Talwandi Sabo Power Limited v. Punjab State Power Corporation Limited





  
  

   


  

!"# $% #&'('$)*  + +

 ,  -

  ,
















-  
  ,




 

 * .

, +

-


- -      
 
 
  
   
 
  
 
 
  
 
 
 

 
 
 !
 


"  
! 
  
  
 
# 
  
$
 
%%
  
%

  
 
 

  &&&&

- - 

/

+

0!1
2 

'
  
%

(
%

%


  ! 
 

)*+,-+-.

/ 
0* 1

 
 


%

!

%%" 2! 
 

)*+,-+-.



 

/ 
0*

(

%%
 
/

!') &!(# * '
  
" 


(
%

 %
--34--,
 
5 

2







" 


 



 6 

! 
 

)*+,-+-.
/ 
0*



(

% 
 ( %
' (% - 7 
 %




(!



! " 

/ 
0*

! 
 
"

(  %

 
 
"

" 

%
 


"
(
%
%
"

 
"
!
"
(


 ! 
   )  
 !
 
% 

5 %

 
"
 
! 
  

(!



 (
"
  


!
( 



%

%
 2


  
  

/ 
0*
(


( 

%
 / 
0*
8 7 
 %



(!

 
"
  !
("




 


!
"

 


% 
 ( %
' (%
"
 
"

%! (
 
(

 
9" 


! 
 
"


(



(

% 
 ( %
' (%


"
(  


 
 
%!
 


%


( 

%
(% 


"


  

 ( %
' (%

  

!


%% "




  
 ( 
9
(!



" 



  

%!

(
 % 
(

 ( %

' (% "

 


 
( 

%!


 
(





( 

 ( %

' (%
"
6 

(



! 
(






%


(
0 
(

 % 

%!
  (



( 

% 

 ( % ' (% . 7 
 %
(!


! 
 
 )*+,-+-.




 


 





*3 )

  ( 


5%

*::3
 
 


;
;

( 


" 
(  


 


 

(


 

*3 )




  



 

% 
  
" 

( 

5 
"
  


!



),



9
% 
(!


! 
 

% 
( 



%"
( 


 ( %

' (%
"
6 


   
%%

%!

"
" 

 
(



 %!





  

 
"
% 



(


 ( % ' (%

**+--+-8

"


"
(  

%%

%
"%% (
  
(
"
(
"


! 
  

%


 



(


( 

%
(% 

(
%
 
%


 

(


  


!   

% 

"



( 

! 0   
 
 


 

  

!

%(%

(

  3 <



 
 !
 
% 
 5 %
"
 
! 
  

(!


  
"  

 %
--3


5 

2


!(% 
 (%
9
(!



! 
 

(



 "%


%
 


 %!






*3 )


3



"
 !

 


  %
 



(

 ( % ' (%
9
(!



%


*3 )





(



 %!




 
"

% 


!
%(%






%




), -

)8




  

  


%(%

(  !






!(%
% , 2

 

% 
 %


  =
' 
"

 
("

 


!
"

 


% 
 ( %
' (%
"
 
"

 ( %  



%
"
 
(

 

(

" 5  
7!
" "
% 

 
( 

%   ( %
' (%
" (

 %!



"
 
(
 

   


*3 )





 
"



 / 

0))

*++8-+-.


  
'
  
 
 *++8-+-.
/ 
0))

 

 0        

           !"  #$ %& $'(
 ) 
* "+ , *$
 -. '" 
'
% //!

) 
*0   0         *

"+       1

"

 * *"
"  202
 ' / 
 3"+ , *
*        "+  *+     "  *
+   
  4+  2
  5     %   !"%  6*
+% **  



 "

  , *    
 % ("+   *  *+")
 %7

"

 ,)  0 + "

 * , *  !

%     !"  " 
(   


 *
"*% ( 
 0"***)
 ) 
  

     "+     , *     *+  

  !

 0  "     !"  

+  
* * "

 '

+% 0

  "8  *"
" 202
 ' / 

" '"!""+  

   2)"$:

+ ,+ 

-;2$:, ;. 0  
* * "<  !



0" *+

  6 % !"0"   "

 %+% , * !

      

   *       , *1

"

  *+

!

!"0 "   "

  *    
 +)
 *+

  !

  *       
    6
    0 "

  *+

  * 
 "

!"          +  "     6    

  !



"7*



    +6



: 
  %


  
"%
"

 

 ( %  

( 

% 
 ( %
' (%


 %!
% "
 


*3 )





  %



"  


 !

(%


%!;

(!




(

 %

( 

(% 


"
  
 !
 +*+:-++=
'  

  %

 
#8
"%
"





"
 !
"
  


  


  %

 
#.

"%
"


"

(  





(
 


 %!





/


  

' (%
"%
(
 
 !
(!

 

 


 
'  

!
"

 
(

% 
 ( %
' (%


  
 %!




 
(


  
 %!



(
 !

   ! 
 
"




  %

 
#*+


! 
  "%
"


  



"
"
 !
"
 
  

  
 
'  

 
#*.3

"
%

 %


( 

(% 





(
 

 % 
 ( %
' (%




%%
"




    ( 


  %

 
#*.,
"%
"


 %!


"

  % 
2

" 

  
 %!


