High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/36549/2025dismissed

Amritpal Singh v. Union Of India And Others

2026-04-16The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Sanjiv Berry15 pages

-1-

6&789:;<7= =>=:

'('*' ??

>8 = =>=9 & ) +' ?9 >;

= =>=9 ' ?9 >;

= =>=9

$'()( @@ &'

'( '

(

@ '(

!" #

% &'('

''"

*+'

''" *+'"

/ " *

(

" *+'"

' , )

+) ('

$- .

+'"

''1 "

* (

" '

! +' , )

+) ('-" .

*' '

) ('

) !)"

$2 " *+'

!) & " *+

" *+'

3 2"

0' *+' , )

+) ('- .

' &) 13"

)4 *+' !'

'" &) 13

-2- ?

( ' ' ) ' + +' ==9 ' . +' ==A () (''2( (() +' .

. +' ('

' ' '*'

*' ''

' ?A > >;

=>=: ,

'B)' &7?- ((' 34 0(+ ('" ( ,'( '

8-" +)(

'*'

*' ''

' .

=8 >;

=>=: 'B4 ' ' ( ( '*'

' ' ?8 >8 =>=;

' *'4 )('" ' ' ( ('

+) ('"

(((' 34

''" *+'"

( + 4 ' ' ' '*'

*' ''

( 3'

+ '

' 4 +') ('" 3) )

' '

(

( ' '

'' 3 3''

()31'+' ' ( ' '*'

*' '

?E >8 =>=8" .

( 'B4 . ( + )' 34 ('+ '

' '*'

*' ''

' ?8 >8 =>=;

;" .' 34 ' )

' ' ((' ?A >;

=>=: * *'

'B)' & &7?

;

' ' ('

+) (' '" () + '

' )

' ' '*'

*' '

( (' ' .

( ,-

' ' + ''

.' ) 0(+ (' +

.4 'C3 2' ' ' !*' ('" ( ()3 3' .' ''( 3'

+ '' 3(' ('

(*4

) '4 '+ (+" .

' +'

3'+ )3+ ' ( ('(D

-3- ,- ' ' ((

' ) )

' ' '*'

*' ''

0( (+ (' .( ''

' . .'( )C( 8 ,=- '+)4 +" ?<E> ,F G 3'*4-D ,- + '

(

' '*'

*' ''

' ' 'D ,*- &' ( 4' 3''

( .

( F'('G ' )'

' !) ''

)" '(' ' *

3''

4' (

++ +)(' ' ( )'D ,*-

'' ( +

' ' 0(+ ( '"

( 3 4 .' ' '+ '

' 34

& ,) )-"

(D ,*-

'' ( *' B' 2 3'.''

' ( + )+ ('+*' + 4 ' ' 'D ,*-

'' ( + ' () ' 'B('

+' ' )

' ' '*'

*' ''

() ' '( ) (" ' ' ('

+) (' '

( '' ) *)( '+( (" +)

* 0 7

" #

$" $%

&''( %"$%)(*+%

, ))"

" % -". $ % //0,

+%# 1% 2, $ %

3*4% $ % 5 *66 5 - 0+%4*

3,% ) $% -% %$ $ % '/'5 ) *)

$% '/'5 &

&' + " ' ' ('

+) ) ('"

) !)" (( ('

$2 2 " *+'" '

' &)

13"

( ' ' () ' )

' ' '*'

*' ''

( ,- '

+ ''

' 0(+ (' )C( 8 ,= =- " ' ' ('

+) (' ' &) 13 ( + '

-4- 'B '((

FG 'B' .

'B'((

F0( (+ ('C(( ' &+ +'G ('+ 8 ,8- (

+*' (

)4D ,-

'+ + ?8 ,=- !'

' )('( +" ?E<A ( '' ) + '

(" . ( ' (

) ( +)'

' ) " *+' *'( # ( )('" ' +' ( +' ) )

$%" +%" +% %+ ;$

% 89.

-* '//55/ , ?>-"

- 7))$ ")

))"

" % # .)9 ."

'//&5 , ?A- - )) * "

%$."

" #

$" $ $% '/'5/5' , =E-D ,- '( 3 '7.( (' '.''

