&!'+CC+ +!/#$)$1$)&#+,+#2&**"!3)+ +,0-+#2)#13'3)!31*$+#3"- +#2 &&,)#< 3'"*" 7+ #&$ +((,)3+5," $ $& 13' +341))$)&# # %+3$- ("$)$)&#"!,+#2& &7#"!7"!"$!"+$"2)#+#1#%+) )!*+##"!5.$'"!"(&#2"#$ '" ("$)$)&#"!7"!"

"*+2"$&+((,.1#2"!$'"+#2

&&,)#< &,)3.7')3'7+#&$+$ $+,, +((,)3+5," $& $ $'"*- '&7"8"!- 3&*("#+$)&# +*&1#$ 7+ 7!&#<,. 7)$''"

",2

&!"&8"!-)$'+ #&$5""#2)(1$"2$'+$$'"(& ")&#&%$'",+#27+$+6"#& &8"! %!&*$'",+#2&7 7#"!("$)$)&#"!+&#$'"2+$"& &%(+)#<&%$'"+7+!2)$",% > # 13'3)!31*$+#3"-$'"%+1,$,)"

7)$'$'"!"(&#2"#$%&!2",+.

.)#< $'"2)51!+,&% %3&*("#+$)&#+*&1#$)#%+8&1 1!&%("$)$)&#"!,+#2&7#"!%&!

! #& C1$)%)"2!"+&# &!"&8"!-$'")1")#'+#2'

'++,!"+2.5""#2)31"2)#2"

"$+), 5. $') &1!$ )# & ::== &% > 2"3)2"2 &# ? @ ","8 8+#$ (+!+<!+('& ?

?+#2? +!""F$!+3$"2'"!"1#2"!

1!$'"!*&!"- $'" +7+!2 )# $'" (!""#$ 3+" 7+ (+"2 9 : 9 +#2 $'" (&")&# &% $'

'" +341)!"2 ,+#2 7+ $+6"# $'"!"

+#2 $'"# #5.$'"!"(&#2"#$-'&7"8"!-$'

'"(+.*"#$7+!","+"2)#%+8&1!

1!&% ("$)$)&#"!&#: : #)$)+,,.

,.-$'"3&*("#+$)&#7+#&$!","+ +"2 )#% %+8&1!&%$'"("$)$)&#"!+ $'".'

'+2+((,)"2%&!$'"5"#"%)$1#2"! +# #2 &&,)#<3'"*")#$"!*&%$'" ("3)%)3$)(1,+$)&#*+2")#$'"+7 7+!2 2+$"

$"29 : 95.$'" ("

("!+##"F1!" 9-$'"("$)$)&#"!7 7"!" 3&* **1#)3+$"2&#,.&#@ : :$'

'+$$'"+#2 &&,)#<3'"*"7+ +(( (,)3+5," $& $'" (!""#$ +341))$)&# # 7')3' 7+ 3+!!)"2 &1$ %&! 3+!8 8)#< "3 3$&! - '+CC+! %&! (15,)3 1$),)$)" +#2 3&**"!3)+, "3$&! ("! !"3& &!2- )$ 7+ $'"!"+%$"! &#,. &# :

: :- $'" 3&*("#+$)&# +*& &1#$ 7+ !","+"2 )# %+8&1! &% ("$)$)&#"

"!G ,+#2&7#"! + ("! +7+!2 2+ 2+$"2 9 : ? ((+!"#$,.- &# +33&1#$ &% ( ("3)%)3 $)(1,+$)&# 5""# *+2" )# +7+ +!22+$"29 : 95.$'" +5&1$&%%"!)#<&%$'"5"#"%)$&%, ,+#2 (&& &,)#<$&$'",+#2&7#"!-$'"!"(&# &#2"#$*)<1)2"2+#2*)!"(!""# #$"2 $'"* * %&! *+6)#< $'"* +((,.)#< 1# #2"! $'" +#2 &&,)#< 3'"*" +#2

$'"!

!"+%$"! !"*+)#"2 )$$)#< $)<'$ &# 13' +((,)3+$)&# %&! ."+! $&<"$ "$'"! 7)$'

$'&1$!"(&#2)#<&!7)$'&1$"8"#!

!"8"!$)#<$'+$$'"+)2(&,)3.7+ +(( (,)3+5," $& $'" (!""#$ +341))$)&# # (!&3""2)#< # 13' 3)!31*$+#3 #3"- 2",+.)#2)51!+,&%3&*("#+$)&# #)#%+8&1!&%$'",+#2&7#"!)(1!

1!",. +$$!

!)51$+5," $& $'" !"(&#2"#$ +#2 $ $'1 $'". +!" %&1#2 &5,)<+$"2 $& ( (+. )#$"

"!"$$&$'",+#2&7#"!G("$)$)&#"!% %!&*$'"2+$"&%+7+!2) " 9 : 9 $),, $'"2+$"&%+3$1+,!","+"&%(+.*"

"#$) " : :-)#+33&!2+#3"7 7)$' "3 3$)&#;9&%$'"3$ H ? # 8 8)"7 &% $'" +%&!"+)2- $'" (!" "#$ 7!)$ ("$)$)&# ) 2)(&"2 &% % )# $"!* &% C12<* *"#$ (+"2 5. $') &1!$ )# & ::== &% > 2"3)2"2 ? @ 33 3&!2)#<,.-$'"("$)$)&#"!'+,, 5""#$)$,"2%&!!","+"&%$+$1$ $&!. )#$"!"$ 1#2"! "3$)&# ;9 &% >?9 3$- %!&* $'" 2+$" &% +7+!2 $),, $'" 2+$"

" &% 2)51!"*"#$ &% % 3&*("#+$)&# +*&1#$ $ ) %1 1!$'"! 2)!"3$"2 $'+$ $'" #""2%1, 5" 2&#" 7)$')# + ( ("!)&2 &% $7& *&#$' %!&* $&2 2+. ","- !"(&#2"#$ & '+,, 5" ,)+5,"$&(+.3& $&% @-G$&$'"("$)$)&#"

"!$&7+!22",+.+7",,+3&$ $&# +33&1#$&%1##"

3"+!.+#21#3+,,"2%&!,)$)<+$)& &#

"# #2)#<+((,)3+$)&#/0-)%+#.'+,, +,&$+#22)(&"2&% / 0 / 0 / 0 / 0 (!), (!), (!), (!),=- =- =- =- = $)6 '

'"$'"!("+6)#<G!"+&#"2 " '"$'"!!"(&!$+5," " G& G&