 "
"
 !
(
"


  
 
 
"

 


 
(


%


*3 )

  *+
'  



%


%


 



*3 )




"

(

% 
 ( %
' (%
'   


),




"
%
"

%
% %



"

"

%


*3 )







 %
  

!
"%
%
'
  


*3 )

 
 
 

 0  -.'*  "" 6
 
*   +

"     ""+ 
*  +   "*
 = ** > 

 

 ! 
"


6
"
 

 % 
 %



"
  


!(%

   



"%
 


 !

9?(%
 ! 5 

      



 !"

# 

$%    &%  '(    '

 )        *   *

 +   ),


- . (!


"


9  5 

 %
--3

--,


5 

2

( 
"



/ 



% 
! 
9  

 
#*-

*=


  
 !
"
   

 0  9  '"'
 
      !

 *        +  *
+%  "  


 3
 5 

 3
 *  
 '"'
%0  

8

:6)
( >0

 + 
+ 0  "
% ("+ 2% )
 +

(6
*0  *( 2; -*  **.

2

 !

 "


  *(*     *( 2" *?> @!,'& &0, %
6


( )

0   
*   '"'
 66666666 

@+
 %  
+07%         (  
 
 
         @  >(  $   (   5* '


  @%-

.

 $   % 

 ()  8 ;

  9  ( 
       *
(  "

   !

 
  "  +  *  *0 B   

 
 % 0 
0     " 
* % 
%   % 30* "'
          " 
          
  " 
  "+ *+  & C( ?@%- // .$  B0(%

  + 6
  *0(  '
   % B


0* + *

"+
7"+ $A  
+A ++*"
 + *

"+3 )
"+A +%     +  
(+*'
    ""+ B

 
  
  (*   
(( +  , %       0     0   

+ 
"+0



 

(
 %    0  * 

    "   + * = -*  **.

@  %*D6
 
0)

"+ *
 "

 
!

*0 " 6
     6
*  +%  0     *+     

  
1" 1

0"+  * !

  "+       (7 " 
 *- 9" 

5 



  
"

 

  
"
  


  
  

%"


"

 9 
5 

 %
--3


5 

2

(
 "



/ 


% 
!
(

 


%% 
/%
 
 
" 
 


%

 
   
!%
  
"
% 
  
(
9?(%
 !
5 


  !



(

 
$ 
@


/ 0

+%& 1

*  2

 +% ),

- .3% ' %
 


  
 !

 

 0      
            "

 

$
0   0

 + 
+ 0%   2@ '"'
%)
 +

  (  6
*  0     *(      2 $
  
 
  **
)    E %

+ *( " 
+% 
  
**"-$$
  -. '
.

!

" 
 %  "0  (  * 0"'
 A     *

** $
  % "*


0"0 
++ '  %0
 '
  
 *(   
"+  "


  $
         '
  @    

 
 %  0   

*    * 
" '
  ) 0 

 ** $
  '
%+ B   0  "  6+ 

 *
      0  

%  7    

     +  *
+  

"  "+     "(       
  

 
           *

  0    *+ 
7 ) 
 66 66 66   ,   

*   ( *
+ 3    (  ) 
  
"+  $


 2 

 "7*0  B  

 * * '
 !

 ( *
+  (  (+ ** ("E %(0 (  %  +  *    
+ !

 0
 !7$ ($ 

F

0 

(    8-$ *

%*  . ;G' *( 0

0 %

///%( * $


 2 " 
+ 

  G:(   0 %      0        ( ) 
$


 2   "  6
    

  ) 
    + !

 0 @&EB H  
 -2.&($*$ /   8-$ **

%*.   G!

  *         "  + "

     0   6
      ) 
 $


% 
* B



 
 0(

(  0

   ( ) 
  +  *   -.-". 
 * 3
+
( * 
 @ 0 
% 0 *

"
%  ' 
D

 6
 ) 
(   "+0 6
 ) 
 (     %    
           *
    
  "  +     
      ** "+   B     *
    *

 *
     3   -
.    **+ 
  !

0 ;+;

  ;0    +;         

 
(  
0I + 
 ("+  0  
!



*"+ 
 +%(0%      "
     *(     0     
 *

  
   
0%  *
" ("
*

0 !

B     ((  *  *0$


   +"
  B   0 (
% 0   +%


  3    
  +       
 *
 *
  **%


+) +
( $


    0   0 +   + 
  "+      ' 
D  0  3 @      B   ( (+  0 **= *) 2
   4 ,

-)

%



*3



"


  

%
"
!(% 

),




  


" 

"
%
  %
--3


5 

2

 " 
% 

    !

   4 ,

-

%%
   (%  !




  
 
( 


  
 
  %!
%


*3 )




"


   
 






/ 


!

%(% 

),





  


 

    !

   (%

),




 

 0 5.% 

 6     % - .J>0

  + 
+ 0 "
% **

 0 -   .    "+0 **


   *

 % +8

-.  * "


 I -".            +     
/I



    " 0 
  -.'**

   ""

-.

* * "


-.

 "


-. 
 I -".                
  -.> 
**

*

 ** 
%"  



 70++ ** $*  *8
2
"


  


 !

 

5 

 
  
"


  
" 

"

(
%
  %
--3


5 

2


 (%
 !(%

"



/ 


!
%(%

   *. 5 6% 

  


 !


'



% 
( 
"


 .++++40

1
'  
"
 

 

 
"

9 
5 
7 %
 

5!!
"

 

 
!
 !
 *3 


!%
 

 
!  + +

- -  7

 A


 B 4# A
 (%  B 4#