)C( 8 ,8-

,*-

+' '' ( ('4 **' * 34 ' !*' '

?= 4(" .

( )4 + ' . ' '('

+('"

( +

' ' '*'

*' ''

((' 34 0( (+ ('

'( *'D ,*- #) ' ' +' ( +' ) ('+ + 8 ,==- !'

' )('( +"

?E< <A" + '

' . )' +) ,(

' - ( ''' 3' ' G '*'

,*- ( ( + '

' 3'

' &) 13 ( +( (' 2( . '' '(( ( ?: '( ( '

3 ' !) ( 0''

'B)' &7:- ' 7( ' ' (

' ( 4 '4 4

) $$"" 2"

%".7"

% :(6*%

",+ * *+ '' , :E?-" ( + + '

' 34 ' ' ('

+) ) (' ' &) 13 '*'

( + )+ '( +

(+) ) H' 34 ((

' '*'

*' ''

' '

)

4" ' ( +('"

( +' +'' ('

+4 4

( ()31'

'+*'

' 3(' 31'+ +*'

,*-

() ' '(

(" .

+ ( *' 3 3''

' ' ) 34 ' ' ('

+) ( (' ' &) 13 ,?- )(*0%+%

$ % 5&

-5- ,=- <%$

$ % 5& ,8-

%%"

4(5 ,;-

) +*)%# 1%$ -

" # $" $ % ,:- -6= !

" % "," ;"( (%" $ %

# $ $"'//&/ ,9- -%+ *)% " -%+ *

3*4 % '/ //'/

+') (' ( '

' 34 ' ' +) (' ' '"

.) 3' ' '

*' ' !) ( 0''

'B)'

&7:- .

'()' ' 0( + (' (( ' )

' ' '

'*'

*' ''

( ''

'*' .

+*'(C

**''

C((+ ' ' ' . '''

( .

(' '

( '

' ' 3'+ )3+ '

' '.

. ,- (

. 7 '''

(D ,- ((+ . ''

('( '((D ,- ((+ . '

4(+4 ' ' '( ( .

*' ' '

4 )3 +4 'B(' ' 'I( ('

''( (

( 'D ,*-

' +)(' / ( ('(D ,*-

3' '

H ,*-

34 2

!) ''

)" . ' ' + ''

+'( ( !)''

) (' *)(

')( +( 'D ,*- 4 '' ' >< ?> =>=;"

' ' +' 6

13 &+' '' ' ( (( '( &+' &) 13

)' '

( & +' 34 +) +

( ?:

'( .

*+4 (' ' (2'

-6- *) ' '( ( (

' .'' +

' 1 2

+( (' ( '" .

.'' ''

' 34 ' ( .' ( ( H

( ' . '(('( ' # ' ( ) ' ' *+'( .

'' '

'+ &' ' ( '

- .( . ' 34 ' '

,*-

+' + ' &) 13 &+'

('+) )4C('4 3' ' ' ( ?:

'( ( .

7( '

( H ,B- *+ ' ' '"

'4 !)''

)" .( ' ' > >< ?> =>=; +

' '

'( '

( ' ' + +' 0''

'4D ,B-

' ' (4+ (( .( ('

' ' '3'( ' ) )3+ ''34 +'

*' '('

' )3+ 'D ,B- ' *'( '

' )' !)''

) *' # ?:< ' ?> ?> =>=;" &+'

/2)" 0(+ #2 " (''

( )2 1 /

" '' /) ,' ((' '+'(' !)''

)-" $21''

J J

0)34"

)2 ''

J )2 ) ,+)( 3 ' '+'(' !)''

)-" &* '

. ''

.'' ' '+'

+4 4 .

(+(' ( .'' 3'

' )(' ) ) '4 ()

)( .' ( ' +) 4 ' )' 31'+ +'

/ (

'" .

.( '+

. (

' (

' ) H 34 '

*) ' 0(+ (' (( ' &+' * )( 0(+( * ' ' ' ?:

=>=:)C( 8 , ,8- ( 3'' 1)(+

# '4 '''

+' + * *'

+'"

'+ ( 8,=- 8,8 8- ' ' ')+' 3'.

-7-

-1%)+%$ % $"

.%"

), ,

!"#$

) %$

& '

( *+

),-

/ %

* # & 1 1)

(( 0 # 1&23456 23 7 345!&

) 7! 8&

(

&%$

& &

0 #

9 '

0 #

' & & ' &

!& +

% $

& + $

& & ). 9

& & % %

-8- ;

'+ 8 ,=- '.'

'( '

' !*' '

((

' '*'

*' ''

(('" '('+ '( " ( '+'((4 '*'

3'+ + )3+ ' ' ( '(

'+ 8 ,8- "

.'* *'" 3'(.( .'( )

!*' '

' ()+ .' *'( ' )C( 8 ,=- 0(+ (' (( ' & +' ' *

' ((+ +

+ ' ' ('+ 8,=-

.'*'" ' ' ('

(' ' + '

( ' ''

.' ' 0( + (' ( 'K)' 3'

(+C + '

C'*'

+ .

4 (' '

'('

' )3+ ' ( () )+ " ( + '

' + ' '

.' 3 4 ' ) ' 0(+ (' *' ' ' ?:

= =>=:

( 7'( ' '4'( . ( +' ( '*'

C +'

+ ( + '

' ' ( ' ' ?:

= =>=: ( '+ ' *

(.''

.'( ' 0(+ ( ('( (( '( & +'

' '

' &) 13 .

( .

' 'B + 'B '+ ,8- '

( ( ) ' ()3' ((+ + '' ) )C( 8 ,8- .

+ '

.' ) 0(+ (' 34 *2 2

('+ 8 ,8 8- ( ''( 3' +'

C'*'

)(" ( + '

' ''

( .'( 34 ' ! *' '

)C( 8,=- 0(+ ('( 34 *2

'+ 8, ,8- +

3' ) '

' 'B) + 'B) '' '+ 8 ,8- '*'( ' .' ( 3'(.' )

' !*' '

)C( 8 ,= =- ' !*' '

( ((' ' ( .' ( 3' 3'( .' 3'

) ' 0 0(+ ('" )C( 8 ,8- " ' .

(

-9- ((' 34 ' !*' '

) H

()+ 0(+ ('

' (( ' &+' 'B'+(' .'( + '' )

!*' '

)C( 8 ,=-

' (( + 3' *' 34

!*' '

34 *2

('+ 8 ,8 8- ( ( ' ('

' ( + ' ' )C( 8 ,=-

' 'B'((

)(' ('+ 8 ,8- F++)(

+'( '*

2'4 '* 4 ' . ' + ( ' 1)(+ 0(+ (' (( &+'@

G '( 4

' '( + )' .'

!*' '

3' '*'

C +'

C(+ 7+'

+ )C( 8 ,8-

'B'((

F'*

4 'G )(' ('+ 8 ,8- + +'( .( ' + '*'

C +'

+ ' ''

*) 0 0(+ (' + 3' (( '" 3) ' 'B ('+ 8 ,8 8- '(

'*'

' !*' ((

'+ '

' )'

((' 34 ' '( '

' !*' '

=> >=:"

) H

' 0(+ ('(

(( '( &+' .

&) 13 'B'+('

' .'( ' '('+ +*'

0(+(C1) )(+ '( )C( 8 ,8-

( 3'

' '+ '3' '

' 'B ('+ 8 ,=- ,8 8- +

3' )+' 34 )(*'

' 'B ( +'" .

( '*'

'B'((

F'*

4 'G"

) ' 3

''( 3' '"

' ) '

'B'+(' '' ()'

' ()'

()+ '

' .' ) ) ' 0(+ (' 3'

'*'

C + '

C(+ +'

+" .) ) *' 'B'((' ' ('

'B ' *(

' 3('

+' '' ( +' + ' '

( )'

(

-10-

( '

( ' '(

( '*'

*' ''

( ' +'4 +*' '( 3 3' '

( ' +''

) 4C0(+ ('

3(' ()31'+*' ((+ +

) ' ) 31'+*' ' ' .( '*'

* *'4 ' ' 34 4 ' )

' '" ''

' ( 2' )3+ ' ('+)4 ' 3'

'1)+'

6' ' ( '''

. ' + '

' ' ('

(' ' ''

( 3''

' ' 0(+ (' ' ' ((

' )

' '

' ' .( +' 3'' ' 0 0(+ (' .( ''

& ,)-" ( ( ' '' ' .

.( '' '('+ + ' )' !)''

' ( 4'

( ' ++)(' *' # ?:< ' ?> ?> =>=; ( ' '

' *)( . '(('( ' '( ( .

' *+H' 34

' ' *3' '+ '*'( ( '' .( ()+'

' 3'' 0 (+ ('" (" ('4 *' '(

((+

' ( '* *'

*'4 ' '" ' ()

3'+ )3+ ' ('+)4 ' 4 ('

. ' . ' '+( ( +' 34 ' ' ('

+) ) (' ' ' ' () + '

' ' ' '*'

*' ''

' .

' ,-

* 07

?> ?

' ( +('" ' 'B ) .' ( 4 ) '

'( 3' ) 4 ' ''

)' 2

'+*' '

''('

()+

( 3''

(' ' '('

+('

'' '" ' ( '+( ( *

-11- ,-

" # $" $ % &'' ?> =

' '( +(' .( +' 34 ' ' ('

+) (' ' () ' )'

( '

( '' .' + '' 3 34 ' !*' '

)

' 0(+ (' )C( 8 ,8 8- A= ' ( 1) '

( ')('" ( (''

' 'B ) .( ' *'. *

' ++)( +'( '*

2'4 '* 4 ' . ' + ( ' 1)(+

0(+ ('" ' !*'

+ ''

' ( .'( ) )C( 8 ,=- 34 *2

('+ 8 ,8 -

( 1) '

'( (4

' !*' '

( ((' ++)( +'( '*

1)(+

' +) 0(+ ('" ' !*' '

+ ''

' ( .'( )C( 8 ,=- 34 *2 2

('+ 8 ,8- )

+) 0 0(+ (' 4

( 1) ) '

' 'B )

( '

' . ( (' 34 ' ' ('

+) (' ' ' ' ' F'*

4 'G + 3' '(+*'4 ' ' ''

( .'( 34 ' !*' '

+ 4 4 3'

(+ +'

+ 34 .4 ' + ' '*

(+ ( '" ( ( ' +('

,- ( %"$% )(*+%

, ))"

" % - ". $%

// ?> ' ( +('" ' 'B ) '(('

4 .( '

' ''

' ' ( ) 3 3' '' ( '" .

' !*'

'B'+('( .'( '

) 0(+ ( '

)C( 8 ,8- L ' ( +('" ' ' F'*

4 'G .(

K)'( " ( ( ' '('

+('

)("

' +) B ' ( +('

" (' ( ( *

-12- ,*- 0, +%# 1%2, $ $ %

3*4% $ % 5*665 ?> ;

' ( +('" ' ' '*'

*' ''

.( (' ( ' 34 ' 'B ) ' +') ('(

+'" ()+ ( 7'+ (

' ' '('

.( 2' '

34 ' !*' '

' 'D ( ' '('

' ()3( '

' ' '*'

*' ''

.( *' 34 ' !*' '

. ?= 4( ( 'B'+)

,*- - 0+%4*

3,% )

$% -%$ $ % '/'5 ?> :

' ( +('" ' 'B ) .( '

. '

' '*'

((' )C( 8 ,=- &'( &'*'

')( +*'( '

'(" 0 0+(" 0) '

'(" !

+ '

'( !3 33'( +" ?<E9" .

'' ' 0* (

+ &'(

)

) ' ' ' '*'

' 'B ) (((' ' ' 34 )

' ' 0*( '

+ &'(

) .

+'("

'(('

4 '('+ ' ' ''

" ()31'+ +*'

((+

) 4" + +' . ' *(7M7*( ) )3+ ' ( (4 . 3' ( +)(

' . .

( 1) '

( '( ((( ' 4

'" ( ' + +) B

' ( +(' ( ''

,*- ) *)

$% '/'5 &

?> ' '( +('" ' 'B ) (' (' ' '

'*'

' +( 3)' ' ''

)' + )

3' 3

' ( '1)+ '

+' )3+ '

( '+( (

-13- ( * '" ( + +' ' ' *3' .

+''

) 4 ' '('

+(' ( ( ()+'

() ( ((+

' ' ('

+) ('

( ( +' 0* (

+ 1)

' 1(

+ +) %*

4 $% '

'' ??

=>>8 0*( '

+ '+ (

34 4

) + + %%

7% % $ % '/' > ;"

)( ( " .

'' ' '( ( '*'

.'' K)( '

!*' '

+ '

.' )

' 0(+ (' .''

(+C'*'

C +'

+" ( ( ' +( ('

( (''

'('

'+( (

' .( +' 3' ' ' '('+*' )( ( .

4 +'

C'*'

2 +' .

*' (' ' '

( ' '

' !*' '

' .'

'( ) ' 0(+ ('

+) (+ )C( 8 ,8-

''(" ' ( +('" '

' ( 3''

( .

34 ' 1 +'

" .

2 + +'

=>==7=8

( 0(+" .( .

.' 34 *)( +'

( .

' ' ' .

.( **' *)( '( +*'( '

) ) +

( ' *3'" ( 2''

?: '( (

7( '' 34

' ( ' 3'

**' ' )' !) ''

) *' # ?:< ' ?> ?> = =>=; *)( '( ( .

'I( '+ '+ +

'+ . '4 '((" .

4 3''

**' +((73 ' 'B+

' (" 3) ( 3 '

'3'( *)( '(

( .

*' 3''

(' ) ' .) +*'( ,&'*'

- +" ?<9 9A ,&-" 3'('( ' '

( +' 4 +'( ' ' (4+ + (( (' 34 34

)

')( +*'( ( &

7&) 13 ''+C''+)(( (

-14- '(

+' *)( ( +'(

(+( &) 13 .

.''

( .

2 ' ' ' ''

3'+ )3+ '"

4 4 +) (+" 3) +(( ' (+( ' &) 13

) '" ( 3' '

' '' 3(' ' '

' *3' 3 3'' 0(+ ('" (" ( (' 3*'" *' )

' ' ' ?A >;

=>=: ,

'B)' &7?-" '*'

*' ''

.( ''

' .

=8 >;

=>=:

( '

' .( )4 + ' 34

!*' '

)C( ?= ,?- *' ' ' =;

>9 =>=: ,

'B)' & &78-"

+ (' *' '(

' (' 34 ' ''

)'"

' ' '" ' ('+)4 ' '

+' )3+ ' ( )4 '

'+' ' '' ( ( ''

3(' ' '

'+C ' *3' . ' + +' ' ) 4

' '+ +*'

'+ ( " ( ( 3''

' )C( < "

( ( 3''

( +( ('" ( ' *(4 )4 4 + ()' ) '

>< >9 =>=: *'

'B)' &7= '' ( ()+'

+)(' ''

' ) ' ' *( (

)(" ( ) (

' )3 *'

+( ++) ( +'(" ((+ .( *' 34 ' &) 13 3 34 (()

' ' ?:

=>=: +)

*' 3''

(+C +'

C'* *'

7 +'

)(" ' ( ' ' ?:

=>=: .(

4 (()'

'+ '(" )

' 0(+ ( '( (( '( &+ +' 'B'+(' ' .'( ' !*' '

34 *2

('+ 8 ,8- '*'

*'4 '

' ''* ' 'B'+(

' .'( + '' *' ' ' ?:

=>=: ,

'B)'

' 7 =C?-" 0( + ('" (" .) )4 ((' ' )

' ''

-15- ' '

' ?A >;

=>=: ,

'B)' & &7?- .' 4C '

4 '' ( ( + 4 '''

+' ''

' + ('+)( 3*' ( (+)(( " ( +' ( 4

' )

' ' '*'

*' ''

((' ( ' ( ) ' ' .'( 1)+ '*'.

('K)'

4" ' '('

' ( ( (((' . ) + (

?9" =

! - #

>=9 , $ % - 0!

' '

' ('2

C'( '

' '3'

%'(C %'(C